Groundhog Day: 7 Pressing Questions You Probably Missed

Groundhog Day

Today is Groundhog Day, and while America holds her breath to see exactly how long winter will last based on what side of the bed a small hairy creature got out of this morning, the rest of the world ignores the real tradition of the day and goes back to their DVD and blu-ray shelves to rediscover Harold Ramis' seminal Bill Murray starring comedy. It's dark, it's brilliant and it features arguably Bill Murray's finest performance of his career to date. And like the greatest films, it also comes with a raft of questions to engage those film fans who like to scratch beneath the surface of and discover more. So to celebrate, we're doing just that. And of course, we'll be exploring exactly how long Phil spends trapped in the perpetual loop of Groundhog Day - more of that to come...

7. How Long Does It Take Phil To Decide To Kill Himself?

Groundhog Day 3

Does Phil really resort to trying to off himself as quickly as he does, simply because he is unable to get Rita to fall for him (which appears to be the suggestion of the film's linear progression, at first glance)? Is he that close to the edge that such a thing is enough to push him completely to despair? The Answer It's probably not all that long, really. When I wrote the How Long... article I postulated that it would likely only take Phil around 20 days from the onset of his despair to reach the point where he wants to kill himself repeatedly in search of an end to his Hell. That was based on the fact that Phil is entirely self-centred, and the very idea of spending any time in Punxsutawney, let alone the prospect of eternity there, repulses him at the start of the film. And look how quickly he turned to crime - it's not as if he has the conventional moral compass of an every day man - that's got to have caused some acceleration in his decision to die. But then, that doesn't mean he took only 20 days trapped in Punxsutawney to kill himself - he spends an awful lot of time attempting to legitimately woo Rita, or at least stealing information and using it to his benefit - remember this is the man willing to spend six months becoming an expert in flicking cards into a hat. So really, he has to have been in Groundhog day at least a while (more than the more than 10 years it takes to become fluent in French)

6. Does He Really Learn French Fluently?

Groundhog Day 6

When I originally wrote my assessment of how long Phil spends trapped in Groundhog Day, one of the most contentious issues seemed to be my suggestion that Phil learned French fluently. People laughed and screamed (or I imagine so anyway) at my ignorance - of course he didn't learn French, he blatantly learned a single line in order to impress Rita on his long-game attempt to impress her/trick her into having sex with him. But that's wrong. The Answer Yes, he does. Though it might appear he only learns a single line of poetry, and then blags his way through the follow-up question, there are two hints that confirm he became fluent: 1. It's poetry: in order to understand the nuances and rhythms of a poem, you have to be fluent in the language, otherwise what you say will come out with the inflections in all the wrong places, which would probably be noticable to anyone with a passing knowledge of French, let along SOMEONE WHO STUDIED FRENCH POETRY AT COLLEGE! 2. Phil knows the nature of his predicament: in order to sleep with Rita, he knows that he has to account for every eventuality. What if she had asked a series of complex follow-up questions (which any sane person would when discovering someone else appreciates the extremely rare thing you spent many years of your life devoting your mind to)? Would Phil have merely shrugged and gone back to the drawing board to try again the next day? No, that's not what the underlying message of Groundhog Day is - it is an exploration of chaos theory, and of the many branching alternate realities that spring forth from any moment. Phil's ultimate hell is that he has to attempt to simultaneously account for them all in order to gain his ultimate goal - access to Rita's genitals.

5. Could It Really Be All A Trick?

Groundhog Day 7 Having watched both Groundhog Day and The Truman Show, my brain did what all nerd brains do eventually, fabricating links between the two to establish a shared mythology that just plain doesn't exist anywhere else. Specifically, I began to consider whether Punxsutawney is a manufactured community, filled with actors, and controlled by an unseen power who sought to teach the notoriously brusque and self-centred reporter an extremely long-winded lesson in morality, in order to change him for the better. And then when you look really closely at the film, it all begins to fall into place, because not everything is as identical as it first seems... On the first day, when Phil looks out of his window, the truck turns right just at the moment the radio duo shout "Groundhog Day.", but the next day this changes, and the shout comes ahead of the truck turns. Something smelled fishy, and then a further revelation: just before Phil meets Ned, on the first three days we see two women walking together in the background, one wearing blue, but then on the fourth and subsequent days the woman in blue is by herself. Perhaps the other "extra" was called away to work elsewhere? Perhaps. So is it all an elaborate trick played on Phil? The Answer Well no, silly, those are just great big continuity errors. Besides, unless the hospital facilities in Punxsutawney are literally on the very leading edge of every single form of medicine, there is no way Phil could have survived being "stabbed, shot, poisoned, frozen, hung, electrocuted, and burned" and wake up without a scratch every morning. It's all a lot less straight-forward than that.

4. How Long Does Phil Spend Trapped Reliving The Same Day?

Groundhog Day 2

Simple, but profoundly engaging, this is the age old question that drives Groundhog Day's success, as well as the morbid fascination with the darker possibilities of eternal resetting life that I will come to mention. We know the film implies a long time passes, because of some of the things Phil manages to achieve, from mastering ice sculpture to becoming an expert at card throwing, but exactly how long does Phil actually spend reliving the day over and over? The Answer 33 years and 350 days It's a lot more fun finding out how we came up with that number. http://youtu.be/9jiKYtyDg5c And here's the actual working out of the numbers (which may all seem a little odd without their explanations.)

3. What Does It All Mean?

Groundhog 1

Unlike most comedies of the time, Groundhog Day is a profound experience. Aside from featuring a groundhog driving a car - which was profound in itself - it explores some pretty dark recesses of humanity, and opens up some seriously murky possibilities, mostly in the shape of the unexpressable questions that us curious folk inevitable explore. In light of the fact that he was so willing to rob a security truck, and he used his "powers" to dupe at least Nancy, and probably Rita at some point into bed, what other crimes did he commit when he suspected he'd never escape his living Hell? The mind boggles, but as one commenter on my Groundhog Day calculation article so aptly put it, there was probably wasn't "a single item in Punxsutawney that he hasn€™t had sex with by the end. Animal, mineral, vegetable." And it is these darker elements that remind us that Groundhog Day has a lot more meaning than a selfish man having to work out how to be selfless. So what exact is the meaning beneath the surface of Bill Murray's best comedy? The Answer Well it could all just be an extended metaphor concerning self-growth and realising the value of altruism, but it could just as easily be a thinly-veiled religious allegory, exploring the abusive relationship between a Christian diety and His followers. Personally, I go for the idea that Phil is in fact dead, doomed to relive his final day for eternity until he is forced to become his own idea of Hell, a selfless people person who is less concerned with sex with a beautiful woman, and more concerned with getting a young couple a pair of WWF tickets. Come to think of it...

2. How Exactly Did Phil Get WWF Tickets In A Single Day?

WWF Groundhog Day

All-in-all this is the most testing of all the questions aimed at Groundhog Day, and it focuses on the tiniest detail during the feel-good final day sequence when Phil finds himself. How exactly is it that Phil manages to get his hands on two WWF tickets for Michael Shannon and his brand new wife? It's not like he could get to a box office to pick them up, given the whole trapped in a perpetual loop thing, and the last time I checked the WWF schedule of around the time, I didn't see a major event in Punxsutawney... The Answer Well, either he had some serious contacts, who were able to bring the tickets to him from outside of Punxsutawney, since he couldnt actually leave (though that would pretty much compromise the whole can't leave situation), or someone in Punxsutawney already had the tickets and he borrowed or bought them for the young married couple, which quite frankly is far too non-magical for my liking. What feels slightly more appropriate to the darker tone of the film is that Phil spent some of his time in the loop learning how to be an expert forger, and simply duped the couple into believing his fake tickets were authentic to give them a thrill. It's still a selfless act after all, and Phil was never to know that his perpetual day would come to an end, leaving his beneficiaries without their tickets.

1. Who Is This Man, And What Has He Done With Bill Murray?

GroundHog Day Cover

There is no excuse for poor blu-ray covers in this day and age, but because of the intricacies and idiosyncracies of artistic taste, it's fairly rare that all designs will be universally loved. The abomination that is the Groundhog Day cover above is an entirely different story: that man on the right, with his fat chubby waxen face bears slight resemblance to Bill Murray, but it's certainly not the same man in the film within the box. And why are his hands so freakishly over-sized? What needs to be asked is why the hell hasn't this image been cleaned up or removed entirely in favour of something more iconic for the cover, like the infamous bed-side alarm clock for instance? The film has to be an essential part of every discerning film lover's collection, and yet the cover is nothing short of an impediment. Roll on the Criterion version of Groundhog Day I say, or when someone similar puts together a definitive edition including multiple commentaries, visual essays and a cover that doesn't look a bargain basement knock-off. The Answer Sadly, it's just a really, really bad image of Bill Murray. Happy Groundhog Day.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.