Leonardo DiCaprio: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

You had my curiosity, but now you have my attention.

It's fair to say that, over the last decades, no actor has been as consistently great as Leonardo DiCaprio. After first breaking through in What's Eating Gilbert Grape, he achieved new heights of stardom thanks to his performance in Titanic, which became the highest-grossing movie of all-time and swept up at the Oscars (although there wasn't even a nomination for Leo). It launched DiCaprio, only in his early-20s at the time, to global fame, with his face adorning the bedroom wall of pretty much every girl of a certain age (and probably a few a bit older) on both sides of the Atlantic. With his pretty boy good looks on display in that, and Romeo + Juliet before it, it was no surprise he captured female hearts, and it would've been easy for him to slip into a comfortable career of romantic roles. Thankfully for us, that's not the path he chose. While he might have had a slight wobble immediately after Titanic came out (in fairness, it must be hard to follow up the (then) biggest movie ever), his career has generally been a string of challenging roles and complex characters, working with great directors such as Quentin Tarantino while becoming this century's muse for Martin Scorsese. His acting has been so fantastic in this time that the fact he hasn't won an Oscar has become a one of the film industry's longest-running jokes. Now it looks like that's going to be put right with The Revenant, it's time to look back on his best roles (and a few rare misses).

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Howard Hughes - The Aviator (2004)

When everyone complains about DiCaprio never winning an Oscar, and the injustice of it all, this is the one that really stands out as a moment when he genuinely could have taken home the little gold statue. It's his most obviously Oscar-worthy role, but thankfully isn't one that veers into Academy baiting, instead offering a great portrayal of Howard Hughes, focusing on his aviation and his attempts to make movies. DiCaprio successfully charts his turn from a billionaire into something of a madman, yet manages to retain an air of sympathy that allows you to continue rooting for him. He brilliantly captures Hughes' obsessive-compulsive natures, as well as successfully conveying the fear, anger, and excitement that make up the different facets of the character. The film may have been a bit long, but his performance never drops.

4. Arnie Grape - What's Eating Gilbert Grape (1993)

The role that first started to get a young Leo noticed, and earn him his first Oscar nomination, was that of Arnie Grape, the younger brother of Johnny Depp's titular Gilbert in this sweet 1993 film. Depp was the bigger name at the time, and while he's good in the movie it's DiCaprio who completely steals the show. Arnie is developmentally disabled, and DiCaprio fully captures that in a range of tics and quirks, but also makes sure to give the character a real innocent charm - whether it's climbing the water tower, fighting with his brother, or not fully understanding what is going on around him - which provides the movie with its considerable heart.

3. Calvin Candie - Django Unchained (2012)

As mentioned, DiCaprio has been great for a long time, but the last five years or so, starting from Shutter Island and the simply magnificent Inception (which didn't make the cut because, while an amazing film, is not as reliant on his performance) has been a pretty incredible run of form (with one notable slip, but more on that later). Coming in the middle of this run is his performance as Calvin Candie, the despicable slave owner in Quentin Tarantino's Django Unchained. The film really picks up when we get to his ranch - Candyland - and you truly start to realise that while Candie is a charming man, he's also an immensely cruel one. He absolutely dominates the movie from there on, and is utterly captivating every moment he's on screen (it's no real surprise the film takes a dive in the final half hour or so, once he's out of the picture). He delivers the line of the entire movie, and even cut his hand during a scene and continued on without a second thought. Again, going back to films that could have won him an Oscar, the Best Supporting Actor should've been his for this role, and yet he wasn't even nominated.

2. Jordan Belfort - The Wolf Of Wall Street (2013)

Jordan Belfort is an absolutely disgusting man, showcasing the worst of corporate America's greed. DiCaprio captures that perfectly, but yet also manages to make him utterly hilarious in his and Scorsese's most recent collaboration, which is their best to-date. The Wolf of Wall St is three-hours long, but at no point does it start to drag or feel even close to that running time. The reason for that is DiCaprio. While the audience knows they're supposed to hate Belfort, DiCaprio just cuts loose and absolutely goes for it, never letting up in his performance while giving a masterclass in physical comedy. He's arrogant, he's smart, he's a complete bastard, but he's earning himself and others a lot of money and he is absolutely convinced that it is his God-given right to do that. In Titantic he yelled that he was the King of the World; in The Wolf of Wall Street, he acts like it.

1. Hugh Glass - The Revenant (2015)

It was getting to the point where fans were wondering what DiCaprio had to do to get himself an Oscar: he'd gone full villain, he'd played an outrageous real life figure and several historical ones, and he'd played a mentally handicapped child. Aside from a trans character, there weren't many cliches left to plunder... But the actor had one final string to his bow: disappearing so far into method that Daniel Day Lewis might have been concerned for his well-being. He might have drawn the line at actually being mauled by a bear, but for The Revenant, DiCaprio made some serious sacrifices, staying in character no matter what and chowing down on raw bison liver despite being a vegetarian. This is no empty method-stacked performance however: DiCaprio's Glass is raw and devastating, cut from the Frontier landscape perfectly like a walking shredded nerve. It's an incredibly compelling performance and one that should legitimately earn him the Oscar win he's missed out on so narrowly for years.

5 That Sucked...

5. Amsterdam Vallon - Gangs Of New York (2002)

This film is important because it was the very first of the Scorsese/DiCaprio partnership, one that in the last decade has delivered some incredible work from the pair as the actor becomes the director's 'new De Niro'. Unfortunately, that's the best you can say about it, because it's also the worst collaboration between the two. DiCaprio's Amsterdam Vallon is the lead protagonist of the film, but while the actor would obviously get it right later under Scorsese, his performance feels at times like he's trying too hard to show he has the chops to work with Scorsese, rather than simply doing it, and he never really feels like the film's lead. Of course, that comes to the other problem. He's acting across from Daniel Day-Bloody-Lewis! Not many could contend with such a cinematic giant giving a mammoth performance, so it's not really a discredit to Leo that he fails to shine, but it's still one of his weaker performances, especially compared to what would come after with Scorsese.

4. Kid - The Quick And The Dead (1995)

Starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Russell Crowe before they achieved worldwide fame, and Sharon Stone after Basic Instinct, The Quick And The Dead is directed by Sam Raimi years before he brought Spider-Man to the big screen, and features a screenplay worked on Joss Whedon before he was recognised as the genius he is today. And, well, it just sort of exists, there to be ignored and forgotten about. It's a weird mix of talent that didn't work, and while it's not the worst thing that DiCaprio's done, it's not a performance that people are going to remember, simply coasting by on his good looks and some skills with a pistol.

3. J. Edgar Hoover - J. Edger (2011)

The one where Leonardo DiCaprio gets made up to look older and fatter, gets a little big angry at times, and offers pretty much nothing else. Clint Eastwood's biopic of the FBI founder simply meanders through the greatest hits of his life, and while DiCaprio looks impressive, he never really gets into the role or offers any sort of great insight into the character. It instead feels like a 'ok, this happened, now make him look older and do this, now make him look even older and do this'. It's a lacking performance in a film that is generally lacking, although in the hands of a different director you feel this could've turned into something much more.

2. King Louie XIV/Philippe - The Man In The Iron Mask (1998)

DiCaprio's first role after Titanic was actually playing two people, taking on the dual role of the dastardly King Louie XIV and his more heroic twin brother Philippe. Based on the works of Alexandre Dumas, it takes stories of the musketeers and churns them out into whatever this is. There's an impressive cast, with the likes of Jeremy Irons, Gerard Depardieu, and John Malkovich playing musketeers, but an air of them just phoning it in. Ironically, DiCaprio has two roles in the movie, but his presence is hardly felt at all throughout it, although it does have the weird trivia of him winning the Razzie for Worst Screen Couple as the twins.

1. Richard - The Beach (2000)

The peak of his post-Titanic slump is this less-than-successful adaptation of Alex Garland's novel, about an American who goes backpacking in Thailand. Ewan McGregor was the initial choice for the role, but when he stepped out it was DiCaprio who stepped in and, well, he probably wishes he hadn't. Feeling like it's just trying to capitalise on his fame at this point, he spends a lot of the film with his shirt off and trying to convey angst by just being a bit shouty, unfocused, and generally a bit of a mess. Given the talent involved in this film - it ranks as one of Danny Boyle's worst as well - it should have worked a lot better, but both direction and acting failed this one, with DiCaprio nominated for a Razzie Award for Worst Actor. Still, at least this was the end of pretty boy DiCaprio. Oh, he's still a beautiful man, but it was the last of those post-Titanic roles that seemed a bit too obvious a cash-in, and a turn to taking on far more serious and challenging roles.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.