Middle-Earth On Film: A Visual History

There's more than just Peter Jackson's movies...

Gollum lord of the rings
New Line Cinema
So many movies are dubbed "the new Star Wars". Just a few months ago everyone was quick to highlight Guardians Of The Galaxy as a defining cinematic moment. But while Marvel's space fantasy certainly has some objective similarities with George Lucas' saga, in terms of cultural impact and ability to bring a whole generation together, you can't beat The Lord Of The Rings. They may not be sci-fi, but in terms of technological advancement and uncompromised world-building Peter Jackson's three-movie epic is the real inheritor of Luke Skywalker's crown. They even have prequels that are widely regarded as a weaker exercise. The phrase "modern classic" is thrown around a lot, but in this case it's more than fitting. Of course, Jackson's Middle-Earth movies were far from the first attempts at bringing the works of Tolkien to the screen. Since he first published his seminal novels there's been many attempts to bring the adventures of the Baggins' to life, with only a handful coming to fruition. Come and a take a look back over the making of cinema history - how did The Lord Of The Rings almost end up differently, and which different versions actually exist? It's all here in this gallery.

14. The Hobbit Extended Editions (2013-2015)

The Hobbit An Unexpected Journey Martin Freeman Bilbo Baggins
Warner Bros. Pictures

Just like The Lord Of The Rings, The Hobbit has its own Extended Editions that expand upon the original releases. Unlike the earlier movies, however, there are fewer additions and, more importantly, the films were made with this later edit in mind.

The Extended Editions are more fitting of Peter Jackson's idea for a whole trilogy based on The Hobbit - the dwarves get more development and the mythology is deepened, leading to an overall better experience. How the whole thing works together will have to wait until The Battle Of The Five Armies gets the treatment later in 2015.


13. The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies (2014)

The Hobbit The Battle Of The Five Armies Bilbo Baggins Thorin Martin Freeman Richard Armitage
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Battle Of The Five Armies rounded off The Hobbit trilogy and tied it even more directly into The Lord Of The Rings, delivering an experience that will delight The Hobbit's fans as much as it'll rile up its detractors.

This is likely the final movie set in Middle-Earth for a good long while, unless Jackson manages to wrangle the rights to The Silmarillion. Watch this space.


12. The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug (2013)

The Hobbit The Desolation Of Smaug Bilbo Baggins Smaug
Warner Bros. Pictures

Just like The Two Towers, The Desolation Of Smaug wasn't part of the original plan for its trilogy. Unlike the second The Lord Of The Rings, however, Desolation didn't exist until well into post-production - the decision was made less than six months before the release of An Unexpected Journey.

The original split in the duology was going to come after the barrel sequence, which here forms the lynchpin of the second act. The big draw this time around was less about seeing Middle-Earth again, and more the new; it marked the debut of the series' dragon design.


11. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012)

The Hobbit An Unexpected Journey Gollum Bilbo Baggins Martin Freeman Andy Serkis
Warner Bros. Pictures

Jackson had considered making The Hobbit before he ended up making The Lord Of The Rings, but after a change of mind the version ultimately released came in the shadow of his mammoth achievement.

The original Middle-Earth novel was split into three, with the single narrative fragmented. The reaction was mixed - some found the whole thing ponderous and overlong, while others were just happy to be back in Middle-Earth once more.


10. The Lord Of The Rings Extended Editions (2002-2004)

The Lord Of The Rings Mouth Of Sauron
Warner Bros. Pictures

Any Tolkien fan worth their salt knows the Theatrical Editions of The Lord Of The Rings are just a window into a much bigger story. The Extended Editions, released in the winter following the original version in cinemas, added in upwards of 30 minutes of content to each film.

The most substantial was Return Of The King's, which expanded on many sequences, as well as adding in a proper death scene for Saruman, although all come out as very different experiences, steeped even more in Tolkien lore.


9. The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King (2003)

The Lord Of The Rings The Return Of The King Frodo Baggins Elijah Wood
Warner Bros. Pictures

The highest grossing Middle-Earth movie and one of the best regarded, by The Return Of The King is was clear Tolkien's work was no longer the reserve of high-fantasy obsessives.

Fantasy is a genre the Academy are all but allergic to. Which makes The Return Of The King's Oscar success (it won all eleven of its nominated awards, matching Titanic and Ben-Hur as the most honoured movies) all the more incredible.


8. The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers (2002)

The Lord Of The Rings The Two Towesr Helms Deep
Warner Bros. Pictures

Bridging the homespun joy of the Shire and the epic battles to come, The Two Towers showed Fellowship wasn't a one-off, although it almost never existed.

When originally pitching The Lord Of The Rings, Jackson had resigned himself to making at most two movies - there was no way a studio would put up the cash to make three lengthly movies back-to-back. Thankfully New Line Cinema thought differently to the rest of Hollywood, convincing the director to work the story into three movies.


7. The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring (2001)

The Lord Of The Rings The Fellowship Of The Ring Gandalf Balrog
Warner Bros. Pictures

A New Zealand director best known for incredibly gorey horrors took on Tolkien next, but unlike the other crazy adaptations Peter Jackson had a major studio behind him keen to help him realise his vision.

Had The Fellowship Of The Ring not been as successful, things could have gone very different for the franchise. It's popularity allowed Jackson the extra time and money needed to bring the following two films up to scratch - otherwise they may have gone straight-to-DVD.


6. Hobitit (1993)

868156

Fabulous Journey wasn't the only adaptation of Tolkien made for foreign TV audiences. In the early-nineties Finnish TV network Yle made Hobitit (The Hobbits), which, contrary to the title, is actually an adaptation of The Lord Of The Rings.

Following just the adventures of Frodo and Sam (that's a way to keep the budget down), it's a pretty epic undertaking, running for nine half hour episodes. Given its limited scope, it's not all that bad, although compared to what came next it's not really worth your time.


5. The Fabulous Journey Of Mr. Bilbo Baggins The Hobbit (1985)

The Hobbit Russian
Lentelefilm

Skazochnoye Puteshestviye Mistera Bilbo Begginsa Khobbita is the Soviet take on The Hobbit and shows just how sloppy an adaptation of Tolkien can be.

The plot is greatly reduced, the focus kept entirely on the dwarves quest.

On the one hand, as Russian children's special, it's hard to judge it too harshly. On the other it's a terribly acted exercise with shocking special effects that make it look like a cheap amateur stage production (which is basically is).


4. The Return Of The King (1980)

The Return Of The King Cartoon
Topcraft Rankin/Bass Productions

Bakshi's adaptation was a big financial success, but didn't prompt a sequel. That didn't stop a version of The Return Of The King, a TV film made by the same guys as The Hobbit, coming out a couple of years later.

It's far less technically accomplished than the film it unofficially sequelises, but it's reassuring to see the disjointed animated Middle-Earth get a vague resolution.


3. The Lord Of The Rings (1978)

The Lord Of The Rings Cartoon Frodo Baggins
United Artists

Coming less than a year after The Hobbit, although not related in any real way, Ralph Bakshi's The Lord Of The Rings adapts The Fellowship Of The Ring and The Two Towers in a highly stylised animation that relied heavily on rotoscoped live-action footage.

For a long time this was deemed the best screen adaptation Tolkien fans could hope for, remaining pretty faithful to the book. Today, however, some of it (especially Sam) look a bit silly.


2. The Hobbit (1977)

The Hobbit Cartoon Bilbo Baggins Gollum
Rankin/Bass TopcraftABC Video Enterprises

It soon became apparent that the best way to realise Middle-Earth on screen would be through animation. Tolkien actively disliked Disney, so must have been pretty happy to see it in the hands of Jules Bass and Arthur Rankin, Jr.

Relying heavily on the music of Tolkien's text, The Hobbit is a spry 77 minutes long, originally made as a TV special, that remains faithful to the source, bar cutting less-important elements.


1. The Failed Attempts

The Lord Of The Rings Beatles
Warner Bros. Pictures

Since their first publication in 1937 and 1954 respectively, there's been numerous attempts to try and bring The Hobbit and The Lord Of The Rings to the screen that stumbled at various stages of production. Middle-Earth just proved too vast and the content too sprawling to be properly realised by the standards of the time.

The most noteworthy almost-production was a Beatles-starring, Kubrick-directed picture floated in the late-sixties (imagine John Lennon as Gollum), although other attempts are pretty interesting, including a John Boorman-helmed take that, some startling divergences from the source aside, sounded to be of a similar scope to the iconic later adaptation.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.