Meryl Streep: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

At least until they finally make Kramer Vs Kramer Vs Alien Vs Predator.

What kind of sane human being doesn't like Meryl Streep? Well there was that one guy who said as much to Zooey Deschanel's character during a speed dating montage in an episode of New Girl, but she kicked him to the curb immediately. Because how could you possibly date a person with such an incorrect opinion. A three-time Academy Award winner who has the record for the most Oscar nominations of any actor (fifteen for Best Actress and three for Best Supporting Actress), as well as being the most-nominated performer in Golden Globe Awards history with seven wins, not to mention a load of BAFTAs, critic's awards, Streep is one of the most-decorated actors in history. And not without good reason. She's probably the greatest living actor working in the business today, both on the big screen and on stage, with an unparalleled knack for adopting the nuances, accents, and tics that make a character seem like an actual human being. This weekend she appears as The Witch in the musical adaptation Into The Woods which looks...well, not amazing, but she'll be good in it. Her career is one almost entirely made of highs, but every so often, there's a couple of lows hidden in there. As we do every Friday (or Sunday if we are running a little late!), let's examine the five best and five very worst performances in actor's career. This time, Meryl Streep.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Clarissa Vaughan - The Hours (2002)

Whilst Streep often excelled in embodying real-life people in films €“ she won accolades for her part as Margaret Thatcher in The Iron Lady, where what could have been a shallow pantomime impersonation was far more fully-realised and sympathetic €“ in The Hours it's Nicole Kidman that got the gongs for her performance as Virginia Woolf. Streep's appearance in the film, meanwhile, is as a character in the modern day who is the living embodiment of the titular character from Woolf's novel Mrs Dalloway. As New Yorker Clarissa Vaughan she has a quite dignity and intensity that suffuses the rest of Stephen Daldry's film, which also stars Julianne Moore. The scenes with Streep are perhaps the highlight of the film, however, as she spends a day preparing for a party she's throwing for her old lover and friend Richard, a poet and author living with AIDS who is to receive a major literary award. It's an emotionally devastating but even-handed film, and Streep nails it.

4. Susan Orlean €“ Adaptation (2002)

Of course, she does do an excellent job whenever she plays actual people, too, although it's debatable how close her performance in Spike Jonze's Adaptation as Susan Orlean is to the actual staff writer for The New Yorker, since Charlie Kaufman's script diverges from Orlean's book The Orchid Thief in some fairly radical ways. In fact, it was a good thing Streep was on board to keep things somewhat grounded. Adaptation is by no means a traditional, well, adaptation. Orlean's book is about the Florida orchid grower, breeder, and collector John Laroche. The film is about a fictionalised Charlie Kaufman €“ played by Nicolas Cage in a wig that's actually supposed to be crap for once €“ struggling to turn the book into a film, with imagined scenes of him reading the book where Laroche is played by Chris Cooper, and Orlean by Streep. At the end it turns out the two are lovers, involved in a drug production operation where orchids are processed into a psychoactive substance. Which is notably not what happened in either The Orchid Thief or real life. Streep ably makes the leap from the straight, proper performance as the Orlean from the book, and the hysterical action-movie villain that she turns into by the end.

3. Joanna Kramer €“ Kramer Vs Kramer (1979)

Adaptation is one of the lighter roles Streep has found acclaim for in recent years, winning another Golden Globe for Best Supporting Actress. Where she has done the majority of her best work, though, has been in the straighter, more emotionally draining dramatic performances of the sort of The Hours €“ and, perhaps most famously, Kramer Vs Kramer. Robert Benton's film received five Academy Awards in 1980 in the categories of Best Picture, Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Actor, and Best Supporting Actress. Kramer Vs Kramer is the film that put both Streep and co-star Dustin Hoffman on the map as two of he biggest stars of the time, even though the former had originally been cast in a bit part. She didn't give Benton a second chance to regret moving her up to a starring role, however, with Streep doing a sterling job in a mostly thankless task as a woman who demands a divorce from her workaholic husband, causing rifts between their children, friends and extended family. Absolutely fantastic, humanistic and engaging.

2. Zofia "Sophie" Zawistowski €“ Sophie's Choice (1982)

Of course compared to this gruelling historical drama, Kramer Vs Kramer is the feel-good hit of the summer! Streep was so eager to get the starring role in Alan J Pakula's film she begged the director after getting her hands on a bootlegged copy of the script, despite the original novel's author imagining Ursula Andress in mind for the part of Sophie. Watching the film now, however, it's impossible to imagine anyone but Streep in the role. Kramer Vs Kramer might be the film that finally made her a household name, but it was Sophie's Choice that began Streep along the road of playing rich, complex and ultimately tragic characters in films that have some strong historical and emotional roots. As the Polish immigrant entangled with an emotionally unstable lover who seeks solace in a young writer, Streep is absolutely believable, relatable and sympathetic as she slowly reveals her tragic past: despite her father being a Nazi sympathiser, she still ended up in a concentration camp, forced to choose which of her two children was gassed to death, with the emotional scars still raw.

1. Sister Aloysius Beauvier €“ Doubt (2008)

The late seventies and early eighties may have been the prime time for Meryl Streep as transcendent, cathartic performer, but she's not been dragging her weight since. Not by a long shot. Recently she's starred in the satirical The Devil Wears Prada and the dark farce of August: Osage County, but she reached the height of her controversial, complex and just straight up difficult to watch performances with 2008's Doubt. Opposite the other strongest actor of his generation (until his untimely death last year) Phillip Seymour Hoffman, Streep is absolutely electric in this adaptation of John Patrick Shanley's Pulitzer Prize winning play. Spurred on by the suspicions of Amy Adams's Sister James, Streep's nun Sister Aloysius Beauvier investigates accusations of impropriety with an altar boy on the part of Hoffman's Catholic priest Father Brendan Flynn. It's a story that could so easily tip over into hysteria, or else broad parody, with the horrifying reality of widespread child abuse in the Catholic church a contemporary hot button topic. Everyone involved manages that aforementioned quiet dignity Streep essayed in The Hours, with the occasional explosions of emotion from her repressed nun being all the more powerful. A career-best performance to be sure. Unfortunately, the same can't be said for every film Meryl Streep has appeared in over the years...

...And 5 That Sucked

5. The Chief Elder €“ The Giver (2014)

Like many of the actors that appear in the 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked articles €“ including, notably, her Doubt co-star Phillip Seymour Hoffman €“ Meryl Streep doesn't often give genuinely bad performances. She doesn't really have it in her. Regardless of the project, she will always give it her all, and always give a performance at the height of her considerable abilities. So, really, the question is about which projects she has been involved with the really didn't deserve those considerable abilities, or else didn't much benefit from them. That can easily be said of last year's The Giver, the long-awaited adaptation of the classic young adult novel that co-starred Jeff Bridges. Streep just didn't have a whole lot to do. The story of a dystopian future where humanity's traumatic past has been wiped, but for a Receiver Of Memory who thus advises society on the best courses of action based on their forgotten history, is a strong one. But the film fell flat on its face by all reports, with Streep called on to do nothing but be wise and old.

4. Lisa Metzger €“ Prime (2005)

Some of Streep's recent great performances have been the lighter ones. Doubt was a career stand out to be sure, but it's been just as enriching and entertaining to see her as the venomous fashion magazine editor in The Devil Wears Prada, the emotionally confused divorcee in It's Complicated, and the hysterical matriarch in black comedy August: Osage County. Some actors who are fantastic in a dramatic context just can't hack comedy. It's a completely different set of skills, and a tough nut to crack. For the most part Streep has succeeded in her parlaying her dramatic skills into prat falls €“ it's just that she doesn't always pick her comic turns so carefully as her straight roles. As is the case with Prime, a forgettable and mostly forgotten rom-com from a few years ago with Uma Thurman as an €œolder€ woman who gets involved with a much younger man, and discloses all of the juicy details to her therapist, played by Streep. Shock twist €“ the therapist is the boy's mother! And the film never quite recovers from that pretty trite little plot turn. Everyone does a fine job, it's just a very middle-of-the-road film that never demands too much from its stars.

3. Julia Child €“ Julie & Julia (2009)

Speaking of which, remember Julie & Julia? Probably not, because it wasn't a particularly great film €“ produced in the wake of other feel-good movies that seem to be based on cookery books, alongside Julia Roberts's Eat, Pray, Love €“ and because Streep's character, the real life chef and TV personality Julia Child, isn't quite the cultural touchstone in the UK she is in the US. It doesn't help that the concept of the film is gossamer thin. Based on a true story, but not much of one, the film follows young New Yorker Julie Powell (Amy Adams) as she runs each of the 524 recipes in Child's Mastering the Art of French Cooking for a blog she calls the Julie/Julia project, contrasted with the early years of Child's culinary career. Julie & Julia is one of the few examples of Streep overstepping the mark a little with her performance as a real-life figure. Something she always manages is to stop her character from ever falling into caricature, embodying a personality rather than being boiled down to some recognisable catchphrase and the like. Which isn't the case here, sadly.

2. Kay Soames €“ Hope Springs (2012)

It's true that besides being hopelessly sexist and borderline misogynistic (besides racist and a whole bunch of other prejudices reflecting the culture's own issues), Hollywood has a problem with age. Whilst there are plenty of plumb roles for men far into their twilight years, they're often positioned with romantic partners who are a fraction of their age, leaving older actresses without a lot to do. So in a way, Hope Springs should be celebrated for being a film about an older couple, and treating that with a degree of respect and humanity rarely touched upon in a Hollywood production. On the other hand, it's a film where Meryl Streep and Tommy Lee Jones go to Steve Carrell for advice on how to spice up their marriage. It's not a particularly bad film, per se, it's just a hopelessly uninspired one. Julie & Julia appears to be reaching for something, but it's never clear what. Hope Springs doesn't even seem to be attempting that, with Jones getting most of the good lines and even those are few and far between.

1. Donna Carmichael €“ Mamma Mia! (2008)

A film that boasts such a glittering ensemble almost demands attention: Meryl Streep! Amanda Seyfried! Pierce Brosnan! Stellan Skarsgård! Colin Firth! Erm, Julie Walters! It's an all-star cast to be sure. It's just a shame that the project that would unite such a large amount of acting talent would have to the be the ABBA musical, Mama Mia!, one of the cultural phenomena of the decade. Not that that means much. The general public have freaked out about much less. Those Compared The Meerkat adverts are still airing, for example. Perhaps the strangest part of Mama Mia's existence is that the producers decided to go not only with actors who had not background with singing for a musical, but actors who seemed to be actively awful singers. Streep fairs a lot better than most €“ because, really, nobody could be quite as bad as Pierce Brosnan's take on When All Is Said And Done €“ but c'mon, who hires Meryl Streep on the strength of her pipes? She's adept as switching between the big roles and the more fluffy parts but really, this is way below her. It's way beyond anyone involved, but especially an actor whose achievements are as numerous and varied as Meryl Streep's. And yet rumours of a sequel persist. Are they even any ABBA songs left? And will audiences be subject to well, this again?

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/