Jack Reacher: Never Go Back Review - 3 Ups & 6 Downs

An immensely lazy sequel.

Jack Reacher
Paramount Pictures

While it doesn't standing among Tom Cruise's bigger box office successes, 2012's Jack Reacher was nevertheless a solid enough hit to earn a sequel, no matter the complaints from fans of the source material that Cruise simply wasn't right for the part.

Four years later, Jack Reacher is back with an adaptation of Lee Childs' 2013 Reacher novel Never Go Back, yet as acclaimed as the book was upon release, this movie? Not so great.

Critics largely agree that Jack Reacher 2 is a mediocre sequel that, while hardly bad, just doesn't do enough to justify its own existence beyond mere box office dollars, and feels like a waste of so many talented creative people.

Will the word-of-mouth sink its box office, or will Jack live to fight another day? The coming weeks will tell, but until then, here are 3 ups and 6 downs from Jack Reacher: Never Go Back...


Downs...

6. Outrageously Bad Dialogue & Re-Dubbing

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Cobie Smulders
Paramount

While the original movie wasn't exactly a paragon of wit and intelligence, it did manage to serve up a few memorable dialogues, such as Werner Herzog's infamous story about chewing off his fingers. Never Go Back? Nah.

The script for the sequel feels cobbled together from a spy thriller cliche generator, trotting out ridiculously trite placeholder lines we've all heard dozens of times before, while bringing little in the way of wit or invention (except perhaps for when Cruise asks Cobie Smulders' soldier Susan Turner, "Did it offend you more when I treated you as a woman or as a man?")

Worse still is the film's odd abundance of re-dubbed dialogue, which has been done so carelessly that there are a handful of scenes where characters' mouths aren't at all moving in sync with the dialogue. It's outrageously unprofessional for a $60 million movie starring one of the world's most famous actors.


5. The Idiotic Teenager Character

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Danika Yarosh Tom Cruise
Paramount

The movie's trailers have largely downplayed the fact that, in addition to the central Cruise-Smulders dynamic, there's a teenage sidekick character, Samantha Dayton, played by Danika Yarosh.

While Yarosh does fine with what she has, that sadly isn't very much, and her character ultimately ends up more of an irritating affectation than a fun twist on the expected formula.

The nature of her role in the movie is probably best not mentioned, but rest assured that Samantha is obnoxious, commits a number of straight-up idiotic acts (even for the low standards of a 15-year-old), and gets a highly unsatisfactory resolution to her story...assuming you can even be compelled to care by that point.

Excising this subplot and springing for something else, anything else, would likely have improved the film significantly.


4. Not Enough Action

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Tom Cruise
Paramount

In fairness, the first Jack Reacher wasn't exactly dripping with action sequences, but it did serve up a few thrilling set-pieces. While Never Go Back is directed by the talented Edward Zwick (The Last Samurai, Blood Diamond), there's a curiously low amount of action, and the little that is there is directed with utter, anonymous indifference.

Sure, there are a few entertaining scenes of Cruise running, but the brief bursts of violence are mostly just by-the-numbers and visually flat, meaning the movie can't even really be excused as a hollow but explosive action extravaganza.

Given how game Cruise always seems to put himself in harm's way for the sake of a movie, it just feels like a wasted opportunity not to take advantage of that.

Simply, there's nothing even close to the electrifying car chase from the first movie here.


3. The Absolutely Terrible Villains

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Robert Knepper
Paramount

It was always going to be a tough act to follow considering that the first movie was lucky enough to get Werner Herzog as its villain, but Never Go Back makes almost no effort to craft a compelling antagonist.

The focal villain is a man known as The Hunter (Patrick Heusinger), who doggedly chases Reacher and Turner down throughout the movie. He's largely stoic and doesn't really get to do much other than be violent, so it's hard to even call him much of a character.

Then there's Robert Knepper's malevolent General Harkness, whose screen time totals around five minutes, which given Knepper's talents at playing creepy slimeballs, just feels like an absolute waste.

They really didn't even try to come up with an interesting baddie here. Woeful.


2. The Emotional Beats Fall Totally Flat

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Danika Yarosh Tom Cruise Cobie Smulders
Paramount

One of the movie's big mistakes is in trying to inject some emotion into what is fundamentally a no-nonsense popcorn flick. Cruise's Reacher has always been rather on the quiet, one-dimensional side, and that's basically fine for what these movies are, so to try and make the audience connect with his journey emotionally is incredibly difficult...and ultimately unsuccessful.

There's a subplot in the movie which hints at some of Reacher's greater humanity beyond beating the crap out of people, but because Reacher's such a cipher in the first place, it's hard to really give much of a damn and comes off as disingenuous. That it all builds up to an unintentionally hilarious anti-climax of a reveal about Reacher's personal life only makes it feel that much more pointless.


1. It Might Be The Most Generic Movie Of 2016

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Cobie Smulders Tom Cruise
Paramount

Yes, that's quite a claim given the middle-of-the-road quality of so many of 2016's releases to date, but Never Go Back is so firmly rooted in the tired tropes of the spy thriller genre that it almost feels like they did it on purpose as some sort of self-aware parody.

Sadly that's not the case, though, and it's basically just a bland regurgitation of all the plot beats you've seen in literally dozens of other similar movies. Given Cruise's typically high batting average when it comes to genre movies, it's genuinely bemusing that he agreed to work from a script so utterly formulaic and lazy.

Someone could've easily cranked the screenplay out over a long, booze-soaked weekend with no qualms at all.

Yet with all that in mind, here are 3 reasons you might still want to check the movie out (though probably on Netflix in six months' time)...

And now for the ups...


Ups...

3. Tom Cruise & Cobie Smulders' Chemistry

Paramount

The one unequivocal success of Never Go Back is that Tom Cruise and Cobie Smulders are a great pairing: they have a fun push-and-pull with one another, and it can even be argued that Smulders ends up overshadowing the leading man with her sassy, no-bulls***, bada** performance as a soldier falsely accused of espionage.

The pair just about manage to carry the film through scenes that without their combined presence wouldn't play anywhere near as well, and above all else it proves that Smulders really needs to get an action franchise of her own, or at least get more roles in the genre. Even when she's strangling a guy twice her size to death, she's totally convincing.


2. It Avoids The Cliched Romance

Paramount

As great as Cruise and Smulders are in the movie, it's a pleasant surprise that the script doesn't opt for the ultra-cliched route of pairing them together romantically.

While this is actually hinted at throughout the film, it's cleverly subverted several times, such as one scene in which Susan talks to Reacher while wearing a bathrobe. It looks like things could get hot and heavy, but we're pulled back from it and their dynamic is all the more satisfying as a result.

Instead, Jack and Susan basically end up playing a**-kicking surrogate parents to Samantha, which while not executed with as much panache as it could have been, is at least a million miles away from a PG-13 sex scene that bonds the two leads together forever more.


1. The Final Fight

Jack Reacher Never Go Back Tom Cruise
Paramount

And finally, though the action is incredibly hit-and-miss throughout the film, at least the climactic fight between Reacher and The Hunter is probably the movie's best scene.

With a unique setting, a wealth of smash-mouth violence and a ludicrously amusing ending sequence, this brawl may be fairly basic in terms of set-up (it's basically just a fist-fight), but it brings the visceral brutality that almost everything in the movie leading up to this point was lacking.

If a third Jack Reacher movie does in fact happen, more of this please.

What did you think of Jack Reacher: Never Go Back? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.