How Every Robin Can Appear In The Batman 2

Matt Reeves can build an instant Bat-Family!

The Batman 2 Robins
Warner Bros./DC Comics

The Batman was a huge success and has already been greenlit for a sequel. With that greenlight has come the hotly debated subject of Robin's inclusion in the next film.

With the themes and story dynamics of the first film, it only makes sense to include Robin in the second. This Batman not only works well with a partner but has a newfound ambition to inspire as a symbol of hope. These elements make the introduction of Robin feel inevitable.

So, it's not a question of if, but more how the next film will include the Boy Wonder and which Robin it will be. Conventional wisdom would tell us that it will be Dick Grayson, as he was the original. However, movies often take liberties depending on the story they want to tell and what's most popular at the time. By this standard, any of the Robins might be on the table.

Interestingly, the comics have already provided an answer to how every Robin could be present in The Batman 2 while perfectly matching the established tone. This approach, while very different to what fans expect, could make for the perfect sequel.

9. We Are Robin

We Are Robin
DC Comics

The most organic approach to bringing in a cinematic Robin that would gel with The Batman's tone is to borrow from Lee Bermejo's 2015 series, "We Are Robin". There, Robin was expanded from one individual into a youth vigilante movement.

This tale follows the adventures of a team of untrained teenage vigilantes who form in the wake of the real Batman's disappearance and replacement by a cop (Jim Gordon) in a mech suit. His dismissal of the teens leaves them both confused and defiant, choosing to act largely on their own and now distrustful of their few adult allies.

By The Batman's end, the Caped Crusader's new goal (after inspiring terrorists) is to transition from a symbol of fear into something more hopeful. The consequence is that while he may no longer inspire wackos he now sets himself up as an example to kids who will want to be just like him.

If Robin isn't just one kid but an entire gang of teen crimefighters, the opportunities for who can be Robin open up. Dick Grayson, Jason Todd, Tim Drake, Carrie Kelley, Stephanie Brown and anyone else who's called themselves Robin might be in the sequel.

Should the next movie adopt "We Are Robin" as it's model, it would also solve the problem of tonal shift. Introducing one colorfully costumed kid fighting at Batman's side might be a lot more distracting than if through the course of the film he encounters and takes charge of a gang working against the same enemy.


8. Mystery Approach

Batman Mystery Of The Batwoman
Warner Bros.

The challenge in introducing Robin is the threat that his presence might alter the tone of the film or that he could steal the show entirely. While nobody wants a repeat of the Schumacher films, Nolan's approach of toying with the idea but overly downplaying it is equally bad.

However, The Batman offers up the solution in it's own storytelling. If Robin (not unlike Riddler) is introduced as a mystery character operating independently of Batman, the audience once again gets to follow Bruce's POV as he pieces together the identity of his new ally while also dealing with the threat of the film's primary villain... whoever that turns out to be (*cough* Court of Owls *cough*)

A movie like this might be best served by drawing influence from 2003's animated "Mystery of The Batwoman"; a picture in which Batman has to uncover the identity of a reckless and unwanted new ally. Characters like Dick, Jason and Tim could be introduced throughout The Batman 2 and each be teased as possibly Robin before, like in the animated feature, they are revealed to be working as a group.

This mystery approach offers the chance to introduce most of the main Robins while preserving the detective elements and potentially sparing the audience the tedium of going through the motions of Robin's origin.


7. Damian Wayne

Damian Wayne Joker
DC Comics

Most versions of Robin could in some form be fairly easy to adapt to any upcoming film and, in the case of multiple Robins, potentially fit into a narrative with only limited lip service given to backstory. The same cant be said of Damian Wayne. His background has major implications for both the characters and the plot of any Batman film he might be a part of.

Bruce finding out that he's a father is a big deal. Fatherhood would necessarily become the driving force for his character development. Then bring in the League of Assassins stuff and Damian becomes the centre of the plot.

It all sounds great, but premature for the second film.

However, there is a way to include Damian in the next movie without making it about him. In "Robin: Son of Batman", it is revealed that the young Wayne spent a year doing missions for the League of Assassins in an initiation called the 'year of blood'. Adapting this plot and introducing him under an alias while on mission could work.

If, for instance, they were to run with the "We Are Robin" idea, Damian might be brought in as just another of the Robins. His true identity could be a fun reveal and would serve as perfect sequel bait. And if his alias happens to be a name fans will recognize like, say, Terry McGinnis, who was technically Bruce's biological son, it's just gravy.


6. Tim Drake

Batman Tim Drake Robin
DC Comics

Tim Drake is arguably the most popular Robin, being the character most identified with the role for an entire generation. If any Robin other than Dick was going to be brought into The Batman 2 as the singular Robin, Tim tops the list.

Starting off as the ultimate Batman fanboy, Drake is distinctive for being the one Robin who really went out of his way to get the Boy Wonder job by figuring out Batman's secret identity. Rather than being pulled by tragedy into the Caped Crusader's world, Tim inserted himself and the tragedies followed.

Tim Drake comes from a different background than other Robins, having more in common with Bruce as a child of privilege. When we meet him in "A Lonely Place of Dying", his parents are neglectful, leaving him largely unsupervised as they travel and eventually meet a sad fate. This would be a good element to preserve in an adaptation as it provides him the means and motivation to act independently in spite of his young age.

Tim's always been depicted as a child prodigy and a computer wiz kid. Both are traits which, for any scenario with multiple Robins in the sequel, define his likely role as the guy in the chair.

But as the Dark Knight's number one fan and a genius, Drake might just be the brains of the operation. He could even be the one who brings the Robins together and puts them on the trail of the movie's villain... whoever that might be (*cough* Court of Owls *cough*).


5. Jason Todd

Jason Todd Robin Death
DC Comics

Jason Todd, being a street kid with a chip on his shoulder, fits the concept of a Robin gang better than most. His tendencies towards recklessness and thuggery stand out as having a certain amount of dramatic potential.

In a team dynamic, Jason's the rebellious hothead, the Raphael of the group. He's the one who probably thinks he should be in charge and is willing to go a little bit over the line. He's also the character who doesn't make it out alive.

Jason famously dies in the classic '80s story "A Death In The Family," in which readers actually voted for him to kick the bucket. One criticism towards the idea of including Robin in any sequels, is that teenagers fighting crime is an inherently dangerous and reckless notion for the relatively grounded reality established by The Batman. For a Robin to actually die by the end of the movie would hammer home the idea that reckless actions can have consequences in this film setting.

Just as importantly, much the way that Troy's death in "We Are Robin" shook the team's resolve, Jason's death could serve the same function in a film narrative and force the surviving characters to make hard choices.

Of course, the introduction and subsequent killing of Jason in The Batman 2 would pave the way for a quick cinematic introduction of the Red Hood or Arkham Knight if they want to get funky.


4. Dick Grayson

Robin Dick Grayson DC Comics
DC Comics

Given his status as the original Robin, Dick Grayson is the foregone conclusion in the minds of many fans as the one and only Robin who should appear in The Batman's sequel. And in any by the numbers adaptation of Robin's origin, they would probably be correct.

However, if the film was to opt into the idea of more than one Robin, where exactly would Dick fit? The answer would likely still be very much at the centre of things. If there was going to be a variation of "We Are Robin", Dick would almost certainly be one of the main leaders and likely the character who gets the most screen time.

It would definitely be a bad idea to age Grayson up too much, as nobody wants a repeat of the Schumacher films. Still, in a scenario where he's part of a larger group of Robins, he'd probably be one of the older ones and fall around 16 or 17 years of age.

Your writer expects there wouldn't be much need to change Dick's backstory. In fact, starting him as Bruce's ward would offer up the entertaining possibility of them each leading a double life behind the other's back.


3. Other Robins

Carrie Kelly Robin
DC Comics

Many characters have donned the domino mask over the years outside of the primary four Robins. There are Robins who could rightly be expected never to appear in live-action, and in fact a few whose appearance even in animation would be unlikely. However, in a world in which The Batman's sequel treats its audience to not one Robin but several, a world in which that movie does take inspiration from "We Are Robin", all of these secondary Robins are actually on the table.

Fan favorites like Carrie Kelley from The Dark Knight Returns and Stephanie Brown - who is best known from her roles as Spoiler and Batgirl, but did briefly take on the identity of Robin - are high on the list. But in a situation in which there's a whole gang of Robins, even the most obscure versions could be in play as supporting characters.

There's the actual cast of We Are Robin to consider, as well as Elseworlds characters like Drake Winston from Batman 89 or Tris Plover from Legends Of The Dead Earth. It's even possible that truly obscure characters like Bruce's ill-fated and mostly forgotten ward Lance Bruner could show up.

While it may be a bit much to expect the robot Robin from DC 1000000, if codenames were to come into play, any version of the character could at least become an Easter egg.


2. A More Responsible Batman

Batman The Dark Knight Returns
DC Comics

Bringing in Robin has the unsavoury aspect of child endangerment. While easily glossed over in comics, it isn't a good look in a big screen adaptation. Likewise, aging the sidekick up tends to come off as awkward and forced.

One option is to lean into it. The Batman was never afraid to wear the weirdness on it's sleeve. Matt Reeves could put the unhealthy aspect of Batman indoctrinating a child into a dangerous lifestyle on the front page. But presenting Batman as a child abuser would make him a lot less likable, as evidenced by "All Star Batman And Robin The Boy Wonder" - a book which is infamous for (among other things) the Dark Knight's abusive treatment of Dick Grayson.

If a Batman-inspired gang of teens begins fighting crime on their own, Bruce is the more responsible party for taking them under his wing. Rather than putting minors in danger, he is taking charge of minors who choose to put themselves in danger and providing them with training, supervision and rules. Interestingly, this exact thing happens in "The Dark Knight Returns". The Robins in "We Are Robin" are similar to DKR's Sons of Batman, and it would make perfect sense for a movie adaptation to blend elements of both.

This also presents the opportunity to do the one thing Batman films love to do; shamelessly borrow from "The Dark Knight Returns". Imagine Batman on horseback, leading an army of youths through a city in chaos., but this time they wear Robin's colors.


1. Instant Bat Family

Bat Family Detective Comics 1000
DC Comics/Tony Daniel

One aspect of Batman lore which rarely makes it to the big screen is the Bat-Family. This is primarily because these kinds of movies tend to take the long approach, generally introducing no more than one or two major characters per outing. The last real attempt at building a Bat-Family came in the final breath of the Burton/Schumacher film franchise, and no real progress has been made to that end since we last saw Batman, Robin and Batgirl running towards the screen in the final shot of the franchise-killing "Batman and Robin" in 1997.

The great thing about a gang is that it has a lot of members. Likewise, a youth movement is going to have a lot of supporters. In short, if Matt Reeves does decide to take inspiration from "We Are Robin", the movie doesn't need to stop at only bringing in the canonical Robins.

Barbara Gordon (Batgirl), Helena Bertinelli (Huntress), Cassandra Cain (Orphan) and Jean-Paul Valley (Azrael) are just a few additional characters who could be introduced, but the potential extends to bringing in almost any character who has ever allied with Batman

This idea could also include characters like Stephanie Brown, Dick Grayson, Jason Todd and Duke Thomas moving on from being Robins and taking on their new identities as Spoiler, Nightwing, Red Hood and Signal, respectively. The result of which is the organic development of a complete Bat-Family by the end of a single movie.


Batman Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Robins?

Tim Drake Robin
DC Comics

1. How Many Robins Have There Been In Canon?

2

3

4

5

Contributor

Early Ray Mixon hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.