Logan Lucky Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs

Another winner from Soderbergh.

Logan Lucky
FilmNation

Logan Lucky is in cinemas now, the first film from master director Steven Soderbergh since 2013's widely-praised Behind the Candelabra, after which he entered semi-retirement from movies before thankfully, finally emerging last year.

His latest effort has been warmly received by critics as yet another sharply-helmed, hilarious and terrifically-acted heist caper from the director, one that's sure to be regarded as a cult classic in the coming years, even though it unfortunately bombed at the box office.

A great film bombing with audiences is bad enough, but it's especially disheartening as the film was a mid-budget experiment of sorts, with Soderbergh attempting to distribute it outside of conventional Hollywood means, effectively cutting out the middle-man. Sadly, his bold effort has seemingly failed.

Still, if you're craving something other than the glut of CGI-heavy blockbusters in cinemas right now, do yourself and Soderbergh a favour by throwing this immensely charming movie a couple of your hard-earned bucks...

Downs...

3. Seth MacFarlane Is Totally Miscast

Logan Lucky Adam Driver Seth Macfarlane
FilmNation

As fantastically cast as the movie generally is, Soderbergh makes one misstep by casting Family Guy's Seth MacFarlane to play Max Chilblain, a douchey British businessman who gives the Logan brothers some trouble throughout the film.

MacFarlane, with a giant, presumably fake mustache and over-the-top accent, plays the part like one of his cartoon characters, and as such sticks out as the movie's single caricature, whereas the rest of the cast slinks into their roles incredibly well.

MacFarlane sticks out every second he's on screen, and while it's not strictly a terrible performance, Soderbergh probably should've cast someone else in the part.


2. The Third Act Drags A Little

Logan Lucky Hilary Swank
FilmNation

At 118 minutes in length, the film ends up running just a little too long in the final stretch. After a superbly entertaining introductory first act and a terrific second act that covers the central heist, act three over-extends itself and drags out its conclusion far more than is necessary.

It certainly doesn't sink the film, but the script and editing could absolutely be tightened up somewhat in the final half-hour, such that it doesn't grind to a halt quite so dramatically.

Trimming 10-or-so minutes off the back end would make the overall result feel so much tighter and decidedly less indulgent.


1. The Heist Is Undeniably Contrived

Logan Lucky Adam Driver Channing Tatum Daniel Craig
FilmNation

Granted, heist films are typically quite contrived, and Soderbergh's no stranger to over-the-top capers with his work on the Ocean's movies, but still, the central heist here is propelled forward by confidence just a little too much.

There are a couple of beats central to the heist that rely far too much on dumb luck, and while the overall sequence is undeniably a blast to watch, it is undermined slightly by how much one's disbelief must be suspended.

Again, though, it's a caper and doesn't need to be totally realistic, but a few overly convenient moments do upset the balance a little too much.

Still, Logan Lucky is for the most part a thoroughly entertaining film, so here's everything Soderbergh got right...


Ups...

6. Daniel Craig Gives His Best Performance In Years

Logan Lucky Adam Driver Channing Tatum Daniel Craig
FilmNation

This probably won't be too surprising to anyone who watched the movie's trailers, but yes, Daniel Craig's performance as Joe Bang, an explosives expert who joins the Logans' heist, is the film's easy highlight.

Craig hasn't exactly given many memorable recent performances outside of his work as James Bond, so it's incredibly refreshing to see him taking such a radical divergence from his usual fare.

With his bleach-blonde hair, deep southern drawl and array of prison tattoos, Craig is clearly having an absolute blast here, and above all else, it's proof he really needs to do more comedy roles in the future.

If he landed a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination next year for this riotous performance, it would be thoroughly well-deserved.


5. It's Got An Incredible Game Of Thrones Joke

Logan Lucky Dwight Yoakam Daniel Craig
FilmNation

The film has a ton of fantastic gags, but there's none better than an incredibly funny extended joke involving Game of Thrones, and the absurd length of time it's taken author George R.R. Martin to finish the novel series off.

Spoiling the gag would be criminal, but considering how many movies and TV shows make ham-fisted references to HBO's pop-culture phenomenon, it's refreshing to see a film make a nod that actually feels organic and, best of all, is actually hilarious to boot.

Plus, one can sense that the gag has a little personal truth in it from writer "Rebecca Blunt", who is widely expected to be Soderbergh under a pen name, considering Blunt's lack of other credits or online presence.


4. Steven Soderbergh Continues To Prove His Mastery

Steven Soderbergh Side Effects
Open Road

What a joy it is to see Steven Soderbergh return from his short-lived "retirement" from filmmaking, and with Logan Lucky he continues to prove that he's one of Hollywood's most consistently reliable mid-budget directors.

Every frame has Soderbergh's auteur stamp all over it, enhanced by the fact that he not only served as director, but also cinematographer and editor, not to mention most likely wrote the script. All of these elements work in terrific concert and show an artist in full control of their project, as was always his intention with his radical distribution model.

It's simply great to see Soderbergh still putting out great movies like this, and with his next film also already wrapped, it seems like his love for the rigours of filmmaking may well have returned.


3. It's Surprisingly Affecting

Logan Lucky Channing Tatum
FilmNation

Probably the most unexpected thing about the entire movie is its subtle yet effective emotional component. Numerous scenes explore Jimmy Logan's (Channing Tatum) relationship with his young daughter, Sadie, and there's a third-act pay-off to these scenes that sneaks up on viewers.

It certainly doesn't hurt that young actress Farrah Mackenzie is absolutely fantastic in the role of Sadie and has terrific chemistry with Tatum, while Soderbergh chooses to under-play the scene in question, rather than go the sappy and saccharine route.

Considering this is at its core a hillbilly heist movie, you'd be forgiven for being shocked at the film having any sort of emotional component whatsoever, let alone possibly wringing a tear or two from you.


2. The Superb Ensemble Cast

Logan Lucky Daniel Craig
FilmNation

Like the majority of Soderbergh's movies, he's assembled an absolutely fantastic supporting cast, and the aforementioned Seth MacFarlane issue aside, he exploits them perfectly.

Tatum and Adam Driver are the superbly game leads and Daniel Craig steals every scene he's in, while the likes of Riley Keough, Katie Holmes, Katherine Waterston, Dwight Yoakam, Sebastian Stan and Hilary Swank bring plenty of flavour to the table.

It's a testament to Soderbergh's pedigree as a filmmaker that a number of these actors have mere minutes of screen time each, especially Waterston, Stan and Swank, but each makes the most of their material, and help the film sustain through even its slacker moments later on.


1. The Tone Is Perfect

Logan Lucky Daniel Craig Adam Driver Channing Tatum
FilmNation

Soderbergh is pretty much a master of tone at this point, something he re-affirms here with a film that has plenty of fun with its hillbilly heist premise, but also important doesn't dehumanise or mock its subjects in a mean-spirited way.

It's an extremely tough balance to strike, but Soderbergh pulls it off with his usual delicacy, keeping things light for the most part and, on occasion, striking with unexpected emotional resonance.

While many writers and directors struggle to make their films feel fully-formed and on an even tonal keen, Soderbergh makes it look so damn easy every time, and that's one of the many reasons why he's such a keenly regarded filmmaker.

What did you think of Logan Lucky? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.