Ghostbusters Review: 6 Ups And 4 Downs
Hemsworth beats Slimer.
Well, this is a nice little surprise. Ghostbusters, the movie sexists have been hating for the better part of two years that got down-votes galore and even has online critics refusing to review it, is good. Nothing special, but a solid, fun, creepy summer flick. It’s fine guys. It’s fine.
Considering that summer 2016 has thus far been a major disappointment (after Captain America: Civil War most big releases have been dead on arrival), getting a film that manages to be genuinely entertaining in spite of its faults is a breath of fresh air. There's a lightness of touch here and an understanding of what an action-comedy needs be that more po-faced contemporaries have missed.
Make no mistakes - there are problems with Ghostbusters that mean it won't have the longevity of the original (and will give anybody looking to hate it enough fuel to do so), but they fade into insignificance next to what it gets right on a character and thematic level. Here's six ups and four downs from Ghostbusters.
Bonus Down - The New Theme

Right, before we get to the real downs here’s an iffy one – the new theme. Oh god, it’s terrible. Why they got 2016 Fall Out Boy I do not know, but it’s somehow more grating that you’d even expect. It’s telling that before the UK press screening they played the Ray Parker, Jr. version on a loop.
But, thankfully, this ear-bleeder is barely in the film – the only bit that plays is the most palatable twenty seconds over a montage. Dodged a proton bullet there.
Ups:
6. The Recasting Works

Tackling the major issue head-on, these new ‘Busters are good. The characters fit the broad archetypes of the original, but with enough new stuff in each to be memorable by themselves. The actual personalities could have been more fleshed out – especially Melissa McCarthy, who is just playing herself – but the actresses are so likeable that you’re with them through the adventure.
It's refreshing that they don't lean into cliché. McCarthy's evolved from the fat schtick, the race card is played much less with Leslie Jones' Patty than feared (it's there, but her arc has a bit more too it) and Wiig can be both serious professor and smitten schoolgirl (which can admittedly get a bit annoying when the film's trying to move forward).
The stand-out, and most immersive, is Kate McKinnon, who is a ball of eccentric energy as the team’s techy Holtzman. She doesn’t get many belly-laughs and her jargon waffling is irritating rather than endearing, but it’s such a constantly off-kilter performance you’ll be chuckling along.
5. The Gender Politics Are Front And Centre (And Work)

OK, let’s address the Stay Puft Marshallow Man in the room. The gender-swap recasting is far from the end of the movie’s politics. Like Paul Feig’s other films, this is very much about where women fit in modern society, and it’s pulling no punches. We see how they’re treated in the scientific community (and the film has a nice undercurrent of scientific method versus scientific glory) and as celebrities, and it's with resistance.
That’s right – the movie is about the backlash, viewing it in the cold light of day with a mixture of punching-back and derision. Some of the more targeted jokes – and there’s a lot - were probably added in after the casting reaction, but the movie is intrinsically built on how people would react to a female Ghostbusters and asking what that says about all parts of society. That’s… really quite smart.
4. It’s Really About Dealing With Bullying Though

For all that gender stuff, the real message of Ghostbusters is something more universal. It’s about dealing with bullying, and on a broader sense not being afraid of who you are. To quote the movie's subtitle from the final card, it's about being able to Answer The Call (bit forced, but it's forced in the movie too).
You see, both Kristen Wiig’s Erin Gilbert and the movie’s villain were bullied growing up for their interest in ghosts, but they've elected to deal with it in different ways; he's used it to power resentment and plotted to get back at those who wronged him, while, in contrast, over the film she comes to embrace what makes her unique and make herself stronger.
It's again got a bit of an undercurrent of commentary on the backlash (I imagine some Ghostbusters die-hards won't be too happy about some of the comparisons), but the message is bigger than that and speaks of true inclusivity.
3. More Jokes Hit Than Miss

The first good joke in Ghostbusters comes about twenty seconds in. Twenty seconds. Not bad from a film most assumed would struggle to get you to smile even once. From then there’s a constant run of gags, both big and small, that mean you’ll be chuckling along through most of the film. I really don't want to spoil any of the knock-outs, but rest assured there's plenty of surprises.
There are misses, I'm not gonna lie. A lot of the pop culture references are based around incredibly obvious gags about classic movies – there’s a contextually messy Scarface “say hello to my little friend” – and some of the more awkward interaction stuff feels contrived. But overall it’s funny. Even jokes like that fell flat in the trailers work in context.
Well, except that Exorcist possession stuff. That was as cr*p as it always looked.
2. Chris Hemsworth Is F*cking Hilarious

OK, so Ghostbusters is quite funny, but Chris Hemsworth is something else as the gang’s dim-witted receptionist. Every single joke the film makes with him lands. Christopher's never really justified his position as the biggest Hemsworth - every role feels like a generic action hunk or a riff on Thor - but this one reveals his comedic skill.
It's also one of the film's best examples of character development. There’s something really endearing about Kevin, so while you’re laughing at him in a way, over the film (like the gang) you begin to really care for him. An expanded role in a sequel beckons.
He’s like Jason Statham in Spy – someone you didn’t realise could do comedy and in the trailers looked to be playing it too broad, yet in the movie is so consistent you get excited just seeing him in a scene.
1. The Cameos And Throwbacks Are More Than Blind Nostalgia

There’s a lot of cameos in Ghostbusters 2016 from the original 1984 cast, which, unlike the trailers, I won’t spoil, but will say are all brilliant; each actor gets a fitting appearance that honours them personally and their place in the canon. Although what's so interesting is that they don’t just pull you out of the movie – they strengthen the viewing experience.
Likewise, the film is full of throwback references, but they’re not really all that cloying or distracting; they're obvious, but fitting. It’s not just blind nostalgia; the film is using them to push the gender and bully stuff from earlier.
That’s what so interesting here. Ghostbusters isn’t a legacy-quel like Star Wars: The Force Awakens or Independence Day: Resurgence, but neither is it just a straight-up do-over. It’s using things that you know to tell something new that exists by itself.
Downs:
4. It’s Edited To Hell

Like most 2016 blockbusters - X-Men: Apocalypse, Alice Through The Looking Glass, Independence Day: Resurgence and many more - Ghostbusters is rather curiously edited.
The pacing of the story is all over the shop, with massive time jumps quickly followed up by stagnant development. Characters feel like they’re doing things just because the plot demands it – they know what the villain’s up to just because the audience does and there’s a bizarre bit when a character returns at the climatic moment and everyone’s like “welcome back!”, but they never left. It’s more “Were you gone?”
Crazily, its individual scenes can also be a bit of a mess, with what should be essential sequences - like the really not good at all Exorcist fight - chopped down to the bare essential beats and having no chance to breathe.
The whole thing can feel like a montage. We’re not seeing full sequences, we’re seeing a quick taste of something. Like Batman V Superman, it’s like this is cut down from a bigger film, but at 116 minutes I doubt that.
3. There’s A Lack Of Real Conflict

One peculiar thing about Ghostbusters is that while the movie’s engaging, the characters likeable and the action thrilling – there’s a great bit where McKinnon gets to show her stuff to the original theme – there’s a real lack of proper conflict in the film.
You’re never in doubt the good guys will win, and not because this is big summer fun, but because there’s unclear stakes and so it's hard to get properly invested in it (I don’t actually know what the villain’s scheme was). You could argue that this is all about the jokes, but this means that as an overall film it's weaker.
Part of this comes from the general chilled interplay between the characters, but those editing issues won’t have helped either; all the choppy and sudden scenes mean there’s even less tension than you’d expect. In fact, aside from one scene at the start, it’s never really scary, more creepy.
2. Stilted, Flat Blocking

I don't meant to condescend, but dialogue scenes don’t just need to be dialogue – you can have movement and sight gags and all sorts of things to better tell your story. Ghostbusters has some of this stuff - gags especially - but it fails on a basic blocking level.
So many scenes, especially the expository ones in the first half, are incredibly poorly blocked. You have these big, interesting sets, but the actors just stand on the spot in very rigid formations with the camera filming them straight on or at right angles. It’s very unengaging scene construction that makes things feel more stilted than they need to and puts full focus on the script, meaning that when that does flub, it's more noticeable.
I'd wager this is a repercussion of the high amount of improvisation in the film. The actors can ad-lib all they want, as long as they stay in the same spot so the cinematographer doesn’t have to improv too. But this isn’t any of these guys first time in this sort of film – they could have really done something more exciting.
1. Slimer Is An Unnecessary Irritant

OK, wow. Those first three downs were pretty heavy, huh (although not enough to overpower the humour, character and themes). Let’s round things out on something a little more fun, and one that’ll probably be music to any detractor’s ears – Slimer doesn’t work.
All the other references are nicely pitched, but this one is so obvious and obnoxious and unfunny it doesn’t work. It's pure fan service, with no purpose in Ghostbusters 2016 as a movie; a big green turd turning up randomly in the third act just doesn’t fit with the tone the film’s being working for. I know you kinda have to include him, but there's better ways that this execution.
There’s also the female Slimer sh*t, which is just… I mean… HOW DOES THAT WORK?
Have you seen Ghostbusters? What did you think? Have your say down in the comments.