How Scream 4 Should Have Ended (And What Came Next)

Could Scream 5 have taken Ghostface into new territory?

Scream 4 Ending
Dimension

It may be hard to imagine these days, but back in the early 90s, the horror genre was not as booming as it is today. The state of the genre was doomed to a feedback loop of churning out sequel after schlocky sequel of the three big franchises: Nightmare on Elm Street, Friday the Thirteenth, and Halloween.

Oh and there were those pesky Chuckies and Leprechauns running about, too. But general audiences and critics were not interested in these decidedly unfresh films that kept coming out. If horror was going to survive into the 21st century, the genre needed to find a way to bring general audiences back into the theatres. And as if by magic, in 1996, Scream did exactly that with its fresh new spin of meta-commentary, a whodunit approach, and of course all those likeable, cool characters such as Randy, Dewey, Gale, and Sydney.

Although Scream 2 is pretty much universally agreed to be one of the best sequels in the history of horror, Scream 3 aka “the Scooby-Doo one” seemed less like a real film and more like a parade of celebrity cameos. SERIOUSLY, was Jenny McCarthy actually in that movie?!

At that point, mercifully, the franchise was smart enough to know when it had worn its welcome and took a break for 11 years. Then the original creators behind the first film, screenwriter Kevin Williamson and director Wes Craven, got the band back together and Scream 4 promised to bring the franchise back for a new generation. Except what we got was a Lifetime movie passing as a Scream film. Did we really need nearly every female member of the cast to be wearing hair extensions? 2011 was such a different time.


3. What Went Wrong?

Scream 4
Dimension Films

Many, many, many factors contributed to the finished product of Scream 4 not being what Williamson originally intended. Nobody aside from those who worked on the film can tell us exactly what happened, but there is enough information out there that now we can perform a postmortem on the failed reboot.

Very early on in production, entertainment news outlets were reporting troubles on the set. Namely, actors Lake Bell and Lauren Graham both quit within the first week of production. We also know that Courtney Cox and David Arquette’s marriage was falling apart as the film was shooting. Cox cited Arquette’s partying with the younger cast members to be a point of conflict, and shortly after the film wrapped, Arquette went into rehab.

Meanwhile, Dimension studio head Bob Weinstein and Williamson were fighting over the screenplay, with Weinstein demanding changes. Inevitably, because you don’t fight mega producers and win, Williamson was released from his duties and replaced by Ehren Kruger, who had previously replaced Williamson on the third film in the series.

So what did Kruger add to the film? Well, Craven has stated that Kruger reworked the beginning and some dialogue throughout the film, but the most significant change Kruger made was to the film’s ending...


2. The Changes...

Scream 4 Jill
Dimension

Scream 4’s final act mirrors the final act of Scream 1, with the remaining teenagers carousing and watching scary movies at a house party. Ghostface picks off members of the party one by one until Sydney is the sole survivor and then the killers reveal their identities to her, tell her their motives and how they plan to get away with it. That’s how all three films in the series ended...

Except Scream 4 doesn’t end there. Instead there is a second climax in which Sydney, Gale, and Dewey face off against Jill, the surviving killer, in the hospital. This is a second, tacked-on climax that left many hardcore fans of the series scratching their heads.

It turns out the fans were 100 percent right to think something was wrong here. This entire hospital sequence was added after Williamson was fired from the film. This second climax served to solidify that Sydney survived and conquered Ghostface yet again. But this was not how it was originally supposed to go down.

Williamson’s script ended with Sheriff Dewey and first responders arriving at the scene of the bloodbath. Dewey stands over Sydney’s body and laments the sobering reality that he was not able to get there in time to save her, and the scream queen has finally been bested by Ghostface. Next, Dewey would find Sydney’s cousin, Jill, still alive and presume that she was the one to defeat the killers this time.

Williamson’s script did end with an ambiguous line, of a paramedic yelling into Dewey to tell him that one of the bloodied victims still had a pulse. The screenplay did not make it clear whether that victim hanging on by a thread would have been Sydney or one of the teenagers (perhaps it could have been fan favorite Kirby?).

So what would have come next?


1. Scream 5

Scream 4
Dimension

Now, here’s where the prospects for the rest of the series would have gotten interesting. There could have been two possible routes the next film would have taken: If Sydney did in fact die, then Scream 5 would have picked up a couple years later while Jill is living life as a full-fledged Kim Kardashian-level celebrity when someone else taking on the guise of Ghostface begins killing people around her and taunting her that he or she knows her secret.

Another route Scream 5 could have taken would have been if Sydney did survive, then she might have spent the period between films in a coma and Scream 5 would have dealt with her recovering, maybe having a touch of amnesia. Jill then would have needed to find a new partner to help her finish Sydney off before she recovered her memories of their showdown in Scream 4.

Both of those possible stories for Scream 5 sound like they could have dealt with some deeper issues, such as Jill’s ruthless pursuit of becoming famous, or Sydney dealing with post-traumatic stress and the repressed memory of her cousin nearly killing her. Regardless of which way the film went, it seems that Kevin Williamson and Wes Craven were eager to take the Scream saga into new territory.

But let’s posit something else. If this was the planned trajectory for Scream 5 and perhaps Scream 6, that means the role of main protagonist would have shifted from Sydney over to Jill, played by Emma Roberts. Roberts had up until this time appeared mostly in kids TV shows and movies. Scream 4 was supposed to be her breakout role into more adult content. This was still a few years before she teamed up with Ryan Murphy for Scream Queens and before she joined the ensemble of American Horror Story. She hadn’t quite proven her chops yet. Try rewatching Scream 4 and it’s hard not to criticize Roberts’ performance.

Among the other actors, her performance sticks out like a sore thumb, especially when she was totally outshone by Hayden Panettiere’s performance as Kirby, Jill’s best friend. Kirby was this headstrong female character who could go head-to-head with any Ghostface on horror trivia, which would have been pretty much a perfect new protagonist for the series. Sadly, Kirby met her end in the film and it was a shame to see her go.

Jill, by comparison, was largely underwritten and actually more annoying than anything. Roberts didn’t seem to be remotely invested in the role whatsoever. It’s like she didn’t know how to act in a Scream film - just listen to her awful Ghostface impression! In real life, Roberts has even stated in interviews that she had never even seen the original Scream.

So what if after shooting was well underway, Craven and the studio began to have buyer’s remorse? What if they determined Roberts was not capable of carrying the rest of the franchise on her shoulders, and that’s when they ordered the ending be rewritten?

Right now, with Craven’s untimely passing in 2015, and everything that’s happened with the Weinsteins and their production companies, the future of the series is up in the air. Perhaps the only way to bring Ghostface back to the big screen would be if a new writer and director came along and offered a treatment that would undo all of the sequels in the same fashion that David Gordon Green and Danny McBride did with last year’s Halloween.

So what do you think? Let us know which version of Scream 5 you would have liked to have seen and whether you think there is any hope for us getting any more Screams in the coming years.


Watch Next


Contributor

Kyle Mustain hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.