Johnny Depp: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Tonto and Silver The Lone Ranger

Johnny Depp just might be the most famous movie star in the world right now; whether you're a dedicated film buff or a casual viewer, you're going to have seen a fair share of his works, which is exactly why the guy's worth $350 million and has a swell of fans ranging from the teenage to the middle-aged. Depp is a great actor when he wants to be, but he's also one of the most inconsistent A-listers in Hollywood, turning in masterfully controlled turns and utterly unfussed, sleepwalking efforts one after the other. His latest effort, The Lone Ranger, opened in the US this week to a dismal box office and savage reviews, which alongside other things, criticised Depp for giving another of his famously phoned-in performances. We thought it apt to trawl back through the revered actor's filmography and look at what worked and, well, what sucked...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Sweeney Todd - Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber Of Fleet Street

Sweeney Todd

Teaming with his regular collaborator Tim Burton, Depp proved an unexpected facet of his talents by starring in an adaptation of the acclaimed musical Sweeney Todd, playing the titular murderous barber who teams with the local pie-maker to kill the locals and pack them into pies.

This could easily have been another example of Tim Burton excess, of a film that's all style and no substance, yet the performances combine with a pristine execution to make this one of the director's - and the actor's - better late-day efforts.

While Helena Bonham Carter might steal the show vocally, Depp nevertheless holds his own alongside her, hewing away from his heroic rogue stereotype and playing a truly savage character who is nevertheless an absolute hoot. The film also gives us a rare opportunity to see Depp die on-screen, getting his throat slit and graphically bleeding out.


4. Gilbert Grape - What's Eating Gilbert Grape

What's Eating Gilbert Grape

Though he's overshadowed in every way by Leonardo DiCaprio's stunning, Oscar-nominated performance as Gilbert's mentally challenged brother Arnie, Depp is a perfectly-picked everyman to make this wonderfully affecting story work.

Depp, who was by this point well known for playing youthful drifter-type characters, plays the part to a T, an affable character who nails down the film's earnest yet genuinely emotive tone.

It would have been easy for Depp's titular character to just be seen as a bit of a weirdo, yet Depp digs his heels in and imbues some subtle nuances into the character that make his relationship with his family - or as is often the case, his lack of it - thoroughly engaging.

DiCaprio may have taken the lion's share of the praise, but such a volcanic performance always needs a more sturdy ballast behind it, and that is Depp's superbly-played task here.


3. Ed Wood - Ed Wood

Ed Wood

One of Depp's most nuanced though least-appreciated performances comes in Tim Burton's superb document of the world's worst movie director, Ed Wood which, unsurprisingly, is one of the pair's least financially successful films to date. Burton takes the genius approach of shooting the film in much the same B-movie style as Wood did his own movies, allowing Depp to harness one of his very best peculiar, oddball performances.

Though the film could easily have been a skewering of an awful filmmaking non-talent, Burton instead takes a more heartfelt approach that celebrates the man's passion over his technical skill, and Depp conveys this in a quietly affecting manner. The Wood we see here has an almost childlike fascination with storytelling, and while he never achieved any acclaim whatsoever, the man's name has become etched in the annuls of film history forever more. This film could not have hurt.


2. Jack Sparrow - Pirates Of The Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl

Though Depp was already well-known as a Hollywood heartthrob and talented actor in quirky dramas, it really is his 2003 appearance in Pirates of the Caribbrean that propelled him to ridiculous levels of fame (and even more ridiculously-sized paycheques).

Depp not only won the hearts of a new generation of fans worldwide, but he also scooped a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination for his work as the drunk, roguish, mascara-clad pirate who ends up being a lot more likeable and memorable than the rather bland Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley.

So strong is Depp's presence that he has pretty much single-handedly steered the film into a multi-billion dollar franchise, with the fifth entry preparing to go into production within the next few months. Though the character has pretty much worn out his charm by now, he is still the most entertaining aspect of these increasingly-awful films, though it would be nice if Depp would stop taking these evident paycheque roles (exorbitantly profitable though they surely are).


1. Edward Scissorhands - Edward Scissorhands

Edward Scissorhands This performance may have flown under the radar of Oscar voters, but for me it is unquestionably Depp's strongest work to date, as well as his best film overall. So fruitful was Depp's initial collaboration with Burton here that it kick-started the well-known partnership between the two, with Depp playing the titular character, a deformed young man who lives on the outskirts of a sleepy suburban town, and upon being "discovered" by a kindly local, is taken in by her family. The film works on so many levels, most specifically as a satire on middle-class suburban life, but the real treat is Depp's quietly composed performance as the scarred, timid man who has spent years without any human contact, instead living alone in a castle in the hills. Seeing Edward be exploited by the locals is genuinely heartbreaking to watch thanks to Depp's nuanced turn, which doesn't explode into fierce emotion but instead turns inward, his face displaying much confusion and anguish at his predicament. Depp also nails the countless moments of comic relief, specifically when his surrogate "father" (played by Alan Arkin) gives him a drink of "lemonade" (it's actually alcohol).

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Willy Wonka - Charlie And The Chocolate Factory

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

Fruitful though his work with Tim Burton has been, it's also unearthed its share of absolute dreck, especially in the last decade or so. One such effort is Burton's admirable if misguided Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, which tries to take on a classic movie - and, above all else, a classic performance - but can't quite find the right tone to strike. Depp gives a wildly self-indulgent, irritating performance that he reportedly modeled on Michael Jackson among others, one rightly derided by the original Wonka himself, Gene Wilder.

I suppose one can't criticise Depp for just ripping off Wilder's attempt - it is new and ambitious, but it's just not very good. It's totally crazy and more than a little creepy, but there's the feeling here that Burton should have reined the actor in a little, rather than essentially letting him just do whatever he wanted with the cameras rolling. Had I watched this as a child, I doubtless wouldn't have slept for weeks.


4. Dean Corso - The Ninth Gate

The Ninth Gate

Johnny Depp being paired with Roman Polanski; what could possibly go wrong? A surprising amount, going by their woefully dull supernatural thriller The Ninth Gate, which has Depp playing Dean Corso, a man searching for a book that can apparently be used to summon the Devil.

Despite the interesting premise, which should make for a disturbing, creepy little thriller, this one barely registers a pulse - as is uncommon for both Polanski and Depp - and feels nothing like the director's other major satanic work, Rosemary's Baby.

Despite working with such an acclaimed director, one can't get the feeling that Depp is particularly excited about it, delivering a soporific performance that earned the actor some of the worst reviews of his career, even if the movie did end up turning a profit.


3. Kemp - The Rum Diary

The Rum Diary

Here's a film, however, that certainly didn't make anyone any money, raking back a mere $24 million against a budget reportedly double that. Despite the promise of some sexiness by way of Depp having a dalliance with the vivacious Amber Heard, this one failed to draw in audiences, likely because of its niche subject matter, which had Depp playing the plucky protagonist in Hunter S. Thompson's titular novel.

Essentially following along similar lines as his Raoul Duke from Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, Depp plays a writer prone to manic episodes, though the craziness just isn't anywhere near as pronounced or memorable, and the film is utterly, utterly forgettable as a result.

It'd be difficult to appreciate that this was a passion project for Depp when he seems to have put such little effort into bringing it to life. Just soulless.


2. Barnabas Collins - Dark Shadows

Dark Shadows

Easily the worst and most pointless collaboration between Depp and Burton, Dark Shadows is an adaptation of the classic 1970s TV soap, yet for a film about vampires, it's curiously de-toothed and sterile. This is the film that confirmed Depp and Burton's working relationship was as toxic as it once was prosperous; it allowed each to be lazy and try to coast off the other, yet when they both decided to phone their work in, the result was this sexless, dull, inept "comedy".

Depp again goes full Willy Wonka, indulging every ridiculous tic imaginable, and while his silly accent does sort of suit the tone they're shooting for, he's just not given anything of interest to do, short of a quick roll in the hay with the delectable Eva Green (easily the best thing about the film).


1. Frank Tupelo - The Tourist

The Tourist And still, Depp was able to plumb even lower depths with the hugely disappointing 2010 film The Tourist. This is a film that ticked a lot of boxes for a lot of people; Depp and Jolie finally being paired on screen as star-crossed lovers, an exotic foreign setting (Venice), and an acclaimed director (The Lives of Others' Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck) - what could possibly go wrong? The real problem with The Tourist, other than the fact that the ludicrously $100 million-budgeted action comedy has an awful script, is that Depp and Jolie curiously don't have a whole lot of chemistry. Their banter isn't very exciting, neither of the two seems particularly into what they're shooting, and there's not even a steamy sex scene like 99% of people watching the film wanted to see in the first place. Instead, we get the two hottest movie stars on the planet...and nothing happens. Awful. Which Depp performances do you love and hate? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.