Kick-Ass 2 - 5 Changes From The Comic That Ruined The Film
It's a treacherous road a filmmaker walks when adapting beloved source material. He has to satisfy the fanbase, an often mentally unhinged lot, ready to pull out their pitchforks and torches the moment a character's wardrobe changes color. Equally important is taking into account the needs of mainstream audiences, whose attention spans are often far more fish-like than the average comic fans'. The best movie adaptations are able to satisfy both bases. The worst satisfy neither. I went into Kick-Ass 2 with pretty high expectations, having been a huge fan of both the first movie and the comic series. But as I sat in the theater watching I couldn't shake the feeling that something was seriously wrong. Most of the scenes from the comic were there, but something just felt off. The unpleasant feeling started to creep up on me that I was watching a truly awful film. But why, I wondered, would a film that retains most of the scenes from the comic seem so different from its source. The answer? It lacks virtually everything that makes Kick-Ass, well, Kick-Ass. Often crude, inappropriate and perplexing, the movie retains many of the comic's scenes while leaving out their purpose. Worse, writer/director Jeff Wadlow seems content with appealing to the lowest common denominator and ripping out any integrity from the comic's characters. He imbues his film with none of Kick-Ass 1 director Matthew Vaughn's ingenuity, comic edge, or visual pleasure. Instead there's a gaping void where comic writer Mark Millar's original ideas were left to die. 5 changes in particular struck me as disrespectful towards both the material and movie audiences. Here are the 5 biggest changes that ruined Kick-Ass 2.
5. Inappropriate Comedy
Part of the fun of the Kick-Ass comic series is its satirizing of violence. Yes it can be dark, edgy and dramatic, but Millar knows how to have fun with the darkness too. He knows fans want to see blood and guts. Thus it's completely exaggerated, and becomes almost Quentin Tarantino-like in its depiction. Much of the comedy flows naturally from the violence. So even when the Mother F**ker slaughters dozens of innocent civilians, his narcissistic ranting inspires a chuckle. When Hit-Girl plunges swords into the faces of criminals it's so over the top you can't help but laugh your ass off. The potentially awkward paring of disturbing violence with satirized comedy works for Millar, but Wadlow does away with it completely. Take the scene where Hit-Girl takes revenge on the mean girls (pun intended) for leaving her alone in the woods. Rather than the inspired roof top hanging from the comic, she takes out some absurd weapon called the Sick Stick (clearly a product of Wadlow's own uninspired imagination) which causes the girls immediate explosive diarrhea and uncontrollable vomiting. Ummmm.... why is this funny exactly? I don't find vomiting particularly hilarious. I suppose the goal was to get all the other kids in the lunch room to laugh at the girls for hurling chunks everywhere. But frankly if I'd been sitting in the lunch room and witnessed this, my first instinct would be to immediately stop eating my lunch and swear vengeance on the lunch lady. The scene is just so crude and ugly, and lacks any of the zing from the revenge scene of the comic. There's no basis of character or purpose, it's just a sell-out for gross-out humor that neither amuses nor feels like a satisfying revenge for Hit-Girl. A scene like this would fare better in Jackass, or American Pie, or some other teen schlock flick. But perhaps the worst offender in the comedy department is Mother F**ker's rape of Night Bitch. The scene in the comic (featuring Katie Deuxma instead of Night Bitch) is presented as truly horrifying and disturbing. The rape is meant to show the brutality of real world super villainy, and it doesn't pull any punches. But, shockingly, Wadlow decided to use this scene to play up the comedy. Mother F**ker barges into her house, has his cronies roughly pin Night Bitch to the wall, unzips his pants and... can't get it up. This results in what I'm sure Wadlow intended as a HILARIOUS attempt for Mother F**ker to get an erection by jerking himself off. Not only is this completely unfunny and awkward, it's a shameful attempt to gloss over genuine brutality. Millar's key to weaving both comedy and drama into the comic is knowing how to balance them, to fuse the comedy and drama when appropriate. The comedy never rings as an attempt to cover the drama, rather it works in tandem with it. But here the comedy is a shallow attempt to hide the ugliness. If Wadlow had really felt the rape was too much for the movie he should have done away with it altogether. By including the rape and glossing it over he actually draws more attention to it. It makes Wadlow look callous and disinterested, as though cramming in a rape scene is no big deal. If he had given the scene its proper dramatic tone it would have had a purpose for the story, spurring on Kick-Ass's hatred of Mother F**ker. Instead the scene is just awkwardly in there, seeming completely unnecessary and all the more unsettling because of it. And speaking of unsettling...
4. Sexualizing Hit-Girl
3. Rushed Pacing And Editing
Many scenes in Kick-Ass 2 are completely rushed to the point where the viewer feels zero emotional impact. The early scenes are acceptably paced, but by the time we reach the death scene of Colonel Stars and Stripes the movie charges into overdrive. It becomes a whirlwind of blood, violence and death too fast to properly register anything. While the death of the Colonel hits home mostly successfully (thanks in large part to Jim Carrey's scene-stealing performance) each subsequent scene is ripped of its core. Consider: there is virtually no breathing room after the Colonel's death, just the brief conversation at the diner table, and then we're immediately thrown into more Mother F**ker carnage. The movie cuts from there to Dave's father finding out about Kick-Ass, to his father's arrest, to his murder, to Dave's reaction, to the funeral, to the firing rocket, to Hit-Girl on the truck - all in 10 minutes or less. It's particularly offensive that Wadlow would blow through the death of Kick-Ass' father as though it's just an unimportant plot device. In the comic, his death provides the emotional core. It has a huge impact on Dave, and causes him to doubt all of his life choices. It's heart-wrenching, and is justifiably given ample space in order to deal with the emotional consequences. In the movie it's impossible to feel anything. We move so quickly between scenes that they lose all of their impact, without which the subsequent violence - like the big team showdown - feels unjustified. This is why critics everywhere have been calling Kick-Ass 2 pointless schlock. If only they had read the comic, they would see just how much of it is Wadlow's fault. Judging from the rushed treatment of these scenes, Wadlow's mind was only on one thing: action. Anything in between the action scenes is treated as second fiddle. Ironic considering the action scenes aren't even well put together. Vaughn's dazzling choreography is replaced by Bourne Identity shaky cam. But unlike in Bourne, the technique isn't used to create a unique style, it's just used to cover a lack of talent in executing action sequences. Breakneck cutting and repetitious switching from wide angle to close-up artificially intensify scenes like Hit-Girl's attack in the alleyway of her fight on the truck. This is the laziest form of constructing an action set-piece, only pleasing to the most untrained eyes. It's obvious why the film had problems telling a coherent story. Consider this: the first Kick-Ass film, based on only one graphic novel, ran over 2 hours. This film, based on 2 entirely separate graphic novels, is around 20 minutes shorter. Huh? The movie could have really benefited from an extra 15-20 minutes to give those later scenes more room to breathe and allow the proper audience impact. It would have been easy for Wadlow to extend some of the scenes, but I suspect either his heart wasn't in it, or he's just completely incompetent at storytelling. Probably the latter, considering his Rotten Tomatoes track record. On the subject of incompetence, please turn to the next page...
2. Changing The Ending
I love the ending from the comic. An epic battle in the middle of Times Square ends with Hit-Girl getting arrested (!!!). It's a very Empire Strikes Back-esque cliffhanger, with Kick-Ass and his crew poised to attempt to break Hit-Girl out in Kick-Ass 3. ...And the film completely loses all of that. Instead, the movie ends with the most clichéd superhero wrap-up imaginable. Kick-Ass and Hit-Girl share a contrived Hollywood kiss, Dave gives up being Kick-Ass, Mindy leaves the city for good, and Dave gives us some half-assed narration about how he learned the real secret of being a hero is to just be himself. This ending feels so tacked-on I can't decide whether to laugh in derisive hysteria or cry tears of despair. Exactly where in this movie does it suggest that the moral of the story is to NOT be a super hero? Is it the part where Hit-Girl takes down Mother Russia by dosing herself with a shot of Hulk Strength? Or the part where Kick-Ass bands a team of 50+ heroes to have a super powered brawl with the villains? Sorry, but I don't see anything in there suggesting it's better to be a normal guy, not with Wadlow excising all of the comic's multilayers. The movie's ultra quick wrap-up comes completely out of the blue, it's way too neat and tidy, and strangely seems like they're aiming to end the series with this installment. But why would they do that when there's still Kick-Ass 3 to come? Could it be that Wadlow knew just how awful his movie was, and figured that ending it with the comic's cliffhanger would be the equivalent of cinematic suicide? I wouldn't be surprised. Then there's the aforementioned kiss between Hit-Girl and Kick-Ass... NO! Just... NO! Enough with the ultra-pedo stuff! These two should NOT be kissing. Part of what makes the Kick-Ass/Hit-Girl relationship so unique and interesting is that there is zero sexual tension between them. There can't be, because in the comics Dave is 16 and Mindy is 12. But beyond the age gap, it's important in Millar's universe that there be no romance between the two central characters. Millar's story takes place in our world, and in our world two people don't get together simply because they're both dressing up and fighting on the same team. Relationships are much more complicated than that, and only clichéd Hollywood archetypes allow for the pairing of male-and-female protagonist. The Hollywood coupling has no place in a film whose source material constantly strives to go against traditional character dynamics. Since Wadlow is clearly viewing Kick-Ass through the lens of an audience pleaser, he's considering only what he thinks the stereotypical movie audience wants, and not what actually makes sense for the characters. Wadlow failed to grasp that the Hit-Girl/Kick-Ass relationship is one of mutual respect and admiration, not a romance. Just the age gap alone makes it icky. Sure, in the movie the difference in ages is 16 and 20 rather than 12 and 16, and it's more a case of Hit-Girl wanting to experience a first kiss than the inklings of a genuine relationship... but it's still icky. Read on to see what all this badness boils down to...
1. Losing The Comic's Theme
Truly the greatest loss in translation from comic to film was the destruction of the very ideals that define Kick-Ass. The comic has never proclaimed that dressing up as a super hero is the only way to deal with your problems, or promoted the training of 10 year old girls as assassins. The violence is a peg underscoring the theme that the real world isn't a comic book. In the real world, dressing up as a super hero can have major consequences, sometimes devastating. Sure, there might be some fun and games to have along the way, but the truth always comes back to bite these characters in the ass, most notably in the loss of both Mindy's and Dave's fathers, the rape of Katie, and murder of Colonel Stars. More-so than in any other comic series - where losses are part of the super hero standard - the losses here indicate to these characters that they've got to take stock of the real world. If they truly want to become heroes, they must embrace all that being a hero entails, including the concepts of losing a battle and a loved one. Kick-Ass is about what it REALLY means to be a super hero. The first film captured this theme perfectly well, with Big Daddy's death in particular serving as a reminder of the realties of walking the streets in a costume. But the theme is completely lost in Kick-Ass 2. We lose the lesson that real world brutality has a toll on super heroics because there's no consequence to any of the brutality in the film. Violence is dolled out on both sides, hero and villain, and there's no impact on either end. Night Bitch's rape is made comedic and insignificant. Dave's dad's death is shown for all of 10 seconds. There's no real punishment for the villains, there's no true lessons for the heroes. The movie simply tells us that all of the world's evils can be solved with a massive barbaric brawl. None of the villains' actions are acknowledged in any meaningful way. Consequently, you wind up feeling indifferent towards Kick-Ass's battle with Mother F**ker. The murders and rape are barely given a second thought. Consequently, it feels as though Dave has no real reason to want to beat him - aside from "because the script said so." Wadlow has given us a cover without a book, a superficial travesty that looks like the comic but doesn't act like it. Kick-Ass 2 is a lazy mess that would have been all too easy to fix if only Wadlow had been paying attention to his source. As a massive fan of the comic, I'm deeply offended, and can only hope that Kick-Ass 3: the movie manages to make amends. Keeping Jeff Wadlow far away from it is a start. Bringing back Mathew Vaughn would be the real kicker. Do that, and I'm sure I'll be cheering on Kick-Ass and Hit-Girl once again. Especially if she calls criminals c**ts while "Banana Splits" plays in the background. That'd be sweet. What are your thoughts on Kick-Ass 2? Do you hate the movie as much as I did, or am I completely off base? Sound off in the comments below and let us know!
