Gladiator 2: What Really Happened?
A story of Ridley Scott, Nick Cave, and the craziest movie sequel that never happened.

Gladiator was a huge hit when it released back in 2000, achieving the fabled double whammy of being a commercial smash AND a critical darling that played well with the Academy.
It took over $450 million at the box-office, making it Ridley Scott's highest-grossing movie - a record that would remarkably stand until 2015's The Martian - and went on to be nominated for 12 Oscars, winning five of them including Best Picture and Best Actor.
It was, however, a tightly contained story: it told of a very specific person in a very specific time period, and with Russell Crowe's Maximus dying at the end of the movie, and most of the other key players going the same way, there wasn't an obvious route for a follow-up. That's never going to stop Hollywood from trying though, as Scott, Crowe et al have been trying to make a sequel to Gladiator for almost two decades.
With new talk of a potential sequel ramping up in recent years, it's time to look back on the storied history of Gladiator 2 - which, yes, involves time travel - and ask what really happened?
6. The Initial Sequel Plans

While rumours began to swirl of a follow-up movie after the success of Gladiator, it wasn't until 2001 that interest really started to firm up, with producer Douglas Wick stating that it was something being actively pursued, if they could find the right story. It wasn't a sequel, however, but reportedly a prequel that they were looking at then, as a means of potentially keeping star Russell Crowe - who was at the peak of his pulling power after his turn as Maximus - around for the movie.
It would've focused on Maximus' earlier soldiering days and his romance with Lucilla (played by Connie Nielson in the movie), but that idea didn't gain much traction, however, and it wasn't long before alternate plans were being discussed.
The next idea on the table was a sequel, with Wicks and Dave Franzoni (who co-wrote the original) looking to produce, and John Logan (who also contributed to the first's screenplay) set to write. This one would've been set 15-years after the first movie, and put the focus on Lucius, son of Lucilla, as he attempts to discover who his real father was, while the Praetorian Guards ruled Rome.
The twist in the tale here, though, was that it'd be revealed that Lucius is actually the son of Maximus - a twist that Scott decided led to the movie going away from what made the first Gladiator work, becoming more the story of Rome's corruption and demise rather than of Gladiators, and too "rambling and complex" in the process.
5. Russell Crowe's Involvement & A Multi-Generational Tale

A big question mark over the sequel was the involvement of Russell Crowe. While a prequel could easily have brought him back as a slightly younger version of Maximus, the ending of Gladiator couldn't be so easily undone.
A prequel would've solved this, of course, but that idea didn't seem so appealing to DreamWorks, while Crowe himself is reported to have started researching Roman ideas of the afterlife in order to explore what might've happened to Maximus after his death and how he might return in the film.
A compromise of sorts, then, would've seen Gladiator 2 become a multi-generational tale in the same vein as The Godfather Part II: with prequel elements detailing Maximus' early life, alongside the sequel story focused on Rome afterwards and incorporate the story of Lucius. Again, though, it never went much further than the initial development stage, but it's after this things started to get weird.
4. The Nick Cave Script

With Scott and Crowe both interested in making a follow-up, and DreamWorks certainly keen on it too given how well the first one performed, the director and actor went to an unlikely source for a script: Nick Cave.
Yes, the Nick Cave who was the frontman for Australian experimental rock band Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds. The Nick Cave who once fronted a band known as being "the most violent live band in the world". That Nick Cave. (Although, in the interest of fairness, he had written the critically acclaimed The Proposition, so it does make slightly more sense in context.)
And, well, the script was as wild as his stage performances.
The film opens in the midst of a storm, with two thieves looting the armour and weaponry from Maximus' lifeless body - only for Maximus to suddenly awake. This is not his resurrection, but the afterlife, through which he's guided by Mordecai. He's brought to the remaining Roman Gods, who are a shadow of their former selves, and tasked with bringing down their brother Hephaestus, who has been spreading dissent. If he kills Hephaestus, then he'll be reunited with his wife and son in the golden wheat fields of Elysium.
So it is that Maximus finds and kills Hephaestus, only to be transported back to Rome, his body flesh and blood but his life eternal, with the story resuming some 18-years after death. Lucius is now leading the Romans in the genocide of Christians, and Maximus finds his old friend Juba, with whom he forms a resistance to fight back against the Romans. He transforms the Christians into a true army, resulting in a bloody battle that could well be the end - but there's much more craziness to come.
After the end of the battle, Maximus orders his men to regroup and prepare for another fight. Except that fight doesn't actually come in Ancient Rome. Instead, Maximus is transported to the Crusades in the Holy Land, and then to various other battles, from World War II to Vietnam, travelling through time and fighting in a number of the biggest, bloodiest wars across history. It ends with Maximus in a toilet at the Pentagon, wearing a suit, where he then walks into an office, opens up a laptop, and gets ready to address a number of other men, presumably about the new threats facing the world (this was right in the War on Drugs and War on Terror period, after all), before fading to black.
3. The Reactions To Cave's Script

Incredibly, Nick Crave's script wasn't made into a film, but that's not to say everyone was totally against it. Ridley Scott, for one, has spoken quite positively about it, saying they tried to make it happen and that it "works very well" as a piece of storytelling, and the Crowe didn't want to let the idea go. There are, however, different reports on Crowe's opinion on the script.
While the actor told Empire that he and Scott did consider it for a while, even calling Cave a "brilliant writer" and acknowledging how difficult to was to find a way of bringing Maximus back from the dead, the Bad Seeds frontman remembered things differently, recalling on Marc Maron's WTF podcast (via Den of Geek) that he told him he "didn't like it mate" to both the story and the ending.
To be fair, though, Cave seems to be remembering a different script entirely, adding that the Gods sent Maximus back to kill Christ, and that he even wanted to call the movie Christ Killer(!). The musician goes on to say it was a "stone cold masterpiece," but that he wrote it because he knew on "every level" it would never get made, referring to it as a "popcorn dropper". Because why else would you write a 103-page script?
2. Ridley Scott Revisits The Idea, With Crowe In Mind

After Scott and the studio couldn't agree on a direction to go in, with the studio keen on the safe option, Scott wanting something different, and, well, whatever Cave's option could be called, plans for Gladiator 2 fell by the wayside for around a decade.
That was pretty much the case until 2017, when Scott, speaking at South by Southwest Film Festival, told EW that he knew how to bring Crowe's Maximus back for another film, saying:
“I know how to bring him back. I was having this talk with the studio — ‘but he’s dead.’ But there is a way of bringing him back. Whether it will happen I don’t know. Gladiator was 2000, so Russell’s changed a little bit. He’s doing something right now but I’m trying to get him back down here.”
Aside from the absolute savagery of Scott saying Russell's *changed a bit*, that was pretty much all we got on the matter, and it didn't look like it'd seriously lead anywhere.
1. Gladiator 2 Is Now Happening

Except, of course, Gladiator 2 is ready to re-enter the development arena. News reports frequently in recent years claim that Scott's going to be at least producing the movie, and looking to direct it too.
Peter Craig (who is no stranger to long-gestating sequels, as he's also doing the screenplay for Top Gun 2) is writing the script, although it's unclear at this stage if Russell Crowe will be back. It's said that the movie will focus on... yep, Lucius, son of Lucilla, or in other words it's the movie that was first put into development immediately after the first.
There are, however, ways of bringing Crowe's Maximus back, even if the actor himself might not be looking much like his old Gladiatorial self. They could use CGI to de-age him for a more active role, or simply have him appearing using repurposed footage from the first one, with Crowe merely recording new dialogue for the movie, with Maximus serving as a vision to Lucius or in a flashback sequence.
Of course, there's also the question of whether any of that SHOULD happen. While Gladiator's reputation now isn't quite as strong as it was after release in 2000, it is nonetheless a Best Picture winner and a genuine epic. Crowe isn't the same performer, and Scott isn't quite the same filmmaker. A new story might be fine, but it may be better to let Maximus simply remain a legend, instead focusing on the next generation.
Are you not entertained?
Are you excited for the prospect of Gladiator 2? Let us know down in the comments.