Ghostbusters 3: 10 Reasons It's A Terrible Idea

Ghostbusters 3 logo Even if you aren€™t a Ghostbusters fan, everyone will have heard something about Ghostbusters 3, the film that may or may not be getting made sometime in the future. Every week there seems to be a different story about what is or isn€™t happening (there have been so many "official" announcements confirming multiple developments, I honestly have no idea what is actually going on anymore). So the more it gets talked about, the more I start to think that Ghostbusters 3 is a terrible idea, and that's because...

10. Aykroyd Could Mess Up

Dan Aykroyd It has been well-documented that Dan Aykroyd is dedicated to getting Ghostbusters 3 made. Many reports and rumours state that Aykroyd doesn€™t really care if Bill Murray agrees to it or not as he just wants to make the film. However, this seeming obsession with making Ghostbusters 3 could lead to it being a terrible film. How many times have you written something, like a song, an essay or a script that you thought was amazing only to realise looking back that it was actually awful? It€™s worse when you€™ve been so dedicated to a project as well; you€™ve put so much effort into it that you simply can€™t see anything wrong. The same thing could happen with Dan Aykroyd. He€™s been so desperate to just get the film made he may have written a terrible script without realising.

9. Sequels Years After The Originals Rarely Work

Terminator 3 film poster Some of the best film franchises came from the 1970s and 80s: Terminator, Die Hard, Star Wars. All of these films won the hearts of fans from across the globe, and all of these films also had rather disappointing sequels released years after the originals. Terminator 3 was pretty poor, especially following the massively popular Terminator 2; Die Hard 4.0 wasn€™t too bad but still was nowhere near as good as the films in the original trilogy; and let€™s not get started on the Star Wars prequels (they weren€™t very good). So many sequels that are made years after the original film end up being poor, often because a new writer or director comes in or because the tone is changed to appeal to new, usually younger, fans. If Ghostbusters 3 changes in series€™ formula too much, it might just lose the spark that made the first two films great.

8. Don€™t Ruin A Classic

American Pie Book of Love A lot of people might scoff at this one, as every time a sequel or reboot of a classic film is mentioned, at least one person will say €˜This is a different film, how will it ruin the original?" But let€™s take another franchise: American Pie. The first two are some of the best comedy films of their generation, but since then there have been several straight-to-DVD releases that use the American Pie name (Band Camp, Book of Love) that have been absolutely awful. Now, when someone mentions American Pie, you will end up remembering these films and how terrible they are. Sure, the originals are still great, but the memory of the other films will taint your view of the overall franchise. This could be the case with Ghostbusters 3, because if the new film ends up being awful, every time you think about or watch the originals that bad memory of the third will still linger in your head.

7. They Already Did Ghostbusters 3

Ghostbusters The Video Game Well, not exactly, but when Ghostbusters: The Video Game was released in 2008, Dan Aykroyd told the media, €˜To me, this is the third movie." This was a fair comment, as the game€™s storyline was original and written by Aykroyd and Ramis, included almost all of the original characters (including Walter Peck, the EPA worker who has no dick) and was, most importantly, a fun experience. The cinematic presentation of the game made it feel like you were watching a film rather than simply playing a video game. But it was the game€™s graphics that really made it feel right, as they allowed the Ghostbusters to look just like they did during the original years; how we remember them looking. That is one of the biggest problems with a new film, because...

6. They Are Too Old

Bill Murray The last Ghostbusters film was released in 1989, and over the past 20 or so years, the original cast have aged quite a bit. The power of graphics allowed Aykroyd to set the video game in the 90s as a direct sequel to Ghostbusters 2, but Ghostbusters 3 has to be set decades after the originals because of the age of the actors. Whilst Ernie Hudson and Dan Aykroyd don€™t look too old, Bill Murray and Harold Ramis have aged considerably. There€™s nothing wrong with this, as of course they were going to age after so many years and both are still great actors, but having Murray looking like an old man and Ramis gaining weight and somehow looking shorter (if it wasn€™t for his voice, I wouldn€™t have realised he was playing Seth Rogen€™s dad in Knocked Up), it just wouldn€™t look right. Murray expressed this view himself when he was apparently quoted saying "No-one wants to pay money to see old, fat men chasing ghosts." Some people have suggested a way around this, however...

5. It Will Focus On A New Team

Seth Rogen Paul Rudd A lot of the rumours about the story of Ghostbusters 3 involve a new team being trained up to take over from the old guard. The originals will realise the limits of their age and will have to find some new faces to help them take on their greatest ever threat. At the end of the film, after one last hurrah, the old team will hand the reigns over to their younger counter-parts and take their retirement. However, a lot of fans don€™t want to see a new team taking over. They loved the original Ghostbusters films because they loved the characters. They loved Venkman€™s cockiness, Egon€™s logical, scientific approach to everything, Winston€™s €˜let€™s do this€™ attitude. If a new team is brought in then we won€™t see as much of the originals, as the film will have to focus on introducing the new team and developing their characters.

4. Hollywood Will Make A New Series Out Of It

Ghostbusters merchandise We all know Hollywood revolves around money. If a film doesn€™t make enough revenue, it€™s not getting a sequel. And if a film strikes box-office gold, you just know producers will milk it as much as they can. If the general rumours of what will happen in Ghostbusters 3 are true, the film will end with a new team replacing the old one. Seeing the original team leave and having a younger team taking their place would pave the way for an entirely new Ghostbusters franchise. But without the original team, is it still Ghostbusters? If Die Hard doesn€™t have John McClane, is it still Die Hard? If Toy Story didn€™t have Woody and Buzz, would it still be Toy Story? It might be a Ghostbusters film in name, but as I said in the last point, it€™s the characters of Venkman, Ray, Egon and Winston that made the other films truly great.

3. It Won€™t Meet Expectations

Ghostbusters fans Ghostbusters is one of the most popular cult franchises in the world. Like Star Trek and Star Wars, many of its fans are extremely devoted, spending thousands on replica proton packs and hours of their time building their own Ecto-1€™s. So after over 20 years of waiting for a third film, the expectations of many fans would be sky high. The Dark Knight Rises was highly anticipated and there was only a four year wait for it after The Dark Knight. The backlash from some people on how terrible that film was because it wasn€™t exactly how they wanted it just shows how difficult it is to please everyone. When Ghostbusters 3 is finally released, a lot of the most dedicated fans will be expecting the most amazing experience of their lives; a level of expectation that will be almost impossible to satisfy.

2. Bill Murray Doesn€™t Want To Do It

Bill Murray Ghostbusters This is the biggest talking point of all of the discussions and media hype around Ghostbusters 3. Is Bill in? Is Bill out? Almost every week something is €˜definitely confirmed€™ by someone. Some rumours say he randomly called Dan Aykroyd at 3.00am one night to say he€™s on board, others say that Bill actually shredded a copy of the script after he had finished reading it. But whatever the truth is, and even if he is eventually persuaded to be involved, it€™s pretty obvious from all of the fuss so far that he doesn€™t want to be in the film. And that disinterest will become clear in the final product as, although Bill Murray is still an incredibly funny actor, he won€™t be giving it 100% for a film he never really wanted to do in the first place.

1. A Lot Of Fans Don€™t Even Want It

Ghostbusters 3 logo They are too old. Bill Murray doesn€™t want to do it. It€™s been too long since the last one. There are just so many reasons why Ghostbusters 3 could be terrible that many fans just don€™t want it to happen. They are more than content with Ghostbusters 1 and 2, with the memories of the good times these films gave them. It€™s a shame that they didn€™t make a third one sooner during the 90s or even in the early part of the 2000s, but they€™ve accepted this. Sometimes it is just better to leave something you love rather than drag it out and flog it to death, killing everything that made it great to start with. And if the fans don€™t want a new film, then who would they be making it for? But maybe I€™m wrong. Hopefully I€™m wrong. Maybe Dan Aykroyd knows exactly what he is doing and will write an amazing film that is the perfect way to end the story of the Ghostbusters. However, with the amount of time it€™s taking to just get the film off the ground, the odds do looked stacked against him, so maybe he should just let it go. What do you think? Do you agree that Ghostbusters 3 is a terrible idea or are you looking forward to a third film? Give your views in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Been gaming since the Megadrive. Loves Batman, Futurama and Blackburn Rovers. Mild obsession with collecting steelbooks.