MCU: What Every Major Hero ALMOST Looked Like

It was almost SO much different...

Marvel Heroes Concept
Marvel Studios

Even though part of the MCU's success has always been apportioned to how well-planned the whole expanded universe was from the moment it occurred to Kevin Feige, there's enough information out there to suggest that lots of the movies came extremely close to being completely different.

There's no way Edgar Wright's Ant-Man was anything like Peyton Reed's for instance, or Jon Favreau's Iron Man 3, or Patty Jenkins' Thor 2... And Joss Whedon was always pretty clear on how different Age Of Ultron was to his intial plans. That's just how films evolve over time, and no amount of forward planning would change that.

Even on a smaller level, we've seen that the MCU almost saw some wildly different specific scenes, and even further, it seems that some of the characters who ended up in the first ten years of Marvel's tentpole franchise could have looked radically different. Sometimes that's for the better, but sometimes there are what ifs that may have even looked cooler.

Thanks to the raft of concept art that's out there now, we have a fairly good insight into what the Avengers COULD have looked like had their alternate looks been approved...

22. Captain America

Captain America Concept 1
Marvel Studios

Thanks to EW, we got a look at a couople of new concept art pieces both for Captain America's period look before he's frozen and the more modern look for the sequels. That blue jacket might have been striking, but he would have stood out like a sore thumb in open combat, so toning it down was a smart idea.

Meanwhile, you can see the thinking in the modern body army even without the star spangled details...

Captain America Concept 2
Marvel Studios

There's also another excellent alternative to the period outfit out there too combining ideas used in other costumes.

Cap Concept 4
Marvel Studios

And finally, the all-black Cap outfit has to rank as one of the most egregiously overlooked concepts, while you can probably see why they didn't go for the US Agent one...

Captain America Concepts
Marvel Studios

21. Spider-Man

Spider-Man Infinity War Concept
Marvel Studios

As these alternates looks at the Iron Spider suit for Avengers: Infinity War shows, there was some consideration to give Peter Parker some pretty cool looks, including one Venom-inspired costume and one far closer to the comics version of the Iron Spider suit.

Spider-man Iron Spider Concept
Marvel Studios

Some of the designs were pretty damn cool and it's a shame we didn't get to see them. Particularly as the more understated designs are vastly better than the more garish blue red and gold of the final film.

Spider-Man Concepts Infinity War
Marvel Studios

20. Captain Marvel

Captain Marvel Concept
Marvel Studios

It absolutely wouldn't have been the right direction for the costume, but at one stage of the concepts for Captain Marvel, she could have worn this more understated, primarily blue jump-suit style uniform.

In the end, the decision to go a little more traditionally cosmic and to channel the comics more is much better. The red and gold elements really make the design.

At one point, Marvel almost had her famous sash from the comics (which randomly turned up in Infinity War on Cull Obsidian's heavy axe for some reason), but it was dropped before she came to the big screen.

Captain Marvel Sash Concept
Marvel Studios

Maybe it was just too impractical and they went for an Edna Mode-style "no capes" rule?


19. Vision

Vision Concept
Marvel Strudios

The final version of The Vision is probably the most striking design in all of the MCU, given his red "skin" and robotic good looks. He stands out, to say the least, but he might have looked even more otherworldly - and like one of the Sovereign from Guardians of The Galaxy Vol 2 - if they'd gone with Andy Parks' silver and gold look.

He also came up with some alternate colour schemes with a completely different impact.

Vision Concept 2
Marvel Studios

Terrifying.


18. Black Widow

Black Widow Concept
Marvel Studios

Though it was slightly over-sexualised, Black Widow's transformation from Tony Stark's assistant into the catsuit wearing, tendril haired Black Widow had a big effect in Iron Man 2 - particularly as it successfully nailed the whole femme fatale thing.

But some artwork from Ryan Meinerding confirms that she almost had a much more functional, Metal Gear Solid-like tactical suit that she could have worn - as well as an entirely different haircut. The choice to go green was a bold one, given her name, so it's not all that surprising it wasn't used.


17. Iron Man

IRON MAN CONCEPT
Marvel Studios

There are countless alternatives to Iron Man's finished look in his movies, as concept artists have taken as much glee in the details of his suits as Stark himself did when he tinkered his way to an Iron Legion in Iron Man 3.

Some had shoulder-mounted cannons, others were more like Space Marine suits and others simply changed the design up to look even more bulky...

Iron Man Concept 2
Marvel Studios

The opportunity to design lots of burner suits for Iron Man 3 inspired some more... wacky designs too, like this grabby claw arm version...

Iron Man Arms

And who wouldn't want to see a buzzsaw-armed Iron Man?

Iron Man Buzzsaw Concept
Marvel Studios

16. Scarlet Witch

Scarlet Witch Andy Parks
Marvel Studios

The Scarlet Witch of the comics was defined as much by her headpiece as she was by her powers (and infamous instability) so it was a shame when Marvel Studios went with a more toned down design to reflect her new backstory. But according to Andy Parks' early concept designs, they did entertain the idea of giving her some headwear. And it definitely adds something to her look.

Parks also offered a couple of other alternate designs early on with vastly different approaches...

Scarlet Witch Concept 2
Marvel Studios

15. Hulk

Hulk Concept Art
Marvel Studios

The Hulk is a slightly different beast to the others in this collection, since there's only so much you can do with a big green monster man - and messing too much with his look was always going to be a bad idea. BUT, at one point the hairier Hulk was an option for Thor: Ragnarok thanks to Ryan Meinerding. How dashing!

The most gorgeous artwork out there is from artist Aaron Sims, who did concept art for The Incredible Hulk, including this more tender look at the Jade Giant...

Marvel Studios

14. Ant-Man

Ant Man Concepts
Marvel Studios

Ant-Man's suit seems to have been mostly set straight away in the design process - at least the colour scheme and the general look (which is fairly close to the classic comic book design).

But his helmet went through a lot of different possible designs before the artists settled on the final version. Some of which were actually more striking than the chosen design.

Ant Man Concept 2
Marvel Studios

The mad genius that is Josh Nizzi also came up with a load of concepts for ants with special capabilities - the best of which is this nitrogen tank ant, which would have been able to freeze enemies...

Marvel Studios

13. Bucky

Bucky Concept Art
Marvel Studios

Though he hasn't been a hero for his entire run in the MCU so far, Bucky (or White Wolf as he's apparently preferring to be called these days) is back on the right side of history and that's a good thing for his future in the MCU. Provided he survives.

Anyway, back when he was returning as The Winter Soldier, Josh Nizzi offered an alternate design concept with multiple replaced limbs and a distinctly wild man look about him.

Artist Rodney Fuentebella also offered an alternative that was closer to the final chosen design...

Winter Soldier Concept
Marvel Studios

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.