Kiefer Sutherland: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Jack Bauer's finest hours.

As the son of acclaimed Canadian actor Donald Sutherland, Kiefer Sutherland always had a lot to live up to; renowned today for his distinctly husky voice, gruff characteristics and unabashed charisma, there's no denying that Sutherland has managed to mark himself out as a wildly versatile talent. Indeed, Sutherland's appeal doesn't extend from his ability to play a single character type, despite the fact that many seem intent to peg him as a one-dimensional action star. Instead, Sutherland has succeeded in bringing all kinds of varied characters to life. Best known today for his role as Agent Jack Bauer in TV's 24 (a character so popular that Sutherland's performance has near on overshadowed everything else in his filmography, for good or for worse), Sutherland is also remembered for an array of supporting characters in movies such as Stand By Me, The Lost Boys and Flatliners. His massively identifiable voice - gruff, worn; a voice of experience - has also opened to the door to a number of memorable turns. In Phone Booth, for example, his entire performance hinges on his ability to use his voice. Despite a number of good performances throughout the 80s and 90s, Sutherland's career eventually fell to the wayside when he started to take on too many supporting roles and very nearly compromised his potential as a leading man. When it all looked to be over, however, the script for 24 landed on his desk and... well, the rest is history. Despite the near-on iconic status he enjoys today, however, there are - as with any actor who's put their time in - misfires, ill-judged performances, and a few curious oddities to be found in and amongst all the good stuff. To celebrate the release of his latest movie, the blockbuster Pompeii (released in the UK) and the return of 24 next week, join us as we look back at 5 awesome Kiefer Sutherland performances and 5 that sucked...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. The Caller - Phone Booth

The voice. It's all about the voice. It's no wonder that Hideo Kojima, creator of the Metal Gear Solid video game series, hired Kiefer Sutherland to provide to dulcet tones of Solid Snake for the latest games in the franchise. In this underrated little movie directed by Joel Schumacher, then, which has Colin Farrell trapped in a phone booth whilst a sniper - played by Sutherland - looks on and terrorises him from afar, Sutherland's performance lives and dies by his ability to control his voice. We never really see much of him, and yet the voice literally says it all. If the movie itself doesn't make all that much sense - does it really need to? - the interplay between Farrell's trapped character and Sutherland's enigmatic villain, billed merely as "The Caller," works wonders. Obviously a movie set in a single location had to ensure that the one on one banter between its protagonist and antagonist worked well, but together they are brilliant. It's difficult to make your presence known in a Hollywood film using just your voice alone, but just as Scarlett Johansson did recently in Her, Kiefer Sutherland near on steals the movie with his.

4. Nelson Wright - Flatliners

Flatliners is not a great film. It's confused and somewhat pretentious. What can be said about it, though, is that it contains one of Kiefer Sutherland's most interesting and therefore essential performances - one that resonants from the very first frame to the very last. If you haven't seen Flatlines, the Joel Schumacher-directed film touches on the subject of life versus death. As Nelson Wright, Sutherland's role is integral: wanting to explore what happens when you die, he's the medical student who convinces his friends to assist him in a bizarre experiment. Unhinged, delusional or downright crazy, Sutherland is oddly mesmerising as the ambitious and overzealous Wright. Indeed, as we try to go along with him for the sum of the picture, Sutherland's confident performance manages to stay with you long after the movie is over - far more than those performances offered up by big names like Julia Roberts and Kevin Bacon. If the film ultimately stretches all logic asks too much of its audience, it's worth checking out purely for Sutherland's work; there's a lot going on beneath the surface, and it's gripping.

3. Ace Merrill - Stand By Me

Stand By Me's Ace Merrill is one of those curious characters who has inspired a bizarre amount of attention for what is essentially a low level villain; alas, is there something about Kiefer Sutherland's performance that makes his turn here so memorable, or is it purely a case of, "Look! It's Jack Bauer!" Whatever the reason that Merrill has inspired countless fanfics (you read that right - there are tons of them) or T-shirts, there's no avoiding the fact that Merrill is brilliantly rendered by Kiefer Sutherland; we're supposed to hate this guy, after all, and we do. Perhaps best-described as a "knife-wielding douchebag," the terrifying thing about Merrill is that he transcends the barriers usually found in "bully" characters in kids' movies - Sutherland ensures that Merrill is a genuinely frightening guy and is therefore capable of anything... and that includes stabbing a child with a switchblade for no good reason. With a cigarette dangling between his lips and that bleach blonde hair, he's a great antagonist and one that Sutherland manages to make surprisingly memorable, given his relatively thin amount of screen time.

2. David - The Lost Boys

Kiefer Sutherland's third collaboration with director Joel Schumacher to make our list has him as one of the most iconic vampire villains to have ever graced our screens - as punk idol David in brat pack classic The Lost Boys, Sutherland is charismatic, mesmerising, otherworldly and - above all - really, really creepy. Wherever your opinions lie as to the quality of this movie in general, there's no denying that Sutherland's undead baddie is the highlight of the piece - it's no wonder people remember Kiefer above everyone; he's the best part of the movie. How, exactly, did this then relatively unknown actor manage to infuse his vampire antagonist with such notably edgy cool? Granted, David is certainly a creation of pure evil... but the movie is slightly flawed in the sense that Kiefer manages to make being dead sound like a hell of a lot of fun. Though the movie certainly wasn't designed purely as a vehicle to show off Sutherland's talents as an actor, that's certainly what - looking back upon it now, years later - it feels like. There's something undeniably intoxicating about the way he carries himself on screen.

1. Jack Bauer - 24

Well, what did you expect? Without a doubt, Kiefer Sutherland's finest hour - or hours, as it were - stem from his performance as Agent Jack Bauer on Fox's 24. This was the show that made Sutherland both a household name and a television icon; so much so, in fact, that the character of Jack Bauer had since been brought to the same God-like level as Chuck Norris and has even been gifted with his own array of "facts" ("Jack Bauer once won a game of Connect 4 in 3 moves," to cite a famous example); his influence on pop culture at large is plainly huge. But aside from being infamous for his endless resourcefulness and unrivalled badassery, Bauer has offered Sutherland the chance to stretch his acting chops over the course of the last 13 years. It's not surprising that Sutherland picked up both an Emmy and a Golden Globe for his turn as the Counter Terrorism Agent, given that the actor somehow consistently manages to strike the perfect balance between sympathetic and unbreakable; granted, the show might never have took off in the way that it did without Kiefer Sutherland to keep Jack running.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Bosco - Marmaduke

Given that so much of what makes Kiefer Sutherland so great relates to his distinct voice, we thought it would make sense to shine a light on a voice-reliant role that didn't go quite so smoothy; that of Bosco in Marmaduke, which pretty much showcases what it looks like when an actor phones in a voice performance. The movie itself, based on the dog-themed comic strip of the same name, is downright terrible, and absolutely everybody involved hopefully felt ashamed when they saw the finished product. There's not an ounce of creativity in the whole thing. And that extends to the voice cast, who all seem to have been picked as the "easy" go-to choices for this sort of thing. We need a Hollywood actor who's already voiced the lead character in every second animated film ever made and can be Marmaduke? Owen Wilson! A mexican cat? Get George Lopez, of course. And now we need someone who sounds tough for this bad guy dog character? How about that guy from 24? Kiefer Sutherland? Great! There's a sense, then, that Sutherland simply turned up, read his lines in one take, and got the hell out.

4. Buster McHenry - Renegades

Renegades is odd. Really odd. As a half-baked sort of action thriller, it features a very young Kiefer Sutherland doing his very best to carry an awful movie and failing to succeed in the task. The most curious thing about Renegades, though, is Sutherland's odd little mustache, which has to be one of the most unintentionally funny things ever. Research denotes that Sutherland was just 23-years-old in this movie, and despite sounding like a teenager in the film, he's caught awkwardly between trying to be Mel Gibson in Lethal Weapon and not that. A true relic of its time, Renegades sees Sutherland's cop character, the unfortunately named Buster McHenry, trying to reclaim an Indian spear when a robbery goes wrong and he's caught having to clean up the mess. None of the movie makes sense, so you can't really blame the actor for looking unsure as to whether he's in a comedy or a serious action movie for the entirety of his performance. He also spends an annoying amount of time screaming his way through the events of the film. But maybe it's worth watching just for the bizarre mustache.

3. David Breckinridge - The Sentinel

There is very little to recommend of The Sentinel, least of all the performances, which are bland and interesting. Michael Douglas and Kiefer Sutherland co-star in this "political thriller" about two Secret Service Agents who are drawn into a conspiracy against the one man they've sworn to protect - the President of the United States. Whether on purpose or by accident, Sutherland channels a less experienced Jack Bauer to little effect. Those who suspect that the actor can be frequently forgettable will be happy to know that they can this as a case study. The problem, ultimately, then, is that Sutherland isn't doing anything different here from his Jack Bauer thing - and given that he's playing a government agent, the two make for an easy comparison. But whereas Sutherland seems switched on and enthused whenever he plays Bauer, here there's a whiff of autopilot, almost as if at the audition a producer said to him: "You're basically going to play a Jack Bauer type character. Nothing you haven't done before." It probably does help matters that the dialogue here is awful and everyone sounds ridiculous.

2. Ben Carson - Mirrors

Presumably a film that was pitched on a whim when somebody thought mirrors had the potential to be scary (though to be fair, it is based on superior Korean horror flick Into the Mirror), Kiefer Sutherland spends most of this terrible horror yarn looking about as lost as his character, Ben Carson, an ex-cop who begins to investigate a series of mirror-related deaths in a department store. Clearly not a natural fit for the material at hand (Kiefer Sutherland as the lead in a horror film? Nah!), his performance feels shoddy, underdeveloped and a bit weird. Oddly, he also - at points - seems to randomly lapse into Jack Bauer mode, shouting things like "Dammit!' in the style of everyone's favourite CTU operative. As a result, there's a sense of the muddled about his Ben Carson; one minute he's fine, the next he's shouting his mouth off and going rogue like he's been inspired by an episode of 24. Granted, there's a funny moment where he points his gun at a nun, but it's not enough to save the movie, because we're not sure that it's supposed to be very funny. Kiefer deserved better than Mirrors... and so did we.

1. Dr. Daniel P. Schreber - Dark City

There are many who would be quick to praise Kiefer Sutherland's quirky, purposely idiosyncratic performance in Dark City as a notable achievement for an actor who is often lambasted for playing broody action types over and over again; truth is, admirable as Sutherland's part in the deftly underrated Dark City is, he's totally miscast as Dr. Daniel P. Schreber. It's not just that he doesn't look the part, he doesn't feel natural to it at all - to the point where you wonder why director Alexander Proyas didn't bother to search out for somebody more suitable. As Dr. Schreber, a man who works for the elusive "Strangers" in a dystopian future, Sutherland mostly finds himself shouting things down the end of a telephone to little effect. It's not entirely Sutherland's fault; he does what he can, given how ill-fitted his own acting style is to that of the character he's playing, but the problem is rooted in the casting. It also doesn't help that nobody else in the movie seems sure how to play things, either. Even Jennifer Connelly, who is usually good in everything, is noticeably awful in this. It just doesn't work at all. Like this article? Agree or disagree with our choices here? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.