John C Reilly: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

Mr Cellophane...

John C Reilly Tale Of Tales
HanWay Films

Just as there was a Brat Pack of Hollywood's hottest young things in the 80s, there should probably be a collective noun for the gaggle of interesting character actors who cut careers out of quirky roles and indie films in the late 90s and early 00s. The likes of William H Macy, Philip Seymour Hoffman and John C Reilly: they weren't necessarily cool, but they were remarkably watchable, hugely charming and more often than not, brilliant.

A lot has changed since then for all three, and Reilly is now probably more known as a comedy actor with a penchant for goofball roles. That actually reflects only a small section of his work, and his CV reads like an exercise in genre-hopping, with his biggest successes invariably coming with human characters with flaws, or marked by tragedy. He's incredibly charming, can be hilarious and he has an earnesty and an authenticity that suits both supporting and leading roles.

To celebrate the release of Reilly's latest - Matteo Garrone's fantastical Tale Of Tales - this week's Awesome/Sucked column goes to the indie darling who seems to revel in taking on surprisingly varied roles. Considering he plays what amounts to a fairytale king for Garrone, variety seems a particularly apt launching point...

5 Awesome Performances

5. Wreck-It Ralph - Wreck-It-Ralph (2012)

Wreck It Ralph
Disney

It might be considered "easy" to perform vocal only roles in movies, but the reality of a successful, nuanced performance in an animation is in fact the opposite. Because, of course, there's vocal work and there's vocal performance - a distinction that marks the most memorable (and usually beloved) turns like Baloo the bear, Cogsworth and Lumiere and Scar from The Lion King.

In each case they channel something that Reilly managed with Ralph - they add layers and recognisable humanity to the cartoon appearance. While Sarah Silverman's Venelope is a grating, colourful spright designed to appear annoying and less complex (until her backstory is revealed at least), Ralph's genius is how real he is. That's the whole appeal of the film of course - the idea that video game character are just like us - but there's something warm, familiar and haunting about his insecurities and his desire for acceptance that make him startlingly human.

Impressively, Reilly never descends to simply doing a silly voice: he treats the material with dignity and it's entirely authentic to the point that his attempted heroic sacrifice at the end is terribly affecting.


4. Reed Rothchild - Boogie Nights (1997)

Boogie Nights
New Line Cinema

Back before he started making goofball comedies with Will Ferrell (they're good and they have their own audience but they're not this rich), Reilly was taking on interesting supporting roles and generally making a name for himself as an intriguing upcomer.

It was roles like his key supporting role in Boogie Nights that told that specific story: it's a performance of warmth, comedy and charisma. And it also set up his later career trajectory in films alongside Ferrell. His chemistry with Mark Wahlberg is the stuff bromantic dreams are made of, and there's something remarkably likeable in the way Reilly's Rothchild bumbles through calamities. He should be more of an unlikable buffoon, but in the actor's hands he's merely misguided and silly, with his magic career pay-off being one of the most rewarding of the entire film.

It's a mostly unspectacular performance, in conventional terms, but it's all about creating a likeable support that makes the lead character more authentic and more believably likeable in term. That sort of thing should never be overlooked.


3. Phil Last - The Good Girl (2002)

Good Girl The Jennifer Aniston John C Reilly
Fox Searchlight

There's just something about Reilly's look that immediately lends itself to hang-dog losers and outsiders: he's not conventionally good-looking by Hollywood standards (whether you like it or not, that matters to casting directors), he gives great "dope face" and he suits indies that tend to feature such characters.

In The Good Girl, he was at peak loser: portraying a stoner with an improbably beautiful wife and life he was throwing away through reckless shlubbing with his no-good stoner best friend. Remarkably, he still makes Phil a likeable, almost tragi-comic figure: he's the archetypal Shakespearean fool, cuckolded (but entirely to blame) whose ultimate "victory" is hollow and tainted.

Reilly plays the stoner element perfectly, and it's his goofy charm that turns Jennifer Anniston (in her best performance) into a villainess with such complexity that you can't help but think you'd do exactly as she did. After all, she's trapped in a world where a life with him is all she can hope to achieve.


2. Dewey Cox - Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story (2007)

Walk Hard John C Reilly
Columbia Pictures

After making a hugely popular (in cult terms at least) comic swerve for Talladega Nights, Reilly cemented his silliest comic period (which also included 2008's Step Brothers, of course) with this gloriously daft spoof biopic. It doesn't quite have the subtleties of a Christopher Guest, but you can tell Judd Apatow's intention was to lampoon the lampooner just as much as the popular music figures it takes off.

Reilly is brilliant as Cox, even when the film isn't all that great or all that funny. He's easily the best thing about it (aside from the ridiculous Beatles riff), never treating the material with disdain and cutting the right balance to suggest this as an affectionate spoof of American music culture rather than a barbed take-down.

Buoyed by his charm (the warming charm of an idiot, it has to be said), Walk Hard plays like an inverted Forest Gump of music history, marred by personal foul ups and tragedy (something Reilly excels at), but still silly enough to be charming.


1. Amos Hart - Chicago (2002)

John C Reilly Chicago
Miramax

For all the well-placed criticisms Chicago's critical adoration inspired, there can be no doubt that John C Reilly deserved his Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination. Even if he didn't deserve to win, the acknowledgement alone was the right reception for his tender, wounded performance as the wronged husband.

Looking at his past supporting roles and his flair for tragedy of the oldest form, Amos Hart might well have been made for him. He's an unspectacular, unremarkable comfortable man, dependable, charming and unexotic in equal measure, and Reilly's sad reflection on his condition - particularly in his version of "Mr Cellophane" is just perfect.

Amos should be a fool (and he is to a certain degree), but the power of his performance is that it sells the deceitful marketing of the film. Despite himself, and despite how obviously he's being played, he's hopefuly and caring and he's sold the Old Razzle Dazzle utterly helplessly. And if it were any other actor you'd blame him - it's just that Reilly is so damn sympathetic.

And now on to the moments where he hasn't shone quite so brightly...


5 That Sucked

5. Maury Slocum - Life After Beth (2014)

Life After Beth Molly Shannon John C Reilly
A24

The biggest problem with Life After Beth is that it's never as ingenious or as original as it seems to think: the unknown zombie trope is something we've seen quite a lot recently, and unfortunately for almost every film in the sub-genre, it's an idea that plays out best as a short sketch.

When elongated to a feature like this, it gets flabby and outstays its welcome, no matter how good the cast seem to be. The central gag runs out of fuel pretty quickly and at that point it's the responsibility of the other elements to pick up the slack.

Unfortunately, Life After Beth was clearly written with the assumption that the zom-com element would be enough, so it leaves nothing else. Reilly (and co-star Molly Shannon) is left without any substance to play with. That means an absence of performance - he's no more than narrative furniture and it's a terrible waste.


4. Larten Crepsley - Crique Du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant (2009)

John C Reilly Cirque Du Freak
Universal Pictures

By 2009, Reilly was attracting more leading man projects after his well-received comedic turns, but quite why he thought this was a good idea to build his profile is anyone's guess.

There was obviously a lot in Darren Shan's book series that suggested adaptation (not least its sales), but it wasn't given to the right people at all. Paul Weitz might have been great for American Pie, but his executive producer credit on The Golden Compass should have offered fair warning for Cirque Du Freak.

Though Reilly offers a spirited performance as ginger vampire Larten Crepsley, he's hampered by the film's wayward tone and identity crisis that fails to establish whether it's trying to be grim or funny. That ends up making him look a little like an idiot, clowning around in a landscape of dull characters all plodding towards a painfully rote moral conclusion.


3. Mr Murray - Dark Water (2005)

John C Reilly In Dark Water
Buena Vista

I actually don't think Dark Water is a fully terrible movie: it's a fairly harmless, occasionally creepy Americanisation of a far superior J-horror original that fudges the spirit a little and attempts to trade solely on the "oh, I recognise these faces more than those foreign ones" feeling Western audiences are supposed to love.

The problem is that Reilly is sort of dropped in entirely needlessly as a recognisable face for the sake of it. He's malevolent enough to convince you that yes, all estate agents really are the spawn of Satan. It's an odd casting, because he's not really known for snivelling weasels and for a character actor to have such little time to build an actual character is just problematic.

Perhaps I'm asking too much, but this felt like a wasted casting: he is never quite enough of a caricature to unsettle and it's hard to destabilise audience expectations enough to accept he's not a good guy under the slime.


2. Richard Wehlner - The Promotion (2008)

John C Reilly The Promotion
Dimension Films

There should be a pretty firm guideline in all agent offices in Hollywood: never sign on to anything Seann William Scott says yes to. Sadly, Reilly didn't heed that message and signed on for this tale of two warring greengrocers seeking the American Dream of their own supermarket to manage.

One is a recovering drug addict from a biker gang, and the other a happily married man with a conscience who feels discomfort at the underhand tactics of their competition. Curiously, Reilly is the latter, making for an understated performance from Scott: it's almost like someone put their names on the wrong dressing rooms on day one and nobody had the heart to tell them.

The film again suffers something of an identity crisis - it sounds like it should be a black slapstick (you can almost imagine it as a smarter Ealing comedy), but it pushes nothing far enough, and it is hamstrung horribly by the casting issue that makes the "bad guy" much more likeable than the supposedly sympathetic one.


1. Happy Jack - Gangs Of New York (2002)

John C Reilly Gangs Of New York
Miramax

Gangs Of New York is a film that lives and dies on performances. Daniel Day Lewis is remarkable in it, and Brendan Gleeson is equally watchable: but it feels very much like they used up the good acting quota and everyone else was forced to be horrible. Leonardo DiCaprio is curiously sloppy, Cameron Diaz is awful, Jim Broadbent is woeful and John C Reilly is over-the-top and detestable.

He's not a good fit, and the result is that it feels like he's playing at being the bad guy, rather than simply performing the character. It's a hard distinction to measure, but it's unavoidable in this case and the performance simply does not ring true. He's hampered not only by having to compete with Day Lewis as a villain (a thankless task) but also with a lack of real depth and a horrific accent.

Quite how the film gets a pass remains a personal mystery (when its entertainment is solely down to DDL's performance), and it's a shame for Reilly that he was ever involved.

What are your favourite John C Reilly performances? Which movies rank as his worst? Share your own rankings below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.