Josh Brolin: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
Thanos' ups and downs.
Imagine you're Marvel. You have to cast Thanos, the Mad Titan who will be the Avengers' biggest threat so far. And this isn't any old one-shot villain - he's one who's been seeded ever since Earth's Mightiest Heroes first formed. What do you do? Why, you cast Josh Brolin, of course. The actor, who started inauspiciously back in The Goonies, has built a profile that has enjoyed a significant boost in recent years thanks to astute career choices (mostly) and a commitment to character performances that build huge screen presence, and he is legitimately considered one of the brightest leading men in the business (and is now a part of the biggest franchise of all time) Brolin is rarely anything but a great performer with an intense and effective screen presence, no matter the demands of the character, and it may seem blasphemous to suggest he has made any missteps at all - but they exist. As with every actor who so broadly straddles the generic boundaries, and so willingly stretches himself in the name of diversity, not everything can be a success - for every career-defining success, there have been regrettable moments where poor content, and an uncharacteristic lack of commitment combined in a perfect storm with disappointing results. So, as Sicario, his latest film, hits cinemas under a wave of great reviews, let's look back at the career moments that have propelled Brolin to his current lofty status as one of Hollywood's hottest properties.
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Dr. William Block - Planet Terror (2007)
In his contribution to the Grindhouse double feature, Robert Rodriguez penned a love letter to the zombie movie with Planet Terror, which follows a rag-tag group of survivors in rural Texas, after a chemical weapon is unleashed. The film is the superior of the two Grindhouse offerings both in terms of narrative and visuals, the grainy filter fits the deliberately schlocky tone and sells it as a modern B-Movie. If you're a fan of violence, ridiculous action and the grotesque, then you'll be right at home here, just as Josh Brolin seems to have been. He fits into this narrative as the sinister Dr. William Block, tasked with treating the first cases of infection, while also dealing with his suspicions that his wife is being unfaithful, which leads him to intimidate her and eventually attack her with an anaesthetic syringe in a notably horrific sequence. His performance in this role is mostly subdued (needle attack notwithstanding), but he provokes lots of tension and his understated menace is almost viscerally affecting. As testament to Brolin's performance, you get a real sense that there is something ominous lurking beneath the surface of the character the second he appears on screen.
4. George W. Bush - W. (2008)
Oliver Stone's biopic following the life of George W. Bush is a surprisingly sympathetic look at the life of the 43rd President of the United States, underpinned by an exceptional character performance by Brolin. Following him from his time at Yale through to his time in office, it offers an insight into the much ridiculed figure, and mixes comedy and tragedy, to show the troubles he had to overcome despite his privileges. Rather than an outright criticism, or even something to mythologise his legacy, we are given an even portrait of the man, to the eternal credit of Stone and the cast. Brolin was the third choice for the role, even referred to as a "last minute" pick, after Harrison Ford and Christian Bale both dropped out of the role, but you wouldn't belive it considering the quality of the performance. When he took on the role, he researched heavily into both Bush himself, including his body language at different times throughout his period in office, and Texan accents in general, and that commitment shines through in the final performance. Brolin's performance, crucially, never crosses the line into caricature. - instead, the portrayal is sympathetic, yet it doesn't alleviate Bush of his many mistakes. It's a frank look at the journey he took to become President and what happened thereafter, which soars thanks to Brolin's character actor credentials.
3. Brandon Walsh - The Goonies (1985)
It's hard to find a film as beloved as The Goonies. It combines friendship, adventure and clear goals into a heart-warming narrative about a group of mismatched kids trying to save their town by following a treasure map left by cinema's second most famous pirate One Eyed Willy. When the Astoria Country Club seeks to expand over the 'Goon Docks' area, the residents are resigned to losing their homes, until The Goonies set out on a weekend of entertainment to celebrate their expiring time in their homes. Their initial plans are let down when older brother Brandon (Brolin) fails his driving test and leaves them without the ability to 'cruise the coast in style' on their last weekend there. Dejected, they begin to search in the attic for something to do, and discover the first clue that leads them on a whirlwind of adventure. Brolin is great in his debut role as the older brother of Sean Astin's Mikey Walsh - he clearly cares about the boys enough to track them down and help them escape violent criminals, and his frustration at the antics of his brother, and his difficulty in balancing that with more typical teenage concerns like girls and street cred, make him a completely convincing character. He even gets a satisfying romantic arc within the narrative, and you can't help but root for the earnest performance that Brolin gives. For a big screen debut - like the majority of the cast in fact, Brolin's performance is particularly impressive, and a great foundation for his career beyond.
2. Tom Chaney - True Grit (2010)
This adaptation of the novel True Grit from the Coen Brothers was something of a cinematic highlight in 2010. For the uninitiated, it follows a young girl called Mattie Ross (Hailee Steinfeld) as she seeks to avenge the death of her father at the hands of the outlaw Tom Chaney (Brolin). Naturally, she cannot do this alone, so she enlists the help of Rooster Cogburn (Jeff Bridges), an alcoholic Deputy U.S. Marshall with a violent reputation, and Texas Ranger name LaBoeuf (Matt Damon) - who is also hunting Chaney for the murder of a Texas state senator, to track him down. Despite having a knack for playing instantly likeable characters, Brolin is equally renowned for his villainous roles. His performance as Chaney is particularly great; he's a despicable character who wouldn't think twice about murdering anyone in his way, and Brolin makes that utterly believable. The performance casts him with an animal cunning, and while he may outwardly seem slow or dim-witted, this serves as something of a front to a very dangerous man, which fits the film's need for a compelling and grotesquely charming villain, given the exceptional cast of characters.
1. Llewelyn Moss - No Country For Old Men (2006)
At number one, another Coen Brothers film, and arguably their greatest. No Country for Old Men is an adaptation of a Cormac McCarthy novel of the same name and follows numerous narrative threads all relating back to a briefcase full of money. After a drug deal gone wrong, Llewelyn Moss (Brolin) comes across the cash and decides to take it for himself. Little does he know, the briefcase has a tracker inside, which acts as a beacon for scene-stealing and utterly terrifying villain Anton Chigurh (Javier Bardem), a hitman who has been tasked with retrieving it. While this game of cat and mouse is played out, the downbeaten Sheriff Ed Ball (Tommy Lee Jones) follows the evidence left by Chigurh. This performance from Brolin is testament to what he can do with very few words. The film is very light on dialogue and it rests on the cast to fill in the blanks with facial expressions and body language, and more intangible characteristics like presence and charisma. Brolin has said in an interview that he was initially nervous of taking on a role with so little talking, and how he would go about conveying the film's ideas without speaking, but his concerns were ill-conceived, as he proved himself particularly adept to the role, which confirmed his screen presence in compelling fashion. As further evidence, despite the fact that his character may not be the most likeable person in the movie, you're still able to root for him thanks to the charisma Brolin brings to the performance. Now we've looked into his very best performances it's time to look at five of those that weren't so great...
5 Performances That Sucked...
5. Derek Bates - Into the Blue (2005)
4. Billy - The Mod Squad (1999)
The big screen adaptation of the critically acclaimed television show, The Mod Squad sees three young ne'er-do-wells given the option between going to jail or becoming undercover police officers, because giving criminals licence to carry guns and go power mad is clearly a great idea. The crims naturally agree to go undercover and are tasked with busting a drug ring, which leads to the murder of the officer who recruited them. Julie (Claire Danes), Peter (Giovanni Ribisi) and Lincoln (Omar Epps) must face challenges from both criminals and their police colleagues who ridicule and underestimate them - for entirely good reason. There are also other notable hurdles the characters can't overcome, such as the film's flimsy plot and indeed its idea of "humour." Most of the choices in this section aren't necessarily terrible performances: Brolin has too much of an on screen presence to be truly awful, but he's been hampered by some terrible material - and must accept some of the blame for his career choices. In The Mod Squad, the material is paper thin and not even his considerable skills are able to save it from mundanity. Playing a villainous ex-boyfriend, Brolin goes through the motions, never offering anything even remotely interesting: his quips fall flat and he never commands the screen when he appears, which is jarring considering his more recent impact. Granted, this was in 1999, and his fame has grown more recently, but this is still a definite low point in his filmography.
3. Josh - Mimic (1997)
Everyone's seen a film like Mimic: it's the kind of paint-by-numbers cheesy horror that packs zero scares, but fatally isn't quite bad enough to encourage you to laugh and embrace it as a cult gem. It's bland, formulaic and incredibly easy to forget, which is especially disappointing considering it was directed by the current go-to director for innovative spooky horror Guillermo del Toro. Dodgy special effects and a contrived premise combine to ensure that it was never going to be anywhere near the best film ever made. The story centers on genetically engineered insects, which were initially bred to kill disease carrying cockroaches - so in that regard, it's sort of based on the Old Lady Who Swallowed A Fly song. Nothing could possibly go wrong there, right? Wrong, the titular creature evolves too much, and somehow adapts the ability to change into human form, which it uses to hunt and kill humans, perhaps as grissly vengeance for all the bugs that get stomped every day. Brolin's performance is pretty much limited to him looking perpetually puzzled and mildly constipated, as the bug devil goes about its murderous duty, including eating him, which is clearly his only purpose in the film. He has literally nothing to work with here and his role as a CDC officer exists purely for expositional purposes. It's a shame to see talent wasted like this, but some of the blame has to go with Brolin, who clearly decided the small part was not worth much effort on his part.
2. Jonah Hex - Jonah Hex (2010)
For all the efforts of its stellar cast, which included the likes of Michael Fassbender, John Malkovich and Michael Shannon, and the huge potential of the source material, Jonah Hex suffered from an unfocused narrative that rendered it virtually unwatchable. Loosely based on DC's graphic novel of the same name, it followed Jonah Hex, a Confederate cavalryman who is betrayed and left for dead by his commanding officer, before being granted rebirth by a Native American magic man, and apparently also licence to get involved in all manner of distasteful ridiculousness. The saddest thing to note here is that Brolin initially hated the script and wanted nothing to do with it, which was a sensible response, but for some bizarre reason, he changed his mind, fostering some bewildering affection for its tongue-in-cheek tone (the self-conscious label of bad film-makers looking for excuses) and deciding to just go for it, which definitely wasn't sensible. While he does his best with the awful material, there isn't much that can be done to salvage the narrative, and that reflects horribly on an actor who should never have debased himself by agreeing to the role. This is generally true of all the actors involved, as their performances were sabotaged by the cinematic shambles, and it's a small mercy that Brolin and his co-stars are still largely taken seriously as leading men after this debacle.

