Jeremy Irons: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

Not just a pretty voice.

For a long time, Jeremy Irons was known to the public as Charles Ryder in the acclaimed TV version of Brideshead Revisited, which aired on ITV in the United Kingdom in 1981. Watching Irons as an embodiment of Ryder, injecting the role with a strange, intoxicating melancholy, it soon became apparent that he might well be destined for great things. If Jeremy Irons' career - through no fault of his own - hasn't quite delivered on the promise of those early years, few would claim that he hasn't at least made a good go of it. At times, it's as if Hollywood doesn't quite know what to do with him (he is often made to play "exotic" or "European") and - as a result - his career has suffered through periods of inactivity. Cast him in the right role, however, and there are few who can rival his unique screen presence. There is a sense with Irons that he's always in on the joke, which allows him to take his unique brand of seriousness - if you can call it that - into the realms of comedy, drama and everything in-between. He's equally at home delivering hammy exposition as he is wallowing in a mournful monologue; he can play both sympathetic and truly loathsome. And then, of course, there's that voice - his trademark weapon, and the trait that has come to define Irons and his talents: a deeply gravelly tone, it's somehow also smooth as silk. Irons' next role has him as the tyrannical architect Anthony Royal in Ben Wheatley's long-awaited adaptation of J.G Ballard's High-Rise, set for release in UK cinemas today. To celebrate Irons' long and eclectic career, it's time to look back at 5 awesome performances and 5 performances that weren't so successful...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Humbert Humbert - Lolita (1997)

Vladimir Nabokov couldn't have written the character of Humbert Humbert with Jeremy Irons in mind, and yet watching Adrian Lyne's 1997 adaptation of his seminal novel, Lolita, it certainly feels as though he might have. Irons is best when playing characters who manage to provoke our sympathies and our disgust in equal measure, after all, and there are few monsters in fiction as likeable as Humbert Humbert. Irons is the best thing about Lyne's otherwise flawed take on the book, which centres on a European professor of French Literature whose infatuation with the pre-pubescent "nymphet" of the movie's title leads him to disaster. He plays Humbert as though his attraction were a mere romantic affliction, and - given the sensitive nature of his obsession - brilliantly emphasises his feelings using subtle facial expressions. From the moment Irons opens his mouth, the actor embodies Humbert as if he were born to play him; hearing the actor speak Nabokov's words is a match made in heaven. It's no wonder that, after the film's release, he recorded an audiobook of his reading the novel.

4. Father Gabriel - The Mission (1986)

That rare movie which sees Jeremy Irons in a wholly good guy capacity, the actor's dedicated performance in Roland Joffe's underrated classic The Mission remains a high point of his career (even if the critics didn't think much of the film at the time). As Father Gabriel, the loyal 18th-century Jesuit priest tasked with building a Guarani Indian mission deep in the jungles of Brazil, Irons successfully holds his own against one of the biggest stars of the era, Robert De Niro, and was even nominated for a Golden Globe. What most people really seem to remember about The Mission is its phenomenal musical score by Ennio Morricone, but Irons' performance is just as worthy of attention. Though he essentially plays the "straight man" to De Niro's disgraced slave trader, Irons works to make his character rich and three-dimensional. It's the sort of assured acting where you begin to believe in the character to such an extent that you forget they are merely fictional.

3. Claus Von Bülow - Reversal Of Fortune (1990)

Jeremy Irons won the Academy Award for Best Actor for his role in Barbet Schroeder's adaptation of the book of the same name. Based on a true story, the film recounts the murder trial of one Claus Von Bülow, a European aristocrat accused of trying to kill his wife with an insulin overdose, and his relationship with lawyer Alan Dershowitz. Reversal of Fortune isn't all that well-known film considering that it contains an Academy Award-winning performance, but Irons is on top form as the mysterious Von Bülow, who may or may not be guilty of his crimes. Irons has spent much of his career cast as "Europeans" to mixed results: here the decision pays off, as the actor makes Von Bülow a strange, otherworldly oddball, imbuing him with a series of weird tics and mannerisms. Transformed with heavy make-up, Irons brings his unique weird of comic blackness to the role, rendering Von Bülow as an eccentric. Black and white characters are no good for Jeremy Irons, but this is perfect: you can't get any greyer than Von Bülow, after all.

2. Scar - The Lion King (1994)

Despite the fact that it's a voice role, to dismiss what is probably Jeremy Irons' most famous role to date, not to mention one of his greatest ever performances, would be a discredit to his man's career on the whole. Who else could have made Scar so memorable? Irons turned down the part at first: Disney phoned him, asked if he wanted to record a few lines for an upcoming animated film about a lion and - coming off the back of Reversal of Fortune - he said no. They later convinced, and even went as far as to model Scar on various aspects of Irons' Oscar-winning performance as Claus von Bülow. Scar is one of Disney's great villains, and in providing his voice Jeremy Irons makes him a truly delicious tyrant. Irons' defining moment here, perhaps, comes during Scar's song, "Be Prepared," which - powered by actor's dulcet tones - is made a classic. Robin Williams' peerless performance as the Genie in Aladdin aside, this could very well be the most ingenious piece of animated movie voice casting ever.

1. Beverly Mantle/Elliot Mantle - Dead Ringers (1988)

When Jeremy Irons collected his Oscar for his role in Reversal of Fortune, there was a telling moment towards the end of his speech when he thanked a director who hadn't even been involved with the picture. "Thank you also - and some of you may understand why - thank you, David Cronenberg," said Irons, referencing their work on Dead Ringers, a psychological drama they had made together two years previously. There are lot of people who think that Irons should have won the Academy Award for his phenomenal turn as twin brothers Beverly and Elliot Mantel in Cronenberg's underrated masterpiece instead, and Irons' nod to the director could have signalled his agreement. Irons offers up the definitive cinematic portrait of identical siblings in this icy thriller. Dead Ringers contains not one, but two flawless performances from the actor, who uses the most subtle tweaks in mannerism to signal which of the two brothers he's supposed to be at any given time. Cronenberg ensures that Beverly and Elliot - gynaecologists caught in a love affair - are totally identical, of course, which makes Irons' work even more impressive. To date, it's his most admirable screen performance - haunting, precise and masterful.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. René Gallimard - M. Butterfly (1993)

Following their excellent pairing on Dead Ringers, Jeremy Irons and David Cronenberg reunited in 1993 to lesser effect with a filmic adaptation of the 1988 play M. Butterfly. Here, Irons - once again cast as a European - plays a French diplomat named René Gallimard who, in the 1960s, comes to Beijing and ends up obsessed with a Chinese opera singer. The movie sets out to chronicle their 20-year-relationship, one filled with lust, romance and a whole lot of deceit. Unfortunately, Irons is miscast in his role. M. Butterfly marks one of those occasions where Irons being cast as a foreigner of sorts is actually jarring; his entire performance is so unnecessarily edgy that it's uncomfortable to watch, which gives the on-screen relationship a fraudulent edge. He's also rather flat, and none of the passion required for the character of Gallimard to come to life is present.

4. Esteban Trueba - The House Of The Spirits (1993)

In Bille August's ill-judged adaptation of Isabel Allende's famous 1982 novel of the same name - which chronicles three generations of a South American family - Jeremy Irons is wrongly cast as the Hispanic land owner Esteban Trueba - another curious case of the actor being hired on his apparent ability to appear as a member of any race. Such a theory is throughly disproved here: Irons doesn't feel Latin in the slightest, and brings far too much majesty to a role that should have been a lot softer around the edges. Though he ages convincingly across the span of the picture, his presence feels false. It's not just Irons who feels out of place; none of the main cast, which includes Meryl Streep, Winona Ryder and Glenn Close, fit the material. Antonio Banderas is the one actor who appears even the slightest bit authentic, and even he feels ill-suited. What should have been a far less serious affair was intellectualised all out of proportion in this adaptation, and it's Irons - cast as the face of solemnity - who ends up taking the fall.

3. Alonso Avellaneda - The Pink Panther 2 (2009)

You can actually see something akin to pain on Jeremy Irons' face as he permits himself to act his way through The Pink Panther 2, a movie that he absolutely must have agreed to appear in on the promise of an extravagant holiday (or two or three or four...). As Alonso Avellaneda, whose ridiculously European character feels like a knowing wink to the countless array of foreigners that Irons has played over the years, he's totally wasted as a Frenchman suspected of committing a robbery by Inspector Clouseau (Steve Martin). It's not a particularly large part, and Irons cannot hide his dismay at having to actually lower himself to a sequel of this kind - even through a mock-French accent. Even Beyonce had the mettle to turn down this awful sequel, Jeremy: what gives?

2. The Uber-Morlock - The Time Machine (2002)

As far as off the wall Jeremy Irons performances go, this has to be the most perplexing of the lot. For reasons unbeknownst to the universe at large, Irons opted for a role in the 2002 version of The Time Machine (based on the novel by H.G. Wells), starring Guy Pierce and - that's right - former pop sensation Samantha Mumba. As if just being in the movie wasn't bad enough, though, Irons agreed to play the leader of a fictional race called the Morlocks, which required the Academy Award-winning actor to wear countless layers of make-up, giving him the appearance of a rejected extra from Battlefield Earth. Forced to wear bright blue contact lenses and have his face painted white, Irons' job is to sit in a cave dispensing Elder-like advice to a confused Guy Pearce. It's mental. At one point, the Uber-Morlock says: "We all have our time machines. Some take us back." There's a good chance that Irons wishes he could use one to delete this from his canon.

1. Mage Profion - Dungeons & Dragons (2000)

Though there are genuine laughs to be had with regards to Jeremy Irons' frankly insane performance as Mage Profion in the horrible Dungeons & Dragons movie, this is a truly terrible performance from a great actor who was presumably told to ham it up to record-breaking levels - something he was apparently keen to oblige. Where to start? Dungeons & Dragons clearly came along at a point when Irons had little else on his plate. How else does one get roped into playing an evil mage in a film based on a tabletop game? Irons spends most of the film with his teeth clenched together, whilst his trademark voice is put through the ringer as he growls and mutters and makes incomprehensible noises in every single scene. He's just all over the place. The weirdest thing about the performance is that Irons, freed from the constraints of the serious films he was used to up until this point, genuinely seems to be enjoying himself. Unfortunately, what he delivers is absolutely bananas: how did the Oscar-winning actor of Reversal of Fortune manage to keep a straight face on set? Like this article? How do you rate Jeremy Irons? Do you agree with these choices for best and worst performances from the actor? Let us know all your thoughts in the comments.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.