Joker: 5 Theories That Actually Improve It

How do you improve something so... imperfectly perfect?

Joker Theories
Warner Bros.

Joker was a smash hit. Despite the controversy surrounding its release, the Scorsese inspired comic book movie broke box office records for October releases, despite a raft of controversy around it.

While both Todd Phillips and Joaquin Phoenix have both been dismissive of a sequel in the past, the success of the movie among critics and the box office has led to the inevitable chatter in the industry. Phillips and Phoenix have stopped short of confirming another movie, but they have both expressed an interest in continuing the Joker's story if a compelling plot can be found.

That being said, it should not be too difficult to find a compelling plot considering the number of questions this movie raises. These questions have also led to a slew of fan theories about this villain's place in the DC Extended Universe, a future appearance of Batman, or even if Arthur Fleck was *the* Joker at all! This article will introduce some of the more interesting theories about the movie, some of which will open doors for future sequels.

*Spoilers for Joker ahead*

5. Joker is the Symbol of Gotham

Joker Clown
Warner Bros.

In the Dark Knight Trilogy, one of the main themes is the idea of transcending into the territory of a 'symbol'. In Batman Begins, Bruce Wayne was clear that Batman could be anyone, that a man can be destroyed or killed, but a symbol is 'incorruptible'. In 2019's Joker, we can see a disturbed mirror of this notion. Rather than the stoic and heroic iconography of the bat as Gotham's symbol, we have the chaotic clown.

In both the Dark Knight Trilogy and Joker, Gotham is a corrupt city with a high crime rate and no hope. The problem is the same in both TDKT and Joker, yet their solutions are different.

In TDKT, the people side with Batman to bring about order and reduce crime. Whereas, the final act of Joker involves a clown riot throughout the city, sparked by the murder of three Wall Street boys by a man in clown make up (Arthur Fleck). In other words, TDKT had the people choose order, whereas Joker had the people choose anarchy.

Rather than the symbol of the bat drawing people into believing that their city can be better and that they can be better, the Joker's iconography shows the city has descended into chaos. This may be setting up the introduction of a Batman character who will have to arrive and save Gotham from its own self inflicted madness.


4. Robert Pattinson's Batman Will Appear in a Sequel

Robert Pattinson Batman
Warner Bros.

The movie ends with the murder of Bruce Wayne's parents as they leave the theatre, a sight that we’re rarely treated to in a Batman (related) movie…

This certainly sets up a Batman in this universe and if, as Phoenix and Phillips have both teased, there is potential for a sequel, it will surely involve the Caped Crusader. Batman is such an integral part of the Joker character, even more so now that Joker's actions directly sparked the event that leads Bruce Wayne on the journey to becoming Batman.

Additionally, Matt Reeves' 'the Batman' is rumoured to be set in the 1990s, so the timelines would line up smoothly, with Joker being set in 1981. Whether or not this will be part of the DCEU is still up for debate, perhaps this new Joker/Batman universe will remain self contained.

Some could argue that, if Batman was to exist in this universe, there would be a significant age difference between Batman and Joker. In the movie, Joker is aged somewhere between 35 (at best) and 45. This means that, as Bruce Wayne is around 10 in the movie, Joker would be around 60 years old by the time Batman shows up.

That being said, this age gap wouldn't be much of a problem in terms of plot. In Batman 1989, there was a 30 year age gap between hero and villain. Furthermore, there is no real need for a physical match between the two. Batman has always easily bested Joker in a fight, the true draw to Joker is his schemes.


3. Thomas Wayne *IS* Arthur Fleck's Father

Batman Joker
Warner Bros.

One of the central points of the movie is Arthur Fleck's parentage. At the beginning of the film, we see that Fleck is caring for his mother yet we don't see a father. In fact, the only mention of a father comes later on, when Fleck reads a letter from his mother, Penny, addressed to Thomas Wayne. This letter reveals that Wayne is Arthur Fleck's father and that Thomas Wayne covered up his parentage to avoid a scandal. This also implies that Bruce Wayne and Joker are half brothers!

However, we later hear Thomas Wayne's side of the story. It is revealed that Penny Fleck had severe mental health issues and adopted Arthur Fleck, before then deluding herself into believing Fleck is her and Thomas Wayne's love child. Additionally, it's revealed that Penny Fleck was admitted to Arkham Asylum, where she was treated for delusions and schizophrenia.

While some may believe that this is proof that Batman and Joker are not half brothers, you may not want to totally believe Wayne's story just yet. Firstly, Thomas Wayne is not shown to be a good man in this movie. He is not the friendly and honourable family man that he is typically shown to be in other incarnations. In this movie, he is shown to be unforgiving and heartless and it would be in his interest to lie about his parentage of Arthur Fleck.

So, it would not be outside the realm of possibility that he cover up this pregnancy to such an extent that records are forged at Arkham Asylum. Further, both Arthur Fleck and his mother share certain psychological traits, such as delusions and wild imaginations, so it would be a big coincidence, if he was adopted, that he would also share these traits with his adopted mother.

According to this idea, Fleck's mother could have also had these mental health issues and been taken advantage of by Wayne.


2. This Joker Isn't *the* Joker From The Comics

The Joker
DC Comics

This theory posits that Fleck's Joker is not *the* Joker from the comics and will not be the nemesis to Batman. Rather, this Joker inspires the comic book Joker who will eventually face off with the Caped Crusader.

If you've seen Joker, you will know that the movie's final act sees a clown riot across Gotham. There are thousands of people in clown masks running around Gotham, smashing up buildings and even killing rich Mayoral candidates/ businessmen. It is clear that Fleck's Joker has inspired thousands of people to 'put on a happy face'. The idea behind this theory is that one of these people will become the actual Joker from the comics.

There are clues in both Phoenix’s portrayal and the director’s comments that support this theory. Firstly, Phoenix’s Joker, while excellently portrayed, is not your typical Joker. While the Clown Prince of Crime is usually seen as deranged, he is also scheming and clever. However, Phoenix's Joker simply seems to be a damaged person who ‘flukes’ his way through the movie.

For instance, he barely escapes the police when they chase him on the train, only managing to escape after the police trigger a fight on the train. Additionally, he only makes it onto the Murray Franklin (Robert De Niro) show because of the crew's incompetence (seriously, why let the guy in the clown make up, who is clearly not well, on your show during a clown riot). This joker wouldn’t really be much of a foil for the Dark Knight.

Maybe Arthur Fleck was never intended to be *the* Joker. As Todd Phillips said, “Maybe Joaquin’s character inspired the Joker. You don’t really know. His last line in the movie is, ‘You wouldn’t get it.’ There is also support for this in the comics, with it being confirmed that there have been three Jokers in the comics.


1. It Was All In His Head

Joker Arkham
Warner Bros.

There is the distinct possibility that Arthur Fleck imagined all of the events in the movie. This isn’t just the usual ‘maybe it was all a dream’ theory we see in films either. During the movie, we see Joker imagine that he is on the Murray Franklin (Robert De Niro) show, visualising himself being praised by Franklin.

Further, we see that Joker has also imagined or hallucinated his whole relationship with Zazie Beetz’ character. Consequently, we could draw from this that most of the movie could have been hallucinated by Fleck. His relationship with his mother may have also been a figment of his imagination, as well as the clown riot and his inspiration for their rampage.

The idea behind this theory is that the Joker made up the whole story while in Arkham Asylum, with the titular character even saying at the end of the movie “you won’t get it.” During the movie we have frequent cuts to the Joker incarcerated in Arkham, banging his head against a door. While we assume that this was in Arthur Fleck's past, perhaps it is his present. The whole movie is a delusion of the joker while locked away in Arkham.

The director of the movie, Todd Phillips, has also added fuel to this theory, claiming that “you could look at [the ending] and go ‘this is just one of his multiple-choice stories. None of it happened.’ I don’t want to say what it is.”


Contributor
Contributor

A writer from Adelaide, South Australia. Aside from Newcastle United, he’s a big fan of DC Comics and A Song of Ice and Fire. Can often be found reading old comic books and complaining about the ending of Game of Thrones.