John Hurt's 10 Most Underrated Performances

John Hurt Alien I've just finished a turn with Tiverton Dramatic Society in A Man For All Seasons, Robert Bolt's classic play about the life and downfall of Sir Thomas More. In this production I played Richard Rich, the ambitious young man who ultimately betrays More, stepping into the shoes of John Hurt who had played him in the Oscar-winning film version. All of which got me thinking: out of all Hurt's great performances, on how many Top 10 lists would Richard Rich make an appearance? Over a career spanning more than 5 decades, John Hurt has become one of the most highly-regarded actors of his generation. He was recently honoured with a BAFTA Lifetime Achievement Award, and seems to work relentlessly on both stage and screen. We all remember the career-making chest-burster scene in Alien, or his transformation into John Merrick in The Elephant Man, but in a career so long and so revered, a few great performances are bound to slip through the net. This list looks to rectify this, paying tribute to one of Britain's national treasures without just falling back on his most famous work and thereby resorting to platitude. So, let's dive into John Hurt's 10 most underrated performances...

10. Stephen Ward - Scandal (1989)

John Hurt Scandal I wanted to include at least one of Hurt's political performances on this list, and was originally going to opt for his main role in the BBC drama The Alan Clark Diaries. But while that performance is a lot of fun, filled with loaded glances and lecherous narration, his performance in Scandal is on reflection far more weighty and interesting. Scandal tells the story of the Profumo Affair in 1963, in which John Profumo, British Secretary of State for War, had a brief affair with call-girl Christine Keeler. After it emerged that Keeler had previously had a relationship with a prominent Soviet attaché, there were concerns that Profumo could have leaked national security secrets to her. Profumo lied to the House of Commons about their relationship, and when the truth eventually came out, he resigned in disgrace and Harold Macmillan's government collapsed soon afterwards. In the film, Hurt plays Stephen Ward, the upwardly-mobile osteopath who befriends Keeler, invites her to live with him and introduces her to Profumo at a party, inadvertently putting things in motion. Hurt paints a wonderful picture of Ward as someone seemingly upstanding, respectable and friends with all the right people, but who has a seedy and manipulative underbelly. Hurt never over-eggs the seediness, letting the circumstances of his character speak for themselves, resulting in a memorable performance.

9. Aragorn - The Lord of the Rings (1978)

Aragon Lotr Animated

Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy is an astonishing achievement, and played a big part in getting me seriously interested in film. But whilst it is widely considered the best attempt to put J. R. R. Tolkien's epic on screen, it was by no means the first. Back in the late-1970s, animator Ralph Bakshi had a reasonable go at the events of the first two books - and John Hurt was on board as the voice of Aragorn.

There are a great many things wrong with Bakshi's version. Aside from only covering the first half of the story, its visuals haven't dated very well and it is not as tonally strong; frankly it is difficult to see how anyone could prefer it over the Jackson version. But the voice artists are one of its saving graces, particularly Hurt's performance as Aragorn. While Viggo Mortensen's take is perhaps the definitive portrayal of the character, Hurt still brings out his strength and resilience, with his rich, deep voice being a source of both threat and comfort. This is the first of two voice-only choices on this list, which isn't entirely surprising; while Hurt has lent his voice to narration many times (e.g. Lars von Trier's Dogville and Manderlay), he hasn't done a great deal of animation voice work. Nonetheless, he brings a lot of weight to the part of Aragorn, helping to balance out the often goofy eccentricities of Gandalf and the hobbits.

8. Jellon Lamb - The Proposition (2005)

John Hurt The Proposition Both this and the following entry are what might be referred to as "old man cameos": a revered actor turning up in old age for a very brief part, which in some cases shapes the rest of the film. John Hurt is only in The Proposition for about ten minutes, but it is a memorable ten minutes. The Proposition is the debut feature by John Hillcoat, who would later direct The Road (starring Viggo Mortensen - see how this all fits together?). Working from a script by the legendary singer-songwriter Nick Cave, it tells the story of criminal Charlie Burns (Guy Pearce), who is forced to hunt down and kill his older brother Arthur (Danny Huston) so that he and his younger brother can go free. Set in the Australian outback in the 1880s, it's a very atmospheric story with big Old Testament overtones. Jellon Lamb is a bounty hunter who is also on Arthur's trail. In his main scene, he and Charlie confront each other in a house, share a drink, muse about Charles Darwin and then Charlie knocks out Lamb and leaves. In the wider context of the plot, it's something of a whimsical diversion, but Hurt's gravelly voice and ragged appearance also add to the arid, unforgiving atmosphere of the film. If nothing else it's a memorable cameo which lifts some of the film's more ordinary elements.

7. Control - Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy (2011)

John Hurt Tinker Tailor Many people had problems with the film version of Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy. Some claimed that it didn't have the depth of the TV series, starring Alec Guinness - and there are certain moments where some small details have been lost or compressed. Others thought it boring, a film in which nothing happened and nothing was explained; on this, I would profoundly disagree. But one thing that most people have praised is the film's cast, and on this front Hurt hasn't quite got the credit he deserves. For those not in the know, Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy is a spy thriller written by John Le Carré, which follows the attempts of George Smiley (Gary Oldman) to find a double agent who is operating at the highest level of MI6, colloquially knownas The Circus. The title refers to the nicknames assigned by Control (Smiley's late boss) to the members of The Circus' main committee. While the TV series focussed on the twists and turns of Smiley's investigations, Tomas Alfredson (Let The Right One In) is more interested in the malaise of 1970s Britain, the redundancy of Smiley's profession and the sexual frustration and repression of the main characters. Hurt is in Tinker, Tailor only for around 5 minutes. His character sets up the search for the mole and gives us the title, before promptly popping his clogs in his hospital bed. Doesn't sound like anything special, but Hurt's performance goes some way in setting the mood. His wheezy delivery, in smoke-filled rooms cluttered with papers and dingy lighting, paint a picture of a mind and world that are slowly dying, desperately trying to retain power and do the right thing even when all seems lost. While Oldman deserves huge plaudits for his performance, it is Hurt who lays the groundwork in which that performance makes sense.

6. Jesus Christ - History Of The World, Part I (1981)

Jesus Henry There have been many memorable portrayals of Jesus Christ in cinema. Think Robert Powell in the mini-series Jesus of Nazareth, Willem Dafoe in The Last Temptation of Christ, Jim Caviezel in The Passion of the Christ, or Ralph Fiennes in The Miracle Maker. Unlike these names, Hurt's performance is essentially comedic, serving as the foil to Mel Brooks, but he still does a very good job in turning what could be a po-faced cameo into an integral part of the comedy. History of the World, Part I is an episodic film directed by and starring Brooks in five different roles. It charts the history of the world from the Stone Age to the French Revolution, stopping off in the Old Testament, the Roman Empire and the Spanish Inquisition along the way. While it's nothing like as funny, insightful or original as Monty Python's Life of Brian, it's still a really fun film which finds Brooks firing on all cylinders. Because the film has so much history to cover, Hurt's character is only on screen for two minutes. But in that two minutes he has a memorably witty exchange with Brooks, similar to the "Who's On First?" routine of Abbott and Costello. Crucially, Hurt resists the urge to play our Lord as overly serious; there is both an innocence to him and a sense that he is in on the joke. It's a very nice little moment and one of the highlights of a funny if sprawling film.

5. The Horned King - The Black Cauldron (1985)

Tbc Disney's The Black Cauldron is a strange little film. Heavily butchered by Jeffrey Katzenberg during its production, and beaten by The Care Bears Movie on opening weekend, it is perhaps the closest that Disney has ever come to an animated cult classic. The film has all manner of problems in both its narrative and characters, but it does have a cracking villain in the shape of the Horned King. The Black Cauldron is based loosely on the Welsh adventure series The Chronicles of Prydain, which were heavily influenced by Tolkien (him again). It follows an "assistant pig keeper" called Taran who sets off with the fortune-telling pig Henwyn (just go with it), and becomes embroiled in a plot by the Horned King to use an ancient evil cauldron to create an army of the undead. In short, it's a zombie film for children, and had the studio not got cold feet with its more gruesome scenes, it could have been a really good one. Hurt's performance as the Horned King is terrifying. The character design is scary enough, with the long cloak, horns and the skull-like face, but add in the forbidding, echo-y voice and the dark motivations, and you have one scary villain. That's not to mention the surprisingly graphic manner in which the character gets dispatched. While most Disney villains just fall to their deaths or die off-camera, the Horned King gets his skin ripped clean from his bones while screaming in agony, and then his body is vaporised by pure evil. Ouch.

4. Richard Rich - A Man For All Seasons (1966)

Oojfojofj This was bound to show up somewhere on the list given my introduction. But the role of Richard Rich is so pivotal in the story of A Man For All Seasons that without an actor of weight and ability, the story cannot move forward, at least not at such a pace. Richard Rich was Hurt's first genuinely big role, and he carries it off very well. A Man For All Seasons is adapted from Robert Bolt's award-winning play of the same name. It tells the story of Sir Thomas More (Paul Scofield), Lord Chancellor to King Henry VIII (Robert Shaw), who resigned from his office and was eventually executed for refusing to acknowledge the King's divorce from Catherine of Aragon and his subsequent status as Supreme Head of the Church of England. It won six Oscars, including Best Picture and Best Actor for Scofield. Rich begins the story as More's friend, who is then seduced by offers of power by the King's secretary Thomas Cromwell (Leo McKern). It's a role that embodies one of the play's big themes: the triumph of status and materialism over spirituality and morals. Hurt is required to transition from a pathetic, insecure weakling to a stately gentleman, albeit one firmly under Cromwell's thumb - and it's very convincing. He counterpoints his anger in the early scenes with a sense of gracefulness later on, and he has enough presence to hold his own against both Scofield and McKern.

3. The Storyteller - The Storyteller (1988)

John Hurt The Storyteller Jim Henson's legacy in film and TV is in no doubt, with The Muppets on both the big and small screen, the continuing success of Sesame Street, and cult classics like The Dark Crystal and Labyrinth. But just before his tragic death in 1990, Henson created another wonderful series which praised the art of storytelling and the value of folk and fairy tales, The Storyteller. The Storyteller consists of nine episodes, each one dedicated to a faithful retelling of a lesser-known folk tale, such as 'Sapsorrow' (starring Alison Doody from Indiana Jones), 'The Heartless Giant', 'The Three Ravens' (featuring Miranda Richardson) and 'The Soldier And Death'. In each case the material was played straight, with Henson employing puppets and animatronics to recreate the many dark, gruesome and grotesque creatures that inhabit the stories and challenge our heroes. Hurt serves as an anchor and frame for the stories, bickering about their meaning with a puppet dog voiced by Henson's son Brian, who later directed The Muppet Christmas Carol. The voice and make-up are brilliant, and he gets a beautiful balance between embracing the more ridiculous elements of the stories and giving weight to their often unusual morals. The entire series is a wonderful achievement, but 'The Soldier and Death' is particularly enjoyable, both for the story and for Hurt's rendering of it.

2. Timothy Evans - 10 Rillington Place (1971)

Wjojwd With only a week to go before Hallowe'en, many of us are on the hunt for a good scare. So if you're a fan of serial killer stories, but are bored with the Hannibal movies or their many derivatives, you could do a lot worse than checking out 10 Rillington Place. Coming 20 years before The Silence of the Lambs, it's visually a lot more restrained but just as terrifying and in some ways a lot more tragic. 10 Rillington Place is based on the true story of John Christie (Richard Attenborough), who murdered eight women in the titular house during World War II and buried their remains in the house and back garden. When new tenants arrive in the form of Timothy Evans (Hurt) and his family, Christie offers to help his wife get rid of an unwanted pregnancy - only to rape and strangle her to death, and then kill her daughter. Evans, being illiterate and of limited intelligence, is tried for the crimes and hanged in one of the biggest miscarriages of justice in British legal history. For most of the film, Hurt serves as a foil to the skin-crawling Attenborough, whose character is so far removed from the image we now have of him as the avuncular, grandfather figure in Jurassic Park. But in the final act Hurt comes into his own, with his fear and confusion at the sentence burning its way into our memories. The hanging scene is one of the most nerve-shredding in cinema, and the whole thing is well worth a look this Hallowe'en.

1. Caligula - I, Claudius (1976)

Johnrnrnrnr There are so many fascinating characters in I, Claudius that it's hard to pick a favourite. There's Sian Phillips' cold and scheming Livia, George Baker's repressed and spineless Tiberius, Derek Jacobi's brilliant rendering of the stammering title character, or even Christopher Biggins as the childish Nero. But for pure, demented intimidation, equal parts ridiculous and terrifying, John Hurt's Caligula really takes the prize. I, Claudius is a 1976 BBC series based on the novels by Rupert Graves, which tells the story of several Roman emperors of the Claudian dynasty, beginning with Augustus (Brian Blessed) and finishing with Claudius himself. Structured like a mob drama or soap opera, with characters speaking in vernacular English, it's a highly compelling piece of drama which still holds up as one of the finest things the BBC has ever done. Hurt originally passed on the part of the mad emperor, believing, in his own words, that "the known world couldn't possibly be led by a lunatic of this nature." Having been persuaded by director Herbert Wise at a party, he took to it like a duck to water, embracing the grotesque nature of the character and bringing a terrifying energy to the middle of the series. Caligula is a character who is both completely insane and completely genuine: he has absolute power and no control, all of which makes for compelling viewing. Hurt is equally scary when he's screaming as when he's softly whispering, and he gives Malcolm McDowell's more infamous rendition a run for its money. Have I missed any great performances out? Drop me a comment below...

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.