Matt Damon: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Jason Bourne - The Bourne Franchise
The Bourne Identity came out of nowhere and made it clear that Damon, previously tethered almost exclusively to dramatic and comedic roles, could also excel as an action star par excellence. Girded by Doug Liman's sturdy direction, the movie was a smash hit, and made it clear that audiences were prepared to accept the actor in an unconventional role. When Paul Greengrass got his hands on the franchise in 2004, he transformed it into a visceral, well-oiled machine with The Bourne Supremacy, upping the violence and impact, and therefore pushing the physicality of Damon's performance considerably. The result was high critical acclaim. The best of the bunch, however, was saved for last; The Bourne Ultimatum saw Greengrass and Damon deliver easily one of the best films of 2007, a savagely intelligent, extraordinary action flick that gave Damon easily the most scintillating set-pieces of the series, and also the strongest characterisation. This is a rare blockbuster franchise that managed to tantalise both the mind and the adrenal gland.
4. Mark Whitacre - The Informant!
Damon re-teamed with his frequent collaborator Steven Soderbergh for 2009's The Imformant! Though not one of Damon's biggest hits, it does feature one of his most nuanced and committed performances, playing corporate whistle-blower Mark Whitacre. Based on a true story, the role required Damon to gain between 20 and 30 pounds to more closely resemble the doughy protagonist, though this is not merely a gimmicky turn for the actor; Damon has such a strong grasp on the tone Soderbergh is shooting for that he couldn't fail. The film was divisive because of its oddly comic, idiosyncratic tone, but Damon perfectly interprets it, delivering a performance that represents Whitacre as a hilariously downtrodden, desperate sad sack thrown into an impossible situation and simply clawing to get out. Though Damon was nominated for a Golden Globe, he certainly should have had more attention on the awards circuit that year.
3. Colin Sullivan - The Departed
Matt Damon is a natural for playing a good guy, so it's rare that he ever takes the villain role, though as State Police Officer Colin Sullivan, he totally knocked it out of the park in Martin Scorsese's Best Picture-winning crime drama. Sullivan is a corrupt cop trying to help his crime boss pal Frank Costello (Jack Nicholson) smoke a rat out of his crew, using his considerable resources to do so. The result is a brilliantly sniveling performance from Damon, one which sees the actor at easily his most unlikable, as the net draws ever-closer on undercover cop Billy Costigan (Leonardo DiCaprio). In a film packed with brilliant performances, Damon is certainly one of the stand-outs, his greatest moment being when Costigan takes him hostage and threatens to kill him, resulting in him breaking down into a pathetic, sobbing mess, moments before...well, those who've seen it know what's coming...And though the ending was changed from the original climax in Infernal Affairs, Damon shoots it through perfectly (pun intended).
2. Scott Thorson - Behind The Candelabra
It goes without saying that had Behind the Candelabra been released theatrically in the US before its HBO TV premiere, it would certainly be nominated for numerous Academy Awards next year, but due to the Academy's archaic rules, Michael Douglas and Matt Damon may have to settle for Golden Globes and/or Emmys. While Douglas obviously takes the lion's share of the praise for his volcanic, effervescent performance as Liberace, the film wouldn't be much about anything without Damon's staggering supporting turn as Lee's live-in-lover Scott Thorson. Though Damon is noticeably about double the age of the real Thorson when our story begins, it's easy to forget this once the story gets going. Damon is fascinating to watch as the initially shy young man who soon enough becomes Liberace's assertive lover, before becoming embroiled in flagrant drug use and plastic surgery addiction. Fully committed to a challenging role, this is easily one of Damon's best...
1. Will Hunting - Good Will Hunting
But not his best, a distinction that goes to his central performance in Good Will Hunting, one which saw him receive an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor at the mere age of 27, making him one of the youngest nominees in history. In addition to this, Damon also won an Oscar with Ben Affleck for writing the movie, cementing the versatility of his talents. Still, in terms of the performance, Damon's turn as the underachieving genius with a photographic memory is stunning to behold, as he tries to allow his better nature to rise above his personal issues. It might not be as action-packed as Bourne or as funny as The Informant!, but it's certainly the most authentic and true-to-life work, delivering an affecting character study of an unconventional yet extremely likable character. The film would go on to be nominated for 9 Oscars, winning one for Damon and Affleck, and also Best Supporting Actor for Robin Williams. And now, click "Next" to see 5 performances that sucked...
...And 5 That Sucked
5. Cale Tucker - Titan A.E.
Titan A.E. may have been a box office bomb and viewed indifferently by critics, but in effect, it's really not all that bad. Damon provides the voice for protagonist Cale Tucker, a 19-year-old man who ends up separated from his father just as Earth is destroyed by an alien species called the Drej. The rest of the movie is his effort to avenge Earth and his father by taking the aliens down once and for all. The problem, though, is that Damon doesn't really have the lively, animated voice that you need for a cartoon. Don't get me wrong, the guy is superb in live-action, but animation requires actors who can heighten and exaggerate their usual personality a little, something that Damon categorically fails to do here, and as is also noticeable in his other animated performances (notably Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron and Happy Feet 2).
4. Benjamin Mee - We Bought a Zoo
Cameron Crowe was so Hell-bent on getting Damon to star in his movie that he sent him a CD of songs he'd written and a copy of the classic movie Local Hero along with the script in an effort to convince him. It evidently worked, yet the actor doesn't get to be much more than a cog in a machine in this blandly inoffensive, schmaltzy offering from the director. Damon is far from terrible in it, but the down-the-line script just gives him absolutely nothing to do. Given that this performance (and the film entire) had been courted for awards in the lead-up to its release, it was very dispiriting indeed to see Damon doing nothing more than going through the motions, because the script didn't really allow him anything more. Though hardly offensively awful, it's just a massively missed opportunity to tell a fascinating true story.
3. Gerry - Gerry
Easily Gus Van Sant's weakest and most divisive collaboration with Damon, Gerry revolves around two characters, both called Gerry (played by Damon and Casey Affleck), who end up getting lost in the desert and spend the rest of the movie wandering around and talking, ahead of a violent climax. Though the film might click for those who can tolerate, even enjoy Van Sant's methodical, minimalist approach, it invites many of the same criticisms as his later movie Elephant, that it's needlessly meandering, tedious and even pretentious. Damon and Affleck really aren't given much at all to work with, meaning that they, like their characters, are simply left wandering in the wilderness. While one can appreciate that the actors likely took the role because of its experimental nature, it probably served them as a work-out more than it did most audiences an entertaining time at the movies. Even the most coveting director has to give us something, but here, Van Sant denies his actors any agency at all.
2. Willhelm - The Brothers Grimm
Terry Gilliam's mess of a film, The Brothers Grimm, stars Damon as one half of the titular sibling pair, Wilhelm, in a tale that depicts them as con-artists in Germany, when they are faced with a curse which will require them to rise to action. Charismatic and charming though the performances from Damon and co-lead Heath Ledger are, there's just no escaping the fact that Gilliam's film is, as so many of his are, complete style over substance and little more. Unsurprisingly, Damon was not the first choice for Willhelm - it was Johnny Depp - but Bob Weinstein didn't believe Depp commercially viable enough, something Damon openly mocked when Depp's Pirates of the Caribbean franchise blew up half-way through filming. Still, it could have all been worse; Damon was originally supposed to wear a fake nose, too, and the experience couldn't have deterred Damon that much, because he's starring in Gilliam's upcoming The Zero Theorem, wearing a profoundly silly white hairpiece to boot.
1. George Lonegan - Hereafter
But the #1 spot has to go to the most tremendously disappointing of all the films on this list, and easily Damon's most misguided performance, playing former psychic George Lonegan in Clint Eastwood's dreadful Hereafter. George is a medium who is lured back into the gig pretty much against his will, due to the uncomfortably intimate details he hears about people's lives, and soon enough he finds himself involved with a young woman named Melanie (Bryce Dallas Howard). Though it's more tolerable because Damon's story is just one of several throughout the film, we're never really allowed to just soak in Damon's character - largely due to his brief screen-time - such that when his story reaches its rather somber, even depressing conclusion, we're not feeling anywhere near as much as we should be. Damon is given very little to work with, and it shows; his chemsitry with Howard is never really allowed to flourish, making the "painful" final sequences of his story just seem pretty inert and devoid of feeling. Terrible, and nobody escapes in tact. Which Matt Damon performances are your favourite and least favourite? Let us know in the comments below.
