Keanu Reeves: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Take the red pill and see what the plank has to offer.

Keanu Reeves has been the object of much mockery in recent years. We've all heard the jokes about his wooden performances (The Day My Face Stood Still and all the rest), and he has frequently chosen roles which unintentionally pander to those expectations. Besides Hayden Christiansen, he is perhaps unrivalled among actors in the level of popular derision he attracts. But in spite of this, Reeves is capable of turning in a fine performance when he is given the right materials and a director who understands him. Like Nicolas Cage, he will go many performances of phoning it in and then deliver something a lot more interesting to remind us of why we made him a star in the first place. Long before he was immortalised in The Matrix, Reeves turned in a number of very fine performances in efforts both indie and mainstream, and for all the derision, he continues to enjoy a certain level of success. Nowhere is this more apparent than his latest film, John Wick, a stylish, self-aware thriller that reveals a respectful criminal subculture to modern New York. Although it looks like another of Reeves' "for the money" project, there's a real charm to his main character and adrenaline to the action. To celebrate, we're taking a look back at the highs and lows of one of Canada's most popular exports. And in time-honoured fashion, we begin with five performances which truly demonstrate his acting chops...


5 Awesome Performances...

5. Kevin Lomax - The Devil's Advocate (1997)

While Reeves is often positioned as a leading man, much of his best work comes in supporting or ensemble piece; you could even argue that The Matrix is an ensemble piece until its heroic final act. We begin with a film in which he manages to hold his own against one of the biggest actors of our age, in a neat little thriller from Taylor Hackford, director of An Officer And A Gentlemen. Based upon Andrew Lieberman's novel of the same name, The Devil's Advocate stars Reeves as Kevin Lomax, a brilliant defence lawyer who has never lost a case. Having successfully defended a teacher on a charge of child molestation, he is approached to join the swanky New York law firm Milton, Chadwick & Waters. As Kevin wins them case after case and makes a lot of money in the process, things turn increasingly sinister, particularly around the identity of Milton himself... The Devil's Advocate is a good, solid Faustian tale, doing for upmarket courtroom dramas what Angel Heart did for private detective stories. While it's largely Al Pacino's film, his wild, often outrageous performance would be ridiculous without a more temperate soul to balance it out. That is where Keanu comes in, constantly dialling it back and calmly stating his arguments and counter-arguments against Milton's schemes.

4. Scott Favor - My Own Private Idaho (1991)

It's interesting to note how Shakespeare very often separates the good actors from the not-so-good. On the latter end belong such turkeys as Ethan Hawke's Hamlet or the recent Aussie version of Macbeth; on the former, anything directed by Kenneth Branagh. My Own Private Idaho missed out on that assessment because it is a vernacular adaptation (i.e. it doesn't use Shakespeare's own language), but it has merit enough to earn a place on this countdown. The film is loosely based on Shakespeare's Henry IV Parts I & II and Henry V, which are often presented together in a condensed version known as Hal V. Directed by Gus van Sant, it follows the story of best friends and gay street hustlers Mike (River Phoenix) and Scott (Reeves), who fill the roles of Sir John Falstaff and Prince Hal respectively. Scott is the wayward son of the Mayor of Portland (standing in for King Henry IV), who intends to retire when he turns 21 and inherits his father's fortune. But Mike, who suffers from narcolepsy, has other ideas, and the film follows their exploits soliciting sex and travelling all over America. Following close on the heels of his debut Drugstore Cowboy, My Own Private Idaho finds Van Sant at the top of his game, giving us well-written, interesting characters with none of the navel-gazing pretension of his later years. Reeves and Pheonix bounce off each other very nicely, with the former successfully capturing the dual reluctance of the character, both to accept his responsibilities and to give himself fully to life on the road. It's a subtle and understated turn which gels with both his fellow cast members and Van Sant's spaced-out sensibility.

3. Neo - The Matrix (1999)

There's no way you could do a list about Keanu Reeves and not mention The Matrix. While Bill And Ted was the film that launched his career, this is the film that immortalised Reeves, for good and bad (as we'll see later). The Wachowskis' film broke new ground in many ways, making martial arts films popular again, pushing the special effects envelope with "bullet time", and setting the aesthetic standards (alongside Gattica and Dark City) for a new generation of sci-fi fans. On the very slim chance that you've never seen it, The Matrix is a sci-fi action movie set in 1999 (or so it seems). Reeves plays Thomas Anderson, a software developer by day and a hacker nicknamed Neo by night. One day he has a fateful encounter with a woman named Trinity, who informs him that everything he thought was real is in fact an elaborate illusion created by machines. After meeting her boss Morpheus, he takes a trip down the rabbit hole into a horrifying reality that no-one could have imagined... Neo is very much an everyman character, spending much of his time reacting in amazement as everything he took for granted is dismantled, de-constructed and re-contextualised. He serves as the audience's way in to a series of fascinating concepts and philosophical questions, and it therefore makes perfect sense to put Reeves in the role. Not only does he not look physically extraordinary (in the way that, say, Hugh Jackman often does), but he plays the emotional developments with great naturalism. We bond with the character because his confounding reflects our own, and without getting this right, the film would have sunk without trace.

2. Don John - Much Ado About Nothing (1993)

If someone came up to you and tried to convince you that Keanu Reeves and Denzel Washington were half-brothers, chances are you would either laugh in their faces or send for the men in white coats. But that's exactly what Kenneth Branagh managed when he put the two actors together for his terrific take on Much Ado About Nothing. To briefly recapitulate, Much Ado is a story of romance based upon and confounded by confusion. Set on the island of Sicily, it follows two young couples: Benedick and Beatrice, who hate each other passionately, and Claudio and Hero, who are about to marry. The play involves Don Pedro getting the first couple to over-hear staged gossip about each other, that they might confess the love they did not know they had for one another. Sadly, his wicked half-brother Don John has other plans... Don John is one of Shakespeare's more underrated villains. Maligned by his half-brother, he seeks out of pure spite to sabotage a virtuous marriage by spreading rumours about Hero being unfaithful - rumours which are widely accepted and almost lead to Claudio's death. Reeves may not play villains very often, but he is very capable in this role, with his still delivery serving as a sinister counterpoint to Washington's mischievous smiles. It's an unusual choice but a gamble that pays off, with Reeves coming through well thanks to Branagh's guidance both on- and off-screen.

1. John 'Johnny' Utah - Point Break (1991)

One of the common criticisms about Reeves is that he has spent his entire career playing surfers and slackers, channelling his work on Bill And Ted into every role regardless of how appropriate it may be. It's therefore kind of fitting that his best performance should involve a large amount of surfing - along with sky-diving, American football and a number of other macho exploits with the star of Dirty Dancing. Directed by Kathryn Bigelow (The Hurt Locker, Zero Dark Thirty), Point Break is an action thriller about a group of bank robbers called the Ex-Presidents, so called because they wear masks of US Presidents during their robberies. Reeves plays Johnny Utah, an FBI agent assigned to spy on a group of surfers who are believed to be the robbers. The more time he spends with them, the more he is taken in by the rebellious philosophy of their leader Bodhi (Patrick Swayze), to the point where he questions which side he should really be on. Like most of Bigelow's films, Point Break is a very macho, male-driven affair. As with The Matrix, Johnny is a character who serves as the audience's way in to a strange and very driven world, and increasingly comes to believethat he belong there. And like The Devil's Advocate, Reeves' by-the-book nature and growing indecision is a great counterweight for the often manic Swayze. It's a performance of great sincerity, produced by an actor who was clearly having a lot of fun. Having proved his worth so far, now let us venture into more planky territory and look at Reeves' worst performances...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Johnny - Johnny Mnemonic (1995)

Keanu Reeves has had a love-hate relationship with science fiction throughout his long career. Aside from his contributions to The Matrix, his performance in A Scanner Darkly brought him a fair amount of acclaim. But the genre has also been less kind to him on numerous occasions, the first being Johnny Mnemonic, the first and so far only feature film by music video director Robert Longo. Based very loosely on the short story by William Gibson, Johnny Mnemonic stars Reeves as the title character, a "mnemonic carrier" with a data storage device in his head for transporting valuable information which is too sensitive for the Net. Seeking to regain his childhood memories, which having the device impairs, Johnny takes one last job from his handler Ralfi. But the information he carries is highly valuable to two different parties, who will stop at nothing to get hold of it... While the influence of Gibson's story can still be seen in sci-fi (most recently in Elysium), Johnny Mnemonic is at best ordinary and at worst rather risible. Gibson expressed regret that the film had taken such a mainstream approach to his quirky little story, and sure enough Longo is not that capable a director, being far more at home with pop videos than complex storytelling. But even with these mitigating factors, Reeves fails to acquit himself; his performance is listless, dull and unsympathetic in a manner which doesn't endear him to the audience or enhance the story.

4. Alex Wyler - The Lake House (2006)

Whenever he comes across an unbelievable piece of casting, film critic Mark Kermode would invoke one of two examples to illustrate his point. One was "Meg Ryan is a helicopter pilot", relating to Courage Under Fire, and the other was "Keanu Reeves is an architect", relating to our next entry.

Nominally a remake of the 2000 Korean film Il Mare, The Lake House is a time travel romance which reunites Reeves with Sandra Bullock 12 years after their first encounter on Speed (which only just failed to make this list). They play Alex Wyler and Dr. Kate Forster, an architect and doctor who lived in the same house in 2004 and 2006 respectively, and are able to communicate with one another through a mysterious letterbox. Inevitably, romance blossoms, but how will their growing love be requited? Time travel romances range from the brilliant (Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind) to the flawed (The Time Traveller's Wife) to the downright ridiculous - and it is in this latter camp that The Lake House belongs. Neither the scriptwriter nor the director have any real grasp of the mechanics of time travel, so that the film loses its audience by increasingly breaking its own rules. But even if you do as Roger Ebert did and try to see the film as just a romance, it comes up short because of Reeves' performance. While Bullock is her usual annoying self, Reeves is mopey and uncharismatic in a way that Shia LeBeouf could only dream of being. It's an incredibly inert piece of acting - which brings us nicely onto the next selection...

3. Klaatu - The Day The Earth Stood Still (2008)

The Day The Earth Stood Still is a sci-fi classic, combining a timely theme of global nuclear annihilation with 1950s B-movie trappings and able direction by Robert Wise, who went on to make The Haunting and West Side Story. Any remake would have to justify its existence with more than simply improved effects, which is pretty much all that it has going for it. But the most curious quality to Scott Derrickson's film was his decision to cast Keanu Reeves as Klaatu. The Day The Earth Stood Still begins in the present day with a large spherical spaceship landing in Central Park. The alien Klaatu emerges, along with a giant robot Gort; after Klaatu is shot, Gort emits a powerful energy beam which temporarily paralyses all human life nearby. After being taken to a military hospital, Klaatu is analysed and explains that he has come with an ultimatum for humanity: to cease the destruction of their planet's natural environment, or be wiped out of space and time forever. Considering that Klaatu is an alien who begins to assimilate human behaviour, you'd think that Reeves would be a natural choice even in his plankiest moments. In fact, Reeves' acting is so wooden and unchanging that he makes the CGI Gort appear to have a lot more personality. Far from being intimidating, his Klaatu sounds like a bad impression of Mr. Spock - which could be passed off as an obscure in-joke, given that Wise later made Star Trek: The Motion Picture. But no amount of pop wisdom or pointy ears can salvage either this film or Reeves' shockingly inept performance.

2. Neo - The Matrix Reloaded/Revolutions (2003)

This may seem an unusual and unpopular choice, given the mixed reception of both Matrix sequels and their continued defence by loyal fans. But it is very palpable to believe that these films were where Reeves' technique and approach to characterisation started to work against him and give rise to all the jokes about him.

The Matrix sequels see Neo, Trinity and Morpheus continuing their quest to liberate mankind from the machines that have enslaved them. In Reloaded they lock horns with the Merovingian, a powerful programme who is holding captive a valuable resource called the Keymaker. In Revolutions Neo travels to the heart of the Matrix to fulfil his destiny, while Morpheus attempts to hold off the destruction of the human city of Zion. In the midst of all this, hundreds of Agent Smiths turn up and Neo has to fight them.

Much of the blame for these films can be laid on the Wachowskis: buoyed by the huge success of the first film, they got too big for their boots and lost all sense of discipline. But Reeves is equally guilty of loving his character too much, becoming a prisoner of his own performance and fighting against any opportunity to show emotion. Even considering Neo's less interesting development in the sequels, there is more to the character than being so focussed that he isn't as emotional as those around him. In short, Reeves takes something that was once heroic and by his own hands make it desperately dull.

1. Jonathan Harker - Bram Stoker's Dracula (1992)

There's an awful lot to like about Francis Ford Coppola's Dracula: the lavish Gothic sets, its general fidelity to the novel, Gary Oldman's brilliant central performance and so on. It's a wonderfully bonkers offering which remains one of the high points of the 1990s vampire wave that also included the likes of Cronos, Innocent Blood and Interview With The Vampire. But like its titular character, it has one huge Achilles' heel: Keanu Reeves' disastrous turn as Jonathan Harker. Harker is one of the central characters of Bram Stoker's novel. He first encounters Dracula as a trainee solicitor, having travelled to Transylvania on behalf of a client, been imprisoned in Dracula's castle and barely managing to escape with his life. Upon marrying his fiancée Mina and returning to London, he encounters Dracula again and vows to destroy the vampire who comes to prey upon his wife, enlisting Van Helsing to help him in the act. Many American actors have come a cropper with English accents, but none moreso than Reeves. Every line is delivered as though he is still figuring out how each word should be pronounced, resulting in a performance which is stunted, unconvincing and emotionally drab. The shaving scene, one of the most famous in the novel, is rendered inert by Reeves' inability to respond either to the props or to Oldman's deliciously hammy Dracula. It almost ruins a really great film, and deserves pride of place as his worst performance. Disagree with the choices? Drop me a comment down below.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.