Joaquin Phoenix: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

In a recent interview with Elvis Mitchell of Interview Magazine, Joaquin Phoenix expressed his distaste for the Oscars, calling them, quite simply, "bullsh-t". It's clear that Phoenix is marching to the beat of his own drum, but it's a shame he shows such disdain towards the Oscars, since as of late, his choices have brought about some of the finest performances of his career that one would hope could finally land Phoenix the golden statue he deserves. In fact, over the past ten or so years, Phoenix has proven himself to be one of the finest and most versatile actors working today, delivering a string of increasingly daring, edgy, and career-defining performances that put most of his contemporaries to shame. Phoenix's dedication to each performance, and immersion in the characters he portrays, harkens back to De Niro's work with Martin Scorsese in the 70's and 80's. He even manges to find interesting angles to approach the increasingly rare Studio film characters he portrays. Phoenix is such a gifted actor, one would be hard-pressed to find any genuinely terrible performances in his filmography. However, his talents haven't prevented him from appearing in a few stinkers in his time. So without further ado, here are five of his best performances... and five that were lackluster.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Leonard Kraditor - Two Lovers

James Gray could be credited as the director who truly uncovered Phoenix's talent and exposed it to the world - Phoenix's volatile turn in Gray's film The Yards was the first testament to his abilities as an actor, and tendency to fully commit and immerse himself in his performances, if the characters provided him with enough depth to work with. Phoenix delivers an equally impressive but far subtler performance in Gray's most recent film, Two Lovers, starring opposite Gwyneth Paltrow in one of the finest performances of her respective career. Phoenix plays a Brooklyn bachelor torn between two women - his attractive neighbor, or his more homely family friend whom his parents wish he would marry. The film was unfortunately overshadowed by Phoenix's shenanigans that wound up becoming the film I'm Still Here, and the movie and performance remain criminally underrated and underseen - though there seems to be no bad blood between Phoenix and Gray; he is starring in Gray's upcoming film, Nightingale, to be released sometime in 2013.

4. Commodus - Gladiator

Gladiator has received a lot of backlash ever since it won the Oscar for Best Picture back in 2001, but I maintain my belief that it is one of the finest entertainments of the last twenty years, a high point in Ridley Scott's career, and an immensely enjoyable and successful reinvention of the classic Sword & Sandal epics of the 50's and 60's. Gladiator has so much going on - grand battles, thrilling fight scenes, arresting imagery, lavish production design, and an epic scope - that the villain had to truly stand out if he were to leave any lasting impression. And Joaquin Phoenix delivered on that front, in spades. Still relatively unknown at the time having only a handful of feature film roles under his belt at this point in his career, Phoenix had carte blanche to create an iconic villain. And he delivered on that potential, in spades: Phoenix's Commodus is one of the most chilling, memorable villains in any blockbuster film in recent memory. Phoenix truly seems to revel in Commodus' wickedness; his performance is effortless, and it looks as though Phoenix genuinely had a lot of fun embodying this character. Not one to miss out an opportunity on some rich character work, though, Phoenix also manages to inject the villainy with a little pathos, portraying Commodus' inferiority and his father's disappointment in him as the crux of his thirst for power. Phoenix ended up landing a much-deserved Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination, but did not win.

3. Johnny Cash - Walk The Line

Phoenix had delivered fantastic performances prior to his 2005 starring role as Johnny Cash in the James Mangold-directed bio-pic. But this performance showed the first signs of Phoenix's true dedication to the Method, allowing himself to be fully immersed in a character and undergo a physical transformation as well as an emotional one. Phoenix doesn't look particularly like Johnny Cash - he has a longer face, a thinner frame, and more attractive features. But he truly becomes Cash in this film, changing his voice, expression, demeanor, and even singing all of the songs on the soundtrack himself. Overall, Walk the Line is a well-made, handsomely produced but ultimately somewhat generic musical bio-pic (it was the predominant source of parody for the film Walk Hard: the Dewey Cox Story), but Phoenix's transformation into the legendary Cash elevated the film above the tropes of the genre, and it earned Phoenix his second career Oscar nomination, this time for Best Actor in a Lead Role.

2. Freddie Quell - The Master

It's hard to really describe just how incredible Phoenix's performance is in director Paul Thomas Anderson's latest opus, in theaters now. It was his first feature film role since I'm Still Here, after a near four-year absence, and everyone was wondering what this new Phoenix would bring to the table. What he ended up delivering was a Kubrickian level of dedication and immersion to his performance unlike anything he had ever done before. Phoenix's physical transformation is one of the most striking elements of his performance as alcoholic drifter Freddie Quell: His back hunched, swinging his arms like an ape, his frame thin, his face twisted and distorted, mumbling and slurring his speech out of the corner of his mouth like he is just learning how to behave in society for the first time, and failing. Phoenix€™ physical commitment to the performance doesn€™t stop there, either: he flings himself into scenes of raw violence that look and feel completely real. After I'm Still Here and in light of his recent anti-Oscar remarks, it is clear that Phoenix does and says whatever he pleases at this point. He has stripped himself of the expectations one has for an actor, and throws himself fully into a state of pure impulse and instinct. It is a crowning achievement in the art of acting and the Method, rivalling that of Daniel Day-Lewis's Oscar-winning turn in Anderson€™s previous film, There Will Be Blood. If there is any justice, this performance will garner Phoenix an Oscar nomination - and a potential win - despite his recent remarks.

1. As Himself - I'm Still Here

When talking about the Method, people tend to have a number of go-to examples of the finest examples of immersion in a role that truly exemplify the lengths actors will go for their craft. People talk about De Niro participating in actual boxing matches and gaining an incredible amount of weight for his Oscar-winning performance as Jake La Motta in Raging Bull. Or they talk about Martin Sheen actually being drunk, high and losing his mind during the disastrous year-long shooting schedule of Apocalypse Now. They talk about Christian Bale's extreme weight loss for films such as The Machinist and The Fighter, or they talk about Daniel Day-Lewis' entire filmography - refusing to move and having to be wheeled around and fed to immerse himself in the life of Christy Brown in My Left Foot, or living off the land for months in order to portray Nathaniel Poe in The Last of the Mohicans. However, nobody seems to mention Joaquin Phoenix's performance in I'm Still Here which, for my money, is the single greatest use of the Method by any actor in the entire history of the technique. Some of the hesitation might stem from the fact that, for a while, nobody was sure if this was a documentary or a work of fiction. For the longest time, it seemed as though Phoenix had actually lost it, quit acting, and decided to become a quite terrible rapper. Even after Phoenix and his brother-in-law Casey Affleck (who is married to Joaquin's sister, Summer Phoenix, and who co-starred with Phoenix in To Die For) came clean about the film, people still had a hard time to believe that everything was staged. Which, to me, is the greatest testament to the power of the performance one could ever expect. Forget staying in character while on set, researching roles, embodying characters, physical transformations, or any of that stuff. Joaquin Phoenix began portraying the role of Joaquin Phoenix in late 2008 and didn't stop acting the part for two entire years. He lived and breathed this character, from the physical transformation (the hair, the beard, the body fat) to the asshole demeanor, the failed rap career, the delusions of grandeur. All of it, every single moment, both the ones captured on camera and those not, were part of the act. And that is why I'm Still Here is Joaquin Phoenix's crowning achievement, and his finest performance to date.

5. That Sucked...


5. Doug Hoult - Inventing The Abbotts

In the shadow of his older brother River Phoenix's death, Joaquin had a lot to prove in his early career. River was considered by many to be one of the finest actors of his young generation, and Joaquin really had to step up if he was to walk in his brother's acclaimed footsteps. Unfortunately, things don't come that easy, especially when you're just starting out in the business. Prior to Inventing the Abbotts and following a string of guest roles on various TV shows, Phoenix had a small but memorable turn as a high school student seduced by Nicole Kidman's fame-crazed weatherwoman in Gus Van Sant's brilliant and underrated dark satire, To Die For. Abbotts was Phoenix's first starring role in a film, and one can see why he picked it - the film is certainly not the typical Hollywood fare that young actors usually go for to increase their exposure. Unfortunately, though, Inventing the Abbotts just isn't a good film. It's a bland, forgettable soapy melodrama bogged down by some very questionable directorial choices and an overall vapid, emotionless script. At this point in his career, Phoenix was a young up-and-comer who was hired for his youthful looks more than for his acting talent, and his uninspired performance in this film reflects that very well.

4. Jack Morrison - Ladder 49

It's hard to really understand why Phoenix even agreed to make this film in the first place. He had recently appeared in the hugely successful M. Night Shyamalan film Signs, so he couldn't have been desperate enough to be looking for more paycheck roles. Perhaps he genuinely saw something inspiring in the story about heroic Baltimore firefighters, a particularly hot subject in the post-9/11 climate in the United States. Again, it's not as though Ladder 49 is a particularly terrible film, and at no point does it feel as though Phoenix is phoning it in. But the material never provides Phoenix with enough depth or range to deliver anything but a typical, bland, cliched performance, and the film itself smooths too many edges and simplifies too many complex emotions to be taken seriously in any way, shape or form. Plus, it doesn't feature nearly enough hammy acting from John Travolta, who, like the rest of the movie, plays it too safe for anything interesting to come about from it.

3. Bobby Green - We Own the Night

Not all directors are always operating at full capacities, and even true talents like James Gray are bound to slip up every once in a while. We Own the Night is the polar opposite of Gray and Phoenix's subsequent collaboration, Two Lovers: It is a clunky, lazy, generic thriller full of ridiculous plot twists and overly dramatized moments. Gray, blessed with access to some of the finest actors working today, totally fumbles the execution, and even the actors can't save the film. Not for lack of trying, either: Again, it's not as though Phoenix and his talented co-stars deliver sub-par performances. Rather, they are simply not given anything to work with, between the sloppy scriptwriting and heavy-handed directing. With a shamefully underdeveloped character, Phoenix has nothing to latch onto as a performer and ends up sleepwalking through the film.

2. Max California - 8MM

Without a doubt the low point of his early career, even Phoenix's talents and ambitions couldn't save this Joel Schumacher-directed stinker. Phoenix plays a heavily tattooed, spiky-haired Goth; a seedy video store owner named Max California who helps Nicolas Cage's detective discover the truth about a snuff film found by a wealthy widow among the belongings of her recently deceased husband. Cage and Schumacher, of course, are no strangers to this sort of ham-fisted, over-the-top pulpy material, but Phoenix feels squarely out of place in their presence. He is clearly trying to have fun with the role, but he can't quite match the commitment to utter insanity that Cage brings to the table, and consequently, his performance feels a little lackluster. Additionally, it doesn't help that the screenplays is one of the absolute worst and most ridiculous ever produced as a high-budget feature film. Luckily, Phoenix followed this film up with the one-two punch of The Yards and Gladiator, which pretty much sealed his career from then on out. But 8MM was a slippery slope, and he almost didn't make it out in one piece. Nicolas Cage, for example, couldn't resist, and has continued to make movies just as bad and even worse than 8MM in his subsequent career.

1. Lucius Hunt - The Village

It's always hard to surmise just what an actor might be thinking or feeling on a film set just by looking at their performance in the final film. Michael Fassbender, for example, frequently scoffs at his mainstream roles in films such as X-Men: First Class and Prometheus. But one would be hard-pressed to notice his disdain from his performances as they appear in the films themselves: In both cases, it seems at least that Fassbender is fully dedicated to the role. In fact, he is the best part of both those respective films. However, one needs to look no further than The Village to see a troupe of genuinely talented actors, quite clearly and plainly, bored out of their minds. Struggling with some of the hammiest dialogue ever written and a plot so ridiculous it's impossible to think how anyone could take it seriously, almost all of the performances in this film suffer, even honest efforts from Bryce Dallas-Howard and Adrien Brody. Phoenix, as the romantic lead, is himself barely present: a bored, lackluster performance that does not become his abilities or pedigree as an actor in the slightest. Phoenix actually delivered a very enjoyable, genuine, light-hearted performance as Merrill, Mel Gibson's character's brother, in M. Night Shyamalan's previous film Signs. I suppose he saw something in the young director, or enjoyed the experience enough to come back for another round. Apparently, the script for The Village had very high levels of security around it in order to protect the twist ending. Often in these cases, actors will sign on for a role without reading the entire script. Perhaps that's what happened here. But whatever the reason, what's for certain is that this is the most shameful stain on Phoenix's otherwise mostly illustrious career, especially as of late.

Contributor
Contributor

Oren Soffer is currently a Junior majoring in Film/Television production at NYU Tisch School of the Arts. He has been harboring and fostering a love and passion for cinema since early childhood. Though he mainly focuses on making movies these days, he still enjoys writing about them as well.