How NOT To Make A Comic Book Movie (Why These 10 Failed)

Not all comic book movies are successful — most of them actually suck.

X-Men Apocalypse Singer Olivia Munn
Fox

These days, it seems every major blockbuster is based on a comic book property, and almost all of them rake in a billion or more at the global box office. Let's face it, comic book movies are easy money for studios these days, but that doesn't mean they are all created equally.

It's a sad fact that most comic book movies suck... and they suck hard. Some of the biggest box office bombs were based on one comic book or another, which just goes to show that there's a right way and a wrong way to make a comic book movie.

It's only recently that these sorts of movies could be considered well-made, but the past 40 years are speckled with a few good ones. Superman, Batman, and Blade are some early examples of good practices in making a comic book movie, but even those franchises went off the rails with their fourth, fourth, and third sequels, respectively.

The movies that do well should be studied by filmmakers, so they don't churn out the horrific crap that Hollywood has spewed out over the years. These ten films are some of the worst to have been inspired by a comic book, and they stand as examples of what NOT to do in adapting a comic book for the silver screen.

10. Redoing The Ending In A Rush - Dark Phoenix (2019)

X Men Dark Phoenix
Fox

2019's Dark Phoenix was the biggest box office bomb of the year it was released, and it ended up being a terrible adaptation of Chris Claremont and John Byrne's greatest story written for the comics. "The Dark Phoenix Saga" was one of the most important X-Men stories ever told, so this adaptation had to be amazing.

Of course, it wasn't, and it ended up being so far from the source material; few people even bothered to watch it after the reviews came out. The film suffered from several problems, but the biggest one was the ending, which was changed shortly before it was released.

The ending of the movie originally had one that was similar to the ending of an MCU movie (Civil War, as opposed to the assumed Captain Marvel), so the studio opted to reshoot the whole thing, so as not to be compared to the popular Marvel Studios film. If the script had only deviated from the script up to the ending, it might have worked, but changing it like that ruined the movie.

On its own, it's not incredibly terrible, but a lot of the plot elements seemed forced and unnecessary. The death of Mystique was meant to be a pivotal turning point, but they let that out in the trailers and ruined the surprise. That alone was a major problem, as the marketing for the movie only managed to push potential viewers away.

The movie cost $200 million to produce, and while it technically made a profit with a $252.4 million global box office haul, the marketing costs made it a $133 million loss for the studio.


9. Ignoring The Source Entirely - Supergirl (1984)

Supergirl Movie
Warner Bros.

Back in 1984, David Odell wrote a spin-off to the popular Superman films released in the late '70s and early 1980s. The movie that was produced was set within the world of that Superman, but the film delivered a world unlike any seen in either of the Superman films or the comics featuring Supergirl.

There were some aspects of the character that did make it to film, but the overall adaptation dropped a lot of what makes Kara Zor-El special. The film is set after the events of Superman III, which apparently had Superman taking care of a peacekeeping mission millions of light-years from Earth.

While that minor detail met with no explanation, Supergirl arrives on Earth from a pocket dimension hosting the survivors of Krypton in what is called Argo City. When the Omegahedron, which is a powerful artifact that powers the city, goes missing, Kara is given leave to find it.

On Earth, she somewhat falls into the role she had in the books (with some changes), but the biggest issue with the story was that the Omegahedron landed in the hands of Selena, a witch who used its power to do all sorts of weird magical silliness, including summoning a giant shadow demon to defeat Supergirl.

Supergirl is what her name suggests; she's basically a female version of Superman. Like the Man of Steel, she tends to handle big threats and having her fight a magical witch to recover something called the Omegahedron didn't make a lot of sense. It's completely dissimilar to the comics, and the fans who watched it weren't impressed.


8. Hiring A Director Who Checked Out Halfway Through - X-Men: Apocalypse (2016)

X Men Apocalypse Oscar Isaac
Fox

When X-Men: First Class was released, it seemed as if the inconceivable timeline and poorly adapted previous films were a thing of the past. Unfortunately, as the franchise drove on, it attempted to adapt one of the biggest plotlines and characters related to the X-Men franchise: Apocalypse.

The Age of Apocalypse storyline from the comics is one of the best-written story arcs around, but the adaptation that was released in 2016 had some serious problems, many of which came about during filming, while other problems related to how it was adapted from the comics.

Olivia Munn, who played Psylocke, gave an interview to Variety, where she pointed out several issues that occurred during filming. Her biggest concern was how men and women were treated differently during filming, and she pointed her finger straight at the man in charge, director Bryan Singer.

"...It seems strange that Bryan Singer could check out and say he had a thyroid issue. Instead of going to a doctor in Montreal, [...] he said he had to go to L.A. And he was gone for about 10 days is my recollection. And he said, ‘Continue. Keep filming.’ We’d be on set, I remember there’s a big scene that we’d have, and we’d come back from lunch, and then one of Bryan’s assistants would come up and show us a cell phone with a text message on it. And he texted to the actors, ‘Hey guys. I’m busy right now. But just go ahead and start filming without me.’”

If the person who is responsible for directing a film leaves his job to his support staff for almost two weeks, you're going to end up with a film that fails to meet expectations.


7. Misunderstanding Your Lead Character - Judge Dredd (1995)

Judge Dredd Stallone
Buena Vista Pictures

Back in 1995, Sylvester Stallone hopped onto a project that "adapted" Judge Dredd from his popular British comic 2000 AD. There are a lot of independent comic book characters who are popular, but Dredd is easily the one most people know, as he's been around since 1977, and has a huge fan base.

This movie failed for more than one reason, but if it had to be drilled down to only one, it would be the almost complete abandonment of the source material. Stallone couldn't do the film and keep his helmet on, which is something the fans of the comics couldn't accept.

Here's something the filmmakers should have known going into this thing, and it's something any fan of the comics will tell you: Judge Dredd never takes off his helmet. Even if he does it in the comics, his face is always obscured. Judge Dredd is one of the only comic book characters fans don't even know what he looks like, but what they do know is, he doesn't look like Sylvester Stallone.

Other than the obvious helmet issue, the movie jammed an unnecessary romance into the plot, featured humor and a comic-relief in Rob Schneider that seemed alien to the setting, and the acting was about as over-the-top as possible. If this movie could be described with one word, it would be "overacted."


6. Choosing A Subject No-One Cares About - Jonah Hex (2010)

Jonah Hex Josh Brolin
Warner Bros. Pictures

Two years after Marvel Studios launched with Iron Man and the Incredible Hulk, DC gave one of its characters a shot with Jonah Hex in 2010. The film starred Josh Brolin as the titular character, John Malkovich, Megan Fox, Michael Fassbender, Will Arnett, and Michael Shannon, so it had a great cast.

Why would a movie about a comic book character with an all-star cast fail completely? The main problem with Jonah Hex is that he's not a popular character outside of comics. Even in the world of comics, he's niche, and there aren't that many people clamoring to see him adapted to the silver screen.

The same could have been said of Blade when his first movie dropped in 1998, but the biggest difference between those two films is that where Blade was good, Jonah Hex was disturbingly awful. The acting in this movie wasn't the problem, as everyone involved gave it their all, but there really wasn't much to work with.

The movie is weirdly short, coming in at only 81 minutes (with credits), so it seems rushed and incomplete. The plot jumps around from point to point in a way that leaves the audience wondering what the hell they are watching, and ultimately, the film was so bad, DC opted to reboot it.

Jonah Hex was a disastrous box office bomb as well, having made just shy of $11 million on a budget of nearly $50 million.


5. Using A Terrible Script - Tank Girl (1995)

Tank Girl Lori Petty
United Artists

Tank Girl is a popular independent comic book created by Jammie Hewlett and Alan Martin back in 1988. The titular character lives in a tank and takes on various missions before getting labeled as an outlaw for her sexual inclinations and drug use. It's a fun book, and it was well written and illustrated.

A movie based on the character could have been great, but unfortunately, the one we got in 1995 wasn't just a bad adaptation, it was a bad movie overall. The dialogue relied heavily on one-liners, and they aren't particularly punny if you get out meaning.

Another problem the movie faced was that the character and comics had a cult following, which meant that the already-present fan base was relatively small compared to other comic book properties like Superman and Batman. To combat this, the movie needed to appeal to a wider audience, but everything done to achieve this only made the movie seem cheap and cheesy.

One thing this movie did remarkably well was the soundtrack, and while that makes for a great album sale, it shouldn't be the sole focus of the film. Compared to a movie like The Crow, which also had a compelling soundtrack and a smaller comic book fan base, Tank Girl failed to find the right mix by relying too much on the music and less on the story and dialogue.


4. Hiring A Ludicrous Lead - Steel (1997)

Steel Movie
Warner Bros.

Do you remember when Shaquille O'Neal starred in a Warner Bros. Superman-esque movie in the late '90s? If you do, you and Shaq may be the only two, because hardly anyone saw it in the theaters or bothered to watch it since it was released in 1997.

In the comics, Steel is John Henry Irons, a former weapons designer who decided to create an Iron Man-type suit of armor, so he could fill the gap of superheroism left following the (apparent) death of Superman. The character was one of the few fans liked in those dark times of overproduction, and a movie of Steel could have worked.

Sadly, it didn't. The movie was put together on a relatively small budget of only $16 million, and it managed to pull in a paltry $1.7 million, which actually seems like a lot, seeing as this movie was celluloid trash. One of the biggest problems with this film is the man they picked to star in the titular role.

Shaq could certainly dunk, but that didn't make him a good actor. He's showed up in several films as a side-character, and that works, but don't cast him in a role like this just because he physically fits inside the suit. The acting in this movie is horrendous, and it's hard to watch as a result — it's as simple as that.


3. Alienating The Fanbase Entirely - Catwoman (2004)

Catwoman Halle Berry
Warner Bros. Pictures

When Catwoman was released in 2004, it emerged from more than a decade of development hell, and it should have stayed there. It was initially going to star Michelle Pfeiffer with Tim Burton on to direct, but that eventually fell through, and after people were brought on, it eventually landed on Halle Berry to star as Catwoman.

If you've ever read a single issue of a Catwoman comic... no, scratch that; if you've ever read a comic book of any kind that contained a depiction of Catwoman, you wouldn't recognize her in this movie. The main reason why this film failed was due to a complete abandonment of the source material.

Literally, everything about Catwoman was stripped out and redone, and it completely destroyed this film. Catwoman was no longer Selina Kyle, she was Patience Phillips, and she got an overhauled origin story as well. It can't be stressed enough: this movie has nothing to do with the DC Comics character.

When you develop a comic book movie, it's important to remember that there's already an eager group of fans ready and willing to see it. When you alienate them completely and deliver a sub-par film, it's going to fail. Catwoman cost around $100 million to make, and it only made $82.1 million at the global box office.

The film was so bad, Berry knew it, which is why she is one of the few stars to ever show up and claim a Razzie. When she stood at the podium, accepting the award, she said, "I want to thank Warner Bros. for casting me in this piece-of-s***, god-awful movie."


2. Not Getting The Tone - Howard The Duck (1986)

It's a tough call between what's more embarrassing for Lea Thompson - Jaws 3D or Howard The Duck
Universal Pictures

Back in 1986, Marvel and Lucasfilm did something weird: they made a movie adaptation of Howard the Duck. The character had been around since 1973, and he was mostly a satirical character, but more importantly, there wasn't a huge fan-base that demanded a movie be made about him.

Regardless, they pushed through and created a film that's as strange as it is awful. It's definitely one of those movies that's so bad, it's good... or at least, so bad, you have to watch it at least once to see what passed for an acceptable movie pitch in the mid-1980s.

The film has several funny points, but it's mostly off-putting due to the implied romantic relationship between the titular duck and Lea Thompson's character, Beverly Switzler. One scene, in particular, has the couple in a bed with a sheet showing only their shadows, and if you weren't creeped out by that, you should talk to a professional.

Bestiality issues aside, the plot is convoluted and strange, though the acting in it wasn't horrible. The Howard the Duck effects and other special effects used throughout the film were what you'd expect out of Lucasfilm, and it did star Lea Thompson, Tim Robbins, and Jeffrey Jones.

Still, a bad movie is a bad movie no matter who's in it, and Howard the Duck is arguably a terrible film. It won four Razzie awards and only made $15 million off a budget of $37 million.


1. Chasing Cheese (And Money) Too Much - Batman & Robin (1997)

Batman & Robin
Warner Bros.

If you were to say the words "infamous" and "comic book movie" at a party, odds are, someone would ask you if you're talking about Batman & Robin. The movie is the very definition of what NOT to do when making a comic book movie adaptation, and it was a complete bomb.

The movie failed for a number of reasons, including the presence of far too many villains, a ridiculously unbelievable plot, cheesy dialogue, ridiculously obvious product placement, and worst of all, Bat-Nipples. Yes, the costume department felt it was necessary to outline nipples on Batman's chest, making it impossible to take this movie seriously.

The dialogue was a key issue with fans, as it was little more than a thousand one-liners strung together, one after the other. Arnold Schwarzenegger may have played a decent Mr. Freeze if he had something normal to say, but his terrible puns were so bad, people walked out of the theater.

Frankly, there's a lot that could be said as to why this movie failed, but above all, it didn't respect the fans in any way. The various changes and complete lack of anything even remotely serious showed the audience that the filmmakers weren't interested in entertaining them; they seemed only interested in pissing them off.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Dark Phoenix
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jonathan is a graphic artist, illustrator, writer, and game designer. Jonathan retired from the U.S. Army in 2017 and enjoys researching and writing about history, science, theology, and many other subjects. He writes for ScreenRant, CBR, NerdBastards, Listverse, Ranker, WhatCulture, and many other sites online. You can check out his latest on Twitter: @TalkingBull or on his blog: jonathanhkantor.com