King Richard Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs

Will Smith turns in one of his finest performances in this riveting sports drama.

King Richard Will Smith
Warner Bros.

Landing in cinemas and on HBO Max this week is one of the year's most buzzed-about dramas - the Will Smith-starring sports biopic King Richard.

Smith, who has kept a relatively low cinematic profile over the last few years, is back with a project sure to remind everyone of his firm acting chops in the dramatic arena - and that, yes, he's still hungry for an Oscar.

Smith is a revelation as Richard Williams, the father of future tennis stars Venus and Serena, in a formulaic but well-executed inspirational sports drama that's guaranteed to score Smith a Best Actor Oscar nomination (and possibly even the win).

Even outside of his terrific performance, though, there's a lot else to enjoy here, namely a top-drawer ensemble cast and slick direction that works through the expected beats with energy and enthusiasm.

It's not the freshest or most unique film you'll see this year, but it delivers the expected goods in mostly gripping fashion.

Whether you're a fan of Smith or the Williams sisters, or simply enjoy a compelling story persuasively told, King Richard has rewards a-plenty to offer.

But first, here's what holds it back from being a true classic of the genre...


Downs...

3. It's A Totally Standard Sports Biopic

King Richard Will Smith
Warner Bros.

The most obvious criticism that can be levelled against King Richard is that it does feel a bit like a "Wikipedia page biopic," plowing through the pivotal beats in its subjects' lives in fairly by-the-numbers fashion.

This is thankfully offset by the clear passion of basically the entire ensemble cast and some rock solid direction, though the film as a whole still can't fully escape feeling like a generic sports movie at times.

Whether you know much about the Williams family's story or not, there's little inspiration or creativity to the way in which it's presented, clinging pretty safely to the genre's stylistic and screenwriting tropes.

But on the flip side, the safety of its framework gives Smith and his co-stars the floor to dominate the screen in pretty much every moment, free of more ambitious filmmaking that might distract from their work.

It's a difficult balance to strike, and while a slightly more adventurous approach wouldn't have hurt, sticking to what works is hardly a fatal flaw here.


2. It Feels A Little Unbalanced

King Richard
Warner Bros.

There's already been a lot of hand-wringing about the decision to center the movie around the Williams sisters' father rather than the sisters themselves.

And while the statuesque portrait of the man absolutely justifies that decision, there are times where audiences are sure to wish the sisters were given a greater focus.

The back-half of the film is certainly more outwardly trained on Venus' (Saniyya Sidney) rise to prominence, though Serena (Demi Singleton) is basically a back-seat passenger for most of the story, her future successes - which easily eclipsed those of her older sister - largely relegated to a closing title card.

Obviously there's only so much that screenwriter Zach Baylin could cram into his script, but the first half might've benefitted from a few more scenes with Venus and Serena as the focal figures, while a more cinematic epilogue could've depicted Serena's later triumphs.


1. The Slightly Overlong Runtime

King Richard Will Smith
Warner Bros.

King Richard isn't a torturous sit by any means, though its 138-minute runtime is a little trying at times, especially in the flabbier first half of the film.

The Williams family's story is clearly an epic one and probably worthy of its own mini-series if we're being honest, though some scenes in the first act in particular do verge on the sluggish side, particularly some of Richard's clashes with local gangs in Compton.

A few nips and tucks would've been welcome overall, though the runtime being a touch over-extended is in no way a deal-breaker.

These issues aside, King Richard gets so much right. Here's why it's absolutely worth watching...


Ups...

7. Will Smith's Superb Performance Makes Him An Oscar Frontrunner

King Richard Will Smith
Warner Bros.

Make no mistake, Will Smith is unquestionably going to receive a Best Actor Oscar nomination for his phenomenal performance as the title character, and there's also a very strong chance he'll take the gong home outright.

This is the sort of Will Smith performance we haven't seen in years - he is 100% committed to the part, and despite his larger-than-life stature as one of the biggest movie stars of all time, he sheds the glitz to comfortably disappear into the role of the sisters' militant father.

It's tough to pick a standout scene because they basically all are: Smith gets a few marquee scenes to do his Oscar reel emoting, but for the most part the actor resists the urge to go big and in turn delivers a surprisingly restrained performance.

Smith ensures to render the man in all of his complexities - a father who clearly cares deeply for his family, but who can also be a source of tremendous frustration at times.

For anyone that's been rooting for Smith to get back to worthy dramatic work, this is a major breath of fresh air, and if he collects a gold statue on Oscar night it'll be thoroughly well-deserved.


6. The Williams Sisters Are Magnetic To Watch

King Richard
Warner Bros.

Though their story sometimes feels secondary to their father's, when the focus shifts to Venus in particular in the second half, it's tough to argue with how compellingly the film brings the sisters to life on screen.

This is largely a credit to Saniyya Sidney and Demi Singleton, who give stellar performances as Venus and Serena, capturing the essence of two of the most famous sportswomen of all time.

As Venus, Sidney is especially excellent playing both a prodigious tennis player and a young girl trying not to get swallowed up in the toxic atmosphere of the tennis circuit - an environment her father is extremely reluctant to expose her to.

Singleton meanwhile conveys the frustration of having to stand in her older sister's shadow brilliantly, and while her part is absolutely the lesser of the two, she shares excellent chemistry with her screen sister.

If the two young actresses continue to pursue careers in Hollywood, they've got incredibly promising futures ahead of them.


5. The Fantastic Tennis Sequences

King Richard
Warner Bros.

Any successful sports movie must find a way to capture the excitement of the sport itself, and King Richard absolutely does that.

Director Reinaldo Marcus Green milks the various training and tennis match sequences for every thrilling drop they're worth, courtesy of some creative shot selections and sharp editing throughout.

Tennis isn't something that's been depicted on screen all that much throughout the history of cinema, but Green's dynamic filmmaking proves how to make even the most straight-forward back-and-forth rally visually compelling.

This is particularly true during the film's climactic tennis bout, which regardless of whether you know the outcome or not, is fantastically presented for maximum gut-wrenching suspense.


4. It's Riveting Whether You're A Tennis Fan Or Not

King Richard
Warner Bros.

Any sports movie that wants a real shot at connecting with the mainstream and even winning Oscars needs to work regardless of your own opinion about the sport.

And King Richard certainly joins the distinguished list of sports films that's tremendously gripping whether you're an avid tennis fan or haven't even watched a single match in your life.

The human interest of the sisters' journey combines with the thrilling cinematic treatment of tennis itself to ensure few will be left unmoved by what is on its own terms just a great story.

This is far from a niche sports film, and while formulaically presented doesn't feel the need to talk down to the audience either, which can be a tricky balance to strike.


3. Aunjanue Ellis & Jon Bernthal Provide Strong Support

King Richard Aunjaune Ellis Jon Bernthal
Warner Bros.

Though Will Smith is rightly garnering the lion's share of the awards buzz for his superb performance, there are two other actors in the movie who really should be courting major awards plaudits themselves.

Firstly there's Aunjanue Ellis, who is simply terrific as Richard's wife Brandy. While it'd be easy for the film to push her to the periphery in favour of her more-famous husband and daughters or even make her a passive wife stereotype, Brandy is well-drawn here as a pivotal piece of the family puzzle.

Her best moments involve dressing Richard down for his flawed decision-making, his ego-centrism, and his over-protectiveness of their daughters. With enough industry support she could easily end up with a Best Supporting Actress Oscar nomination.

And then there's Jon Bernthal, who is cast brilliantly against-type as the sisters' most prominent trainer, Rick Macci.

Macci is a magnanimous and surprisingly funny presence who finds himself increasingly bristling up against Richard when he refuses to take Venus on tour despite her clearly being ready to do so.

Bernthal nails the scarcely-veiled rage at Richard's obstinate behaviour, but also brings a lot of human warmth to the table through his interactions with Venus in particular.

It's not a particularly flashy part, but it is a great performance all the same, and if it picks up enough love following the film's theatrical release, could well lead to Bernthal earning his first Oscar nod in the Best Supporting Actor field.


2. Kris Bowers' Energetic Musical Score

King Richard
Warner Bros.

Another vital part of the package is a killer musical score from Kris Bowers, who offers up a soundscape that's equal parts an homage to classic sports movies and something very much its energetic own.

It's clear that Bowers has taken some overt cues from Jerry Goldsmith's incredibly Rocky score, particularly in the film's later stages, which are totally successful in amplifying the emotion of Venus' climactic match.

Elsewhere Bowers' emotive piano score anchors the film's more affecting dramatic moments perfectly, not overpowering the performances but complimenting them with restraint.

The Best Original Score field is pretty stacked this year with boundary-pushing efforts from Hans Zimmer (Dune) and Johnny Greenwood (Spencer, The Power of the Dog), so while it may not end up making the final five, it's still damn fine work all the same.


1. It's One Of The Year's Most Crowd-Pleasing Dramas

King Richard Will Smith
Warner Bros.

All things considered, King Richard will go down an absolute treat with both Oscar voters and general audiences who haven't had that many truly well-crafted feel-good movies to choose from this past year.

A good old-fashioned crowd-pleasing drama filled with great performances and stylish filmmaking is exactly what many are after right now, and though it's built from the standard parts, it's clearly still a film made great love and care for its subjects.

It's easy to take one look at the trailer and call it Oscar bait, but this film is sure to strike a chord far outside all the chatter about awards.

That the film is likely to connect with such a wide demographic of viewers will however only help its Oscar chances further, particularly for Smith.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.