Logan: 10 Biggest Questions It Leaves Unanswered

The X-Men universe is a tangled web.

Logan Hugh Jackman
Fox

Like almost any great movie, Logan leaves viewers with a ton to digest and talk about as the credits roll, and like just about every superhero movie these days, it also asks almost as many questions as it provides answers.

Logan is a towering achievement of a film that does a fantastic job wrapping up Hugh Jackman's time as the title character, but it also leaves some lingering plot threads up in the air, which fans are sure to be debating for the foreseeable future.

Consider further that as Logan basically feels like a glorified standalone movie, it's very unlikely any of these questions will get straight-up, canonical answers, so fans will have to settle for speculation and the most likely outcome.


10. Where Did Logan Get The Adamantium Bullet?

Logan Hugh Jackman
Fox

The Question: Early on, we find out Logan is in possession of an adamantium bullet which he keeps around in case he ever wants to kill himself, and it ends up being used to kill X-24 at the end of the movie, but where did he actually get it from?

The Likely Answer: Considering adamantium is extremely rare and not just anyone can forge a bullet out of it, it's safe to assume that Logan probably swiped it from a stash at Alkali Lake some time prior.

It's not hugely important to the central narrative for the audience to have an answer to this, but it's still totally interesting to consider how Logan got hold of it.


9. Who Exactly Was Zander Rice's Father?

Logan Trailer Richard E. Grant
20th Century Fox

The Question: In the film's climax, Zander Rice mentions that his father was part of the original Weapon X program, and Logan says that he probably killed him. If we assume that this is referring to the Wolverine cameo from X-Men: Apocalypse (not that it necessarily is), there's little indication of who, exactly, Rice's father is. Was he just a generic grunt or what?

The Likely Answer: You need to defer to the comics for the most probable answer here: Zander Rice's father was Dale Rice, who worked on Weapon X and was killed when Wolverine managed to escape his imprisonment. This heavily informs Zander's choice to become a doctor and attempt to recreate Weapon X.

There's not really any reason for the movie to give Zander a different father, but at the same time, it's never explicitly stated that the comic is gospel here (especially as this is a very, very loose adaptation of Old Man Logan).


8. Which X-Men Died In The West Chester Incident?

Logan Trailer Professor X
20th Century Fox

The Question: During the hotel escape, a radio bulletin mentions an incident in West Chester the previous year that injured 600 people and killed 7 of the X-Men. It's later implied this was caused by Charles having a seizure, but which members of the X-Men did he in fact kill?

The Likely Answer: It could really be any of them, but for it to have the most emotional impact, you've got to believe it was at least a few of the top-tier mutants such as Jean Grey, Cyclops and Storm, who obviously spend a lot of time at the X-Mansion.

Ultimately they're all dead now either way, but the clear suggestion is that Charles' episode took the lives of a number of people very dear to him.


7. Who Are The Other Child Experiments?

Logan Super Bowl spot trailer kids
20th Century Fox

The Question: It's revealed early on that Laura isn't the only child born and bred for Transigen's mutant army, and that there are numerous other children who managed to escape the facility. Who are they, exactly?

The Likely Answer: The only one of the children actually given a name is Rictor, who in the comics was a member of the New Mutants, while the rest appear to be completely new concoctions for the film, such as a girl with ice breath, a boy with the ability to harness electricity, and another girl with Earth-bending powers.

Unfortunately this will probably be all she wrote as far as these new creations are concerned, as there's little chance they'll actually appear in the upcoming New Mutants movie, which will surely select more famous faces to fill out its cast.


6. How Old Is X-24?

Logan Claws
Fox

The Question: It's stated that the X-24 Wolverine clone who attacks Logan was the follow-up to X-23, but how old exactly is the "soulless" entity?

The Likely Answer: This one's a bit of a head-scratcher because X-24 resembles Logan in his prime (about 30 years of age), but it's not possible for X-24 to be 30 years old because Laura, its predecessor, is only 11 years old.

However, Transigen nurse Gabriella's video does briefly show several limbs being grown in jars, so it's most likely that X-24 is literally a Frankenstein creation of sorts, sewn together from body parts independently grown over the last decade and combined into this savage whole.


5. Will Laura Get Adamantium Poisoning In The Future?

Logan Trailer Laura
20th Century Fox

The Question: Considering that Logan is stricken with adamantium poisoning after living for almost 200 years, is this a fate that also awaits Laura in the far future?

The Likely Answer: Like the comics, it's presumed that only Laura's hands and feet are infused with adamantium, and the rest of her body is free of the toxic metal.

While it's still totally possible that the little metal in her could lead to issues and even the same condition as Logan, the fact she has such a comparatively small amount is probably supposed to signal that she'll be OK.


4. How Does Mister Sinister Fit In?

X Men Apocalypse Essex Corp
Fox

The Question: Mister Sinister is first hinted at in the 1983-set post-credits scene of X-Men: Apocalypse, and the character was originally supposed to be introduced in Logan before James Mangold opted against it to retain the film's relatively grounded tone. If it's assumed that he's still in the picture somehow, how does he fit into this movie?

The Likely Answer: It's definitely weird that Nathaniel Essex exists in Apocalypse's 1983 and would potentially still be lingering around almost 50 years later in 2029 without anyone cutting him down, but the easy answer is that Essex is covertly bankrolling Transigen and is the new big bad in the X-Men universe.

Don't expect many (if any) references to this movie when he eventually does appear on-screen, but he's likely going to be the convenient puppet-master behind it all.


3. Why Will The Kids Suddenly Be Safe In Canada?

Logan Trailer Wolverine Laura
20th Century Fox

The Question: A big point is made about the child experiments getting across the border to Canada, where they'll suddenly be safe from Transigen's reach, but how?

The Likely Answer: The real answer is probably that Mangold had to find a way to draw a narrative line between the kids and Transigen, and making it a geographical one was just the easiest way to do it.

In terms of the story's own logic, perhaps Transigen has no legal means to operate in Canada, though it's a pretty big stretch to believe they wouldn't just do it in secret anyway.

This ends up lampshaded somewhat at the end, however, if you consider that everyone who knew where the kids were headed is now dead. So, that helps.


2. Which Timeline Is The Movie Actually In?

X-Men: Days Of Future Past Cyclops Wolverine Jean Grey
20th Century Fox

The Question: The X-Men franchise's approach to maintaining continuity is puzzling to say the least, so where the Hell does this movie even slot in?

The Likely Answer: You can save yourself a lot of headaches if you treat Logan as a mostly standalone movie that just so happens to cherry-pick series elements it wants to (such as mentioning the Statue of Liberty incident and implying Zander Rice's dad was killed in X-Men: Apocalypse).

To answer the question, though, James Mangold has specifically mentioned Logan being a successor to Days of Future Past in interviews, so to that token the film is basically the first to take place after the timeline was altered in that movie.

Logan's placement does make Days of Future Past feel a little less consequential overall (all that sacrifice, only for Xavier to kill a bunch of the X-Men years later), but considering the absolutely ridiculous grasp on continuity the series has, Logan actually slots in fairly neatly for the most part.


1. Why Didn't The Kids Help Logan Fight X-24?

Logan Trailer
20th Century Fox

The Question: Why did the child experiments waste so much time stylishly killing Donald Pierce when they could've offered some much-needed assistance to Logan as he fought and died against X-24?

The Likely Answer: Basically "because reasons", because if everything in a movie adhered to what people should do then most movies wouldn't be very entertaining.

You can also argue that it serves a symbolic purpose of sorts, that Logan's final battle ends up essentially being against himself. And of course, it's also because Logan battling a clone of himself is way more awesome and interesting than Logan and a bunch of mutant kids easily overpowering the Terminator-like creation.

Got any other nagging Logan questions? Shout them out in the comments!


In this post: 
Logan
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.