Hold The Dark Review: 4 Ups & 3 Downs

A cold, forbidding thriller... at least half the time.

Hold The Dark Poster
Netflix

For the past month or so, the trailer Netflix released for their new feature, Hold The Dark, set the mood for the exciting, dark, atmospheric thriller they were marketing. With screenings at the prestigious Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) putting Netflix's production logo on the festival big screen, audiences were certainly eager to see which side of the quality line this particular release fell on.

Not quite living up to the hype, but still worth the price of admission, Netflix's Hold The Dark, based on a book of the same name by William Giraldi, is a mixed bag of "excellent where it's good and insultingly bad where it fails", and in early reviews is as likely to be eviscerated as it is to be lauded. Despite this, there are certain elements in the film that seemingly everyone can agree were done right.

Whether it's the "worst good movie" or "best bad movie" is still up for debate, but here's a more definitive look at what about this thriller is making it so divisive.

Spoilers for parts of the film will be discussed ahead.

First, the negatives...

Downs

3. Mysteries Remain Unanswered And The Ending Feels Unsatisfying

Hold The Dark - Medora Sloane
Netflix

The thing about mysteries, especially mystery films, is that even when some questions are left unanswered, there should still be some satisfaction and resolution to the ending.

Unfortunately, apart from certain likeable people surviving a gruesome massacre by some violent characters on the quest for revenge, there was no satisfaction to be had from the ending, which felt largely unearned.

Despite many subtle moments in the story cluing into character motivations within the story, especially the motivations of its murderers, the end still has undeserving people getting their happy (with a question mark) ending while entirely innocent characters get shafted for no apparent reason, thereby rendering every single murder after the first one completely pointless.

And whether or not that was the entire point of the film—to have undeserving, unsympathetic characters triumph over others—it did very little to justify it in the midst of all the senseless, and eventually pointless, murder.

While the fact that the film feels like a condensed Netflix mini-series isn't necessarily to its detriment, one might wonder why the ending feels like a setup for a new season they're not sure has been greenlit.


2. The Film Tries (And Fails) To Equate Murder To Nature

Hold The Dark - Wolves
Netflix

With the constant comparisons made between wild wolves and the film's human killers, it feels like the narrative is trying very hard to frame these characters as majestic and mysterious wild humans, instead of the murderers of innocent randos that they are within the film. While murder likened to nature has been done before (NBC's Hannibal comes to mind), it... didn't quite work here.

One killed a child with no explanation beyond "the outside gets to you", while the other murders random people who may or may not get in the way of a planned revenge-murder that ended up not happening anyway, making all the other mass murder committed to get to there utterly pointless.

With the movie giving the audience little to empathise with in the characters it tried to elevate, the story ends up feeling self-serious without any self-awareness.

And despite all the wolf-imagery and wolf behaviour being referenced in the film, there is very little about the murderers in the film—who kill others for vague or paper-thin reasons—that reminds any person with access to Google in 2018 of wolves, pack-oriented animals who kill without malice, simply to eat and survive.


1. A Slow-Burn Mystery Turns Into A Senseless Gorefest

Hold The Dark - Murder
Netflix

Though Alexander Skarsgard's introduction as soldier and father Vernon Sloane showed his cold, murderous approach and added to the madness already portrayed by his wife, the movie took way more time showing him kill various randos than actually exploring the mysteries it set up in the first half.

Disappointing, considering how the effective and gripping atmosphere of the film seemed to take a back seat as soon as he began his quest for revenge, with Julian Black Antelope's Cheeon "buying him time" with... more murder.

Even though the first kills are shocking and visceral, by the end there's very little tension involved in whether or not Vernon is going to kill someone. Because his choice of who to kill came down to "everyone annoyed him or who might get in his way, maybe", treating death like an action hero would treat a punch to the face, the murders showed themselves to be as senseless as Vernon's entire revenge arc by the end.

Though the action itself was as cold and calculated as the one inflicting it, the body count became less horrifying and more trite as it rose, dramatic tension sucked away by Vernon's lack of discernment.

And now on to the positives...


Ups

4. The First Half

Hold The Dark - Buffalo
Netflix

The entire first half of the film feels like the great movie it was meant to be—quiet, cold, full of mounting dread, and a mystery that viewers were almost afraid to solve, with a creeping madness in Riley Keough's Medora Sloane that elevated the material, giving it a surreal edge.

It also benefited from being the first half, since most of the questions introduced and posed in the film had yet to be answered, something that only made the last half of the film unsatisfying.

From the strange and perceptive old native woman to the urgent, but largely unsurprised reactions of the villagers to finding a dead body after the deaths of two other children, to Medora Sloane whispering to herself about what was outside the window and accosting Russell Core in the dead of night, and even the equally isolating yet opposing introduction of Vernon Sloane as a soldier in the desert—everything about the first half is poetry in form and motion, the dialogue exchanged between Medora Sloane and Core in the beginning as unnerving as the atmosphere and acting.


3. The Acting

Hold The Dark - Medora Sloane
Netflix

Despite the script being a bit odd in some parts, every role was well-acted, most of the characters, despite many having minor roles, feeling like they had more to them than what was shown onscreen.

Riley Keough played the sympathetic yet unsettling Medora Sloane fantastically, with Jeffrey Wright adding a comforting and enduring humanity to every increasingly terrifying situation he was in. Alexander Skarsgård played the sympathetic yet stoic, largely unfeeling Vernon Sloane effectively, making him a dreaded figure.

James Badge-Dale's Inspector Donald Marium was a great, likeable and kindly heroic figure, and characters such as the old village woman Illanaq, by the compelling Tantoo Cardinal, and Sloane's best friend Cheeon, played by Julian Black Antelope, had enormous presence in their scenes, with intriguing backstories that could have been further explored given more time and attention.

Even the minor characters got to shine, with the few police in the area being sympathetic people, unprepared for the horror they had to face in one of the film's bloodiest scenes.

Though the film had its ups and downs, the performances within were well-done, living up to, and in some case even elevating the material provided in the script.


2. Jeffrey Wright And James Badge-Dale Are Great

Hold The Dark - Russell Core
Netflix

Despite not being the driving force of the movie's main action, but being present for most of it, Wright's wildlife writer Russell Core gives the audience a deeply sympathetic lead, who acts the perfect observer to increasingly insane events unfolding around him.

His look and presence are solid and strong, while also being vulnerable, something that hearkens back to his background as a man who survived around wild wolves by killing one, having "no choice" but holding no anger, and a deep love for the animals.

Though he's capable of taking care of himself, there are much more dangerous elements surrounding him, and his ability to survive it, even in his advanced age, is something the audience will easily love him for.

As a policeman who feels much like a hero in the story, despite Wright's Russel Core being the lead for most of the film, James Badge Dale plays a likeable, smart, kindly figure in Donald Marium, whose presence in the film's gorier parts gave it more weight.

For the latter half of the film, Marium and Core make a great team, their stories compelling and making for more sympathetic protagonists than the murderous Sloane.


1. The Atmosphere

Hold The Dark 6 Overhead Shot
Netflix

The silence that permeated the film, undercut only by the forbidding sound of cold wind in the backdrop, allowed the film to drop both Jeffrey Wright's Russel Core, as well as the audience, into the harsh Alaskan landscape, the madness seeping into Sloane and seen in the desperate wolves almost its own character, like a monster hiding in the trees.

One of the greatest elements of Hold The Dark, and one that is consistently lauded by fans and detractors alike, is the atmosphere set by the isolated yet vast arctic landscape of Alaska, and the wildlife therein. The film utilises its setting effectively, with visually beautiful shots coupled with sound design that made the quiet of the sparsely populated area almost its own character. The madness in the Sloanes, though manifesting differently between the wife and the husband, was palpable whenever they were onscreen.

Despite having long stretches of time with no dialogue whatsoever, the film never felt boring, with the inexplicable dread permeating nearly every scene. Even when the silence was broken by some of the film's more action-heavy moments, the dread set by its atmosphere never truly went away.

What did you think of Hold The Dark? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

Writer, artist, professional animator. Indie comics and Hi Nay podcast creator. Queer Filipino storyteller || @MotzieD on Twitter || Originally from Quezon City, The Philippines. Currently based in Toronto, Canada || motziedapul.com || hinaypod.com