Jason Segel: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

Who'd have thought the man who gave us the Muppets back could also make Sex Tape...

At the relatively young age of 34, Jason Segel has worked wonders for his career: even if you're not convinced by that goofy face and offhand charisma, chances are you're familiar with at least some of his work. A talented individual in a number of creative avenues, Segel first came to us as a character in Judd Apatow's daftly underrated and short-lived TV classic Freaks & Geeks. Since then, he's made us laugh time and time again, and - best -of all - brought The Muppets back to mainstream popularity. Segel is also perhaps best known to the masses for his turn in TV's How I Met Your Mother, in which he played the role of loveable schmuck Marshall Eriksen for a whopping 209 episodes. He's also one of a small bunch of actors - many of whom worked on Freaks & Geeks - who, for some reason, is allowed to pop up in pretty much any Judd Apatow movie for a while, just 'cause (nobody is complaining about this). A talented writer and musician as well as an actor, the future looks bright for Mr. Segel. Very bright indeed. But it isn't all roses and fancy restaurants: sometimes Jason Segel has failed to live up to his potential, and has turned in work of the "rather shoddy" or "somewhat misguided" variety. To celebrate his new film, and his second with Cameron Diaz (who he worked with on 2011's Bad Teacher), we decided to cast our gaze upon 5 Awesome Performances and 5 That Sucked...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Jason - Knocked Up (2007)

Knocked Up1 A relatively small role is this one, but oddly unforgettable at the same time. In what is arguably Judd Apatow's best filmic venture to date, then, Jason Segel plays a character called - brace yourselves - Jason, roommate to Seth Rogen's stoner father-to-be, Ben. Apatow literally has a bunch of Freaks and Geeks cast members (and Jonah Hill) living with Ben, and doesn't even bother to change their names - they're all played by actors using their actual names. Hence, uh, "Jason." Anyway, in Knocked Up, Jason gives a strangely mesmerising performance as an unlikely lothario who attempts to seduce Alison's (Katherine Heigl) sister, Debbie, played by Judd Apatow's real life wife, Leslie Mann. It's not a particularly powerful turn by Segel, nor is it actually much to write home about - the point, however, is that it's a very small part with not much significance, and yet Segel somehow manages to make it incredibly memorable. Certainly his "sexiest" turn.

4. Gary - The Muppets (2011)

The Muppets Movie Jason Segel is pretty much responsible for bringing The Muppets back to mainstream popularity, what with the brilliantly inventive, musical meta-movie that was 2011's "The Muppets" (nice title, guys). And aside from being lead writer on the flick, which was produced by Walt Disney pictures (with songs by Flight of the Concord's Brett Mackenzie), Segel starred alongside the likes of Kermit, Miss Piggy, Gonzo and the rest of the gang, playing boyfriend to the lovely Amy Adams. So Jason Segel plays Gary in the movie, a goofy guy - and brother to the movie's lead Muppet, Walter - who sets out to help the Muppets in their attempt to thwart Chris Cooper's Tex Richman. Though the part isn't particularly groundbreaking, the actor manages to perfectly encapsulate what it means to be a human being in a Muppet movie, and throws himself entirely in the action. Which means that he both sings and dances - and it's downright hilarious to watch.

3. Marshall Eriksen - How I Met Your Mother (2005-2014)

Assumedly, this is the role that most people know Jason Segel for - as Marshall Eriksen on TV's How I Met Your Mother. As Ted Mosley's best friend, Marshall is - according to Wikipedia - a "tall, easy-going, naive optimist from St. Cloud, Minnesota," which is probably the best description of said character going. Many have complained that such a character is really just Jason Segel playing himself, but there's a lot more to it than that - he's an integral element of the show. So much so, in fact, that a lot of what makes How I Met Your Mother great stems from the fact that Segel manages to make Marshall into such a likeable character - an audience surrogate, if you will. Sure, he doesn't have the memorability factor of somebody like Barney (who does, to be fair?), but he's definitely somebody you would want as your own best friend. Segel easily kept up the enthusiasm for this character for the length of the show, and that's to be wholly admired.

2. Peter Bretter - Forgetting Sarah Marshall (2008)

While Knocked Up established the cooler, cockier side of Segel's comic character building, Forgetting Sarah Marshall felt a lot more personal, like a truer reflection of Segel himself - perhaps because he wrote the film. Segel's Peter is the perfect portrait of a hopeless schlub, smashed back to Earth after over-achieving and forced to come to terms with himself, and the fact that he's clearly no competition to Russell Brand's impish, self-destructive rock star. The moment when he discovers that the love of his life is breaking up with him, immediately following his ill-conceived attempt to seduce her with comic nudity is one of the most helplessly funny and tragic moments outside of a Woody Allen film, and it's clear Segel can capture vulnerability perfectly.

1. Nick Andopolis - Freaks & Geeks (1999-2000)

So here's what is still perhaps Jason Segel's best and definitely most defining role - the one that has pretty much carried him through to the success that he's experienced today, and has set the sort of archetype for the kinds of characters that he continues to play. As Nick Andopolis, Segel inhabited one of the "geeks" of the title - and though he wasn't exactly the main character, his performance allowed us to constantly resonate and emphasise with the situation of said geeks. The reason we're ranking this as the best Jason Segel performance, then, stems from the fact that it really feels like the most casual and fresh out of all of his roles - playing this good-natured, mild-mannered character with a cool sense of humour feels inherently Segel, but there was a darker comic edge working beneath the surface that made the character more than just a "geek" - Nick Andopolis felt like a person. And the fact that Segel was less confident an actor felt "real." And now on to the roles he didn't exactly soar in...

And 5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Jason - This Is 40 (2012)

Few actors can claim to have achieved the somewhat inauspicious accolade of being voted onto both sides of this divide for the same character, but such is the case thanks to the second appearance of the imaginatively named Jason. Having played the most diverting of Seth Rogen's slacker friends in Knocked Up, he was brought in for some familiarity in the absence of his former porn-hunting cohort. The problem for Jason though is that he is written horribly in a mean-spirited movie that should have been considerably better than it was. Though there were some fine moments the comedy fell flat for the most part, and it didn't help that everything that made Jason appealing first time out had been utterly sterilised. Yes, it was interesting for about a minute to see his development from cocky ne'er-do-well to insufferable personal trainer, but it didn't fit what we'd known and grown to love about the character in the first place. He was endearing because he was a failure, and didn't seem to care, but to have him evolve into a Starbucks generation douche-bag without comedy to fall back on was too much. He should only ever have pretended he could get whatever he wanted, and never actually been allowed to achieve it.

4. Sam Schecter - Slackers (2002)

Having seen Freaks & Geeks unfairly pulled out from under him, it was a little while before Segel really broke back and until How I Met Your Mother came along he bounced from under-whelming role to under-whelming role in barely seen movies. Those who did see his early millennial movies though would not have been impressed by his turn as student grifter Sam in this paint by numbers cocky teen comedy. It's a very consciously post-Mallrats, post-Clerks revenge comedy that feels like it's been cobbled together from superior films without learning anything from its magpie-ing. And unfortunately for Segel, there's absolutely nobody to root for. Everyone is a cliche, and a grotesque one at that, and it's difficult to shake the feeling that it thinks it's really very smart with it. Frankly, it's not, and it was almost an unfortunate false-start for Segel's movie career.

3. Jay - Sex Tape (2014)

Despite the fact that Segel and Diaz had managed to capture some very appealing chemistry in Bad Teachers, the decision to reteam them for this latest addition to the sex disaster comedy genre (alongside Road Trip, American Pie and their kind) proved to be their Righteous Kill. Unfortunately for such a likeable actor, Segel is hampered badly by poor direction - which seems oddly obsessed with his more sculpted backside than anything else - a terrible script (with far too few successful jokes) and Diaz's terrible performance opposite him. The film clearly thinks itself outrageous and titillating, when it is no more than excruciatingly embarrassing, and Segel seems to have attempted to make up for how terrible the script was by throwing all restraint out of the window. But when the only memorable part of the entire affair is the very cynical sales pitch he gives for the new iPad's hi-res camera, you have to concede that he didn't succeed at all.

2. Kyle - Dead Man On Campus (1998)

Another early effort for Segel, and another that could be chalked up to his wanting to pay some bills and show his eagerness to break the business before Freaks & Geeks offered a short-lived break-through, Dead Man On Campus is still difficult to let slide. Strictly speaking it's hard to pin the film's dismal failure solely on Segel, who in truth only had a passing role, but it's hard not to castigate everyone involved. The so-called dark comedy is an amoral, nasty disaster, reliant on a plot that is inconceivably inhumane, and which - even worse - is lifted whole-sale from fellow 1998 "suicide comedy" The Curve. As a mark of how awful it was, the film has now gone out of print - which must be some relief to Segel and his fellow cast members, but those who saw it will always have that back-of-the-brain nagging that he is always capable of making terrible career choices like this.

1. Horatio - Gulliver's Travels (2010)

If you're going to agree to acting alongside Jack Black in a comedy "vehicle" for his tired shtick, as Hollywood studios fail badly to grasp what it was that once made him one of the most endearing comic stars in the business, you should expect some criticism. Jonathan Swift is probably still spinning furiously in his grave at the very idea that Hollywood would think this was the right way to celebrate his source material. Yes, it's pretty much a kid's movie, but that doesn't excuse the fact that Rob Letterman took all of the charm of Swift's story and threw it out with all of the political allegory and philosophical motifs and turned it into an empty-headed, ugly "comedy" without a punch-line. Segel's Horatio is clearly designed to be the emotional heart of the Lilliputian story, and his arc of finding the hero inside and getting the girl is pure chocolate box tweeness. But unfortunately, it's impossible to commit any kind of memorable legacy in a film whose idea of humour is to have Jack Black urinate a fire out. Which are your favourite and least favourite Jason Segel performances? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.