Kelsey Grammer: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Singling out five of his finest hours and five performances for which he should be committed.

Kin Cheung/AP/Press Association ImagesKin Cheung/AP/Press Association ImagesToday sees the US release of Transformers: Age of Extinction, the fourth instalment in Michael Bay's seemingly endless franchise which has brought him enormous financial success and equally enormous amounts of critical bile and derision (most of which he deserves). While audiences no longer have to endure Shia LaBeouf, the trailers suggest that little else has changed: there's still the obsession with military hardware, the pseudo-pornographic visuals, and the incoherent shooting style that has gradually infected Hollywood. Following in the footsteps of John Turturro, John Malkovich and Frances McDormand (shame on all of you), this film finds Kelsey Grammer taking the Bay shilling. In a way it's fitting that the man who played one of culture's most recognisable psychiatrists should now be playing a paronoid government agent. But there is so much more to Grammer's career than the sardonic radio shrink, or his erudite homicidal maniac with pointy hair. So, before Bay manages to completely ruin his career, let's take a look back at Grammer's output in time-honoured WhatCulture.com style, singling out five of his finest hours and five performances for which he should be committed. We'll begin with a not-so-nutty professor...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Professor Tuttle - Stark Raving Mad, 'The Grade' (TV, 2000)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZW5YBQDOTs During his long run as Frasier Crane, first on Cheers and later on Frasier, Grammer would often make time to turn up in brief but memorable supporting roles in other TV shows. Some of these appearances were mere cameos, like his role as Starfleet Captain Bateson in Star Trek: The Next Generation. But others were more developed and gave us more time to appreciate his talent, and his appearance in Stark Raving Mad is a good example. Stark Raving Mad is an American sitcom starring Tony Shalhoub and Neil Patrick Harris, which ran for one season over 1999 and 2000 before being cancelled. The show revolves around the interaction between eccentric horror novelist and practical joke enthusiast Ian Stark (Shalhoub) and his reluctant, phobia-ridden, borderline-OCD editor Henry McNeeley (Harris). In 'The Grade', Stark writes a book review for a student friend after one of his novels comes up on her class reading list - only to confront her English professor (Grammer) when he only gives the report a 'B'. Grammer has always had a talent for playing pent-up anger and frustration, and he does a really good job of making Professor Tuttle more than just a knock-off of Frasier. His scenes with Shalhoub are well-paced and showcase a lot of Grammer's comic timing; he plays up his confusion about Stark's identity just right, and gets a balance between the frustration and freeform rambling that often characterises middle-aged teachers. If nothing else, this role is a lot of fun and proves that there are several more strings to his TV bow.

4. Dr. Henry 'Hank' McCoy/ Beast - X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)

20th Century Fox20th Century FoxMention the third X-Men film to fans and you will most likely get one of two responses: either abject depression that Bryan Singer jumped the franchise to make Superman Returns (yawn), or seething hatred towards 'Hollywood's toilet' Brett Ratner, who took over the direction and by all accounts did a rubbish job. But every cloud has a silver lining, and even Ratner's worst offerings usually boast a good performance trying to get out. In X-Men: The Last Stand, that performance is Grammer as Beast, a role he has since reprised in X-Men: Days of Future Past. X-Men: The Last Stand revolves around the existence of a cure for mutants, developed by Worthington Labs, which will allow any mutant who wishes it to give up their abilities and live like normal human beings. Believing this cure to be a means to exterminate his race, Magneto (Ian McKellen) reforms his Brotherhood of Mutants and begins an attack, wanting to harness the power of Jean-Grey (Famke Janssen) in her incarnation as Phoenix. The film ends in a hugely overblown battle between rival groups of mutants on Alcatraz near San Francisco. Beast plays a minor part in the proceedings up until the final confrontation; his biggest act is to inject Magneto with the cure, which eventually leads the X-Men to victory. But despite being a passenger for much of the story, Grammer does manage to get to grips with Beast's character. He brings a dignity and intelligence to proceedings which is crucial for the part, and even during the chaotic battle scenes he has a definite presence. It's just a pity that his rendition of the 'St. Crispin's Day' speech from Henry V was cut from the theatrical release.

3. Stinky Pete The Prospector - Toy Story 2 (1999)

PixarPixarIt's hard to believe that Toy Story will be 20 years old next year. What's equally hard to believe is that the second instalment in what is now deemed one of the greatest trilogies ever almost didn't make it into cinemas. Originally envisaged as a direct-to-video project, Toy Story 2 had to be effectively remade from scratch in nine months, after Disney were impressed by initial story reels and gave it a theatrical release date. Fortunately, the film ended up being arguably better than the original, and Grammer deserves at least some credit for that. Toy Story 2 picks up a few years after the events of the first film. Woody (Tom Hanks) is left behind by his owner Andy before a trip to camp after one of his arms becomes damaged. After being mistakenly sold to a collector in a yard sale, Woody discovers that he is a rare collectable, part of a range of merchandise from a long-forgotten children's cowboy show. A group of Andy's toys led by Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen) attempt a rescue, running into all kinds of trouble along the way. But Woody is now torn between being Andy's toy for what remains of his childhood, or being adored as a museum piece for all time. Toy Story 2 is a brilliant film which develops the personalities and ideas of the first film as well as broadening out the PIXAR universe. Stinky Pete is a more nuanced character than Sid from the first film; while ostensibly one of the villains of the piece, his motivations are emphathetic, tapping into the recurring theme of the characters' fear of being abandoned or forgotten. Grammer does a great job with the part, beginning as a gentle, warm and fatherly figure before gradually letting the frustrations of his character bubble to the surface and consume everything.

2. Frasier Crane - Cheers (TV, 1984-93)/ Frasier (TV, 1993-2004)

CBSCBSWhen I reviewed Patrick Stewart's filmography last month, I said that it was far too difficult to pick any one episode from his run on Star Trek: The Next Generation, and that throughout the series' run he had consistently been the strongest aspect of the show. It's much the same story with Grammer's work as Frasier Crane, a character he played for 20 years and which still defines his career in the eyes of many people. Something about his neurotic, sarcastic radio psychiatrist captured the imagination of the American public, resulting in dozens of awards and a show which is still one of the most successful spin-offs ever. For the uninitiated, pyschiatrist Frasier Crane started out as a recurring character in Cheers, the popular American sitcom set in the eponymous bar in Boston. Making his debut in season three, he was positioned as a love interest for Diane (Shelley Long), bringing him into competition with bartender Sam Malone (Ted Danson). After being jilted at the altar by Diane, Crane becomes a regular at Cheers before relocating to Seattle. Here, in Frasier, Crane is living with his father and his brother Niles (David Hyde Pierce), and hosting his own radio show. The show finally ended in 2004 with the two-part special 'Goodnight Seattle'. It's very easy to say that one can't imagine anyone else playing Frasier Crane after all these years, but the fact is much of the character's appeal lies in Grammer's performance. It was his great chemistry with Danson which caused the part to be extended beyond a few episodes, and his excellent comic timing which led to some of the funniest moments in 1990s sitcoms. But on top of the buffoonish elements, Grammer imbues a great sense of intelligence, culture and respect into the part, giving us a protagonist who is pompous but appealing - a rare trick to pull off.

1. Sideshow Bob - The Simpsons, 'Cape Feare' (TV, 1993)

20th Century Fox20th Century FoxIt's very hard to choose between the 16 episodes to date in which Grammer has voiced the brilliant Sideshow Bob. It's certainly true that the more recent appearances of the character have seen him relegated to comic relief, but when the show was in its prime, Robert Underdunk Terwilliger steadily grew into one of the most distinctive and complex supporting characters in The Simpsons universe. But for all the appeal of 'Black Widower', 'Day of the Jackanapes' or 'Brother From Another Series', 'Cape Feare' is still the best Sideshow Bob episode, and the best thing that Grammer has ever done. 'Cape Feare' begins with Bart receiving a series of death threats written in blood. These are being sent to him by Sideshow Bob, serving time in prison for attempting to murder Selma Bouvier in 'Black Widower'. Having pursuaded the parole board that he poses no threat to Bart, Bob is released and begins to stalk The Simpsons. The family are relocated under the Witness Protection Programme, but Bob is never far behind. As its title suggests, the episode riffs extensively on both versions of Cape Fear, particularly the 1991 remake starring Robert De Niro (the cinema scene, pictured above, is a direct reference). 'Cape Feare' has become a classic episode in its own right, with many of its ingredients becoming staples of future Bob episodes. But while he can't take full credit for the hilarious rake joke (created in post-production to fill out time), every other aspect of Bob's success as a character is down to Grammer. His delivery is witty and deliciously cruel, he brings credence to the character's more snobbish aspects, and he sings the entire score of H. M. S. Pinafore with great aplomb. It's a terrific all-round performance which turns what could be just another cartoony psychopath into a rounded, believable and thoroughly entertaining character. Having heard Grammer soar on Gilbert and Sullivan, let's look at five performances in which he sank like a stone...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Joel Cranston - Fame (2009)

MGMMGMIn my Pierce Brosnan profile back in March, I compiled a short list of remakes which are often held up as being as good as, if not better than, the originals. But while the likes of Nosferatu, Little Shop of Horrors and The Thomas Crown Affair all brought something new to the table, the recent remake of Fame did not. Instead it was a blatant attempt to reappropriate an 1980s classic for the High School Musical crowd, and in doing so set the bar for Grammer's bad performances. Loosely reworking the Alan Parker original, Fame follows a group of students through their four years at a New York City performing arts college. Over the course of their time, we see various students growing to specialise as actors, singers, dancers etc. under the guiding hand of various teachers, including Grammer's Joel Cranston. The film eventually builds to most of the characters graduating, with original cast member Debbie Allen returning to play the principal of the school. While the original film had something of an edgy quality to it, particularly in the fates of its female characters, the remake of Fame is about as edgy as a stick of candy floss. Most of the actors are too old to be convincing as students, the storytelling and editing is choppy, and the story as a whole feels completely stake-free. Grammer seems disinterested for the most part, making the least of his lines and trying to get his scenes over and done with as soon as possible. Whether due to miscasting or an awareness on his part of the inferior product, it's a very forgettably bad performance.

4. Robert Hawkins - 15 Minutes (2001)

New Line CinemaNew Line CinemaIt's hard to pinpoint the exact moment in his career when Robert DeNiro stopped caring. While he's occasionally managed to turn in a performance which reminds of how good he used to be (Stardust and Limitless being decent examples), since the mid-1990s his choices have been almost as misjudged as Nicolas Cage's, as have many of his performances. 15 Minutes is another forgettably mediocre entry in his late-period filmography, featuring DeNiro on autopilot and Grammer out of his depth. 15 Minutes stars De Niro as NYPD detective Eddie Flemming, who contributes to a TV show called Top Story hosted by Richard Hawkins (Grammer). Following an apartment fire, Flemming teams up with arson expert Jordy Warsaw (Ed Burns) and uncovers a network of criminals who are fighting over their share of a bank raid. One of the criminals, Oleg, films the murder of his former colleague and everything else he can. When Flemming is captured and murdered by Oleg and his team, Hawkins pays $1m for his 'death tape', whose airing eventually leads to the criminals' capture. Borrowing its title from Andy Warhol's famous quote about fame, 15 Minutes is a heavy-handed, underwhelming thriller. It squanders the opportunity to use its antagonists to make a point about cinematic violence, and its attempts to satirise media hysteria and sensationalist journalism aren't developed properly. Grammer is particularly underwhelming, taking a reasonably meaty and cynical role and delivering his lines with little conviction or interest. As with his work on Fame, it feels like he is rushing himself through his scenes, presumably because he had to get back to filming Frasier.

3. Clark Cooper - I Don't Know How She Does It (2011)

Weinstein CompanyWeinstein CompanyLike Aaron Eckhart before him, Grammer isn't immune from appearing in bad romantic comedies, or at least comedies with a romantic element. Two years after Eckhart found himself in the tepid and tedious Love Happens, Grammer turned up in a supporting role in the equally dull and unrealistic I Don't Know How She Does It. While not the worst film he's ever made (we're coming to that), it is a very good example of how actors can made a bad film worse, by making the very least of the material that is put before them. Directed by Douglas McGrath (who also made the underrated Infamous), I Don't Know How She Does It is based on the bestselling novel of the same name by Allison Pearson. It follows working mother Kate Reddy (Sarah Jessica Parker) as she struggles to balance the demands of her work, her husband (Greg Kinnear) and her children. Things only get more complicated when she takes a position away from her family, working for Pierce Brosnan's Jack Abelhammer. While it's nothing like as bad as the Sex and the City films, I Don't Know How She Does It is a limp, patronising and unconvincing comedy. While McGrath directs with the best intentions, he fails to relate the plight of the protagonists to those of us who don't enjoy such upmarket, wealthy lifestyles. Grammer isn't in the film for very long, but he doesn't help proceedings by phoning in a caricaturish employer. He has no chemistry with Parker and doesn't bring anything interesting to the table. Considering that he won a Golden Globe for the TV series Boss around the same time, it's curious that he could be so boring in a similar role.

2. General George S. Patten - An Americal Carol (2008)

American Carol Kelsey Grammer We've all heard stories about Hollywood's liberal credentials and its battles with the conservative arm of American politics. Whenever a film comes out which satirises or attempts to expose corrupt politicians or big business, you can bet your house that some American conservative will rant and rave about the liberal bias of Hollywood filmmakers. But when the conservatives attempted to do the same, they came massively unstuck with An American Carol, which finds Grammer tarnishing the memory of a great American hero. If you can believe it, An American Carol was directed by David Zucker, one-third of the legendary team behind Airplane! and the Naked Gun films. Taking its structure and plot from A Christmas Carol, the film stars Kevin Farley as Michael Malone, a Michael Moore stand-in who wants to abolish the Fourth of July holiday. To make him change his ways and see the value of patriotism, he is visited by a spirit who takes the form of General George S. Patton (Grammer), who in turn shows him visions of an America overrun by slavery and Islamic fundamentalism. It's tempting to believe that much of the backlash towards An American Carol was simply a reaction against its political views. The reality is that it's just a really badly-made film, with heavy-handed satire, laboured jokes and production values which look every bit at cheap as the likes of Disaster Movie and Vampires Suck. Grammer is awful here, failing to get to grips with the unique mannerisms of the character and delivering the most absurd and didactic lines without a hint of irony or self-awareness. Because he's so clearly a mouthpiece rather than a character, we can never take him seriously enough, and he becomes more and more ridiculous as he tries to get his point across.

1. Lieutenant Commander Thomas Dodge - Down Periscope (1996)

Kelsey Grammar Down Pericsope It's often difficult for actors and directors alike to transfer from one medium to another. By the time he came to make his feature-film debut, Grammer had nine years of Cheers and a further two of Frasier behind him; he was well-liked and widely respected, but doubts remained about his abilities on the big screen. While Down Periscope didn't strangle his film career in the crib, it is the biggest and most perplexing of all his failures, working against so many of his natural strengths. Directed by David S. Ward (The Sting II), Down Periscope stars Grammer as Lt. Comm. Thomas Dodge, an unorthodox US Navy officer who has twice failed to his bid to command his own vessel. Faced with a humiliating desk job, he is handed one last chance by Vice Admiral Dean Winslow (Rip Torn) and given command of a rusty diesel submarine, the USS Stingray, during a war games exercise. Saddled with a motley, incompetent crew that includes Rob Schneider and Harry Dean Stanton, Dodge must uses every trick he knows to win against the ruthless Rear Admiral Yancy Graham (Bruce Dern in shouty mode). Down Periscope is essentially what you would get if you put all the weaker Police Academy films together and set them underwater. The action scenes are sub-standard, the humour is weak and the performances are thin and stereotypical. But Grammer is the biggest problem, being miscast as a happy-go-lucky maverick when he's always been at his best in straight-laced, intelligent roles. Having been given the wrong part, he gurns his way through the set-pieces, trying and failing to channel Phil Silvers as Sergeant Bilko, and doesn't bring any credibility to the character interactions. It's Grammer squandering his natural talent, and it remains his most embarrassing performance to date. Disagree with my choices? Drop me a comment below or visit Mumby at the Movies for more reviews.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.