Ghost In The Shell Review: 8 Ups & 4 Downs

A surprisingly stunning adaptation.

Ghost In The Shell Scarlett Johansson Takeshi Kitano
Paramount

There's been an enormous amount of controversy and fan anxiety surrounding the big-budget, live-action adaptation of Ghost in the Shell, and now it's finally here for fans to judge for themselves.

Critics have been surprisingly positive so far, but with good reason: strip away fanboy nitpicking and that (admittedly discussion-worthy) racial issue, and you're left with a slick, well-executed sci-fi actioner that's among the better attempts to translate anime to the live-action realm.

Fans are likely to be more divided on its merits than critics, but go in with an open mind and you might be pleasantly surprised by how well it captures the essence of the source material.

Power Rangers and Ghost in the Shell both surpassing expectations in the same week... Who would've ever thought it?


Downs

4. It Actually Confronts The Whitewashing Issue (And Some People Will Hate It)

Ghost In The Shell Scarlet Johansson
Paramount

As soon as Scarlett Johansson was cast as The Major, there was hand-wringing online from fans and critics about perceived "whitewashing", citing this as yet another example of Hollywood refusing to open doors for minority actors.

It's a difficult line for the movie to walk, because it probably wouldn't have been greenlit without a Scarlett or Jennifer Lawrence at the helm. That said, what's most surprising of all is that the movie actually directly engages with the controversy in a rather bizarre (and undeniably ballsy) way.

No spoilers here, but one major aspect of the story dabbles in this area, and critics of Johansson's casting will almost certainly feel like the movie is smugly rubbing their face in the fact that a part for an Asian actress was "stolen" by a white woman.

If you're a little more relaxed about the controversy, it's actually a pretty interesting way to respond to the criticism, but there are sure to be a number of infuriated think-pieces in the coming days decrying the movie for what they perceive to be hand-waving of the racial controversy.


3. The Existential Aspect Is Toned Down

Ghost In The Shell Scarlet Johansson
Paramount

One of the best things about the original 1995 anime is that, between the various gorgeous set-pieces, there are some fantastically thoughtful dialogues about the nature of being, what it means to be human and so on.

These conversations and monologues often go on for minutes at a time, and while the live-action version certainly engages with these concepts, it's in a far more pared-down, piecemeal fashion, likely in order to avoid losing more casual audiences.

A little of the emotion and philosophical curiosity therefore feels lacking in the new film, even if it would be unfair to call it an empty vessel or thematically malnourished.


2. It's Rather Exposition-Heavy

Ghost In The Shell Juliette Binoche
Paramount

The new Ghost in the Shell begins with a text-based exposition dump and is fairly loaded with talky scenes of explanation that, honestly, could put a Christopher Nolan movie to shame.

It is sadly fairly unavoidable in a movie with so many complex moving parts that needs to explain itself to a broad audience, and this was also something of a problem in the original film that hasn't really been solved here.

Thankfully most of the talking is still interesting enough, but there are certainly a number of moments where the movie should be showing rather than telling.


1. The Ending Is Changed For The Worse

Ghost In The Shell Scarlett Johansson
Paramount

Unsurprisingly (but disappointingly all the same), the movie's ending has been changed from the original in order to open up that ever-important Hollywood franchise potential.

The finale stops short of the destruction in the anime, instead allowing the movie to serve as a superhero origin story of sorts, as opposed to the original functioning much more convincingly as a standalone movie in its own right.

It's understandable, considering Scarlett Johansson's popularity and all, but it also means that the emotion of the original film's ending isn't quite there, even if there is a fairly noble attempt to replace it with a different kind of cathartic climax.

And now, here's everything that, believe it or not, actually worked in the film...


Ups

8. The Visuals Are Absolutely Incredible

Ghost In The Shell Scarlett Johansson
Paramount

If there was ever one aspect of this movie which seemed like a slam dunk from the outset, it was the style, and by God, director Rupert Sanders (Snow White and the Huntsman) has done a splendid job bringing the stylistic aspects of the anime to faithful life.

Jess Hall's lush cinematography combines with imaginative shot selections, stunning visual effects and impeccable production design to ensure that almost every frame of this movie could be hung on a wall.

It's clear that just about every penny of its $110 million budget made it onto the screen, and considering how easy it would be for casual viewers to label the movie a Matrix ripoff (given that the original GITS actually influenced The Matrix), Sanders manages to cobble together a unique action aesthetic that actually doesn't feel overly derivative.


7. Scarlett Johansson's Restrained (But Bada**) Performance

Ghost In The Shell Scarlet Johansson Suit
Paramount

Whitewashing or not, Scarlett Johansson does a great job as The Major here, giving a restrained turn that skirts around typical bada** femme fatale cliches and actually emphasises her character's internal turmoil exceedingly well.

At the same time, she's absolutely killer during the film's action sequences, and despite her diminutive stature, takes down men much bigger than herself in never-less-than-convincing fashion.

It remains to be seen whether or not her presence will propel the film to box office glory (it's honestly not looking good), but it's hard to imagine a Hollywood talent giving a more capable performance than her.


6. Iconic Scenes Are Lovingly Recreated

Ghost In The Shell Scarlet Johansson Suit
Paramount

Fans should rest easy: a litany of the anime's most memorable and beloved scenes, both dialogue-driven and action-centric, are recreated here in spectacular fashion, and are sure to leave even the most hardcore GITS devoted unable to resist cracking a smile.

Changes are made to most of the big scenes, yes, but there's a ton of iconic imagery here that feels note-perfect in its transition to the live-action form, particularly The Major beating up the garbage man, her hanging out with The Major on the boat, and her climactic confrontation with the spider-mech.

Even if you end up disliking the film, it's hard to argue with Rupert Sanders' dedication to bringing these unforgettable moments to the big screen. Impressive isn't even the word.


5. It Also Has Fresh Ideas Of Its Own

Ghost In The Shell Scarlet Johansson
Paramount

This is by no means a straight adaptation of the anime, however, actually contributing some surprisingly buoyant ideas to the mix that mesh well with the pre-established narrative.

The hardcore crowd might balk at the idea of Batou's prosthetic eyes being given an origin story, for instance, but it feels fairly organic to the story, and sits comfortably along other aspects of GITS lore that are also incorporated into the plot.

A shot-for-shot remake of the anime would've been horrendously boring and rather pointless, so this compromise feels like a smart approach: it gives fans most of what they want while also changing things up enough that it's not a carbon copy.


4. The Stellar Supporting Cast

Ghost In The Shell Takeshi Kitano
Paramount

Who ever expected a live-action anime adaptation to get a cast this freaking good? Aside from Scarlett Johansson, there are three especially stand-out performances in the movie: Juliette Binoche as the caring Dr. Ouélet, Pilou Asbæk as Batou, and Michael Pitt as Kuze.

Batou in particular is hugely evocative of the anime version, while Kuze is an interesting stand-in for the Puppet Master, and Pitt's eccentric performance does a great job teasing out his ambiguity.

Takeshi Kitano is also fun, if underutilised, as Chief Aramaki, getting one memorable action beat but spending most of the movie sat down talking (he is 70 years old, so it's understandable).


3. Excellent Pacing

Ghost In The Shell City
Paramount

Hands up: who gets exhausted by 130-150 minute blockbusters? They feel like an increasing commodity in the Hollywood sphere, but there are very few stories that can't be ably told inside of two-ish hours, so it's refreshing that GITS strips away the narrative bloat and clocks in at a very reasonable 107 minutes.

In terms of actual pacing, the film also does a great job balancing its dialogue-driven scenes (exposition-heavy though they sometimes are) and the stylish action, which is less sustained than you might expect, but basically peppered throughout instead.

It's unlikely you'll be bored or wish the movie would just get to where it's going, because it doesn't screw around from the get-go and is only 25 minutes longer than the rather snappy anime.


2. Clint Mansell & Lorne Balfe's Fantastic Musical Score

ghost in the shell scarlett johansson
Paramount Pictures

Clint Mansell is one of Hollywood's most underrated composers, and with the help of Lorne Balfe, knocks out an entrancingly atmospheric musical score that helps capture the original's cyberpunk aesthetic.

Sci-fi films have been using synths for years, so it'd be easy for this arrangement to feel generic, but it melds perfectly with the heightened visuals to accomplish a terrific feat of world-building.

And for fans of the original, yes, the iconic "Making of a Cyborg" chant theme does appear in the film's closing credits. It would've been amazing to see it used during the opening instead, but at least it's still in there, right?


1. The PG-13 Rating Isn't A Problem

Ghost In The Shell Scarlet Johansson
Paramount

Aside from the whitewashing controversy, another issue fans latched onto was that pesky PG-13 rating, because this is after all a niche property that's a considerable financial risk for Paramount.

The thing is, watching the movie, the PG-13 rating doesn't feel remotely problematic. It's still propulsively violent (thanks to so many of the characters being at least partially robotic), and The Major still wears her skin-tight suit.

An R-rating would've added some nipples and exploding body parts but not much else. Is that really worth getting worked up about, especially considering how fan-servicey the almost-nudity of the original movie is anyway?

The PG-13 rating means the movie looks as gorgeous as it does, which is ultimately more important than some light-ish doses of gore and sexuality.

Have you seen Ghost in the Shell yet? What did you think? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.