Masters of the Universe Reboot: 5 Mistakes To Avoid
Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it...
With the recent announcement that Sony Pictures are in talks with Jon Chu to direct a new, live action, adaptation of the popular 80s property Masters of the Universe; memories of the last live action adaptation come readily to mind. In 1987, Canon Pictures brought Masters of the Universe to the big screen starring Dolph Lundgren and Frank Langella in the roles of He-Man and Skeletor respectively. That film, rife with problems both on screen and behind the scenes was a critical and fan flop and may be the reason this property hasn't seen the light of day in a feature film reboot---even after the blockbuster success of Transformers. Indeed, an entire article could be devoted to everything the 1987 film got wrong---which is basically everything. After 25 years, however, these things are all common knowledge to fans of the series. Therefore, in the grand tradition of "those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it" we will revisit 5 of the biggest, most glaring mistakes made by this film that a Masters of the Universe Reboot must avoid.
5. Pick a Canon
The 1987 film as well as the Filmation animated series are based on the Mattel toy line, Masters of the Universe. The action figures, as originally released, included small comic books that told the story of He-Man and his foes, establishing the battle of good and evil on the planet Eternia; establishing the "first" canon of He-Man. In this canon, He-Man was a barbarian warrior. Similar to Conan he fought against Skeletor's forces as the most powerful man in the Universe. In adapting the property for film and television respectively, both the film and the series established their own "second" and "third" Canon realities from a common backdrop. The series gave us a lot of things that would be adapted by the toy line---each cashing in the the success of the other. The film, in turn, based its plot on the canon of the original toy line and accompanying comics, choosing to ignore the animated series---while still cashing in on the series' popularity. The result was an audience familiar with a toy line, and an animated series---viewing a film adaptation that contained parts of both and yet claimed neither. This would be okay if the confusion were explained---unfortunately it wasn't and loyal fans were left confused about some things, downright angry about elements of the plot that were contrived or seemed to have no recognizable basis in He-Man lore; as well as disappointed about omissions of their favorite elements from other mediums. We know how this affected the 1987 film; which means we know how to avoid it. Given the recent popularity of animated properties from the 80s as live action films---fans may, for the first time, get to see the cartoon they grew up with brought to life. So long as Sony Pictures cashes in on the nostalgia factor that made Transformers a success and got G.I. Joe off the ground.
4. Prince Adam
The idea of ordinary people overcoming overwhelming odds, and finding inner strength in the face of overwhelming adversity is a classic story telling device. In the realm of fantasy and science fiction, that inner strength is often given its own identity. The formula is tried and true---how many of our favorite super heroes have alter egos that are ordinary humans? In adapting the Mattel toy line, Filmation brought with it the idea that a "normal" being would be endowed with the power and responsibility of the most powerful man in the universe through the auspices of a magical sword---thus, Prince Adam was born. In appearance, he looked exactly the same as He-Man aside from his outfit and his voice---something that the 2002 revival of the animated series was sure to fix. In character he was everything He-Man wasn't. He was lazy, irresponsible and although he wasn't a brat, he was certainly privileged and never had to fight for anything in his life. Adam is the last person anyone would expect to be He-Man---and so of course he was He-Man's alter ego.
Dolph Lundgren---known at the time for his role as Ivan Drago in Rocky IV---brought He-Man to life. He did not bring Prince Adam with him. In fact, the first live action adaptation of He-Man had no mention of King Randor, Queen Marlena or the royal family of which Adam was a part. This robbed fans of one of the greatest moments of the animated series and one that many were eager to see on screen---the transition of Adam to He-Man. Fans, including this writer, felt robbed at the omission of this element of the He-Man mythology. A successful He-Man reboot, cashing in on the nostalgia of the past absolutely must include the Prince Adam character and his transition to He-Man.
3. Eternia
One of the biggest problems with Masters of the Universe '87, was the fact that the major plot took place on Earth. It wasn't the idea, or even the execution of this idea that was the problem---it was simply the fact that He-Man takes place on Eternia. Portals to other places have long been a part of the He-Man story---the animated series even visited Earth in the He-Man and She-Ra Christmas Special and Queen Marlena was established as an astronaut transported from Earth to Eternia---so the connection to Earth isn't problematic. What is problematic is the fact that the core struggle of Masters of the Universe is the battle for control of Castle Greyskull between He-Man and Skeletor---on Eternia. In the 1987 feature film, this struggle is minimized both by the fact that at the film's opening Skeletor already has control and the fact that instead of fighting for Greyskull on home soil, they fight on Earth. This isn't to say that a reboot couldn't take place on Earth or even reference the Earth connections listed above. The fact is that in Masters '87, the first act was devoted to getting the team to Earth as quickly as possible and then the rest of the film is weighed down by gags that capitalize on the alien nature of things. Basically, it wasn't what fans wanted, it was used as an unnecessary plot device, and it cheapened the story. If there is one thing we've learned from screen adaptations in the last ten years, it's that the story has to be good or else the fans won't support it---remember Hulk? Yeah, I wish I could forget it too.
2. Don't Reinvent the Wheel
Perhaps the biggest thing that Masters '87 failed at was that it had all the elements of a great He-Man story in place and then bungled them so badly that it was almost unrecognizable. The plot alone is brilliant. Skeletor has finally taken Castle Greyskull, the Sorceress is held captive and Eternia is in a state of war as He-Man and his Masters of the Universe have formed a rebellion to recapture Greyskull and defeat Skeletor. YES! That is everything He-Man should be! So what went wrong? Well, a lot of what went wrong are the previous things on this list. Moving the action, and the champion of this rebellion to another planet is a silly thing to do. Ignoring the things that made the animated series successful while trying to cash in on the success of the same series is ridiculous. The film sought to tell an original story in an established world. That's fine in and of itself, except that the filmmakers got it all wrong. Chiefly this was in the source of Greyskull and the Sorceress's power being the "Eye of Galaxy." Greyskull's power was always locked away, known only to the Sorceress and stored in the Castle by the Guardians of Greyskull. This "Eye of the Galaxy" reinvents not only key elements of the established world, but it also changes the origins of He-Man himself. There's no need to reinvent the wheel. In this case, as in many others, it only served to confuse the audience. A successful reboot has plenty of source material to draw on, and would have no reason to try and retcon, or otherwise reintroduce established elements or characters with changes.
1. Don't Replace and/or Omit Characters
In 1987, the character of Orko was difficult to put on screen. He was largely a phantom, with no face, and hovering in mid air like a ghost. Still, so was Slimer in Ghostbusters and he was presented onscreen so this isn't an excuse. Masters '87 thought it was, however, and so we got Billy Barty in the role of Gwildor. He was literally put in to replace Orko---though it seemed to many viewers he was there only to explain the plot device of the Cosmic Key.
Gwildor was silly, as Orko was. He was small in stature as Orko was. He was comic relief, as Orko was. Gwildor's function as a character, his portrayal by Billy Barty or even his introduction into this film isn't what is in debate here. The fact that he replaced another character---one that was beloved by fans---is the problem. The filmmaker's openly stated this as fact and it has long been one of the major fan criticisms of this film.
From Skeletor's Rogues Gallery, Blade was in place as a vehicle to replace Trap Jaw, providing a mercenary, out for himself demeanor---Trap Jaw was only loyal to Skeletor because it suited him and sought to overthrow him more than once. Trap Jaw was also the master of metal, bladed weapons, usually affixing them to his arm and added a steel jaw to often bite the blades from enemy weapons. There is again no excuse to not have utilized Trap Jaw properly---except that it was perhaps another cost cutting measure used by this studio to get the film produced and save their studio. The fact that Canon Pictures didn't last long after this film's production should be a pretty good indicator of how well this worked. Orko, Cringer/Battlecat, Randor, Marlena, Cyclops, Stratos, Ram Man, Meka Nek and Mer-Man are all Characters that were omitted from the film that deserved to be utilized. Not all of them were replaced in the same manner as Orko and Trap Jaw---at least not as obviously---but were instead either replaced with new characters or left out completely. Any reboot of Masters of the Universe that hopes to succeed must include characters we grew up watching and it must be faithful to their origins and personalities. Sony Pictures has a lot to live up to with a Masters of the Universe film. Let's hope that Jon Chu is up to the challenge. He is, after all, helming the sequel for G.I. Joe---though, I have to admit, I'd prefer to reserve judgement on his ability to handle an 80s animated series adaptation until after I've seen what he can do in that arena. For now, I'm happy to know that there is still life in Greyskull and that Michael Bay is nowhere near it. Have an opinion? Sound off in the comments below.