Ghostbusters Reviews: 10 Reactions You Need To Know
78% on Rotten Tomatoes? It's a miracle!
It's hard to think of a movie that received quite as much pre-hate as the Ghostbusters reboot. When it was first announced that the titular foursome would be played by - brace yourselves - women, the world went absolutely crazy. One popular online critic even stated in a viral YouTube video that he wouldn't even bother to go see it, so offended was he by its very existence (very mature).
Due out in cinemas across the globe this coming Friday, Ghostbusters has already landed in the UK slightly early (on a Monday, of all days: how strange). As such, a good number of critics have seen the flick and have had time to form their opinions.
And you might be surprised to learn that, after all the hubbub, Ghostbusters is... well, fine, actually. Neither fantastic nor terrible, the critical consensus thus far paints a film that avoids stamping aggressively over the legacy of the original and instead manages to be a perfectly enjoyable - if not unnecessary - reboot that manages to entertain for the length of its runtime. It's not amazing, but it isn't pure evil, either.
So, guys, it's time to sit back, relax, and take a deep breath as we comb through a number of early reactions that you need to know...
10. It's Nowhere Near As Good As The Original (But That's Okay)
A common thread running through most of the reviews so far is the fact that Ghostbusters isn't anywhere near as good as the original, a verdict backed with the positive note of that not necessarily being a bad thing. Who expected it to be better than the original movie, after all? We only wanted "not awful," right?
In his review for MovieWeb, critic Julian Roman said that "Ghostbusters isn't remotely on par with the original, but by no means terrible," a sentiment that was also echoed by Eric Eisenberg of CinemaBlend in his own review, who stated:
"No, Paul Feig's Ghostbusters is not as good as Ivan Reitman's 1984 hit. But it is still a fun blockbuster worthy of curiosity and delivering a great number of laughs."
Pajiba's critic Rebecca Pahle had something similiar to say:
"Feig’s Ghostbusters isn’t as good as Ivan Reitman’s. That said, Ghostbusters is still a very fun, solid action comedy."
Movie-goers were probably expecting a movie that fell way, way short of the 1984 version, but the critics have generally agreed that, although this Ghostbusters isn't anywhere close to the stand of the Reitman film, it isn't plainly rubbish, either.
9. It Doesn't Really Do Much To "Advance" The Franchise
When you set out to remake a movie, it's generally thought that there should be a good reason to go ahead and do so, aside from "money!" - either you're updating something that has dated for a new audience, or using the premise to say something new about the world, or a mix of both.
In this department, it's being said that the new Ghostbusters falls short. At least, according to a large number of critics who reviewed the film, many - whilst enjoying the flick to a moderate degree - found that it offered nothing new or established itself as the modern, feminist yarn we were all kind of expecting it to be.
In his review for IndieWIRE, Eric Kohn wrote that "it's worthless if it can't make old ideas feel new," whilst Don Kaye from Den of Geek proposed the question: "Why are we telling this story again, just with different people and a few remixed aspects?"
Variety's critic, Peter Debruge, agreed with these criticisms:
"This otherwise over-familiar remake from “Bridesmaids” director Paul Feig doesn’t do nearly enough to innovate on what has come before."
Enjoyable as it might be, it appears that Ghostbusters doesn't do enough to justify its existence from a modern point of view, and - as such - lacks staying power.
8. Kate McKinnon Is The Best Of The New Four
Kate McKinnon is best known as a star on the current iteration of Saturday Night Live, but she's about to get a major career boost after her work in Ghostbusters - that it, according to the critics, who have largely deemed her character, Holtzmann, to be the best and most memorable member of the newly-appointed gang.
The general consensus seems to paint McKinnon, whose part in the film was largely criticized when the trailers first emerged, as the most unique of the four new 'Busters - largely unexpected, perhaps, given that she goes up against comedy movie veterans like Kristen Wiig and Melissa McCarthy.
In her review for the Toronto Star, critic Liz Braun praises McKinnon as follows:
"You already knew she was funny from her brilliant SNL Justin Bieber thing, but Ghostbusters will show you that she’s spectacularly, fabulously, through-the-roof funny. Go see for yourself. [She] steals the show."
Then there's Caroline Framke's review over at Vox:
"The revelation of Ghostbusters will have to be McKinnon’s Dr. Jillian "Holtz" Holtzmann, who not only steals every scene she’s in but chews it up with a liquid smirk and spits it out for parts."
And in her review for The Daily Beast, Jen Yamato essentially declares McKinnon to be the glue that holds the entire film together:
"McKinnon’s Holtzmann, meanwhile, is the secret weapon of this Ghostbusters. Aside from spewing rapid-fire technical jargon as the team’s resident eccentric gearhead, McKinnon oozes visceral charisma with the swagger of Murray’s Venkman. Hemsworth might be the beefcake on paper but it’s McKinnon who’ll leave moviegoers crushing."
Speaking of Hemsworth...
7. Chris Hemsworth Steals The Entire Film
It was always suspected that Chris Hemsworth, who plays an incredibly dense and incredibly handsome receptionist named Kevin, might turn out to be the film's most valuable player - purely on the basis of what we got to see of him in the trailers (also: the very idea of Chris Hemsworth as a receptionist... hilarious).
True to these predictions, there are very few reviews out there which don't make a point of claiming that Hemsworth is the best thing in the entire film.
"Chris Hemsworth steals the film completely," says Julian Roman of MovieWeb, summing up the general consensus with one swift line.
In her Metro write-up, Caroline Westbrook praises Hemsworth as a genuinely funny comedian with bonafide comic chops:
"As likeable as our central female quartet may be, it’s ultimately Chris Hemsworth who almost steals the entire film from under their noses as bungling, thick-as-a-brick receptionist Kevin. Because Chris – whose character is so endearingly dim he completely fails to realise just how much he is being comically objectified by his new female employees – proves himself to be rather an adept comedian as he bumbles his way through proceedings. Seriously, who knew?"
A few of us knew, Caroline: there's always been a humorous, self-aware undercurrent to the way Hemsworth plays Thor, after all.
6. Paul Feig's Direction Is Rather Messy
Paul Feig isn't the most inventive director in terms of visual stylings, and it's not like Bridesmaids and Spy were particularly pleasing to the eye (to be fair, they weren't really expected or supposed to be, though).
According to a large portion of the recent reviews, however, Ghostbusters is by far his messiest film to date. At least, in terms of the way the film is actually put together, things are a little iffy: there's a noticeable sloppiness and crudity to the editing which makes the film occasionally flat or ugly to look at.
In his review for MovieWeb, Alan Orange called the film "messy," and it's a word that keeps creeping up in number of reviews for Ghostbusters.
Feig hasn't helmed a project so reliant on CGI, either, and the critics have admitted that it shows and has impacted the final product somewhat. Matt Singer of ScreenCrush had this to say on the use of CGI in the last act:
"The humor of the previous 90 minutes gets lost amidst a lot of messy CGI and slo-mo ghost combat."
A point echoed by The Guardian's Nigel M. Smith, who writes:
"Feig falls down a little in the final Times Square spectacular. This is his first effects-laden enterprise and he sometime ladles on the CGI a little thick."
All in all, then, critics have noticed a slapdash element to the production. Not enough to spoil the film outright, of course, but still a bit of a let-down.
5. The Cameos Are Unnecessary & Distracting
You'd think that Bill Murray popping up as a paranormal debunker would have had people cheering in the aisles, or Dan Aykroyd making an appearance as a jaded cab driver would have sent shockwaves of nostalgia around the theatre.
Not so, according to the early reviews: the overall consensus regarding the film's inevitable cameo appearances, of which there are many (pretty much the entire cast of the original film appears), mark them out as somewhat unnecessary and distracting - especially since the film does such an admirable job of being its own thing.
As Peter Debruge writes in Variety, "[the] cameos undercut the new film’s chemistry," and he's just one of many critics who found the old cast members popping up slightly awkward. Scott Mendleson of Forbes felt that "one awful extended cameo single-handedly kills the film’s momentum," which is a pretty brutal assessment.
Then there's this dooming nugget, from HitFix's Drew McWeeny:
"If you’d told me that the worst thing about a new Ghostbusters film would be Bill Murray, I would have laughed in your face. And yet… here we are."
Maybe it would have been better for this incarnation of Ghostbusters to avoid all the self-referential "oh, look, it's the guy from the older movie!" moments?
4. The Villain Is Severely Lacking
The marketing for Ghostbusters never really put an emphasis on the villain character, a weird guy named Rowan played by actor Neil Casey, and there's a good reason for that according to the early reviews: he's pretty lacking as a character.
Germain Lussier's mostly positive review over at Gizmodo nicely sums up the overall consensus with regards to this particular narrative irk:
"Played by Neil Casey, the character is nearly a non-entity. We know he doesn’t like people and is trying to open a portal to another dimension. How he figured out to do this is fuzzy (he’s a genius, we’re told), his motivations aren’t particularly believable (he was mistreated as a child) and the plan itself doesn’t really make much sense (bring ghosts back to kill people). Rowan is a character literally placing obstacles in the way for the Ghostbusters. He does some cool things, especially toward the end, but he’s never a true threat, so there’s no tension."
It's somewhat telling that so many of the reviews actually fail to make reference to the film even having a villain at all, which kind of makes sense if he's as forgettable as Lussier claims.
Oh, well: room for improvement in the inevitable sequel, perhaps?
3. The Main Foursome Have Fantastic Chemistry
Arguably the greatest thing about the original Ghostbusters film is the fact that the main cast have such great chemistry together, even if the movie does lean more heavily on Bill Murray.
Fans and naysayers alike have been concerned that Melissa McCarthy, Kristen Wiig, Kate McKinnon and Leslie Jones would lack the friendship factor of the original foursome, but - according to the reviews - that isn't the case.
As Allison Willmore writes in her Buzzfeed review:
"Jones, McCarthy, McKinnon, and Wiig are so good together - and in ways that are distinctively theirs and not recycled from the past."
Barry Hertz, from the Globe and Mail, throughly agrees:
"From the moment they all cram into a room together - this time above a Chinese restaurant, versus the original’s abandoned firehall - it’s comedic gold."
The A.V. Club's Jesse Hassenger even went as far as to claim that Paul Feig gives the main foursome more love than Ivan Reitman did his own cast, thus allowing their chemistry to come to the surface in ways the original 1984 film didn't allow:
"The four women share a palpable enjoyment of each other’s company, and Feig may love his cast and characters more than Reitman, who ceded much of the 1984 movie to Bill Murray (as one does when Bill Murray is around)."
Good news, of course, given that this is sure to be the first in a long line of Ghostbuster movies; if the chemistry's right, that's half of the battle won.
2. The Jokes Are Pretty Hit & Miss
Whilst the film has been praised for being quite funny overall, some critics have noted that there's a somewhat scattershot nature to the actual jokes in Ghostbusters. That's to say, they're rather hit and miss, with - according to Caroline Westbrook of the Metro - "a few too many of the one-liners falling flat."
And she's not the only one who felt that the comedy was lacking. Stephen Whitty of the New York Daily News writes:
"The all-new, mostly female "Ghostbusters" reboot is in theaters, full of terrific special effects, icky green slime, a horribly haunted Manhattan and, yes, the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man. But the big laughs you’d expect from a "Bridesmaids" reunion of director Paul Feig and stars Kristen Wiig and Melissa McCarthy never materialize."
The middling nature of the comedy isn't enough to derail the film, apparently, because as soon as one gag lands with a thud, another comes along almost straight away to break the ice. In short: it's funny, but not hilarious.
1. It Works Well As A Franchise-Starter
In this horrific day and age of endless sequels and reboots, there's no doubting the fact that Ghostbusters was intended as a franchise-starter of the colossal kind. Amy Pascal, former CEO of Sony Pictures, hasn't been shy in admitting such things, and recently claimed that "[the franchise] is going to be endless. People are going to love this movie so much that’s they’re going to demand more and more.”
So, yeah, it's a film that designed to pave the way for more adventures with these characters, and according to a large portion of critics it's successful in doing so.
As Alex Welch explains in his review for GeekNation:
"If the goal of the latest outing was to make me interested and excited to see this team come together again, then I’d be willing to say that the Ghostbusters reboot is a success in its own right."
From the uproar that has been circulating around the internet for the past year or so, it's certainly surprising to learn that Ghostbusters isn't the disaster that the haters were utterly convinced it was going to be - that, instead, it's a film that works as both a reboot of a beloved franchise and is genuinely worthy of a follow-up!