Jack Nicholson: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
Heeeereeee's Jacky!
Jack Nicholson is a phenomenon of acting - a chameleon who has waded through genres as if they don't traditionally challenge an actor's range, and offering some of the most memorable and explosive performances ever seen on screen.
He has been a supervillain, a devil incarnate, a lover, a wanderer and a madman, and in every case he has brought subtly and nuance that defies the often grandiose delivery of his characters. As his career progressed over more than 6 decades, he has played indie-like characters with the faintest of strokes, as well as larger than life characters ripped from the annals of criminal history, and every one has them has been authentic under his guidance.
He is a master of his craft and an assurance of quality, and it's a shame that his working schedule has lightened in his elder years. But at least we have his career preserved on screen as a living monument to his prowess.
On the occasion of him turning 80, this column celebrates the best and worst of the career of one of the best character actors ever to grace screens, starting with the high-points...
5 Awesome Performances...
5. The Joker - Batman
Jack Nicholson's portrayal of Batman's greatest nemesis, The Joker, has been overshadowed somewhat by the sheer amount of praise and accolade that has fallen upon Heath Ledger's take on the character in The Dark Knight.
That's not to say that Ledger didn't deserve all the applause that his performance received; he successfully rebranded the character for 21st century movie-goers, injecting him with a grit and edginess that was less apparent in Nicholson's own. That said, Jack Nicholson pretty much nailed The Joker back in 1989.
If people now cite Ledger as the definitive Joker, fair enough - but to look past Nicholson's performance in Tim Burton's Batman is a huge mistake, given how the actor somehow managed to pull off the arduous task of playing a comic book villain as exactly that: a comic book villain. Nicholson plunges himself into the role, ensuring his Joker as what is arguably his most crazed character of all time. He mesmerises in every scene, switching effortlessly between downright insane to downright terrifying at the drop of a hat.
4. Walter Schmidt - About Schmidt
The only later stage Nicholson film to make our "5 awesome performances" section, About Schmidt was probably interchangeable with As Good As It Gets, which also features an older Nicholson on top form, but we've gone for this one instead, purely in the hope that it garners the movie some well -deserved attention.
So here is one of Alexander Payne's best - and vastly underrated - films, which features Jack as a retiring insurance salesman who attempts to stop his daughter's wedding to a man he feels is totally unworthy. It also has Kathy Bates naked. Don't let that put you off, of course: About Schmidt contains what some might argue is the definitive performance of Nicholson's career - so much so, in fact, that many were disturbed to find that he didn't take home the Oscar for Best Actor back in 2003 when this thing came out.
As Schmidt, Nicholson nails the role in such a way that you can't imagine the movie existing without him. Displaying fine comic chops and triumphant in moments of genuine emotion, Nicholson makes up for the film's otherwise slow pace. Really, the movie plays as a tribute to his talents.
3. Jack Torrance - The Shining
What to say of Jack's nerve-wrenching performance as writer turned psychopath Jack Torrance in Stanley Kubrick's seminal horror movie that hasn't been said already? Indeed, the image of Nicholson peering through an axe-damaged doorway has become so iconic that it's fallen in the realms of parody more times than we can count.
Still, Nicholson's dedication to his role in this novel adaptation marks one of his all-time best performances. Even if it is a little on the hammy side, somehow he makes the transition work - it's a tour de force in crazy. Stephen King famously said that Nicholson was wrong for the lead role, and from an adaptation point of view, he'd be right: the original source material had Jack Torrance as a regular guy before going apesh*t, thus emphasising the contrast between the two men.
Nicholson, King argued, seemed crazy from the very beginning, thus dulling the impact. It's a fair enough point, but it's also probably true that without Nicholson's unnerving performance at the centre, filling the movie with anxious dread, it would have been a far less interesting flick on the whole.
2. Jake Gittes - Chinatown
Chinatown, often regarded as one of the best films of all-time, is often been lauded for Roman Polanski's dreamy direction and Robert Towne's flawless screenplay, but have we really given enough credit to the movie's leading man, who carries us through the events of this complex picture with all the right levels of confidence, charisma, sleaze and tragedy?
Yes, as private eye Jake Gittes, Jack Nicholson offers one of his more rounded performances. It also happens to be one of his most subtle, restrained turns, further adding to its power.
So Chinatown works as both a deconstruction and as a post-modern take on the noir genre; as Nicholson's detective becomes more muddled as the case begins to unfolds, piece by piece, we feel emotionally connected to his plight, despite a few ill-judged decisions. It's interesting to note that Nicholson appears in every single scene in the movie, no small feat for any actor, but holds his presence throughout.
This isn't a shouty or hammy turn, though - here, you watch a master performer stay immersed until that immortal final line: "Forget it, Jake... it's Chinatown."
1. R.P. McMurphy - One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest
Jack's best performance ever? Undoubtably this one. Milos Forman's wonderful (perhaps even perfect) movie, based on the novel of the same name by Ken Kesey, features Jack Nicholson in a role his was born to play. As charismatic delinquent R.P. McMurphy (and what is Jack Nicholson if not a charismatic delinquent), a convict who fakes insanity and lands himself in a mental institution to escape jail time, Nicholson is working at the height of his powers.
Combining all that his good about his talents as an actor, he's the perfect cross of sleazy and charismatic. Murphy isn't a particularly good guy, of course, and a lesser actor might have struggled to win us around to his side - what Nicholson manages is a compromise. He allows McMurphy to be a real person, with flaws and faults, but one who also inhabits a strange moral centre.
When the calculating Nurse Ratched tries to play the inmates against one another for her own amusement, Nicholson's facial expressions are masterful in their telling power. Not just one of the best Nicholson performances, then, but one of the best - if not the best - of all-time.
And now on to the less brilliant...
And 5 That Sucked...
5. Edward Cole - The Bucket List
As mentioned in the intro, even when Jack Nicholson is phoning it in, he's still a formidable and entertaining presence, a trait which has probably helped him onto becoming one of the most popular actors of all-time - even when he's being basically himself, people are still happy to see the guy. Lucky for some!
Still, his turn in Rob Reiner's boringly schmaltzy The Bucket List, which teams him with fellow legend Morgan Freeman as two cancer patients who set out to fulfill their lifelong dreams before they kick the bucket, seems like a bit of a low point.
Which is to say, the script for The Bucket List is so bad that Nicholson doesn't seem capable of delivering his lines properly - almost as if he's reading them off of an autocue or for the first time. It doesn't help that the whole movie is cloyingly sentimental and treats cancer like something that can be "ignored" in favour of a good time and sky diving; there's a sense here that Nicholson just wanted to hang out with his buddy Morgan Freeman for a couple of months and The Bucket List gave him the excuse to do exactly that.
This film is best left avoided.
4. President James Dale - Mars Attacks!
Jack Nicholson features as one member of a large ensemble cast in Tim Burton's daftly underrated sci-fi movie parody Mars Attacks!, which has him cast as the President of the United States, James Dale. For a part that doesn't really ask much of Jack except to play his usual schtick, it's strange to see that he goes through this movie almost like he's been drugged.
There's a strange, unknowing expression stuck on his face from beginning to end, as if he arrived on set, smoked a massive joint, and filmed his scenes. A wasted opportunity, perhaps? The rest of the cast, made up of actors such as Pierce Brosnan, Michael J. Fox, Jack Black, Glenn Close and Sarah Jessica Parker, are appropriately daffy in their own roles, and seem more aware to the kind of tone that Tim Burton is going for - especially as terrifying CG aliens arrive on the planet to annihilate human life as we know it.
So Nicholson isn't terrible, but he doesn't really seem like he wants to be involved - which isn't all that surprisingly, really, given that he was third choice for the role after Warren Beatty and Paul Newman dropped out.
3. Anger Management
At one point in time, the teaming of Jack Nicholson and Adam Sandler probably seemed like a relative stroke of genius (ahem - that was the early 2000s for you); unfortunately the movie that attempted to cash in on this idea wasn't very good at all, and Nicholson settles for playing himself in a movie that simply requires him to make use of his trademark shark's grin from beginning to end.
Many critics stated they enjoyed how very Jack Nicholson Jack Nicholson was in this joyless comedy, but the sense of performance deja vu on show here is unappealing. In other words: here's one movie where Jack being Jack doesn't really save the picture... almost to the point where everything that is usually so appealing about him (the shark's grin included) feels a little stale.
It does not help an inch that Anger Management appears to have been written in about three hours on the back of a placemat, or that Adam Sandler is near unbearable. The plot is a little bizarre, though it's a shame that the premise - which has Sandler and Nicholson cast as patient and therapist, respectively - couldn't have produced better results.
2. Mark Forman - Heartburn
Jack Nicholson and Meryl Streep, two of the greatest actors of all-time, brought together in a film by the wonderful Mike Nichols? What could go wrong? A lot, actually. Try as they might to make do in this drama about a New York food writer (Streep) who meets a Washington newspaper columnist at a wedding (Nicholson), the biggest problem with the movie is that they share little to no chemistry.
Surprised? Don't be. The script isn't that good either, and the characters inhabited by the leads aren't really worthy of actually having their own movie. So they get by, of course, because they're Nicholson and Streep, but the drab tone and middling story only serve to make Nicholson's performance here... well, a little boring.
His character, a Washington D.C. political correspondent, is a highly unlikable son of a gun, and just as Streep's character does throughout the film, you wonder why she bothered to marry him (Nicholson doesn't have an answer, either). There are moments where you can see ol' Jack coming to life now and again, but mostly this is an uninteresting addition to his filmography.
1. Harry Bliss - Man Trouble
So here it is: the worst performance of Jack Nicholson's career, and a genuinely bad one, no matter which way you look at it. So awful was his turn in Man Trouble, in fact, that the Oscar-winning legend was nominated for a Razzie. As in, an actual Razzie.
Here's the plot: Nicholson stars as Harry Bliss, a security expert who is married to a Japanese woman and finds himself not really loving that situation at all. Then Ellen Barkin turns up and asks him if he'll help her in locating a dog and... seriously, what is this sh*it? And this was a film that happened in 1992, somehow.
Directed by Bob Rafelson, who collaborated brilliantly with Jack Nicholson on Five Easy Pieces (yes, you read that right), Man Trouble is a genuine curiosity that doesn't know what genre movie it wants to be. Nicholson coasts on a performance that literally asks you to remember him as little as possible; the plot is so bizarre that it'll have you scratching your head just from reading the blurb on the DVD cover.
What's more, the dog is the most memorable aspect of the film. Think on that for a second. Nicholson didn't win his Razzie, but he probably deserved to.
Which of these performances do you think rank of Nicholson's best and worst? Let us know in the comments section below.