MCU: Every Thor Appearance Ranked Worst To Best
Point Break. Sparkles. Pirate Angel. Let's give it up for the God of Thunder.
Thor has been a part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe since 2011, appearing in six films over the years. Despite a solid start, an argument can be made that the franchise stumbled for a while in figuring out what to do with him, as it wasn't until his recent reinvention over the last year that finally put him shoulder to shoulder with his fellow Avengers Iron Man and Captain America in terms of popularity.
Regardless of the quality of the road he's been traveling through the years, it's been an interesting journey for the character nonetheless, the Asgardian learning a major lesson in humility and losing more along the way to embracing his role as the God of Thunder than many of the other heroes we've come to know. Through it all, Chris Hemsworth has proven why he was a solid choice for the role, overcoming the character's frustrating underutilization and reinvigorating Thor in fantastic ways we'll discuss later in this list.
Following yesterday's breakdown of Captain America's appearances in the franchise, let's now turn the spotlight on Thor as we wait to see where next year's Avengers 4 takes the hero, looking back over his time in the MCU to date in order to stack up each of his appearances, breaking down what they meant for the character, his arc, and his overall place in the series in order to sort out which film served him best.
6. Avengers: Age Of Ultron
Of the half dozen films that Thor has appeared in over the years, Age of Ultron was the one that truly felt as though it had no clue what to do with the character. It's no secret that much of Thor's personal journey in the film surrounding his trip to the Norns was cut from the movie, resulting in the much-maligned, all-too-brief cave sequence we got.
To be fair, it set Thor down the road that led to Ragnarok and Infinity War, but in the context of the film, the scene's brevity is symbolic of Thor's role in the film overall. Unlike the first film, which carried some emotional weight for him due to the presence of Loki, Thor just felt kind of there the second time around, getting some cool action moments and being the one to fully bring Vision to life but not actually getting anything thrown his way in terms of character work.
Not to mention, the opening moments of Ragnarok ended up brushing off where Age of Ultron left off for the character - with Thor headed out in search of the Infinity Stones - which has only retroactively made his appearance in the Avengers sequel feel more of an obligation than a necessity. That said, we did get the great party scene in which his friends attempted to lift Mjolnir, with Thor worriedly noticing that Cap actually did move it, so it's not a complete loss for the character.
5. Thor: The Dark World
Thor: The Dark World is often considered one of the MCU's lowest points, and for understandable reasons. It's not necessarily visually appealing, most of the Asgardian supporting cast is wasted, it spends too much time on Earth rather than going cosmic, the chemistry between Natalie Portman and Hemsworth leaves something to be desired, and even the main character himself often has the movie stolen right out from under him by Tom Hiddleston's Loki, among other frequently discussed issues.
That said, if you can set aside the overwhelming feeling that the film fails to live up to the potential the first film queued up for it to capitalize on and look past its myriad of faults, it's still a relatively enjoyable watch, and gives Thor more to do overall than Age of Ultron, which is why Thor's own sequel edges out the Avengers follow-up on this list.
Even though Thor is frequently outshone by the much more magnetic Loki, Hemsworth still does a good job with what material he's given, particularly when the character gets to interact with others like Odin, Sif and the Warriors Three, and, of course, his own brother. What's more, the final, portal-hopping fight scene with Malekith is pretty slick. Overall, though, Thor didn't have his worldview memorably challenged and life upended in the way that, say, The Winter Soldier did to Captain America the following year, which left The Dark World feeling more like a harmless little adventure rather than the gamechanger for the character it could've (and should've) been as a result.
4. The Avengers
With how big the franchise has become, it can't be forgotten just how big of a deal The Avengers was back in 2012. It carried the weight of incredible expectations, having to bring together a bunch of disparate characters and tie together story threads from all their solo franchises into one cohesive narrative, all while ensuring that characters like Captain America and Thor weren't overshadowed by Iron Man's then-dominant popularity, something it pulled off with relative ease.
While Cap and Iron Man's personalities clashed and Bruce Banner struggled with the monster inside of him, Thor's motivations throughout The Avengers were clear: To bring his lost brother back to sanity and back home. Along the way, he had to watch his brother kill Phil Coulson and descend into madness by opening the gateway for the Chitauri, all while everyone posited Loki as the embodiment of pure evil rather than the complex, troubled individual Thor knew he was. The film served as a great payoff to what Thor's first movie set up.
And though he didn't spend much one-on-one time with any of his fellow Avengers, the interactions we did get were suitably perfect, whether it be Tony Stark poking fun at the larger-than-life god or Thor's pairing with the Hulk. With the team's coming together in the end earning everyone Thor's respect and vice versa, the hero ultimately managed to shine in a film loaded with a wealth of colorful characters.
3. Thor
I covered this in my rundown of Captain America's appearances, but it bears repeating here that 2011 was a defining moment for the MCU. Both Captain America and Thor were introduced in their solo films that year, two characters that could've fallen flat on their face if Marvel Studios had screwed up their introductions. If their movies hadn't worked, The Avengers - which was already in production before the two films were even released - and the MCU as we know it wouldn't have become what they went on to become.
In Thor's case, we got an introduction that deftly balanced the colorful, Shakespearean world of Asgard that Thor inhabited with the more grounded Earth we'd come to know through the Iron Man films and The Incredible Hulk, the film having enough fun with the fish out of water concept once the character arrived on Earth to acknowledge the potential cheesiness of the whole thing without stepping over the line and disrespecting the character and his comic legacy.
Even if Thor's arc from brash fighter to humbled do-gooder was a bit rushed within the narrative, the fact it worked at all was a minor miracle, a testament to all those involved, including Chris Hemsworth, who worked to make the character palatable for the mainstream as someone who could reasonably exist in a universe where Iron Man was flying around. Thor himself was likable, his introduction opened up a door to a whole new realm of storytelling potential for the franchise as a whole, and without it, we wouldn't have the great character that he is today.
2. Avengers: Infinity War
This year's massive Avengers film was the single biggest MCU film to date, with dozens of characters turning up who've made a mark over the first decade of the franchise. With so much going on, and with Age of Ultron having set a precedent that Thor could end up as background dressing in a movie like this, it could've been all too easy for the newly-energized God of Thunder to have his role short-changed.
Instead, with Ragnarok giving us the Thor we'd all been waiting to see unleashed, Infinity War pushed Thor straight to the forefront, where he became one of the loaded film's primary characters. Right out of the gate, Thor is the one who loses far too much to Thanos - half the Asgardians, Heimdall, Loki, and nearly his own life - and after he is found by the Guardians, he set out on a journey with Rocket and Groot to forge Stormbreaker, ultimately arriving to save the day in Wakanda in one of the film's showstopping moments.
We finally got to see Thor at his most emotionally exposed, ruminating to Rocket about just how much he'd lost - his family, his friends, his home, his hammer, and even his eye - and his most powerful, as Stormbreaker destroys Thanos' army in Wakanda. And though his desire to gloat was the final straw that allowed Thanos to win - something that will undoubtedly take a toll on him in Avengers 4 - Thor came out of Infinity War proving to the world over that his journey doesn't deserve to end next year when the character has only just come into his own.
1. Thor: Ragnarok
And so we've reached the film that did Thor the most justice, last year's Thor: Ragnarok, the third - and hopefully not final - part of the hero's solo franchise. Between his lackluster outing in The Dark World and his mishandling in Age of Ultron, it's hard to deny that Thor's popularity was nowhere near as strong as Iron Man and Captain America's, but Ragnarok changed that in one fell swoop.
Despite scene-stealers like Hulk, Loki, Valkyrie, Grandmaster, and Hela populating the film, Thor finally felt like the best part of his own franchise, Chris Hemsworth allowed to bring his natural sense of humor to the proceedings in a way that none of the past films had truly capitalized on, thanks in no small part to director Taika Waititi's willingness to blow everything we knew up and go crazy. Along the way, he lost friends, his father, his hammer, and his home, but he also proved just why he deserved to be the new king, embracing the true power and responsibility of his role as the God of Thunder.
In all ways, Ragnarok reinvented the character without completely ignoring his journey to date, unleashing his power in ways we'd never seen and giving him a personality makeover that Hemsworth clearly relished from beginning to end, and even though it took over half a decade to happen, we finally got Thor in all his glory in a way that immediately elevated his popularity and did right by the Avenger.