George Clooney: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Even Hollywood royalty can improve sometimes.

George Clooney was a relatively late arrival at the gates of mega-stardom. Having spent his earliest active career years jumping from one low-budget flick to another, between TV roles, the man who would be Batman got his big break with ER, playing a children's doctor, which is pretty much the same as being given a key to all of the women in the world. As Dr Doug Ross, Clooney built a sterling reputation, not only as a dashingly good-looking life saver, but also as a screen presence with the kind of golden age appeal that modern actors don't often display so instantly or so effortlessly. His star arguably came before his acting chops, but despite taking eye-catching, franchise leading roles like Danny Ocean, he also started out relatively small, finding his way with intriguing properties that allowed him to show a diverse skill set, and resisting the ominous type-casting shadows that typically follow any actor known for a break-out "heart throb" role. He is never an incidental element, such is his charisma, and though his track record has been far from flawless, his output in the past decade has been difficult to pick to pieces at all. Thankfully though, Clooney was once jobber, and his transformation into mega-star is only the more remarkable for the fact that the same man who wows in almost everything he appears in now, was once listed in the credits of a movie simply as "lip synching transvestite." With his latest - Disney's wayward utopian Tomorrowland - jet-packing into cinemas on a cloud of extremely mixed responses (edging towards apathy, in fact), there are still stark reminders that despite his capacity to win Oscars and delight film fans and critics, he still has bad movies in him. And unfortunately, when they're bad, they tend to be almost on the Bruce Willis scale of "not really appearing to be bothered at all." As further reminder, here's a look at the two faces of George Clooney: charismatic leading man, but a worse Batman than Adam West...

5 Awesome Performances

5. Matt - Gravity (2014)

All talk might have been of Sandra Bullock's intense, captivating performance as the loneliest astronaut, but as director Alfonso Cuaron is careful to acknowledge, Gravity would have been an entirely different film without George Clooney. The film is consciously and wonderfully absent of concept: it's not so much a sci-fi as it is a tense human drama that is almost incidentally set in space. It busies itself more in capturing feelings and assaulting the senses - literally trying to make the audience feel the same as Bullock - and that experience is to its eternal credit. But even with a seemingly meagre agenda, Gravity would have been far more difficult to take and far less accessible - even with Bullock in the lead - if it wasn't for Clooney's Matt. He is the balance to the piece, the personification of hope who takes a completely lost character and bludgeons her through tender methods into wanting to get home: a singular apathy transformed into a singular compulsion, riding on the back of Clooney's familiar, beautifully measured voice. He is the yin to her yang, the counterpoint that is far more than one dimensional or purely functional, and the performance is almost as noteworthy as Bullock's.

4. Danny Ocean - Ocean€™s Eleven (2001)

ocean's eleven By 2001, Clooney's tenure on ER was over (having left officially in 1999,) and though he'd starred in Three Kings, O Brother Where Art Thou? (more of which later) and The Perfect Storm since leaving his career making role as Dr Doug Ross, it wasn't until he was attached to the uber-heist ensemble remake of Ocean's Eleven that his star really met his potential. Ocean was the perfect character and the perfect opportunity to turn his on-screen charisma into something more tangibly expressed, giving fans who had watched him play odd-ball roles and everyman the opportunity to see him genuinely playing the Hollywood star alongside a stellar cast including Brad Pitt, Matt Damon and Julia Roberts. Not everything was hugely successful about the movie - Don Cheadle's accent being the most jarring fault - but the decision to cast Clooney in a role that had been made originally famous by Frank Sinatra proved an inspired one, given that it is his charm, and the dynamic that he builds with Pitt and Damon particularly that make the film so irresistible, and which inspired two further (largely superfluous sequels.) Following on the trend set by Gecko, Clooney plays a loveable rogue, less morally repugnant perhaps, but not a great deal. He just gets away with an awful lot more because of the twinkle in his eyes, which went a long way to making the film a significantly bigger success than Clooney's first team up with director Steven Soderbergh for the critically acclaimed, but not fan-adored Out Of Sight.

3. Everett McGill - O Brother, Where Art Thou? (2000)

Despite Clooney's cool on-screen persona, and the genuine assumption that he probably enjoys being a star more than being an actor - something that his Ocean's Eleven co-star Julia Roberts has been accused of frequently also - he has a habit of playing it less straight occasionally, and attaching himself to braver, stranger roles like his grotesquely humorous lead in the Coen Brothers' beautifully odd O Brother, Where Art Thou? On similar form to his curious performance in The Men Who Stare At Goats, McGill is a ludicrous caricature for Clooney, with perversely personal undertones - or at least some reflecting the typical image he commands on film. McGill is the extreme end of the same scale as Danny Ocean and Seth Gecko - a luridly charming, definitely snake-like bad guy with a heart, but still driven by greed, and unable to cast off his criminal leanings. Pushed through the quaint, but still dark Coens filter, the character is a self-imagined lothario, believing himself to be the brains of the outfit, and unable to read the obvious sign that intellect only by comparison is not always intellect. Clooney picked up the Golden Globe for Best Actor in A Comedy or Musical Performance for the ridiculous performance, commanding as much attention as he had smouldering in straighter roles to date, but also announcing himself firmly as an actor capable of such comic turns. It's a hugely under-rated performance, and one that would have been lauded more highly had it been committed by a more traditional method actor like Daniel Day-Lewis.

2. Ryan Bingham - Up In The Air (2009)

As the world slowly dripped through the depressing net into recession, depression and disaster, Clooney offered one of his most critically lauded performances as a corporate downsizer, employed specifically to terminate superfluous staff members, as well as giving motivational speeches. Yet again, Clooney soars in a role that shouldn't be likable. He's acting on behalf of a deeply troubling machine, destroying lives, which we see snippets of, very smartly populated by recognisable actors so we know exactly how much we should care about them being cut loose. His pink-slip carrier - Ryan Bingham - has no real life, though he has business success, because the downsizing business is booming, and his company keeps him perpetually on the move, and it takes both the introduction of a young upstart rival, and the chance for romance for him to realise the error in his ways. The film crucially is never over-sentimental about Bingham, and nor does it go out to overtly demonise corporate America, or romanticise the victims too much (though there are touching moments,) and instead it stays committed to a gentle black humour, wrapped in a tender character story about a man trying to save his job, and to save himself from his job at the same time. Clooney is utterly sympathetic - which is impressive given the character's story - and his mix of charisma and comedy is the perfect answer to the heavier subject matter.

1. Matt King - The Descendants (2011)

Up In The Air is widely considered to be Clooney's best role, because of how masterfully he commands the material, and how well the character sits on his shoulders, but it is his performance two years later in the equally darkly humorous The Descandants from Alexander Payne that wins by a nose here. It's difficult not to offer gushing hyperbole, or to sound cliched when discussing The Descendants: it is, after all, a perfectly pitched portrait of grief and of loss, as harm-hearted and endearing as it is ultimately devastating, and important in its presentation of love and loss and life and family. Occasionally accused of being ambulatory - as all of Payne's films seem to be - some of the criticism the mostly adored film attracted almost entirely misses the entire point: this is a removed story, telling of others, and exotics who still live within the borders of America, but who are as alien to the excess of Hollywood and California as if they lived on another planet entirely. There is slower purpose, but no less direction, and though at times Clooney's performance might feel slow, his is one of loss and of being lost, so the tone is entirely right. The film, and Clooney's performance succeed because of their attention to detail, and his slowly unravelling persona is both morbidly fascinating and emotionally devastating. And now on to the roles where Clooney was far less successful...

5 That Sucked

5. Matt Stevens - Return Of The Killer Tomatoes (1988)

It may seem rather unfair to concentrate too much on Clooney's earliest performances, given how far he has come since ER gave him his big chance, but it is precisely for that transformation that roles like this, in disposable, silly movies are so notable. It's a stark reminder that Clooney was once a jobbing actor, picking up paychecks for projects like this, and his recurring role on Roseanne, before he had fully honed his craft thanks to the rigours of filming long episodes of ER in what amounted to cinematic conditions. And it's not just that the film is terrible - that's sort of the point of that sort of schlocky material (which Clooney had already become accustomed to a year before with Return To Horror High) - it's how incredibly bad Clooney is as Matt Stevens. The idea of course here is spoof, but the best spoof movies have a degree of artfulness about them (which is precisely why dross like A Haunted House and Scary Movie 5 missed their mark) - they aren't just stupidity and fart jokes, but Return Of The Killer Tomatoes is sadly devoid of either a brain or straightly presented, well-acted lead performances, so there's nothing to make the comedy work properly. And the result feels like some high school gore fans put together their end of term project starring that kid who lives on the corner who once said he wanted to act.

4. Frank Stokes - The Monuments Men (2014)

On paper, the Oceans Eleven with war and an even more impressive cast should have been brilliant. It's not as terrible as some might have you believe, of course - but the fact that it's not really much of anything is sort of the point of the reaction. Disappointing is not the word. Clooney actually scores double points too for being both the lead and the director who can't get enough out of his lead man. It's partly down to the fact that the director struggles to actually nail a tone - something he was also conspicuously guilty of with Leatherheads - and seems to revel way too much in making the film look great, rather than feel great. As Stokes, Clooney is also conspicuously lacking his Danny Ocean charisma. It's not all that surprising, considering the historical precedent, but that doesn't make it any less frustrating. If it wasn't for the fact that he was directing himself, you'd suspect there was a sycophantic helmer behind the camera, teasing smiles and loaded speeches out in place of actual acting. But then perhaps the fact that there wasn't someone who could add discipline to the performance was the problem. He's clearly not an Affleck actor/director type, and perhaps he does need a guiding hand on his shoulders.

3. Lip-Syncing Transvestite - The Harvest (1992)

Mrs Clooney Gif Gif Actors have to do terrible things in the name of making a living for themselves, and that material invariably gets traded around the internet once the talent makes it big and moves away from playing such roles. Such is the case with Clooney's "performance" in the little-seen, but now infamous The Harvest, in which he was given the auspicious cast billing of "Lip-Syncing Transvestite," a role which probably now haunts him given how many hits its got on the net. In a throwaway scene - which explains the character name - Clooney, sporting a glorious blonde shock wig and golden padded underwear under his leather jacket, swings chimpanzee-like towards the camera, clearing under instruction to sing along seductively. Ignoring the ignominy of the role, it's the artistry of the performance that's a real issue here: Clooney clearly had one job, and he fails it miserably. Not only is he the least convincing transvestite in the history of transvestism, his attempt at seduction has completely the opposite effect as presumably intended.

2. Dodge Connelly & Director - Leatherheads (2008)

Clooney is of course now known as much for his directing chops as he is for his work in front of the camera, but not all of his films have been quite as well received as Confessions Of A Dangerous Mind, or Good Night And Good Luck, or The Ides Of March, and while it's a high hit rate, his miss with American football comedy Leatherheads is more notable for that fact. The problem with the film is mostly that it feels like an attempt to make a Coens film, if the Coens made American Football movies, with the fast talking characters, and the strong looking cast - but the film fumbles badly on its premise, and is utterly forgettable. The actor/director is oddly bland and lacks his usual charisma (even from other poor roles) and though there is something admirable in how well he blends classic spirits like that of Clark Gable to his usual persona, there's just not enough of him left. Whether it's because he duel roled, Clooney feels spread too thinly, and while he's got obvious passion for his story, it feels too much like a vanity project with far too few redeeming factors.

1. Batman - Batman & Robin (1997)

How could it have been anything else really? Though Clooney was well cast as Bruce Wayne and Batman, he was hung out to dry horribly by a terrible script, wayward tone, and the rest of the cast seemingly forgetting that they were professionals. Joel Schumacher ran amock and rough-shod over everything that Tim Burton had done well in the name of Batman, bringing too much pantomime, and too much cartoonishness to the film, and robbing everyone involved of any credibility at all. The film was just too close to everything that was bad about the campy, excessive 1960s TV show, which is well loved now as a cult gem, but which all but killed Batman's legacy on TV and on the page until a revival that took the source back to the the dark tone it had previously thrived on (sound familiar?) If any further denouncement of the film was necessary at this point, Clooney himself despises what became of his chance to be one of the most iconic characters in film history. Whenever asked about it, he openly tears it apart such in an interview with Total Film when he said, €œWith hindsight it€™s easy to look back at this and go €˜Woah, that was really sh*t and I was really bad in it.€ So at least he's aware of what he did. And boy, is he bad?! Given a rancid script, and a barely movable rubber suit enhanced with grotesquely over-masculine muscle tone and for no reason, nipples, it became patently obvious that Clooney was there to be leered over, as opposed to lauded: he is no more than a walking mannequin with big rubber nipples, and in that context, it's obvious why his performance struggled. Do you agree with this ranking? Share your own favourites and least favourites in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.