MCU Phase 4: 5 Comic Book Storylines Marvel Must Avoid

We hate to tell you, but Secret Invasion just cannot work.

secret invasion skrull
Marvel Comics

The MCU hasn't yet put a foot wrong when it comes to directly adapting comic book stories.

With massive comic events such as Civil War, The Winter Solider and Infinity War all getting the blockbuster treatment, it's easy to see Marvel looking for another big, audience-captivating event to adapt for the upcoming Phase 4, which is set to commence with the release of Spider-Man: Far From Home next July.

Perhaps these stories are far smaller in scale? Iron Man's hauntingly personal Demon In A Bottle story influenced Robert Downey Jr.'s performance significantly in Iron Man 3, and Spider-Man's 'If This Be My Destiny' story inspired Spider-Man: Homecoming's most poignant moment.

For stories both colossal and intimate, the MCU has shown due respect when adapting from the pages of their rich comic history. However, there are some comic stories that are just so far-fetched, so bizarre, and so outright confusing that we can only hope the MCU doesn't give them as much as an easter egg in the upcoming fourth phase - for their sake, and ours.

5. World War Hulk

World War Hulk
Marvel Comics

While a lot of elements of the World War Hulk story have already been put to film in Thor: Ragnarok, and the MCU's Hulk appears to be far less monstrous and brutal than his comic book counterpart, World War Hulk still feels like an incredibly likely story to be adapted in the future of the MCU - and it would be a huge mistake if it was.

If there’s one thing the MCU likes, it’s the status-quo - even the universe-encompassing repercussions of Infinity War were dulled by the promise of a follow up and news that several of the film’s fallen heroes have sequels in the works.

This is why, for better or worse, an adaptation of World War Hulk would be a massive detriment to the commercial viability of the MCU. The story, in the briefest of summaries, concerns Hulk losing his loved ones to a bomb indirectly built by Tony Stark and Reed Richards, and bringing war to Planet Earth with an army behind him.

One of the most iconic Hulk stories to date, World War Hulk would make for an inarguably interesting film in the MCU, but unfortunately one that will never see the light of day. For all its radical character development, deaths, and repercussions, World War Hulk would shake up the committee-mandated blockbuster factory that is the MCU just far too much for Disney’s liking, and it's easy to see why.


4. Avengers VS X-Men

Avengers Vs X Men
Marvel Comics

Civil War, if nothing else, is proof that audiences just love to see a grudge match between superheroes. Be it Captain America and Iron Man, or Batman and Superman (which, after the smorgasbord of negative reviews, it is easy to forget was equally as anticipated), we all like to see a bit of a domestic between our favourite do-gooders.

It’s very easy to see, in an MCU whose writer’s room must be currently searching for a means of introducing and establishing their versions of the X-Men, that major crossovers such as 2012’s Avengers vs X-Men event will be considered for adaptation.

However, even entertaining the unlikely possibility that Phase 4 of the MCU will introduce Marvel’s favourite mutants anytime soon, throwing them immediately into a battle with the Avengers doesn’t feel like a particularly good start for newcomers to the X-Men in the MCU.


3. The Clone Saga

Spider Man Clone Saga
Marvel Comics

With the bookies seeming to be liking the odds of Iron Man and Captain America not making it out of Avengers 4, the MCU will be looking for two new figureheads for their universe. One to lead the Avengers and provide a face for the in-universe team like Captain Marvel is shaping up to be, and one to become the new face of the MCU in the same way Tom Holland’s Spider-Man is fast becoming.

With his three appearances in the MCU, Peter Parker has proven himself every bit the plucky, loveable genius who has resonated with mainstream audiences as he did 50+ years ago on the pages of Amazing Fantasy #15. With Homecoming proving that the MCU has found success in wholly original Spider-Man stories (and with the upcoming Far From Home seeming to be an original story also), we can just hope that the creative team doesn’t decide to make their first adaptation a story that almost destroyed Spider-Man for good.

A comic far more famous for the things it did wrong rather than for what it did right, The Clone Saga was a confusing story that even writers at the time have admitted “ended in a fiasco”.

Needless to say, stay away from this one, Marvel Studios.


2. Secret Invasion

secret invasion skrull
Marvel Comics

The MCU, as many fans will know, turned 10 this year.

10 years of Marvel churning out blockbuster after blockbuster feels like an eternity, and the Marvel machine is showing no sign of stopping. The MCU has introduced mainstream audiences to once-lesser known but now-iconic characters such as Iron Man, Captain America and Nick Fury. While comic fans have known of and loved these characters for decades, the MCU bears responsibility for having introduced them to a new generation of moviegoers, endearing them to the public in the process.

Which is why, in a comic event that shook up Marvel history to a considerable degree, Secret Invasion absolutely should not become an influence for the MCU's fourth phase. Characters were killed, betrayed, and some even revealed to be skrulls-in-disguise for years, and fans just aren't ready to buy that level of deception.

Far more a question of what Disney won’t do instead of what they shouldn’t do, Secret Invasion is a Marvel story that would damage the status quo of what is fast becoming (or, maybe, already has become) the go-to ‘safe’ family blockbuster franchise, and should be stricken from the drawing board as a result.


1. Siege

Marvel Siege Thor
Marvel Comics

The events of Thor: Ragnarok and Avengers: Infinity War have gone far in establishing Thor as far more than the boring and uninteresting Avenger we had seen in his four prior appearances. Currently one of the MCUs most nuanced and tragic characters, and with his homeland of Asgard in a limbo between being exterminated and thriving elsewhere in the universe, it’s very easy to see Siege becoming a focal point for Phase 4.

Siege, simply put, details Loki manipulating Norman Osborn into leading a siege on Asgard, which is newly arrived in the US. This, on a surface level, seems like a way for the MCU to please a lot of its fans at once. A reason to resurrect Loki? More Thor? A way to save Asgard? Introducing Osborn outside of his done-to-death Green Goblin guise? That sounds like killing four birds with one hammer!

But, considering Ragarok’s humanising of Thor, and Infinity War making him one of the most vulnerable characters in the MCU, adapting Siege would only work to his detriment.

Undoing all the suffering and subsequent growth of Thor following the death of Loki and falling of Asgard would definitely please fans of the Mightiest Avenger, but would be nothing but a letdown following the story of one of Marvel’s most interesting characters.

Watch Next...


Contributor
Contributor

Writer, film fan, lover of Spider-Man, defender of Max Payne 3 and STILL not quite over Steve Irwin. See me try to be funny on twitter @NokesyPokesy