How The MCU Got So BIG
How did the highest-grossing film franchise of all time find its success?
"There was an idea... The idea was to bring together a group of remarkable people, see if they could become something more."
The Marvel Cinematic Universe has dominated 21st Century cinema, spawning 23 films over 11 years and raking in $22 billion in the worldwide box office. And that’s not counting the multitude of videogames, comics, and television spin-offs that have strengthened the MCU’s status.
It’s easy to harp on about Marvel’s accolades, adoring fanbase, and financial success, yet Marvel’s history hasn’t always been so peachy. In fact, the MCU’s creation was an unlikely rags-to-riches tale. In the early years, one misstep would have spelt the MCU’s end, and no one thought 2008’s Iron Man would birth a cinematic behemoth worth billions.
But with Iron Man’s success, Marvel could slowly outgrow its competitors to become the highest-grossing film franchise of all time. However, Marvel’s superiors (and the Disney overlords above them) didn’t stumble onto cinematic success by dumb luck. Okay, quite a bit of luck was involved.
Still, the vast risks taken and very meticulous planning sure helped establish the MCU as one of the most gripping, tightly bound cinematic stories of all time.
These dicey creative and business choices hold vital clues to how the MCU got so big. But to understand them, we have to go back to the very start – before Marvel Studios even existed...
9. Filing For Bankruptcy
Marvel wasn’t feeling so good in the 1990s. The comic industry had slumped, and Marvel was draining money. While Avi Arad headed Marvel Films, the company mainly made animated series, licensed characters to other companies, and made money off toy sales.
In August 1996, Marvel needed a
financial shake-up, and Marvel Films incorporated into Marvel Studios. This
didn’t stop Marvel from filing for bankruptcy just a few months later.
Marvel sold character cinematic rights to keep themselves afloat, including Blade, X-Men, Fantastic Four, and Spider-Man. However, these licensing deals only helped Marvel in the short-term.
While 1998’s Blade made over $70 million in the US, Marvel only received $25,000. X-Men was also a huge hit, making almost $300 million worldwide, but thanks to a flat-fee negotiation, Marvel got zilch.
Entering the new millennium, Marvel knew they had to do something drastic to keep the lights on.
And that’s when David Maisel, a corporate advisory agent, pitched a strange idea to Arad and Marvel CEO Issac Perlmutter: why don’t Marvel self-finance and self-produce their own movies, keeping 100% of the profit?
It was a solid idea, but Marvel had no cash to implement it. In a bold move, Marvel took out a loan of $525 million from the Merrill Lynch bank to make a maximum of ten films. The catch? If Marvel failed, they would lose the rights to ten of their intellectual properties, including Ant-Man, Black Panther, and The Avengers.
Here was Marvel’s challenge: make a smash-hit debut film, or lose everything. So, which character would Marvel choose to lead their charge on the superhero movie market?
8. Why Iron Man?
As luck would have it, Marvel received some good
news a few months after the Merrill Lynch deal: New Line Cinema’s Iron Man rights
had expired. In fact, many a film company missed out on bringing Iron Man to
the silver screen.
Since the 1970s, the Iron Man rights have been optioned to other companies. The 1990s saw the playboy billionaire passed between Universal, 20th Century Fox, and finally New Line Cinema.
Even when Marvel announced it would be their first independent feature, thirty writers passed on the opportunity. So why use this seemingly unwanted character to kick-off a cinematic universe?
Well, firstly, the successes of Fantastic Four and X-Men demonstrated cinema audiences were open to new characters.
With the superhero trend leaning towards serious, black-clad brooders, Tony Stark stood out with his golden-red suit and cheeky, bad boy attitude; he would set the tone for Marvel’s vibrant adventures. While Iron Man wasn’t the most well-known character, he would appeal to comic fans, who would be Marvel’s gateway into the mainstream market.
The production of Iron Man brought along many risks of its own. Jon Favreau wasn’t known for making superhero movies and caused a stir with Marvel executives with his casting choice of Robert Downey Jr. Many studios considered the actor untouchable due to his personal struggles.
Yet, Favreau remained adamant that Downey Jr was a perfect choice. Marvel gave Favreau a lot of free rein in his directional approach, and Jeff Bridges later described the film as a “$200 million student film.”
All these elements seem like a cocktail for disaster, but by Odin’s left eye did Iron Man beautifully pay off, making a $100m profit in the box office. Marvel Studios had done it!
7. Introducing Kevin Feige
Marvel’s horizons were wide open as they became a worthy filmmaking contender. Fortunately, Marvel had one man who was determined to make the most out of Marvel's box office breakthrough.
Let’s go back to the 1990s. Kevin Feige was an assistant working for Lauren Donner, teaching Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan how to use AOL in You’ve Got Mail.
Noting his deep passion for Marvel comics, Donner got Feige an associate producer role on the 2000 X-Men film, where he impressed Avi Arad with his Marvel knowledge. Arad took Feige on as his second-in-command.
In his newfound role, Feige oversaw all Marvel-related films, including the Fantastic Four series and Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy. Feige agreed with Maisel’s proposal that Marvel Studios should create their own movies. In 2018, Feige, reminiscing about Iron Man, said:
“We didn’t have anything to lose at that point, so it allowed us to just go with our instincts.”
Feige isn’t some corporate moneyman: he is exceptionally knowledgeable of Marvel’s world and characters. While Feige has stated that he never intended to make a cinematic universe, his expertise knowledge led to its conception.
When Avi Arad stepped down, Feige became the President of Marvel Studios, and since then, has worked on every major MCU instalment. In 2013, he won the Motion Picture Showman of the Year Award and is now the Chief Creative Officer for Marvel Comics, Television, and Animation.
Having one person supervise the franchise’s trajectory allowed for each film to flow into one another.
Feige’s creative vision has kept the MCU on-course by interweaving characters, stories, and important plot devices like the Infinity Stones. Feige's deep understanding of Marvel's lore is the MCU's backbone. As Jonathan Kuntz, a film lecturer, told TheWrap:
“Kevin Feige is doing the same thing Stan Lee did for the comic books in the ’60s; he keeps everyone on the same page.”
6. Disney's Acquisition
Love ’em or hate ’em, Disney knows how to sell a
franchise. After the success of Iron Man, Disney purchased Marvel Entertainment
for $4 billion. It sure has worked in Disney’s favour, as their investment has
now quadrupled in size.
Disney’s acquisition opened many new doors for Marvel, particularly in retaining control of their intellectual properties.
In 2010, Disney secured the distribution rights for The Avengers and Iron Man 3 from Paramount Pictures, and obtained Iron Man 1, Iron Man 2, Thor, and Captain America: The First Avenger distribution rights in 2013.
Most recently, they’ve acquired the Fantastic Four, X-Men and Deadpool rights from 21st Century Fox, which may shape much of the MCU’s future going into Phase Four.
With Disney’s backing, the MCU could take more risks with future films, and also spread its story outside the cinema. The Marvel Netflix series and Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. probably have Disney to thank for their TV spots.
Having these programmes for different audiences, like the more mature Daredevil and Jessica Jones, further established the series as a franchising giant.
Disney has even come swooping in to save the MCU from implosion. Prior to Captain America: Civil War’s release, Kevin Feige had a falling out with Marvel CEO Ike Perlmutter over budget.
With Perlmutter threatening to write Robert Downey Jr. Feige almost quit, but Disney took the situation into their hands by having Feige report directly to Alan Horn at Walt Disney Studios, instead of Perlmutter.
5. Assembling The Avengers
Feige grew up with Marvel Comics, and wanted to simulate the feeling that any character could suddenly appear in Marvel films like they could with each page turn of a comic.
Feige had the opportunity to realise that dream, as Marvel had reacquired all the rights of The Avengers. Black Widow was returned by Lionsgate shortly after the Merrill Lynch deal, with Hulk returning to Marvel after Universal’s 2003 Hulk film. The next step was in sight: build-up to an Avengers movie.
Release schedules were tight, with at least one film produced every year (bar 2009). Even if an Avenger didn’t get their own movie, they were at least introduced in another (e.g. Hawkeye in Thor).
On top of introducing characters, the first five films established vital world-building to help facilitate an Avengers crossover. On paper, a supernatural Thor and technological Iron Man don’t gel. So 2011’s Thor presented the Asgardians as an alien race, depicting their “magic” as more of an advanced technology.
Marvel’s colossal contracts signed actors up for unprecedented numbers of movie appearances to solidify future team-ups. Chris Evans, Mark Ruffalo, and Chris Hemsworth signed six-movie standard deals. Samuel L Jackson signed up for nine films as the one-eyed Nick Fury.
Keeping people in-house extended well beyond actors too. The Harvard Business Report summarised an average of 25% of a Marvel film’s core creative group overlapped from one film to another, with an average of 14% for the full crew.
With the Avengers introduced, Joss Whedon was the perfect director choice for an Avengers movie.
Despite The Avengers being his second feature film directing, his television experience proved he could bring together diverse casts of characters, like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Firefly. He had also worked with Marvel in the past creating the Astonishing X-Men comics.
With his expertise, a star-studded cast, and four years of story-telling preceding it, The Avengers was a smash-hit, becoming the third highest-grossing film of all time.
4. Hiring Up-And-Coming Directors
Things dipped after The Avenger’ success, particularly with Thor: Dark World. Director Patty Jenkins quit, later citing she didn’t want the first female-led superhero film to be such a let-down.
Alan Taylor, who took over, called his experience "particularly wrenching”. While Joss Whedon returned for Age of Ultron, it wasn't the critical hit The Avengers was. Marvel had to change, and change it did.
James Gunn was a relatively unknown director. He had only directed two feature films, along with writing for the Scooby-Doo movies. Despite this inexperience, Gunn was hired to write and direct Guardians of the Galaxy amidst strong competition. Joss Whedon said on the decision:
“He is so off the wall, and so crazy, but so smart, such a craftsman and he builds from his heart.”
Guardians of the Galaxy was a complete tonal and thematic overhaul than what preceded it. The Avengers delivered the heroic crossover fans were drooling for, but Guardians of the Galaxy experimented with unknown characters on a much more light-hearted romp. It quickly became a fan favourite.
It’s risky bringing in untested directors to a franchise as big as the MCU. Yet these directors brought new ideas and voices to the table.
Giving up-and-coming directors total creative freedom and budgets they merely dreamed of beforehand produced superhero films that felt like totally different genres. Winter Soldier unfolds like a political thriller, while Black Panther is a celebration of black culture and empowerment.
In a sense, the MCU went back to its roots. Jon Favreau was directing indie and family films before Iron Man. Taika Waititi excelled at oddball comedies, and the Russo Brothers worked with diverse casts on TV shows.
However, Thor: Ragnarok and Avengers: Infinity War are some of the highest-rated Marvel movies.
In fact, Marvel movies that actively pushed away from the superhero genre are rated the highest critically and by the audience. Letting directors play to their strengths not only yielded stellar films, but also kept the MCU hella fresh.
3. Cinematic Universe's Competitors And Why They Failed
As the MCU’s box office numbers grew, other big
franchises took note and tried to create a cash-cow series of their own. Yet
these cinematic universe start-ups never quite reached the MCU’s level of
success; none really came close.
Universal’s Dark Universe stumbled on their first step with The Mummy. Critics slammed the DCEU over Dawn of Justice and Suicide Squad.
Warner Bros have attempted five cinematic universes, including the DCEU, MonsterVerse, and Guy Ritchie’s Arthurian series. But alas, all failed to simulate the MCU’s triumph.
Why are they unable to capture Marvel’s magic? Because Marvel took years to introduce each character methodically, and other cinematic universes tried to play catch-up in a quarter of the time.
Iron Man merely teased an expanded universe in the end-credits scene, because before the MCU could assemble the Avengers, Marvel had to flesh out those characters. It’s no wonder Tony Stark spends most of his time out of the suit in Iron Man than inside.
His journey from playboy billionaire-cum-compassionate citizen of the world makes Stark fascinating to watch. Compare this to the DCEU, for example, that thrust Batman, Wonder Woman, and the big-bad Doomsday into their second feature film.
This isn’t to say that there will never be a contender to the MCU.
In recent years, the DCEU has found its footing with the visually gorgeous Aquaman and heart-warming Shazam, not to mention the buzz surrounding Wonder Woman 1984. Yet franchises’ hasty scrambling to emulate the MCU’s success have done more harm than good, reaching the gold rush far too late.
2. Marketing And Collaborations
Of course, marketing and advertising have been a critical asset in bolstering the MCU’s success. Marvel’s casts and crews all excel in the dark arts of advertising… except their approach is the total opposite of dark.
Every director’s face beams with childish glee as they gush about their
newest Marvel instalment. Mark Ruffalo and Tom Holland are lovable klutzes,
much like their character counterparts, who keep “accidentally” spoiling major
plot points through interviews and Instagram posts.
At the drop of a hat, the whole Marvel cast can be weaponised to advertise a film with simple ad campaigns (e.g. #DontSpoilTheEndgame).
And with promotional campaigns going into the millions (Endgame’s campaign clocked in at over $200 million), the MCU can easily stay in the public image alongside Marvel-designed apparel, Funko Pops, and other merchandise.
In truth, it isn’t actually Marvel who’s leading the advertising brigade. In 2011, Disney dismissed the Marvel marketing team and took the advertising reins themselves.
While Marvel was no stranger to securing big-time partners, like their partnership with Audi, Disney’s acquisition probably didn’t hunt in landing major deals with Coca-Cola and Harley-Davidson. As the years have gone by, the marketing gurus have shifted their target market towards the mainstream. Mindy Hamilton, SVP of Disney's Partnership Marketing, said:
“We’ve grown beyond our target audience of traditional fanboys; now it’s millennials, it’s teens, it’s multicultural and families. We look for partnerships that honor and celebrate in each of these."
Disney’s partnership deals alongside Marvel’s willingness to play ball with other companies have led to direct cinematic improvements too.
Collaborating with Sony let Spider-Man enter the fray, who was a driving force for much of the emotional turmoil towards the end of the Infinity Saga. Marvel gave their blessing to Fox to switch Negasonic Teenage Warhead's powers, in return for using Ego the Living Planet, who appeared in Guardians of the Galaxy 2.
1. The Endgame Strategy
The Infinity Saga is
finished, with Spider-Man: Far From Home giving us a nice little plot-hook for
Phase 4. And while cinematic releases are going through a rough patch right
now, the MCU plans to continue onwards.
It’s astonishing how Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame culminated years worth of storytelling so succinctly, with many a character’s story ending with a satisfying conclusion.
In the age of unlimited entertainment and endless streaming, showrunners and franchisees are constantly vying for our undivided attention. TV series stretch on and on while reboots of decades-old films fill the market, and it feels like nothing will ever end. It’s refreshing to see a franchise permanently close some doors for good.
Marvel has been building up to this moment for years. Feige, Marvel, and Disney have been laying the brickwork for Infinity Saga’s end, with every end-credits scene teasing another Infinity Stone, unseen characters, and Thanos inching closer and closer to Earth.
MCU has excelled by having this endgame strategy implemented early. An Avengers film was in talks in 2003, with Marvel keeping fans updated with sprawling release dates year by year.
Endgame neatly wrapped up ten years’ worth of content. It’s mind-bogglingly impressive with so many characters, storylines, and lore to work around. With Feige treating the MCU like a comic, he knew that every story arc must end.
While Marvel Studios adores its characters, with the past twenty-three films showcasing incredible character development, they know when to let them go. Stark sums it up pretty well:
“Part of the journey is the end.”
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know The Marvel Cinematic Universe?