The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies - 10 Questions We Need Answering

Radagast can't survive to the end credits, surely?

The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies is one of the year's biggest releases and arrives in less than five months, yet actually information is very thin on the ground. Peter Jackson doesn't really need to do much to promote the film beyond simply announce its existence, but you'd expect by now we'd have more than a couple of screenshots and the odd snippet from interviews. A (apparently very short) teaser is rumoured to be imminent but Jackson has said (due to the time it's taking for Weta Digital to finish off the visual effects) we won't get the full trailer until October. OCTOBER?! That's, like, two months before release. The spoilerphobe side of us kinda hopes this sets a precedent in more toned back advertising (we really don't need another case akin to Prometheus or The Amazing Spider-Man 2 where we've seen the whole movie before even buying a ticket), but the rampant speculator side (which will be very much on show today) is starting to get the shakes. With all the changes made between Jackson's trilogy and J.R.R. Tolkien's original book there's a lot more questions about plot than you'd expect in a novel adaptation. Coming up are the ten biggest questions on our minds regarding The Battle Of The Five Armies, along with some theories as to what the answers might be. We'll find out if we're right on December 17th. Please note: as we're using the original book for reference there are massive spoilers within. Tread lightly.

Honourable Mention - Will Bombur Get A Line?

Less than ten minutes into their mission we'd all got to know the individual members of the Fellowship; where they fit in the world, their general personality and, most importantly, their names. After five and half hours with the dwarves in The Hobbit we still don't know who the majority of them are (outside of Thorin, Balin and Kíli they're all pretty interchangeable). Sure, this is a recognised issue in the book as well, but on film it stands out more as a problem; heck, Bombur is still yet to get a line. That's right, the dwarve otherwise known as 'the one that did that barrel roll thing' has yet to say a word. Will Bombur finally get to open his mouth to do something other than burp in the final film? Only time will tell.

10. What Will The Prologue Be?

Each Middle Earth film has kicked off with a brilliant scene setter that serves as a prologue to the main action; the history of the One Ring, Gandalf's fall from a new perspective, the origins of Gollum, the tale of the Lonely Mountain and Gandalf convincing Thorin to reclaim Erebor are all highlights of their respective films. It'd be troll-level logic to think Jackson wouldn't keep up the tradition for Battle. But what will it be about? Our guess would be a scene that's been teased since the very first trailer. Back from when The Hobbit was just two films, the teaser for An Unexpected Journey (which then would end after the barrel sequence) had a shot of Gandalf amongst some ruins being attacked by an white-skinned assailant. A cheeky bit of freeze framing reveals the attacker is none other than Thrain, Thorin's father, played in the films by Mike Mizrahi. As, in the books at least, Thrain is dead by the time the company of Dwarves began their journey this has to be a flashback, so, it'd make a good starting part for the third film. From the decor it seems we're at Dol Guldur, making this a moment referenced in the Return Of The King appendices were Gandalf, investigating the abandoned fortress, finds the former King totally deranged. It culminates in Thrain giving him the map and key that have proven so essential in the films, essentially setting in motion the whole series of events. Of course the scene could easily be cut and left for the Extended Edition like Bilbo's excursions in Rivendell. But until we get a proper answer it'll have to do.

9. Who Kills Who?

For a children's book The Hobbit climaxes with a fair bit of death. By the end of the Battle Of Five Armies (Tolkien wasn't bothered with the definite article) Thorin has been ambushed by Bolg and his orcs, Fili and Kili have heroically died protecting their uncle (thus ending the line of Durin) and Bolg (in the book the leader of the orc army) is finished off by the transforming bear-man Beorn. And in any other case that would be what to expect in the film. However, Jackson has changed much of the relationships for the big screen it's all up in the air. Azog has taken his Bolg's narrative position as orc leader, pushing his son to a subordinate who's clashed with Legolas (who isn't even in the book in the first place). This, as well as the strong likelihood that Bilbo won't sit the battle out on screen as he does on the page means there's a lot of speculating to be had. For our money, this is how we see it going down. Thorin has to be killed by Azog - too much history has been established between them for it to not end bloodily - although we still expect Beorn to end the white orc, although don't be surprised to see Bilbo take a part; this is his story after all. Fíli and Kíli are likely to meet their death to anonymous hands in a similar manner to the book, although the retribution will probably be different, involving a vengeful Tauriel. And Bolg will die at Legolas' hand because he made his nose bleed. There are rumours circulating that Thorin will survive the battle, which strikes as Armitage-fan wishes; it'd be one of the dumbest decision in the entire franchise (and that includes Bombur's barrel knock-out).

8. What Happens To Radagast?

The more observant/pernickety of you out there may have wondered how Gandalf would get his staff back in time for the Rings trilogy after Sauron disintegrated it in The Desolation Of Smaug. The answer is that the staff that gets destroyed isn't the one from Rings; the one Gandalf uses in the original trilogy is Radagast's. Seriously, the one used by Gandalf the Grey in Fellowship is exactly the same as the one the Brown wizard uses in the Hobbit Trilogy (minus the blue, hedgehog-life-giving thing). Which begs the question; what happens to Radagast? The character doesn't originally appear in The Hobbit at all, instead having been brought over from The Lord Of The Rings (where, in the books, he called the eagles when Gandalf was held captive at Isengard), so this is totally up to whatever Jackson feels. The obvious option is that he'll die. It'd certainly explain why Radagast doesn't pop up when the entire of Middle Earth is in peril (he was on mushrooms isn't an adequate excuse) and would actually justify his inclusion in the trilogy beyond Weta getting a chance to show of their kinda realistic animal animation. Killing a wizard hasn't been seen in the series and would certainly make Gandalf feel that little less invincible in the originals.

7. Did Bilbo Already Pick Up The Arkenstone?

It's easy to forget in amongst the molten gold finale of The Desolation Of Smaug that going into the Lonely Mountain was actually meant to be a covert operation. As established in the film's opening, the main goal was finding the Arkenstone, which would in theory unite the Dwarve armies for an assault against Smaug; Bilbo, the burglar, was meant to sneak into the cavern of gold, find the Arkenstone and leave unnoticed. Otherwise known as the Heart Of The Mountain, the jewel discovered in the opening of An Unexpected Journey, symbolises the right to rule as King under the Mountain, so as you can imagine it'll be an essential plot driving force in The Battle Of The Five Armies. At the moment, however, we have no idea where it is. Throughout his exchange of quips with Smaug, Bilbo is chasing the Arkenstone, but the scene devolves into action before we get any confirmation whether Bilbo actually manage to pick it up. There's a couple of moments in amongst the fire and coin-flinging where he could have grabbed it, but Jackson seems happy being coy about it. In the book Bilbo does indeed grab the jewel before Smaug goes to seek 'revenge' on Laketown, but as that little emphasis is put on the question of whether he has it or not (coupled with the trilogy's habit of squeezing in extra action sequences), we wouldn't be surprised to see him acquire it in the last film.

6. Will Tauriel Be Plot Significant?

For all grumbles die-hard Tolkien fans had about Evangeline Lilly's Tauriel for being an entirely original character for the film, she was, for the most part, a strong inclusion. The series has always been light on female heroes (Arwen and ‰owyn's roles were both pumped up in the original trilogy in an attempt to address the balance) and with Legolas taking up the resident arsehole position a genuinely likeable wood elf was much appreciated. Also, her action scenes was pretty damn impressive. Much of the ire was directed at her relationship with dwarve Kíli (thus explaining why he, along with Thorin, are the only two in the company not totally hidden under make-up). Inter-species romance is a very questionable addition to the world and reports that it was dreamt up just before the 2012 reshoots suggest this was a subplot added purely to boost the run-time (because these films have been too short thus far) only further soured the issue. Either way, the romance sub-plot doesn't totally justify her presence. Between her acrobatics and love story, we're still not quite sure what role Tauriel plays in greater events. Jackson went to great pains to create the character, so he must have something for her to do beyond fall for a soon to be dead character, right? If she was just added so there'd be a girl on screen we won't be too impressed.

5. Can We Expect Any More Cameos?

One thing you can't criticise The Hobbit for is providing The Lord Of The Rings fans with plenty of opportunity to geek out at the reappearance of characters from the original trilogy. On top of those already present in the book (Gandalf, Gollum, Elrond, those eagles) we've had Old Bilbo, Frodo, Legolas, Galadriel, Saruman have all been worked into the narrative (although the latter two were already present in events from the appendices). It's amazing The final film offers plenty more of these appearances; Legolas has unfinished business and Ian Holm will no doubt pop up one last time to bookend the trilogy, while we know the White Council will play a large part in fending off the Necromancer (and sending him to Mordor). But could there be more that are being kept from us? Could we be about to get a surprise akin to (SPOILER for X-Men) the return of the original cast at the end of Days Of Future Past? Gollum would be the obvious returner here. Andy Serkis has been an Assistant Director on the trilogy, so getting him to mo-cap suit up one last time would be easy and could be done without causing much of a media stir. Between when we last saw him in An Unexpected Journey (sad in a cave) to where he's first seen in The Lord Of The Rings (captive in Mordor) there's a lot of situations in which he could appear and with Jackson's love of multiple endings don't be surprised if one of those is Sméagol leaving the Misty Mountains.

4. What Will The Dwarves Actually Do In The Lake-town Attack?

In a big divergence from the story of the book (although logical given how cartoonish battles with thirteen protagonists looked in An Unexpected Journey), a small part of the company of Dwarves left in Laketown when Thorin and co. head to the Lonely Mountain. In the short term it allowed The Desolation Of Smaug to have a multi-stranded finale not just confined to the Lonely Mountain, but looking towards the third film it could have a much bigger impact. Picking up exactly where the previous film ended, The Battle Of The Five Armies' first act will probably be dominated by Smaug's attack on Lake-town. Having Fíli, Kíli, “in and Bofur in the low-rate Venice will no doubt give us some people on the ground to empathise with as fire and death rain down, but could they be a little more involved than just recognisable faces among the carnage while Bard fulfils his family's destiny? Like a very difficult video-game boss, Smaug has only one weakness (the loosened scale on his underbelly), which makes it hard for any other attacks on the dragon to not be fruitless padding. So yeah, we have literally no idea what Jackson has in store for these dwarves. Let's hope it's worth them not going to Erebor.

3. Will The Arkenstone Turn Thorin Mad?

Once Smaug is killed, Thorin locks himself in Erebor, refusing to share any of his treasures. In the book it was dragon-sickness (an in-universe word for the greed that a throne room full of gold inspires) that turned Thorin into (more of) an arsehole, but in the film there's the potential it could be something more complicated. There's a recurring theory among fans that the Arkenstone is actually one of the three Silmarils, bright gems of great power introduced in Tolkien's The Silmarilion. They're tied into the backstory of the Middle Earth and are fully explored in the mammoth tome, but for our purposes the important thing is that they can have a negative effect on those who desire them. Due to rights issues (he can't use elements solely from The Silmarilion) this possible connection can't be overtly stated, but it does feel like Jackson's suggesting it. We already know Thorin strongly desires the gem and have seen in the introduction of An Unexpected Journey the extents Thrór went to reclaim the gem upon Smaug's attack, so could this attraction be part of what makes the dwarve King act so selfishly? The films have positioned in him more of an Aragorn role, so a mystical explanation of why he does some bad things would help keep him a noble character.

2. Will We See Balin Reclaim Moria?

One of the most consistent (and in our eyes totally unfair) criticisms of The Return Of The King is the sheer number of endings. After the Ring is destroyed and good has triumphed over evil there's still another fifteen minutes of loose end tying, from Aragorn becoming King to Sam becoming a family man. If you were one of those complainers get ready; there's doubt Jackson will stuff the ending his final Hobbit with the same number of arse-numbing diversions. There is, after all, a lot more for The Battle Of The Five Armies to settle than its print counterpart. Positioning The Hobbit as an all-out prequel to The Lord Of The Rings (instead of the basic predecessor the book was) means plenty of plot points need some resolution to appease fans/avoid confusion for general audiences. So expect to see Mordor rising and the dwarves settling into their old home. One possible ending we'd love to see, however, veers to the unlikely side - the dwarves reclaiming of Moria. Following on from the events at the Lonely Mountain, the mines are taken back by a group of dwarves led by Balin, Thorin's white-bearded second-in-command. We know from The Fellowship Of The Ring that peace doesn't last too long (it's once again overran by orcs come The Lord Of The Rings), but seeing the dwarves take up residence in the mines would serve to make that scene more resonant. Jackson has already brought big battles from outside the timeline of The Hobbit (the original Battle of Moria for one) in the films, so one reaching closer to Rings would be cool to see.

1. Will Jackson Explain The Eagles Plot Hole?

It's the biggest joke about the whole series; why don't the giant eagles fly Frodo and the One Ring to Mordor, cutting out much of the strife that filled the original trilogy? And while some fans will defend this oversight (that even Tolkien himself recognised was an issue) by stating the eagles aren't slaves and make their own decisions, that argument doesn't really hold water. Ignoring the holes in that argument (having free will doesn't mean the eagles would simply let all of their world succumb to evil instead of doing as Gandalf asks), the simple reason it's so hard to swallow is that the films never even try to address it. The eagles are so useful as a plot device, but presenting them without rules turns much of the trekking (which makes up a good chunk of the movies) into a bit of a middle finger. All it takes is for Gandalf to give a couple of lines of dialogue explaining their society and a decades worth of jokes would disappear. Some expect a verbal explanation in An Unexpected Journey (in the books the eagles, like most animals, can talk), but instead the giant birds' appearance only served to further complicate things. Could Jackson use his last foray into Middle Earth (until he gets the rights to the Silmarilion and turns that into a ten-part epic) to finally explain away the most dogged narrative criticism of his films? We'd really like that, although deep down we know he probably won't. What burning questions do you have about The Battle Of The Five Armies? What do you expect to happen? Get the Middle Earth discussion started down below.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.