Joker Review: 9 Ups & 3 Downs

Put on a happy face, because Joker is really bloody good!

Joker Joaquin Phoenix
Warner Bros.

2019 hasn't been a great year for films in general. Sure, we got a great Avengers movie and a great Spider-Man movie and there were some really great surprises like Hustlers and Toy Story 4and lots of solid things like John Wick 3, but there have been way too few revelations.

The biggest is about to play in cinemas around the world, lighting fires, kicking off lots of debate and reaffirming Joaquin Phoenix as an utterly incredible gift to the world of acting. Because Todd Phillips Joker - the movie that "didn't need to exist" - is a triumph. It is blisteringly intense, provocative, subversive and challenging and it might well be Phoenix's best work to date.

It's not a completely flawless movie (and you get the sense that some people might hate it or what it becomes in other people's minds and hearts), but even a balanced analysis comes down firmly on the side of being a true masterpiece.

First the positives, and BOY are they positives...

Ups

9. It Throws In Genuine Surprises

Joker Joaquin Phoenix
Warner Bros.

Thanks to a smart marketing campaign, it never felt like we were being force-fed too much of this movie's story by teasers. There was a lot of story in there and a very obvious framework in there, but the best thing about the campaign is that it played some clever tricks.

What you might perceive to have guessed from those trailers won't necessarily all be accurate and in a marketplace saturated by way too many teasers that seem not to know what teasing really means, it's a hugely admirable achievement.

And in truth, even when you know things are coming, it's so well executed that that doesn't even spoil anything. Because it's not a movie tied to cheap revelations as its most valuable currency.


8. The Disturbing Tone Shifts

Joker Joaquin Phoenix
Warner Bros.

Usually when movies come under scrutiny and the question of tone comes about, you're usually invited to believe that consistency is key. That when there's a sudden, unexpected key change or sequences feel alien, it's not really a good thing.

For Joker, that is very much not the case. Perhaps because of Todd Phillips' background, this is a pitch black comedy at times as well as an intense character portrait and a balls-out creepy drama. When all of those elements converge feels like an expression of Arthur Fleck's own make-up rather than a director losing his grip on what he's trying to say.

It's all very disquieting and it's a wonderful, somewhat haunting experience to wonder whether your reaction to a scene should really have been what it was. That's rare.


7. The Unflinching Portrait Of Mental Health Issues

Joker Joaquin Phoenix
Warner Bros.

Mental health advocacy is a hugely important thing these days, which is why it looked very much like there might be some issues in Joker about fetishising psychosis or claiming genuine mental health issues in a perverse, exploitative way.

I can say, with great relief and a huge amount of respect for what Phoenix and Phillips have achieved that that isn't the case. Fleck's conditions (and not only his) are clearly the result of intense, sympathetic research. He's never a victim of exploitative gaze and there is a welcome invitation to empathise with him as someone being chewed up and spit out by a broken machine.

The film is also quite careful not to say some of the things about his mental health issues that some people accused it of even before seeing it. And crucially, it explores areas of the mental health industry that are only vaguely talked about - the realities of limitations on funding, the lack of progress in some dependants, how people get missed. It's uncomfortable viewing, but that's because we're the ones failing them.


6. The Scorsese Observations Are Incredible

Joker Stage
Warner Bros.

Given that Martin Scorsese left the production almost as quickly as he was announced as a producer, it's absolutely remarkable how well Todd Phillips has done to observe his work and use his approach to film-making and world-building to inform his own.

Gotham looks like Scorsese's New York, it's filmed like Scorsese would have in the late 70s, the use of intense colours to punctuate moments is very much from his school of film-making. But it's done in such a way that it's clearly affectionate and not a cloying tribute.

And as for the story, everything they said about it being inspired by The King Of Comedy and Taxi Driver was spot on. To the point that those three films ought to be shown as a triple bill.


5. It Sets Up Another Movie Perfectly

Joker Bruce Wayne
Warner Bros

For all the talk of this being a stand-alone and one entirely cut off from the rest of the Batman universe, it's impossible not to come out of this movie and not want that to be a lie.

Without spoiling it, the road is set for the possibility of future ties and honestly, the idea of Phoenix's Joker reappearing to further explore his gestation and indeed Gotham's, is just irresistible. In an ideal world, there'd be a trilogy of movies starting here, and taking in Matt Reeves' The Batman. That it would even be possible is a pretty heady thing to be able to write.

Let's hope someone can convince everyone involved to make it.


4. The Subtext Is WAY Smarter Than It Looks

Joker Clown
Warner Bros.

For some more cynical people, Joker was always going to be an exercise in surface level pseudo-level intellectualism and pop culture politics. Because of where it's been released in our historical time and some of the things it explores, it's actually a lot smarter than that. It's a lot smarter than anyone could possibly have predicted when we were told the Hangover director was making it.

Thanks to the proximity of The King Of Comedy and Taxi Driver's themes and an open approach to allegory in terms of the current cultural and political moment tied directly into those film's ideas about identity and dangerous celebrity worship, it's a hell of a think-piece.

There will be concerns (and hold tight for lots of talk about that - and even some later on in this piece), but the film MOSTLY refuses to make Joker sexy. He's a victim, sure, but he's not aspirational to any rational mind. In that respect, it steers clear of The Dark Knight's rampant idolisation of the same character.


3. The Origin Doesn't Compromise The Mythology

Joaquin Phoenix Joker
Warner Bros.

You look at this movie and you look at Ron Howard's Solo movie and it's incredible to think that the same concerns were levelled at both about demystification and unnecessarily filling in gaps that never needed to be filled.

Lots and lots of people said we never needed a Joker origin, despite the fact that we've seen that very thing explored without issues in the comics more than once, and some people may even have chosen not to see it for that reason. I get it, to a certain extent it probably feels like a betrayal of Heath Ledger's legacy, because what he brought to the Joker was an intoxicating sense of mystery, but it turns out we can have both.

Thanks to the ingenious narrative devices employed - not least the idea of an unreliable narrator - and the obvious insistence on keeping SOME things hidden, Joker offers AN origin without trying to be definitive and it's loose enough with its Batman lore that it's entirely possible to not accept it as canon.

But even more impressively, it tells the story so well that lots of people are going to actually WANT this to be his real origin.


2. It's About The Most Intense Movie In A Long Time

Joker Joaquin Phoenix
Warner Bros.

Movies shouldn't only be judged on intensity, of course, because sometimes that isn't the same as saying something is necessarily good. Mother! was intense, for instance and that rubbed half of its audience up entirely wrong. See also: Zack Snyder.

But what we should do - and it's something that gets lost in translation with jargon-heavy criticism sometimes that falls over itself to praise technicals - is judge a feel on its ability to make you feel something. In that respect, Joker is one of the most successful films ever made.

It is provocative, disturbing, occasionally funny, sometimes heartbreaking and the way Phillips plays with the dial on the intensity is incredible. As I've already said, even when you know something is about to happen, there are such subtleties and such craft in how he lays them out and builds up to them that they lose nothing for their expectedness.

At times, you'll realise it's all getting a little bit too much and it's usually when you realise you stopped breathing.


1. Joaquin Phoenix's Performance

Joker Joaquin Phoenix
Warner Bros.

As if you didn't already know, every metric tonne of effusive praise that has been shovelled happily onto Joaquin Phoenix's performance is completely earned.

In a role that he could have used as nothing more than exploitation with a healthy side of pantomime caricaturing on the side, he is subtly brilliant. His is a layered performance of incredible expertise, which will take a lot of watching to catch absolutely everything that goes into it.

At times he's barely human, at others he's horribly so. He's a cocoon and a butterfly and festering maggots all at once and if he is not only nominated but also wins Best Actor when the Oscars come around, that whole awards machine is broken. Look out for more in-depth analysis of his performance on this site very soon.

And now to the negatives...


Downs

3. It Misuses An Excellent Supporting Cast

Joker Robert De Niro Marc Maron
Warner Bros.

For all the brilliance of Joaquin Phoenix's performance, he's not the only one in the film and at times it feels like the majority of the other players are mostly ignored.

It's understandable that the likes of Marc Maron, Shea Whigham, Brian Tyree Henry and Bill Camp would want to be in something this good, but they might as well have not turned up. It's great to see their faces, but they're in it so little that it's almost like being shown things you could have won after you've screwed the pooch on a game show.

Others fare slightly better: Robert DeNiro is good, Frances Conroy, Brett Cullen and Zazie Beetz likewise, but this just isn't their film and while the caveat is somewhat inevitable, it still feels like a bit of a waste that could have been balanced better.


2. The One Weird Musical Moment

Joker Joaquin Phoenix OUtfit
Warner Bros.

Did nobody tell anyone at Warner Bros about Gary Glitter? Like, seriously.

There are some pretty dark issues about Arthur's past explored in a particularly revelatory moment and they're very keenly set up as a key point in his "development" as it were. And then, Rock and Roll Part 2 by disgraced, child-molesting former rock star Gary Glitter plays and Arthur dances down a flight of steps. If you can watch that without your toes curling out through the back of your ankles, you're a strange one.

There's also a slight issue with having Joker walk slow-motion into the camera lens while Cream's White Room plays, because anyone whose ever heard more than 2 bars of that song knows it's inherently tied to coolness. It's a rare time when the mask slips and we get a look at why this film might actually be dangerous.

Which leads us to the point where I lose you...


1. What Comes Next...

Joker Trailer Clowns
Warner Bros.

This is a difficult point to address. It's one that has already been widely explored and used to accuse, prosecute and execute Joker a lot before it's even come out, but there has to be an intelligent conversation about it.

Through very little fault of its own - and this is absolutely partly why the film is so hard-hitting and so important and so darkly beautiful - Joker is going to be a zeitgeist defining movie for people looking to find a reason to feel victimised. Unfortunately, some people are going to look at this movie, which doesn't preach about condemning fantasies, hyper-violence, delusions and dangerous celebrity obsession and all their going to see is the Kill The Rich slogan plastered over it. Or the We Are All Clowns.

Unfortunately, because Joker could never have been a movie about a criminal traditionally brought to justice, there's also an element of over-glorification that will, in the wrong hands, end dangerously. Because Joker and the Gotham protests are not misplaced, they are presented as just reactions to an unjust world, but because that world is so realistic, it's going to kick up a hornets' nest.

Let's just hope that audiences all take away what the RIGHT message is. This is not an overt castigation of the movie, though the approach could have been different certainly. Todd Phillips has been quoted as saying quite openly that he made a comic book movie solely to get eyes on it - that's slightly dangerous too.

It's going to need a lot more talking and this isn't quite the place to do it, but to fail to acknowledge it - no matter how many accusations of snowflakery there might be - would be wrong.

What did you think of Joker? Share your thoughts in the comments thread.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.