Happy Death Day Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

Groundhog Day for Dummies.

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

Continuing its international rollout this week, Happy Death Day is already becoming one of the year's biggest indie successes.

Made for a mere $5 million, the latest horror film to come out of the ultra-successful Blumhouse Productions stable grossed an insane $26.5 million in its opening weekend, and will continue to multiply its budget many times over in the coming weeks.

It's also been reviewing surprisingly well for the most part, and though the majority of critics have basically given it an easy three stars, that's essentially fine for a movie that, while fun, doesn't even begin to reach the full potential of its premise.

If you're craving another time loop movie with a few interesting ideas of its own, though, you could certainly do much worse, and it'll be interesting to see whether or not its success will result in a glut of unnecessary sequels being quickly churned out. Time will tell...


Downs...

5. It's Disappointingly Tame

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

Despite its focus on a woman being caught in a cycle of death, Happy Death Day is a PG-13 horror movie, meaning that it's incredibly low on gore, and the film has clearly had its edges sanded down for the teen set.

An R rating would've been so beneficial to a film like this, allowing for Tree's various death scenes to be comically over-the-top, while the satirical sorority girl chatter would sound much more authentic with a cruder tongue.

Instead, it ends up feeling incredibly tame for the most part, and considering the film's low budget, it's a damn shame it wasn't aimed more towards adults rather than adolescents.


4. It's Basically Groundhog Day For Dummies

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

Countless movies from different genres have appropriated the Groundhog Day time loop gimmick over the years, and to be fair, horror seems like a pretty damn fine fit for it.

However, probably in large part due to the movie aiming itself towards younger viewers, it takes an incredibly superficial and simplistic approach to the familiar premise, literally spelling out the film's logic every step of the way with sledgehammer-subtle exposition.

Whenever a new wrinkle is introduced to the plot, Tree or another character will literally verbalise it to make sure everyone in the audience is keeping up, even if there's nobody else in the room.

Ultimately if you've seen a few time loop movies before, you're probably going to find this treatment a little facile and underwritten.


3. There Are Two Pointless Subplots

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

Happy Death Day clocks in at just 96 minutes in length, yet is still padded out by two woefully pointless subplots.

The first is a melodramatic attempt to inject some emotion into the film, with Tree mourning the death of her mother three years prior, but it ultimately has little bearing on the overall narrative and basically feels like a lame soap opera excess.

The other subplot can't really be talked about due to spoilers, but you'll know it when you see it, because it comes totally out of left-field and takes the film on a needless tangent for about 10 minutes.

Overall, the film would feel much leaner if these plots were cut out entirely and it clocked in at a square 80-85 minutes instead.


2. It's Not Really A Horror Movie

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

Though Happy Death Day is for all intents and purposes a horror film in its name, premise and how it's been marketed, it really doesn't feel like one all that much.

Often the killer plot is put to the wayside and the movie feels like a straight-up college-set comedy, and it likely doesn't help that the PG-13 rating further strips away most of the tension and potential terror.

Younger teens might scream at the litany of jump scares, but if you're at all savvy to the genre, the jumps probably won't catch you off-guard even once.

This combined with the focus on comedy and the lack of psychological horror or gore means that it rarely feels like a true entry into the genre.


1. 50 Cent's "In Da Club" Isn't In The Final Movie

Happy Death Day Phone
Universal

One of the most prominent aspects of the film's marketing was the use of 50 Cent's iconic hit tune, "In Da Club", which was used as Tree's phone ringtone and played as a recurring element every time she woke up after being killed.

In the final film, however, it's nowhere to be heard and is replaced by a more generic song, presumably because Universal couldn't gain clearances for it (perhaps after Fiddy's record label realised how popular the trailer had become).

Considering how iconic In Da Club is, and how perfectly it cements that this is a millennial horror movie, it's a damn shame it didn't make it to the end product. A nitpick, perhaps, but disappointing all the same.

And now, here's everything Happy Death Day got right...


Ups...

5. Jessica Rothe's Charming Performance

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

There's one aspect of this film that absolutely, unequivocally just works more than anything: Jessica Rothe's immensely charming performance.

Rothe does a fantastic job portraying Tree, the initially douchey sorority woman caught in this horrendous time loop, and even when the script doesn't support her well enough, she fully commits herself to the part regardless.

Her charismatic, likeable performance is a big reason why the film works at all, and it seems probable that she's going to have a bright future off of its success, whether that's as a scream queen in the horror genre or in the wider industry as a whole. Bravo.


4. The Mystery Is Genuinely Compelling

Happy Death Day Killer
Universal

While it doesn't always work as a horror film, as a whodunnit it is much more compelling, quickly setting up a gallery of potential killers among Tree's friendship group and leaving the viewer to try and figure it out ahead of the inevitable reveal.

It's easy to get invested in the mystery and figuring out who it is, and while mileage will vary on the quality of the eventual unmasking, the ride getting there is breezy fun.

The basic idea is your typical murder mystery slasher film nonsense, but the time loop twist gives it enough extra edge to feel fairly fresh, despite the movie's many flaws.


3. It's Goofy & Satirical

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

While the balance ultimately tips a little too far in favour of comedy rather than horror, at least the film's humour is genuinely funny, even with its PG-13 limitations.

Rothe's energetic performance and lively delivery definitely helps boost some of the film's wonkier one-liners, but at least there has been a clear effort here to satirise vapid college culture, from stuck-up sorority sisters to goofball frat boys and everyone in-between.

The satire isn't laid on that thickly to avoid alienating the teen crowd, but it still ensures that the film is smarter and more self-aware than you might've expected from the marketing.


2. There's A Great Montage Sequence

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

It's pretty much a given that any movie following the Groundhog Day formula needs to feature a montage of the protagonist working through countless days in their time loop and failing to achieve the task at hand.

Happy Death Day is certainly no exception, delivering a terrific mid-film montage set to Demi Lovato's catchy pop tune "Confident", in which Tree investigates her suspects for the killer's identity and, of course, gets herself killed numerous times in the process.

It's a weird and jarring juxtaposition but one that works exceedingly well, and this is easily the most memorable and best-directed sequence from the entire film.


1. It Cleverly Subverts Expectations

Happy Death Day Jessica Rothe
Universal

Again, no spoilers here, but the film does have a few aces up its sleeve, especially later on, in terms of leading audiences down a certain path and then smartly pulling the rug out from under them.

For a while it seems like the film has under-estimated audiences and seems set to deliver a lackluster conclusion, but writer Scott Lobdell throws in some curve-balls sure to keep viewers on their toes until the credits finally roll.

Basically, the various twists and turns are surprising enough that they'll pass muster with not just the PG-13 crowd, but also genre experts with decades of film viewing under their belts.

What did you think of Happy Death Day? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.