Joel Schumacher's Batman: 6 Things He Did Better Than Nolan

BatNipples This might seem a difficult sell, and to be honest I'm really gonna have to dig deep into my recesses to pull this off - but then, I'm up to the challenge. Why? Because I think it's a worthwhile undertaking: I happen to think that Joel Schumacher is a very good director and it's sad to see how two silly superhero movies have tarnished an otherwise interesting and artistically fulfilling career. Also I feel that Schumacher's two Batman films, as flawed as they are, still have more worth and merit than the unholy trilogy that Nolan and his company produced, and I wince a little bit each time I hear someone singing the praises of Christopher Nolan his great Batman films while ignoring the vastly superior Burton and Schumacher films. Burton will at least get a condescending shout out by Batman fans but Schumacher is still regarded as the devil himself. I feel that most of the problems people find in Schumacher's Batman films are stupid nit-picky fanboy critiques that don't have anything to do with assessing the films as works of art but as comic book fanboy properties. It's utterly ridiculous for a film to be judged as bad just because there are nipples on a bat suit, or because somebody uses a bat credit card. Call me crazy but I happen to think that a film should fail or succeed based on things like acting, plot, direction, writing, etc. It seems that Schumacher gets a lot of flak solely for not depicting the "right kind" of Batman mystique: the kind of Batman people wanted to see. Forget all that frivolous business about making a good movie, just make sure you get the characterization of Batman correct, and if you do then the movie will get a pass even if it's an awful incoherent poorly directed mess. At least that's how it clearly worked for Christopher Nolan. Schumacher's Batman films were far from perfect but they don't deserve half the hate they receive. If people were to step back and take the Bat blinkers off they would see that both Schumacher Batman films have their strengths as well as their weaknesses. Since we never hear about anything but weaknesses, I've chosen to highlight 6 things that I believe Joel Schumacher did right in adapting Batman for the big screen, and 6 things that consequently make him a better Batman director than Christopher Nolan. Maybe if we focus on the good and stop over-emphasizing the bad, we can learn to once again appreciate the cinema a great modern day auteur. Let's get into it...

6. He Cast Jim Carrey As The Riddler

Jim Carrey It seems the passage of time has the ability turn people into haters - how else can you explain the current dislike Jim Carrey garners for his portrayal of the Riddler in Batman Forever? If I recall correctly, when it was announced in 1994 that Jim Carrey would don the famous green bowler hat and suit jacket it was generally regarded as good news. Why wouldn't it be? You have one of the greatest comedic talents of this generation (maybe ever) pouring his talents into the role of one of Batman's most legendary adversaries. Of course the public had every right to cry foul if the execution was poor, but it plainly wasn't . If I may say so, Carrey took the role of The Riddler and knocked it out the of park. Yes, he did bring his trademark rubber-faced humor to the role but, contrary to popular opinion, I don't see that as such a bad thing. After all, isn't the Riddler considered to be one of the more jokey character in Batman's rouge gallery (he does tell riddles after all)? And yes, I know he's supposed to be a psycho (although technically his diagnosis is that of extreme obsessive compulsive disorder) but I ask you, what form of psychosis is not without a little bit of humor? It has always been my observation that crazy equals funny. Tim Burton understood this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9OufCgFZCyU Joel Schumacher understood this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7WornrF-gs Nolan didn't: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79HJj9PewU8 Geez. I'd rather watch the Joker go to an art museum than see him crash that party again. Even as far as homicidal killers go Heath Ledger's Joker is a bit of a buzz kill. Yet, in today's society it seems that the more dark and joyless a film is the better. I would hate to imagine the kind of Riddler Nolanites would enjoy. He'd probably cut his victims ears off then whisper riddles inside of them before stapling them back to his victims head so they could answer. Think I'm going to far? Not if you recall the scene in the Dark knight where a guy is walking around with a cell phone bomb sewn into his stomach. Uhh....excuse me, I paid for a ticket to a Batman movie, not David Fincher's Seven. You guys can have the cell phone bombs and pencil tricks if you want em'. Me, I'm content to watch Jim Carrey's Riddler prancing around Gotham city wreaking his own merry brand of destruction.

5. He Cast Val Kilmer As Bruce Wayne/Batman

Kilmer Batman Let me preface this by saying I'm am not making an argument about who is the better Batman. All I intend to do is put some Whatculture! readers wise to what I consider a very underrated performance by Val Kilmer. The fact that the performance in question happens to be Batman is a coincidence, however, since I know a lot of you out there will probably wonder where my preferences lie I'll acquiesce and give my choice for who is the best Batman ever. What follows is a list of actors who've portrayed the iconic character numbered 1 thru 7 with 1 being the best and 7 being the worst. Kevin Conroy Micheal Keaton Val Kilmer Adam West Lewis Wilson George Clooney Christian Bale Now onto the real subject: the criminally underrated performance of Val Kilmer in Batman Forever. Once again, like with the Riddler we have a case of hindsight hater-ade going on. Val Kilmer's performance, when assessed upon the initial release of the film, was generally favorable. While not considered to be an improvement over Keaton he certainly wasn't a downgrade, and if the movie had any faults it wasn't in his performance. Now, when viewed through the prism of the Dark Nolan era it seems as if Kilmer's interpretation of Bruce Wayne/Batman was never any good at all. Of course it doesn't receive the same amount of hate as the Clooney's Batman but in the same way it has come to be unappreciated and disregarded on grounds that are unfair and ridiculous (not dark enough, too much humor, not enough brooding, bat nipples). Why, may I ask, it is so bad for a little bit of levity to be part of Batman's persona? Yes, I understand that he is a dark vigilante who uses fear as a means of striking terror in his enemies, but that doesn't mean he can't occasionally let a bit of humor into his visage. If not only for his own sake then for the audiences. Too much doom and gloom wears on an audience and can make the movie watching experience unbearable. Also performances that rely too much on overbearing drama can come kind of (unintentionally) silly: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=efQ4XtGwNKM See what I mean? That's a Batman who takes himself way too seriously (I know, I know......Why so serious ). Even the most stalwart fans of Nolan's Batman admitted that Bale's performance was a bit over the top. I know Batman has this dark image to uphold but too much of that stuff is just unnatural. People understand that no person can be all doom and gloom all the time. Even Batman. In order for the Dark Knight to be a bit more of a believable character moments of levity must be implemented into his character. Tim Burton Understood this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zu_lw3cRz3k Joel Schumacher Understood it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NRmJKuIKdpw Nolan clearly didn't: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vhJYt0UL7AQ And please, don't for a moment think that Kilmer (like Carrey) couldn't turn on the menace when he had to. It's just that Schumacher, unlike Nolan, had enough sense not to let it get out of hand. By making room for a bit of levity he was able to direct Kilmer toward a more balanced and accessible portrayal of the Dark Knight. As a result his incarnation (along with Keaton's) remains as impressive today as it did in back in 95 while Bale's interpretation of the caped crusader has already lapsed into parody.

4. Holy Rusted Metal Batman!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k2qvULu70dE I didn't get the reference when I saw the film back in 95' - I was still a youngster and hadn't been hipped yet to the awesome 1960's Adam West Batman. Once I became privy to that classic bit of camp I went back and re-watched Batman Forever and found myself utterly enchanted by a sly loving shoutout in the film to the 60's series in the form of a homage to Burt Ward's iconic portrayal of the boy wonder. Nolan's Batman trilogy all but blanked the Batman heritage, and missed out on a terrific opportunity for fan service and to pay its dues. That is simple arrogance. I don't care if you're a fan of Nolan's ultra "realistic" take on the Batman franchise or not: if this clip doesn't make you crack a nostalgic smile then you truly have no since of humor. Perhaps a dose of the Joker's laughing gas would help? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nltVuSH-lQM

3. The Final Shots Of Batman Forever And Batman And Robin

batman-forever-batsignal (2) If you were given the task of interpreting visually the heroism of Batman how would you do it? How would you go about capturing both the triumphant weight of duty contrasted with the burden of dark vigilantism inherent to the character? I would be surprised if anyone could do better than what Joel Schumacher achieved in his two Batman films. The end coda he directs for his two Batman movies, that of the caped crusader and his partner(s) running toward the screen silhouetted against the darkness with their only illumination being the bat signal is one of the great images in superhero films not to mention all of cinema. It so perfectly captures in an emotionally stylized way what it means to be Batman. Sadly such stylization and emotive storytelling is passé in today's ultra realistic film world, which works out well for Christopher Nolan seeing as his labored dark naturalistic aesthetic could never compare to Joel Schumacher's ultra stylized approach in his two Batman films. Viewers were fooled into believing that Nolan's lazy visuals and muddled philosophies were important cinema when in reality it was Schumacher who delivered the most dynamic emotional cinematic representation of what it means to be Batman. To quote Rouben Mamoulian the great director of Hollywood's Golden Age:
What attracts me to films is not the dialogue It's the imagery, the magic of the camera. And I've always believed in stylization and poetry. If you preserved the psychological truth of the emotions and thoughts of the actors, and combine that with the physical expression that is utterly stylized and that couldn't happen in real life the impact upon the audience is one of greater reality. Perhaps that's why they call it surrealism. This becomes more real to the audience than if you had done it in a realistic manner. Done correctly, stylization carries greater reality in its impact on the audience than everyday kitchen naturalism ever can achieve.
Tim Burton understood this... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=feR_YQ75Maw Joel Schumacher understood this... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vUVvtizLO8 Nolan clearly didn't... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oL7PSlUuWPs Even at his worst Joel Schumacher still has better chops as a cinematic stylist than Christopher Nolan. Watch anyone of Joel Schumacher films and you'll see the work of a born cinematic stylist: you'll see someone who uses all the tools of filmmaking at his disposal to make bold, unique and artistic movies. Watch one of Christopher Nolan's films and you'll see a man who, to quote film critic Armond White, "doesn't have a born filmmaker€™s natural gift for detail, composition and movement". Nolan failed completely at capturing the essence of what it means to be Batman (and a hero in general). All he could do was load down the audience with lame visuals and dull repetitive nihilism and then try to be theatrical and cinematic by tying everything together with a lame contrived ending. People can say whatever they want to about Schumacher's but they must admit he was better able than Nolan to capture the essence of what it means to be the Dark Knight in cinematic form. At least for one glorious shot.

2. Uma Thurman as Poison Ivy

0018f0ex

It's all pure camp. There's no denying that. But it's the good kind of camp. It's the What Ever Happened To Baby Jane/ Mommie Dearest kind of camp. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--RI7tlWuaM I think the difference between good camp and bad camp is whether or not the actor is able to pull off the performance. Arnold Schwarzenegger as Mr. Freeze falls into the category of bad camp because he played the part so over the top that he lost his motivation and let the character get away from him. But Uma Thurman doesn't make the same mistake: not once in the film, whether she was slinking around in her sexy Poison Ivy cat suit or giving one of her sultry super villain monologues, did she ever lose grasp of the roots of who her character was. If an actor is able to do this then the audience wont be distracted by how far out into left field the actor takes the character but rather will go along for the ride. They will be shocked (or appalled) just by how twisted a human being the person has become but they will never lose their investment in the character (think of what Tim Curry in the Rocky Horror Picture Show). Poison Ivy has always been one of the more fanciful villains in Batman's Rogues Gallery. She is a woman with an affinity for plant life that goes far beyond that of the average tree hugger - we're talking about a psychosis that verges on full blown Dendrophilia with homicidal tendencies. A woman driven to new heights of lunacy by her fanatical devotion to mother nature. Rendering such an obtuse character at least halfway believable (in the cinematic sense) would not be an easy task but Thurman pulled it off. How? By finding a base for her performance in a famous example of (overblown) cinematic femininity: Mae West http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVrfHXnUJFc Mae West was a woman who was a feminine force of sexual nature. Poison Ivy functions in the same way as Mae except that in Mae's world men = sex and in Ivy's world plants = sex. By using a familiar cultural touchstone as a basis for her acting, Uma maintained an element of believably in her performance because she was working in a vein of fictionalized woman hood that we as a culture had come to accept. As a result no matter how crazy her performance got, we bought it. I have a lot of fun with Uma Thurman's performance because I see how much gusto she puts into it. Yes, if I had my druthers I would have probably told Uma to dial it back a little bit; maybe tone down the sultry/seductive tendencies from 11 down to 10. But it is still a dynamite performance and I doubt, in the rare event Poison Ivy ever makes her way back to the big screen, that another actress will be able to do any better. Compare her performance to the Nolan villains, and she is head and shoulders above them, because of her conviction and the explicit homages in her performance. And Schumacher deserves the credit for the casting.

1. The Score

360_elliot_goldenthal_0630

Now I'll be honest, if it was 1994 and I heard a new Batman film was going into production without Danny Elfman's iconic Batman score, I'd probably had been pretty angry. Why mess with perfection? Did not Elfman's score perfectly capture the essence of the Batman character? Is there any real reason to change it? Well, if that was the case and I has said that in 1994 then come June 16, 1995 I would have been eating a very big bucket of crow. I'm not saying Elliot Goldenthal's scores for Joel Schumacher's Batman films top the work Danny Elfman did but Goldenthal's work was still very successful and captured in a different way the essence of the Batman character.I think the reason why Elliot Goldenthal was so successful was because he didn't try and rock the boat. He must have figured that he couldn't possibly top Elfman and didn't want to try. What he ended up doing instead was kind of a variation on Elfman's own Batman theme from the Burton era. Here is Goldenthal's Batman theme from Batman Forever and Batman and Robin http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pexxk6tMKLQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhWlEW4mZYk Here is Danny Elfman's Batman Theme from the Burton era: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wgpmdqUEQRM You can call it copycatting, you can say it's a rip off, but you must admit that it's effective. Goldenthal stayed in familiar territory keeping the dramatic use of horns and percussion in grand sweeping fashions. The score has a very rich dramatic texture that mesmerizes the audience and lends a great deal of Gothic mythos to the Batman legacy. Whatever the case you must admit that Goldenthal's score is ten time better than this banal, repetitive forgettable, TV quality, score that Hans Zimmer made for Nolan's Batman. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0wk88rjYS8 Here's hoping Superman fares a lot better. Or else come June 14, 2013 you will believe a man can fly... around the world depressed. So what do you think? Am I mad to think Joel Schumacher's Batman movies actually have strong points? Or is a unfairly railroaded director finally getting the respect he deserves? Please no death threats or bullying. I know Batman fans can be a tad temperamental but lets keep the comment section a safe place for ideas to be shared.

Contributor
Contributor

Raymond Woods is too busy watching movies to give you a decent bio. If he wasn't too busy watching movies and reading books about movies and listening to podcasts about movies, this is what he'd tell you. "I know more about film than you. Accept this as a fact and we might be able to talk."