Johnny Depp: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

An enigma wrapped in a riddle covered in make-up and a hat.

Johnny Depp Alice Through The Looking Glass
Disney

Late last year and early in this one, there was something of a narrative created around Johnny Depp. His performance in Black Mass was gathering some awards buzz, and the idea of this being his 'comeback' was floating around faster than the Black Pearl.

It never quite gained the momentum necessary, with Depp falling short of a fourth Oscar nomination, and while his performance was pretty good in it, the film was rather average. But the question of a Depp comeback became on interesting one.

He's unquestionably one of the biggest movie stars in the world, and has been for well over a decade now, and yet the trade-off seems to have been an increasingly poor choice of roles and over-reliance on weird make-up and silly hats.

Depp truly announced himself to the world in Pirates of the Caribbean, but to film fans he'd spent the past decade cultivating a filmography that set him apart from his peers and belied his pretty-boy looks - he could walk the line between blockbuster star and indie darling with perfect balance and rock-star swagger.

It's not that he's become a bad actor (Black Mass shows that), but rather put more stock into the strange habits and appearances than he has in actually acting. As he gets set to reprise his role as the Mad Hatter in Alice Through The Looking Glass, it's time to look back on one of the most popular and, yes, talented movie stars of a generation; the films that made us fall for him, and the ones that mean he has something to come back from.


5 That Were Awesome...

5. Joseph Pistone/Donnie Brasco - Donnie Brasco (1997)

Donnie Brasco Johnny Depp
TriStar Pictures

Well before he started putting eye-make up on or adding silly wigs and declaring himself a chameleon, a young Depp did some of his finest, most subtle work in the tense, thrilling Donnie Brasco.

He may have profited from a stunning script and career high work from Al Pacino, but Depp's performance is just as worthy of note and celebration. As undercover FBI agent Joseph Pistone, he's a picture of conflict, drawn towards the irresistible criminal life he's trying to bring down from within and wrought by tensions in his marriage caused by his job.

And as Donnie Brasco he's a cool, charismatic mob brat, upwardly mobile, never as overtly violent as Di Caprio's Billy in The Departed, but it feels like he's closer to being seduced. It all works wonderfully without the usually ostentatious flourishes you'd come to expect from later Depp work, and it's a true joy to watch him opposite Pacino.


4. Captain Jack Sparrow - Pirates Of The Caribbean: Curse Of The Black Pearl (2003)

Pirates Of The Caribbean Curse of the Black Pearl Jack Sparrow
Disney

When looking at Johnny Depp's career and fame, it's impossible to ignore the impact that Pirates of the Caribbean has had.

Although Depp was well-known long before 2003, thanks to being a teen idol on 21 Jump Street, and a string of critically-acclaimed films, Curse of the Black Pearl put him into a different stratosphere.

It gave him a second Oscar nomination, but more importantly turned him into one of the world's most bankable box-office stars, and it continues to be the role that defines him. Although easy to complain about the deluge of sequels (which I will do!), it's worth remembering just how good this was, and how great Depp is in it.

Riffing heavily on Keith Richards, Captain Jack Sparrow is a swaggering rock-star of the seas. He slurs and staggers his way through the movie, combining the Rolling Stone presence with endless charisma and physical acting straight of the silent era.


3. Raoul Duke - Fear And Loathing In Las Vegas (1998)

Fear and Loathing In Las Vegas Depp.png
Universal Pictures

If Depp embodied a rock-star for Pirates, then the early signs were there a few years earlier, when he gave a performance that essentially serves as the personification of an acid-trip.

On paper (as in, when you read the book) there isn't really anyway this should work on-screen. The Gonzo work of Hunter S. Thompson is a crazy-ride from start to finish, but Terry Gilliam and leading man Depp somehow manage to translate that perfectly to film.

Following a journey to Las Vegas to cover a motorcycle raze, it becomes a drug-hazed, psychedelic romp without a clearly defined plot or sense of what the f**k is actually going on. It's wonderfully ridiculous, and Depp is the sniffing glue that holds it all together; a funny, paranoid mess that somehow doesn't let up over the course of two hours.


2. Edward - Edward Scissorhands (1990)

Edward Scissorhands
20th Century Fox

The films so far on this list have shown Depp's ability to handle oversized humour and ridiculousness, and if you'd just heard the basic premise for Edward Scissorhands, it'd sound like more of the same.

Instead, this is the film that makes you fall in love with Johnny Depp the actor, and started the once-beautiful working relationship between him and director Tim Burton.

Burton's suburban gothic fairytale sees Edward, a Frankenstein's Monster-esque creation with scissors for hands (obviously), make his way into civilisation and the lives of the family who took him in, and those around them.

It could've been silly, but instead the pair combine to give us something with genuine depth and emotion. While Burton's direction and design can take some credit, a lot of the success is down to Depp, who makes Edward so innocent and gentle that you can't help but feel for him, and yet take delight in his untainted view of the world.


1. Ed Wood - Ed Wood (1994)

Ed Wood Johnny Depp
Buena Vista Pictures

If Edward Scissorhands was the film that birthed the Burton/Depp partnership, Ed Wood is the one where they perfected it, and it still stands as the masterpiece of both of their careers.

Another one that seems a tough sell - a biopic of the man declared the worst filmmaker of all time - we instead got a story that was incredibly compelling and sweet, and it becomes impossible not to root for its protagonist.

Depp doesn't need over-the-top make-up here, just a love of the source material, and the feel for playing an outsider. He plays Wood as a man who takes an incredible amount of joy in his craft, no matter the quality of the movies or the obstacles he has to overcome; there's a constant child-like smile on his face, a wide-eyed innocence, and whether he's declaring a terrible take as perfect or donning an Angora sweater he's a character you really care for and want to see succeed, no matter how small the success might actually be.


5 That Sucked...

5. Captain Jack Sparrow - Pirates Sequels (2006, 2007, 2011)

Pirates Of The Caribbean Jack Sparrow On Stranger Tides
Disney

While the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie was, like the ride it's based on, an endlessly-fun ride, the same sadly can't be said for the subsequent sequels: Dead Man's Chest, At World's End, and On Stranger Tides.

Each one has been bogged down with increasingly convoluted side-plots that people didn't care about, and at least a feeling of the running-time sailing up-and-up (true for the first two sequels, especially the stupidly long At World's End, but On Stranger Tides is the shortest in the franchise).

At the centre of all of them is Depp, whose Captain Jack Sparrow is one of the main reasons the films continuously break the $1bn barrier. An argument could be made for him remaining the best thing in the films, but that probably shows how poor they are. Sparrow hasn't grown over the course of the films, and instead wheels out the same schtick, only now it's wearing incredibly thin. The character is a rock-star, but now he's one of those rock-stars who refuses to age gracefully; he was once Keith Richards owning the stage, but now it's more like Iggy Pop going topless in those car insurance adverts.


4. Frank Tupelo - The Tourist (2010)

The Tourist Johnny Depp Angelina Jolie
Columbia Pictures

This probably isn't the worst film to ever receive a Golden Globe nomination for Best Picture (it was in the often-odd Musical or Comedy category to be fair), but it's certainly one of the weirdest examples in recent years. Or at least it is until you remember that it has two bonafide A-listers, and the Globes is often beholden to celebrity.

A good cast doesn't make a good film, and neither Depp nor co-star Angelina Jolie come out of this one particularly well, as a pair of characters who meet on a train travelling through Europe, allegedly offering a blend of romance, comedy, and thriller.

The film suffers from not quite knowing what it wants to be, with the direction not deft enough to handle both drama and comedy, nor romance and thriller. The leads obviously suffer from a sense of that as well, as there's a lack of chemistry between the pair, with a performance from Depp that just feels rather dull - not something you can often say about his roles, good or bad.


3. The Mad Hatter - Alice In Wonderland (2010)

Alice In Wonderland Johnny Depp Mad Hatter
Disney

The 7th collaboration between Depp and Burton, Alice in Wonderland is the one where it becomes clear they really ought to take a break from each other (and yet, perversely, it's their most commercially successful).

As a big fan of both of them, as well as the source material, I remember being rather excited when this one was announced: Burton! Depp! Wonderland! Instead, we got Underland, a CGI version of the fabled world that has had all joy sucked out of it.

The heart of the book is essentially ripped out, and what's left is a meandering and strangely straightforward film (with a Chosen One ploy and generic end battle). Depp, playing one of the most memorable characters from Lewis Carroll's work, tries to find depth and substance in the Hatter, but only ends up as a muddled mess with a dodgy accent and bright orange wig.


2. Will Caster - Transcendence (2014)

Transcendence Johnny Depp
Warner Bros.

With an intriguing high-concept, a talented cast including Depp, Morgan Freeman, and Rebecca Hall, and marking the first film from Chris Nolan's longtime cinematographer Wally Pfister, hopes were high for Transcendence being an original sci-fi hit.

It centred on a scientist hoping to achieve transcendence, a technological advancement that would create an ever-improving A.I. that would one day surpass human intelligence, but then has to upload his own consciousness when targeted by an anti-tech group.

Despite having some pretensions at tackling big ideas, the film never manages to live up to that notion, with leaps of logic and a failure to deliver any answers to the questions it tries to post. The cast maybe aren't the biggest failing here, but they do take some of the blame, and that certainly goes for Depp as the lead. Maybe it's fitting that for a man uploading his brain to a machine, he gives such a lifeless performance.


1. Mortdecai - Mortdecai (2015)

johnny depp mortdecai
Lionsgate

At some point, Depp's general shtick of playing pantomime caricatures in weird films was going to wear thin and he'd become a parody of himself. Some might say that happened when he continued playing Jack Sparrow after the films stopped being good, others might say it was when he befouled the Mad Hatter for Tim Burton, but it was really when he tried his damnedest to make Mortdecai work.

Unfortunately for him, the film was from a completely different time (when the Ealing comedy was king), and it wouldn't even have been good in that context.

Depp attempted to make something akin to a Pink Panther movie dropped into a modern period, focused around a central art heist, but the script isn't funny enough and Depp's wild caricature sticks out like a sore thumb. He lacks the comedy to balance his lack of restraint and the end result feels more like a parlour comedy you might see from a sixth form school troupe with that one kid who thinks he's destined for stardom.

And there's a reason he's now in middle management at a paper firm.

Which film performances would you rank as the best and worst of Johnny Depp's career to date? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.