Harry Potter: 7 Biggest Problems With The Philosopher’s Stone

Everyone loves the first Harry Potter movie, but there are plenty of problems with it...

Madam Hooch Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

2021 marks the twentieth anniversary of the first Harry Potter movie. Though the books were already a sensation, Harry’s first on-screen adventure introduced many people to the wizarding world, and as such, the film means a lot to many Harry Potter fans.

The set designs and the music are top-notch – a trend that continues throughout the franchise. And given the shorter length of the source material, it’s great to see the first book adapted so closely. There’s also something immensely satisfying about going back to the start of Harry’s journey.

On the other hand, only a fool would argue that The Philosopher’s Stone is perfect. Child actors – in any context – are always a bit of a problem. The central performances are a bit patchy when compared with the later films. The story also deviates from the original novel a few times, and whilst this isn’t always a problem, some changes don’t work too well.

But ironically enough, some of the following issues don’t make the film less enjoyable to watch. All these years later, many of these problems only add to the film’s charm.

7. The Sorting Makes No Sense

Harry Potter Sorting Hat Hermione Granger
Warner Bros

The Sorting Ceremony is an iconic part of the Harry Potter series. Every Potter fan dreams of putting on the hat and discovering which house they belong to.

In the original novel, the students are sorted in alphabetical order, starting with Hannah Abbott and ending with Blaise Zabini.

In the movie, however, Professor McGonagall appears to prioritise the students who are most important to the plot: Hermione Granger, Draco Malfoy, Ron Weasley, and – of course – Harry Potter. Susan Bones – a Hufflepuff – is thrown in at one point, but this seems like a feeble attempt to make the Sorting Ceremony more random.

Whilst this isn’t a particularly big problem in terms of the central plotline, the overemphasis on the main characters knocks you straight out of the movie.

The filmmakers should've used a quickfire montage of all those students being sorted before Harry – like in the book. This would give the Sorting Ceremony a greater sense of longevity, tension, and authenticity.


6. The Convenient Staircase Change

Harry Potter Forbidden Corridor
Warner Bros.
"The Third-Floor corridor on the right-hand side is out of bounds to everyone who does not wish to die a most painful death." – Albus Dumbledore

The Philosopher’s Stone is essentially a mystery story, and the secret of the Third-Floor corridor is a key part of it.

Malfoy’s trick with Harry and the midnight duel doesn’t make it into the movie adaptation, so the filmmakers had to come up with a new way for the characters to find the Third-Floor corridor. Unfortunately, their solution was rather pathetic.

One evening, Harry, Ron and Hermione are on their way back to the Gryffindor Common Room when a staircase changes midway through their ascent. Conveniently, the staircase leads them to the very same corridor mentioned by Dumbledore in his opening speech.

Mrs Norris then turns up, the trio run along the corridor, stumble across Fluffy, and discover the trapdoor. It’s a fun sequence, but ultimately one which feels far too contrived.


5. Harry’s Birthday

Happy Birthday Harry Potter Cake
Warner Bros.

Every Potter fan knows Harry’s birthday is on the 31st of July – which is actually J.K. Rowling’s birthday as well. But in the movie, things don’t really make sense.

Hagrid arrives with a crash and tells Harry he’s a wizard shortly after midnight on his eleventh birthday. Several hours later, they go shopping in Diagon Alley for school supplies. Now laden with books, potion ingredients, and his new owl, Harry trundles into King’s Cross to catch the school train.

But the Hogwarts Express doesn’t leave until the 1st of September. In the book, there are several paragraphs summarising Harry’s final month with the Dursleys. It’s essentially a little transition between Diagon Alley and the start of the school term.

For whatever reason, this transition doesn’t appear in the adaptation, and as a result, there’s an awkward clash between Harry’s birthday and the start of the school term.


4. The Trio Forget They’re Not Meant To Be Out At Night

Draco Malfoy Philosopher's Stone
Warner Bros.

Towards the end of The Philosopher’s Stone, Harry, Ron and Hermione visit the gamekeeper’s cabin and witness the birth of Norbert the Dragon.

Soon after, they walk back up to the castle. The three of them talk openly as they head for the Gryffindor Common Room, and – unsurprisingly – they’re caught by Professor McGonagall.

The movie tries to imply that they were only caught because Malfoy snitched on them, but frankly, the trio should have known better.

Why didn’t they bring the Invisibility Cloak? That would have prevented them from being caught immediately. And if you’re going to snoop around Hogwarts at night, you should at least have the sense to keep your mouth shut, rather than strolling about the corridors like it’s the middle of the day.

Considering Hermione’s supposed to be the cleverest student in Harry’s year, it’s hard to believe she of all people would be so careless, particularly given her obsession with school rules.


3. Madam Hooch Can’t Referee Quidditch

Harry Potter And The Philosophers Stone Potter And Wood Quidditch
Warner Brothers
“Now, I want a nice clean game…from all of you.” – Madam Hooch.

Madam Hooch was clearly lying when she made this pronouncement. Despite the foul play from the Slytherin team, she does absolutely nothing for the entire game.

As well as the constant pushing and shoving from the players in green, Oliver Wood – the Gryffindor captain – is knocked unconscious by a Bludger when he hasn’t even got the Quaffle. And worst of all, Angelina Johnson is forced into a wooden stand and then plummets to the ground. Though she makes a full recovery, her accident could easily have been fatal.

Yet amongst all the chaos, Madam Hooch doesn’t punish a single player. She just sits back and watches the violence without a care in the world.

She turns up at the end to announce Gryffindor’s victory – and that’s it. If she’d bothered to do her job properly, a lot of injuries could have been avoided.


2. Emma Watson Mouthing Lines

Harry Potter Hermione
Warner Bros.

It’s easy to criticise child actors. They don’t have much experience and their performances look particularly patchy when they’re seen alongside acting veterans.

Throughout the filming of The Philosopher’s Stone, Emma Watson developed a habit of mouthing the lines of her co-stars. Director Chris Columbus had to cut numerous takes because of this issue.

Whilst most of Emma’s blunders didn’t make it into the movie, you can clearly see Hermione mouthing Harry’s words as the trio approach Hagrid’s cabin to interrogate him about Norbert. Once you’ve spotted this mistake, it’s impossible to ignore it when re-watching the film.

And funnily enough, Rupert Grint messed up too. When Hermione’s talking about Snape “jinxing the broom”, Ron mouths her words quite clearly.

It’s a strange habit and it knocks you straight out of the story. But thankfully, Emma and Rupert learnt from their mistakes.


1. Harry Doesn’t Do Any Magic

Harry Potter
Warner Bros

Harry Potter is the story of a young orphan who discovers he’s a wizard and goes to learn magic at a fantastical boarding school. You’d have thought, therefore, that Harry would perform a lot of spells whilst at school – but he doesn’t, at least not in his first year.

The only genuine magic Harry does in the entire movie is in Ollivander’s wand shop. Sure, he attempts the Wingardium Leviosa charm and spends plenty of time on his broomstick, but Hermione does all the major spell work.

She fixes Harry’s glasses, opens locked doors, sets Snape’s robes on fire, attacks Neville, and defeats the Devil’s Snare. Her two best friends, meanwhile, just watch in awe as she outclasses them in almost every way.

Whilst Hermione is undoubtedly the most powerful member of the trio when it comes to magical ability, it’s hard to forgive the filmmakers for such a vast oversight. Harry – as the rest of the series proves – has bags of magical talent, and it would’ve been nice to see this from the outset.


Harry Potter Quiz: Harry, Ron And Hermione – True Or False?

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
Warner Bros.

1. Harry Plays Seeker On The Gryffindor Quidditch Team.

Contributor

Love to read and write. Have an unhealthy obsession with Harry Potter. Enjoy running up hills.