Holmes & Watson Review: 2 Ups & 6 Downs

A last-minute 2018 dumpster fire.

Holmes And Watson Will Ferrell John C Reilly
Sony

To the surprise of few, the Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly-starring Sherlock Holmes spoof Holmes & Watson hasn't exactly been winning raves from critics.

If the laughless trailers didn't tip you off, then the lack of press screenings and subsequent scathing reviews sure will. With near-universal critical disdain and a surprisingly low "D+" CinemaScore from audiences, it's fair to call the movie a complete and utter bust.

Reports have since emerged that the film tested so poorly with audiences that Sony attempted to sell it to Netflix, yet even the streaming platform turned it down. And though Netflix doesn't exactly boast high standards for their content acquisitions, it's easy to see why they weren't interested in this one.

A shockingly inept squandering of an actually pretty neat concept, Holmes & Watson is one of the most shambolic holiday duds of the last few years and a mind-bogglingly awful effort for its central comic duo...


Downs...

6. Will Ferrell & John C. Reilly's Oddly Charmless Pairing

Holmes And Watson Will Ferrell John C Reilly
Sony

Though the trailers sure didn't look good, the pairing of Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly should've at least been good for a few laughs, right? After all, at its worst this'll basically be Step Brothers mated with Sherlock Holmes, right?

Wrong. Despite the strength of Ferrell and Reilly's prior pairings, there's a bizarre lack of charm and fun to their portrayals here, bringing little more to the table than some dodgy English accents and a lot of obnoxious shouting.

The magic of their previous collaborations is almost entirely absent, with both actors looking as though they wandered on set without rehearsing their lines and just ad-libbed their way through.

Reilly just barely registers the occasional note, but Ferrell is a complete flat-line, and together, they can wring depressingly few laughs out of the set-up.


5. The Neutered PG-13 Rating

Holmes And Watson Will Ferrell John C Reilly
Sony

When a movie is basically sold as "Step Brothers but Sherlock Holmes", it would certainly help if that movie had the same audience rating as its inspiration.

After all, where would Step Brothers be without an R rating? We wouldn't have the F***in' Catalina Wine Mixer or many of the movie's other unforgettable gags, yet Holmes & Watson instead tones things down for a family-friendly PG-13 rating.

Given the movie's often-jarring editing, one suspects it was shot with an R in mind and trimmed down in the desperate hope of salvaging its box office, but the result is a disappointingly tame film that can't even coast on basic vulgarity or shock value.

Considering the comedic potential in exploring the depravity of Victorian London - namely Holmes' well-noted love of cocaine, which is only fleetingly referenced here - it seems like a wildly missed opportunity to aim towards the family demographic.

A bad movie is still a bad movie at the end of the day, but at least with some profanity, nudity and violence, Holmes & Watson might've felt a little less safe and stale.


4. It's An Insanely Lazy Sherlock Holmes Spoof

Holmes And Watson Will Ferrell John C Reilly
Sony

If you were (somehow) hoping for the movie to be anything more than the most basic, surface-deep Sherlock Holmes spoof, prepare to be disappointed.

So broad and simplistic even the most casual Sherlock fans will likely find it dull and unimaginative, there's little in the way of cleverness or creativity here, with Etan Cohen's script instead dining out on all the well-trod Holmes tropes.

Inevitably, we get a sequence parodying the slow-motion action of Guy Ritchie's Holmes films, yet without presenting anything subversive or basically funny, it's pretty much just a soulless rehash of Ritchie's style.

Lacking the nuance that would make it appealing to actual Sherlock fans, this might've been a cute idea for a 5-minute Funny or Die sketch, but there's little to sustain it at feature length.


3. The Awful Timely "Humour"

Holmes And Watson Will Ferrell John C Reilly
Sony

Because Holmes & Watson is a movie releasing in 2018, it of course has to be filled with "ironic" contemporary humour rather than just committing to its period.

In addition to the abundance of incongruous modern music, there's a cringe-worthy gag in which the duo takes a selfie with Queen Victoria (Pam Ferris), and Rebecca Hall's doctor character makes frequent, embarrassingly on-the-nose references to Donald Trump, while mocking the American political system and their definition of "freedom."

This is one of those movies that clearly should've existed in a comedic vacuum, but instead it strains itself to feel current and ends up not only seeming desperate but also instantly dating itself in the process.


2. It Wastes An Incredible Cast

Holmes And Watson Ralph Fiennes
Sony

It's hard to think of a movie this badly reviewed with a cast this great since the similarly shambolic Movie 43.

Counting the incredible likes of Ralph Fiennes, Kelly Macdonald, Rebecca Hall, Lauren Lapkus, Steve Coogan, Rob Brydon and Hugh Laurie among its supporting cast, it is an embarrassment of riches for a movie that's basically just an embarrassment.

Granted, the film would be even worse without their contributions, but for the most part the roles are pure duds, evoking the easy whiff of a fast paycheck given the conspicuously low number of scenes most of the actors (especially Fiennes) are actually in.

Even accepting the obvious financial incentive, though, it's baffling that so many A+ performers were roped into such a blatantly low-rent project.

Thankfully the actors don't disgrace their dignity too much, but they'll most likely appreciate that few will still remember this one in a couple of weeks.


1. Etan Cohen's Terrible Direction

Holmes And Watson Will Ferrell
Sony

In addition to his awful script, Etan Cohen (Get Hard) confirms with his second directorial effort that he should stick to writing screenplays.

In a year that offered up visually compelling comedies such as Game Night and Blockers, Holmes & Watson's workmanlike lack of visual flair just doesn't cut it.

In addition to the boring, shot-reverse-shot direction, countless scenes have re-dubbing blatantly visible - especially those involving Kelly Macdonald - and with this being the first Ferrell-Reilly team-up not directed by Adam McKay, his presence is sorely missed.

There's nothing basically appealing or fun about the way scenes are put together, forcing even those few moments that do work to fight against the comatose direction.

Holmes & Watson is an undeniable failure, then. But there are a couple of positives which just barely prevent it from being the very worst film of 2018...


Ups...

2. The Boxing Scene Is Genuinely Funny

Braun Strowman Holmes And Watson
Columbia Pictures

There's a single set-piece in the film that actually evokes a few honest laughs, and that's when Holmes ends up at a boxing arena facing off against WWE superstar Braun Strowman (who, amusingly enough, is named "Brawn" here).

The sequence also features a fun cameo from a hook-handed Steve Coogan, a decent joke about PPV sports and male bonding rituals, and blink-and-you'll-miss-them appearances from legendary combat ring announcers Michael and Bruce Buffer.

It's hardly the epitome of smart comedy, but it's a rare scene in the movie where all the elements of filmmaking are actually trying and manage to come together somewhat successfully.


1. It's Mercifully Short

Holmes And Watson Will Ferrell John C Reilly
Sony

It's an undeniably back-handed compliment, but at just 90 minutes in length, Holmes & Watson at least doesn't drag on for an unreasonable length of time.

In its most mild defence, it moves fast and generally doesn't linger on one dud gag for too long (admittedly before simply moving onto the next dud).

Sans credits it's barely 80 minutes of your life, and for the most part it's easy enough to just sit back and soak in the awfulness, rather than end up exhausted by a two-hour barrage of "comedy."

If you want something to serve as white noise while you clean the house, this is the perfect film for that. A ringing endorsement if there ever was one, obviously.

What did you think of Holmes & Watson? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.