Kevin Smith Movies Ranked Worst To Best

Silent Bob's directorial efforts put under the microscope.

Kevin Smith was once the darling of internet movie fans, a self-professed geek made good. In the 1990€™s he had an extremely dedicated cult following, if not huge box office returns for his films, and became a celebrity director who was as known for his own personality as his work. He even wrote some damn good comic books, contributing in many great ways to an industry he adores. Unfortunately, somewhere along the way his star began to wane, as his film output in the 2000€™s dipped in quality quite badly. It seemed that once he ventured into uncharted territory by directing films outside of the View Askewniverse (named in honour of his production company), the wheels began to come off. Smith's first 5 efforts were all connected via the characters of Jay and Silent Bob (the latter played, of course, by Smith himself), but when he left the two loveable stoners behind and tried his hand at romantic comedies and buddy movies, he just couldn't seem to find his voice again. Perhaps Smith's very public persona began to work against him. He has always been active on the internet (currently overseeing his extensive podcast network, SModcast Internet Radio), and has gone on many successful spoken word tours, which often land somewhere between stand-up comedy and exposés of the Hollywood machine. Smith is an affable and self-deprecating presence, but has that led to reviewers being unable to deliver their verdicts on his films in an objective manner, whether consciously or not? It could be said that Kevin Smith himself began to be judged almost as much as his films, rather than his work being taken on it's own merits. This year saw the release of his 11th directorial effort, Tusk, and even though it was a failure at the box office, it has definitely continued a recent resurgence in the quality and inventiveness of his filmmaking. So, what better time to cast your eyes back over the man€™s storied career and rank his movies from worst to best.

11. Cop Out (2010)

Cop Out is a dreadful film. Ostensibly a buddy movie, an action-comedy about two longtime NYPD partners, it is neither funny nor particularly action-packed. Bruce Willis and Tracy Morgan have very little on-screen chemistry, with Willis delivering one of the customarily bored performances that have blighted his recent cinematic output. Morgan, so hilarious on Tina Fey's 30 Rock television show, simply came across as irritating, which isn't ideal considering he was tasked with delivering much of the film's 'comedy'. The only actor who escaped with any credit was Seann William Scott, who raised a few chuckles in a fairly minor role as a small-time hood. Cop Out is the only one of Smith's directorial efforts for which he did not also write the script, and it shows. There is a disconnect between his direction as a studio's 'hired gun' and the Kevin Smith who created all his other films from the ground up. The behind the scenes stories that have since emerged about the production are inarguably more interesting than the movie itself, with Smith going on record for a 2011 podcast that Bruce Willis was extremely difficult to work with, saying that "were it not for Tracy, I might have either killed myself or someone else in the making of Cop Out". Other sources connected with the film fired back that Smith smoked far too much marijuana during filming and barely interacted with the actors.

10. Zack And Miri Make A Porno (2008)

Zack And Miri Make A Porno was "supposed to be the one that punched us through to the next level. Everyone thought it would do $60 to $70 million, and it wound up doing Kevin Smith business". Considering these are the words of Smith himself, it's no surprise to reveal that this movie was a disappointment, commercially and critically. The film made $42.1 million in it's theatrical run, and was burgeoning star Seth Rogen's worst box-office opening in his career up to that point. It co-starred Elizabeth Banks and with a fun premise (lifetime platonic friends and roommates decide to make a pornographic movie to lift themselves out of financial difficulty) it seemed primed to hit big with the same demographic who loved Judd Apatow's comedies (which deliver equal amounts of lewd humour and heartfelt pathos). Unfortunately, it just wasn't funny enough to resonate fully with audiences. It's a decent Friday night watch, an undemanding diversion that will pass a few hours reasonably well, but it isn't something that will live long in the memory. Oh well.

9. Clerks II (2006)

Appearing a full 12 years after the original Clerks, Smith's first film, Clerks II is an intriguing oddity. It received fairly good reviews upon it's 2006 release, even making a few critics' Top Ten lists for the year, and it performed reasonably well at the box office, especially considering it was a sequel to a micro-budgeted cult film from over a decade previous. Reappraising the film, however, reveals a comedy that all too often falls flat and relies far too much on audience affection for the first film. The most glaring failure of the film is that it exposed the weaknesses of the two leads, Brian O'Halloran's Dante and Jeff Anderson's Randal. Both stars CV's extend very little beyond Kevin Smith projects, and even though O'Halloran is mostly a stage actor these days, it is hard to shake the feeling that while they were perfectly suited for a low budget independent movie, when they were thrust into the centre of Clerks II alongside an experienced actress like Rosario Dawson, they struggled to match her performance. Most of the fun of Clerks II comes from seeing Jay and Silent Bob again, as well as other cameos from Smith regulars like Ben Affleck and Jason Lee. However, it was definitely a step backwards in Smith's growth as a filmmaker and doesn't bear up to many repeat viewings.

8. Jersey Girl (2004)

In a career that has seen a litany of box-office disasters and critical savagings, Jersey Girl just might be the most infamous of them all. Starring Ben Affleck and Jennifer Lopez (then at the height of their 'Bennifer' fame in the media), along with Jason Biggs, Liv Tyler and the late George Carlin, Jersey Girl was nominated for 3 Razzie Awards, including Worst Actor for Affleck, Worst Supporting Actress for Lopez and Worst On-Screen Couple for good measure. Ouch. The strange thing about the bile that the film received is that it is actually a good film, a charming rom-com that features a superb performance from Raquel Castro as Affleck's precocious daughter. George Carlin is excellent as Affleck's father and scenes involving these three give the film many of it's emotional high points. The release of 2003's derided Gigli, also starring Affleck and Lopez, might actually be where to point the finger of blame for the failure of Jersey Girl. Gigli was rightfully dismissed as terrible, but then the ill-will that film built up seemed to seep into the perception of Jersey Girl, which was sad. It's no masterpiece, not by any means, but is a good film nonetheless and it's negative reception led Smith to retreat and make Clerks II.

7. Mallrats (1995)

Well, well, well, what do we have here? Yes, Mallrats is another Kevin Smith movie that died a death at the box-office and faced a critical drubbing. Poor Kev. Mallrats was his second film, written and released only a year after Clerks. It starred Jason London, Shannen Doherty and Claire Forlani, none of whom went on to work with Smith again regularly. They aren't very good in the film, to be fair. What Mallrats does have going for it is Jason Lee as Brodie, the comic book obsessed and foul mouthed best friend of London's character T.S. It's hard to believe that Lee had no acting experience before Mallrats; rather, he was a professional skateboarder. His undeniable comic chops led to him becoming a Smith regular and sitcom legend as Earl Hickey in My Name Is Earl. Mallrats has a certain lackadaisical appeal and has since developed a decent following on video and DVD. The opening credits and much of Lee's dialogue exist as an open love letter to comics and the film also features a cameo from Marvel uber-legend Stan Lee, pictured above sporting a snazzy beard. This pretty much ensured that the film will always have a place in the hearts of comic book fans the world over, if nothing else.

6. Dogma (1999)

With Dogma, Kevin Smith tackled religion and the Catholic Church specifically in his own special and unique way. Naturally, this led to bucketloads of controversy, with organised protests delaying the release of the film and Smith receiving at least two death threats. A quick overview of the plot certainly reveals why it might anger certain communities, but also shows that Smith approached Dogma with a previously unseen level of ambition. The plot follows two fallen angels, Loki (Matt Damon) and Bartleby (Ben Affleck) who have been cast out of heaven after Loki resigned as the Angel of Death. Through a loophole, they discover a route back into heaven, but given that existence is predicated on God being infallible, their successful re-entry would prove God wrong and, you know, undo all Creation. Therefore, Linda Fiorentino's Bethany (the last living descendant of Jesus Christ) must team with the Voice Of God (played by Hans Gruber himself, Alan Rickman), two prophets of God (Jay and Silent Bob!) and the thirteenth apostle (Chris Rock), who was omitted from the Bible because he is black. It certainly seemed like Smith was determined to rile people up with this one, but Dogma emerged as a funny and ultimately thought-provoking meditation on organised religion. That also featured a demon made of poo. Yep.

5. Jay And Silent Bob Strike Back (2001)

Undoubtedly the most juvenile of Smith's films, Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back is also arguably his funniest. Equal parts foul-mouthed stoner antics and laser-focused Hollywood satire, the film was a love it or hate it ode to the 'hetero life partners' and catchphrase spouting duo who kept appearing in Smith's films. Your tolerance for this will pretty much rest on how much you can stand hearing Jason Mewes say "snoochie boochies' and "snoogins", all while a veritable feast of famous Hollywood personalities send themselves up in a variety of inventive ways. The list of comic talent involved is extensive. Will Ferrell, Jon Stewart, Seann William Scott, Jason Biggs, Chris Rock, George Carlin, Mark Hamill and Carrie Fisher all appear, along with regulars like Affleck, Damon and Jason Lee. There are even cameos from directors Wes Craven and Gus Van Sant, amusingly counting money rather than paying any attention to the filming of Good Will Hunting 2: Hunting Season.

4. Chasing Amy (1997)

Now this list has finally arrived at a Kevin Smith film that was greeted with a positive critical reception, and deservedly so. Released two years after Mallrats, Chasing Amy was a much more mature proposition, exploring gender roles, sexual experience and the boundaries of friendship, all wrapped up with Smith's trademark snappy dialogue and raunchy humour. It won two awards at the Independent Spirit Awards in 1998: Best Screenplay for Smith and Best Supporting Actor for Jason Lee. The plot revolved around the relationship between Ben Affleck's Holden McNeil, a comic book creator, and Joey Lauren Adams' fellow creator and lesbian Alyssa Jones. Holden is attracted to her and when their friendship deepens, can't keep his feelings in and confesses his love to her. They then begin a relationship, but tensions mount between Holden and Banky (Lee), his co-creator on the comic book. Banky doesn't trust Alyssa and digs up dirt on her sexual past, which leaves Holden feeling insecure and affects their relationship. The film features a brilliant monologue from Silent Bob, the only time he speaks for any real length of time in the View Askew movies. While some may argue that it is disingenuous for Smith to give himself the best piece of dialogue in the film, the story he tells of "Chasing Amy" is undoubtedly emotionally charged and has pertinent things to say about the nature of romantic relationships.

3. Clerks. (1994)

The story behind the financing and making of Clerks, Smith's ultra-low budget debut, is now the stuff of indie movie legend. Smith acquired the paltry budget of $27,575 (which is actually a very hefty sum to a guy who then worked at the Quick Stop convenience store the film is set in) by selling off a large portion of his extensive comic book collection, maxing out 8 to 10 credit cards with $2000 limits, along with money set aside for his college education and insurance money he was awarded for a car lost in a flood. Filming took place entirely at night, as Smith wasn't given permission to film during the day by the Quick Stop's owners. This necessitated filming in black and white and also the plot point that the store's shutters were constantly closed due to a vandal jamming gum in the padlock. Smith, his small crew and actors filmed over 21 straight nights, with Smith working during the day at the shop and going straight to filming afterwards. Clerks is a true independent success story, making over $3 million in the States. What it lacks in filmmaking flourishes or visual style, it makes up for with it's verbose and often hilarious script, the first taste the world had of Smith's trademark writing style. Yes, the film is very profane and yes, the performances struggle to rise above amateur level sometimes, but as a calling card for a young director it was everything Kevin Smith could have hoped for.

2. Red State (2011)

When Red State was released in 2011, it was unlike anything the world had ever seen from Kevin Smith. For one thing, it wasn't a comedy in any way, shape or form. Instead, Smith had written and directed a dark, challenging horror drama featuring a potent central performance from Michael Parks, a character actor previously best known for small appearances in From Dusk Till Dawn and Kill Bill. Parks played Pastor Abin Cooper, a terrifying religious zealot who lured young homosexuals into his Five Points Trinity Church before murdering them. John Goodman played the ATF agent tasked with leading a raid against the Church, and the movie exploded into a shoot-out between the ATF and Cooper's heavily armed followers. The release and distribution of Red State caused quite a bit of controversy, with Smith eventually self-distributing the film under his own SModcast Pictures banner, after initially saying he was going to auction the rights to the film after its premiere at the Sundance Film Festival. Regardless of this messy issue, when the film is looked at objectively, it undoubtedly shows Smith trying his hand at something completely new and outside his comfort zone. The film is not perfect - many have accused it of being overly wordy and too preachy - but it is a very interesting picture nonetheless and does boast several dynamic set pieces and moments of ratcheting tension. Smith coaxes good to great performances across the board, with the aforementioned Parks deserving particular credit for his spine-tingling delivery of Smith's dialogue.

1. Tusk (2014)

As with nearly everything Smith has worked on in his career, Tusk was met with disastrous box-office returns and, yes, a vitriolic response from some critics. By this point, Smith and his financiers probably expected as much and will be hoping that the film finds more of an audience on DVD and Blu-Ray. The interesting thing about Tusk is that certain critics were much more positive, with many praising it's originality and genuine shock factor. It's a movie that will stay with you long after the end credits roll, whether you loved it or were turned off by just how out there it gets in its third act. The film's script is fantastic, with Michael Parks again working wonders with Smith's dialogue, delivering his fascinating and unnerving soliloquies with eloquent precision. Justin Long puts in a similarly strong turn, acting as an excellent counterpoint to Parks. Long's character Wallace Bryton is fully fleshed out, no mere one-note scumbag in distress. Smith also gets top notch supporting turns from Genesis Rodriguez as Long's girlfriend Ally and Haley Joel Osment (marking his maturation to adult actor, after his sterling performances as a child in The Sixth Sense and Pay It Forward) as his best friend Teddy. The third act of the film is really what will divide opinion, as the story simultaneously takes a disturbing, grotesque turn while also introducing a character who changes the tone to something more offbeat and strangely amusing. If you go with the film though, and buy in to everything that Smith is trying to accomplish, Tusk is a singular movie experience. The first meeting of Mr Tusk will haunt your dreams for many nights afterwards. Tusk and Red State ranked above Clerks?! Sound off in the comments below with all your opinions on Mr Kevin Smith and his movies.

Contributor
Contributor

Comics. Movies. TV. Wrestling. Video Games. Husband. Father. Geek.