Julianne Moore: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

We cast our eyes back on the always great actress Julianne Moore. Well, almost always great.

As one of Hollywood's Golden Girls, Julianne Moore can effortlessly switch between comedy, action, drama and horror at a moment's notice, while remaining fantastic across any genre she chooses. British-American by birth, she constantly brings confidence and dramatic weight to her roles to the point where just associating her name with a project adds a further sprinkling of prestige. Naturally, this talent has been recognised by her peers, with Oscar nominations for her brilliant performances in Boogie Nights, The Hours and The End Of The Affair. However, like every actor in Hollywood, Julianne Moore has also been in her fair share of duds, appearing in the just plain bad €“ the reliably awful Movie 43, which features so heavily on these lists it should come with its own special reservation €“ and in projects that simply weren't right for her, such as the noble misfire that was Hannibal. It's not that we didn't enjoy some aspects, but it's hard for anyone to replace Jodie Foster in the role which bagged her an Oscar. So in honour of Non-Stop's cinematic release (and as we've already run down the best and worst of lead Liam Neeson), we'll be taking a look at Moore's huge and wide-ranging career in the movies to find and analyse 10 of her performances €“ 5 that were awesome and 5 that sucked. And please note that her performances aren't any comment on the quality of the films, but just her roles within them.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Jules Allgood €“ The Kids Are All Right

Playing one half of a lesbian couple living in California, Julianne Moore clearly relishes her role in this indie drama that revolves around the couple dealing with the fact that they have to tell their kids about the sperm donor who fathered them. It's a quirky little movie that doesn't take itself too seriously but balances humour and drama well enough that it feels realistic. What makes her performance so brilliant is the simple fact that Moore and Bening create such a loving and caring relationship that you believe they've been together for years, which is more than can be said for some actual couples who've acted on screen together. Moore plays the typical "cool" parent of the two and is a much more forgiving mother than Bening, but they do create a wonderful dynamic. When Moore's affair with her sperm donor threatens the family dynamic, she plays the torn-between-two-lovers storyline part with distinction, enlivening what could've been a horrible cliche, albeit with a novel, 21st century twist.

4. Julian Taylor €“ Children Of Men

Alfonso Cuaron's Children of Men is a film riveted with Oscar-worthy performances, with almost every role being played by someone at the top of their game yet strangely against type. You don't expect to see Michael Caine playing a hippie with long hair, and you certainly don't expect to see Julianne Moore as the leader of a military immigrants rights/terrorist group, but it somehow just works. Moore imbues the role with an understated tension and subtlety, which really works in a film of flashy camera moves and loud explosions. Nothing in her performance is overplayed or over-the-top, and when she meets Clive Owen for the first time in years we instantly sense that these two now-distant people were very close but torn apart by something horrific. Moore is also comfortable firing a gun and we have no questions she could easily lead a large group of terrorists if she needed to, which she does so in this film. The mothering elements also come through and gives the aforementioned reveal €“ her son by Owen's Theo died from a flu virus €“ real emotional heft which ties directly into the hopelessness of the film. Though it's never said outright, Moore's haunted performance gives the impression that she is lost without her son, which is why she is doing the things she does. When she exits the film in a brilliant single shot all done inside a car, we have genuine sympathy and tears even after only knowing her character for a short amount of time.

3. Maggie "Amber Waves" €“ Boogie Nights

Paul Thomas Anderson's Boogie Nights is a much better film than it has any right to be. Who'd have thought that a comedy-drama set in the 1970s porn industry could be so vivid? And yet, against all odds, it was. Moore plays the brilliantly named Amber Waves, who is kind-of like the Farrah Fawcett (it's the 70s, deal with it) of porn, but she's now slumming it in seedier low-paying jobs just to keep up her lifestyle. Moore's tortured Waves is a brilliant portrayal of success and excess in the 70s, made all the more tragic by the fact she's driven by the need to fund her extravagance and cocaine habit. Yet despite the tragedy, there's also some genuinely funny moments from Moore in the various porn scenes of the film. However, that's not the best part of her role €“ that particular laurel has to go to the scenes with her child where she's fighting for custody in the courtrooms with her vengeance-fuelled husband. The scene where she's told she's an unfit mother because of her work in the porn industry and cocaine habit is genuinely heartbreaking and again grants us a moving display of subtlety from Moore, who silently accepts her fate. Moore's the only likeable female character in the whole film, and that's no accident. She and Anderson work hard together to create a three dimensional and layered character, who could quite easily have been just a bimbo airhead. But here she's not €“ she's an actual person facing real problems and difficulties, showing Dirk Diggler that the industry is not quite as glamorous as it seems.

2. Margaret White €“ Carrie

Going into last year's remake of Carrie, nobody expected it to equal Brian De Palma's 1976 seminal work, and yet with the expectations so low came the capacity to surprise. Kimberly Pierce, the director of this reboot, works hard to break away from De Palma's version and the result is a fairly good adaptation of the novel. Yet long before the blood starts spilling in this R-rated horror, the film is already truly scary, and that's down to one person Going into last year's remake of Carrie, nobody expected it to equal Brian De Palma's 1976 seminal work, or even surpass it, and yet in the hearts of many Stephen King fans it did Julianne Moore as Carrie's mother, Margaret White. Unbelievably, Moore's version of Mrs. White gives Piper Laurie's "definitive" version of the character a run for its money, doing away with the screeching harpy elements that Laurie worked into the role in favour of something altogether more chilling. Moore instead brings a quiet malice to the film, manipulating her daughter and everyone around her and creating a seemingly happy environment on the outside that is really just a prison for Carrie. Mrs. White in this film feels like a real person who truly believes the things she says with a steely-eyed resolve, whereas in the original it feels just a little fake. Moore works hard to create a mentally ill woman who has tricked herself into buying her own lies.

1. Maude Lebowski €“ The Big Lebowski

Julianne Moore has a relatively small role in this Coen Brothers classic, but she makes such a lasting impact during his short screen time that it had to top the list. The Big Lebowski, as I'm sure you know, deals with a slacker bowler called The Dude who gets mixed up with a millionaire also called Lebowski and tries to gain remuneration for his ruined rug with the help of his other bowling friends. Moore plays an avant-garde artist named Maude, whose work has been described as "strongly vaginal." She's a sleazy character masquerading as someone with culture and intelligence who obviously got to where she is by sleeping around. It's another example of Moore playing a great manipulative character, because here she sleeps with The Dude solely to have a child, knowing that the Dude probably won't hang around. It's a smart ploy from Maude but she doesn't bank on him being as intelligent as he is. Moore's hilarious in the role and has great fun parodying the "above it all" hipster-type artist who sprouts phrases they don't really understand or care about. Click "next" for 5 performances that sucked...

And 5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Callie Ferris €“ Next

2007's Next was an embarrassment for almost everyone involved, including director Lee Tamahori and critic-proof star Nicolas Cage. However, at the sharp end of all the ire was Julianne Moore, who plays FBI Agent Callie Ferris and really should have known better. Next has a great premise dealing with a Las Vegas magician (Cage) who finds out he can see into the future, who's then pursued by an FBI agent (Moore) who wants to use his amazing abilities to prevent a nuclear terrorist attack. It's shocking that Moore is bad in this film because it's a role she could do brilliantly €“ a great but overworked FBI agent being dragged into a mess she really doesn't want to and also being under the stress of dealing with an imminent terrorist attack that could destroy her country. Unfortunately, she's just wrong for the role and decides to make Ferris into an all-out action girl, which just doesn't work at all. Moore works best when she's in a supporting role and is given some acting to do €“ here she just fires off her gun whilst sprouting cliche "we don't want to hurt you, we just want to help!" lines at Cage, who Cages up the film in the worst possible way. It's hard to believe but she actually comes off more fake than her co-star, which is a phrase nobody ever expected to read and I never expected to write. Let's chalk this one down to "mortgage repayments," shall we?

4. Electra €“ Assassins

Assassins is a cheesy action romp from 1995 that surprisingly was written by The Wachowskis but absolutely butchered by producer Joel Silver and director Richard Donner, turning what should've been a smart action thriller into the most risible of B-movies. It's a hilarious film for all the wrong reasons, even though Sylvester Stallone and Antonio Banderas put in some good performances. Unfortunately, Julianne Moore doesn't. Her computer hacker character is hilarious and does many things that just aren't possible with computers now, never mind the halcyon days of '95. Moore tries her best with the quick-paced and witty dialogue but just doesn't pull it off, which might be a result of her acting style being so different to Banderas and Stallone, who are far more comfortable with in-your-face cheese than the an actress who usually turns in layered, restrained performances. The romance subplot with Banderas is really quite awful and feels stilted a lot of the time, because it comes out of nowhere and the characters are just so different. It's not a case of Moore being bad at acting here €“ it's just the wrong character type. We just don't believe Julianne Moore could ever be a brainy hacker, and it's a role that could and should have been better played by someone else. There's nothing wrong with trying to expand your horizons in acting, but there are some archetypes that just can't be done by certain actors. Unfortunately for Moore, this is one of them.

3. Clarice Starling €“ Hannibal

Hannibal is such a weird clash of genres and crew that it really has no business actually being a film. Directed by Ridley Scott, written by David Mamet and produced by Dino De Laurentiis, it's a cinematic Frankenstein's monster and by god, it shows. The Silence of the Lambs was like lightning in a bottle €“ it came from nowhere, scared the hell out of everybody and cleaned up at the Oscars. Hannibal, however, was a lot more disappointing and heralded the start of the demise of the Hannibal Lecter films. The main problem stems from Julianne Moore, though, who just can't grasp the character of Clarice Starling and comes off looking like a Jodie Foster imitator. We never really believe that Moore is in any danger from Lecter because she doesn't have Foster's naive innocence, instead plays Starling as more of a badass. It's a jolting contrast from the meek individual who cried after letting off her gun in The Silence of the Lambs, and it's ever-so-slightly jarring. It also doesn't help that her accent is all over the place as she tries to imitate Foster and bring her own things to the character. It's a noble effort, but unfortunately just doesn't work. She's at her best when she's taking on Lecter face-to-face and relishes her scenes with Ray Liotta and Anthony Hopkins, but these scenes are few and far between. Again, this is just a case of her being the wrong person for the role. We appreciate what they were trying to do with the character but it just came off phoney and resulted in a disappointing film.

2. Lila Crane €“ Psycho

Nobody came out of Gus Van Sant's 1998 remake of the Hitchcock classic unscathed, but with the film focusing a lot on Vince Vaughn and Julianne Moore, we have to focus on Moore's performance here. We're sure you know the story, but here goes: Marion Crane (Anne Heche) steals $400,000 from her employer and goes on the run, resulting in her fatal stay at the Bates Motel run by Norman Bates (Vince Vaughn) and his mother. Lila Crane, Marion's sister, goes to search for her but finds something a lot more sinister is going on. The main issue with Moore's performance is how she interprets the character of Lila as much more aggressive, manipulative and neurotic than she was in the original. This is all well and good in a normal remake, but considering everyone else is forging ahead with the original's old-fashioned speech rhythms and patterns, Moore's more modern and stylish approach to the dialogue was like a digital elephant in an analog room. Needless to say, it's distracting. Moore's heart really doesn't seem into the role, which is a shame because she fits the character really well. Maybe she just understood it was going to flop majorly and put in a sub-par performance as a result. Sometimes, the classics should just stay untouched.

1. Mother €“ Movie 43

Movie 43 was the cinematic equivalent of a wrist-deep prostate exam. It was painful, unfunny, and not an experience you want to revisit. It's surprising then that it attracted a huge array of stars like Hugh Jackman, Halle Berry, Dennis Quaid, Richard Gere, Emma Stone, Uma Thurman, Gerard Butler, Chris Pratt, Kate Winslet and, of course, Julianne Moore. The plot? Well, there isn't one. And that's not just me being snarky, the plot is really non-existent because it's just a collection of short films strung together by teenagers looking for films on the internet (or, if you're in the colonies, two writers pitching ideas to Dennis Quaid). Moore's segment of the film was actually deleted from the American prints but survived the UK version. On paper it sounds really good, especially with a talent like Bob Odenkirk as the director/writer and Tony Shalhoub as her co-star, but it's just not a funny segment and you can see why they deleted it from the film. And remember, this is the film where Hugh Jackman with a pair of testicles on his chin made it into the cut, so coming a cropper in this particular editing room is so bad it's actually impressive. Odenkirk's style is very dark and witty and it just doesn't fit with the tone of the rest of the zany movie. Moore doesn't look comfortable delivering the dialogue and it might be because she did the role as a favour to Odenkirk, because she really doesn't put in much work and is happy to coast along. It's only about 5 minutes long but it's a torturous watch, not helped by Moore's lackluster performance. It's at least good if you like Bob Odenkirk (and who doesn't) or Tony Shalhoub, but don't go hoping for a great Julianne Moore performance, because there isn't one. She knows it was bad. She knows. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

3rd Year Film and Television Production student at Edge Hill University. Writer of "Stockton's Last Stand" and screenwriter/director of "Hunted" and "Spyfail 2: The Search for Spyfail 1". I also do stand-up comedy sometimes... I'm told I'm marginally funny.