Mother! Review: 5 Ups & 4 Downs

Aronofsky's latest is built to divide.

Mother Jennifer Lawrence Javier Bardem
Paramount Pictures

Darren Aronofsky's latest movie Mother! is in cinemas now, and what a wild ride it is. Though it's honestly best to avoid reading too much at all before you see it for yourself, the film has garnered relatively polarising reactions so far.

Critics have largely praised the film, though there are a high number of both one-star and five-star reviews, indicating that it's going to invite passionate hatred and love in equal measure.

Mother! is not an easy movie to love at times and there are a lot of things that don't quite work, but it is a daring vision like nothing else released this year, so if you want to support an oddball movie starring some very, very talented actors, then you could certainly do much worse.

Either way, the conversation surrounding this movie is going to be loud, so make sure to see it before any of the movie's disturbing surprises are ruined for you...


Downs...

4. The Themes Are Surprisingly Shallow

Mother Jennifer Lawrence
Paramount

Even the least-astute of viewers will surely pick up fairly early on that Mother! is a film steeped in metaphors and allegories, particularly relating to the Bible and also current environmental concerns regarding the future of Earth.

Unfortunately, Aronofsky lays these ideas on incredibly thickly to the point that there's zero room for subtlety, essentially assaulting the viewer with it to the extent that it's liable to cause heavily divisive responses.

Though what Aronofsky does with this is compelling and exciting at times, for the most part it plays as disappointingly simplistic and smugly self-satisfied. It's really a grab-bag of countless symbolic images and references all blended together into a concoction that's not nearly as smart as it clearly purports to be.

And no, if you call the movie pretentious, you're not merely making an excuse for not understanding it. This is absolutely a movie that insists on itself.


3. It's Not The Movie Many Are Expecting

Mother Javier Bardem
Paramount

While a movie should be assessed as far removed from its marketing as possible, it's hard to deny that a lot of people are going to leave this movie frustrated that it wasn't the same film they were sold from trailers.

The marketing largely suggested Mother! to be a more straight-forward studio horror film, but with the end result being much more surreal and bizarre, it's safe to say that casual viewers will end up disappointed, if they even bother staying to the end of the movie.

Granted, anyone who knows the name Darren Aronofsky will have a decent idea of what to expect, but with the marketing and Jennifer Lawrence's presence promising a more mainstream venture, it's going to catch a ton of flak from audiences and likely fall off a cliff after its first weekend at the box office.

Different is good, but studios need to be honest with people about what they're selling.


2. It's Totally Predictable

Mother Jennifer Lawrence Javier Bardem
Paramount

Predictability alone won't sink most films, because the execution of an idea is always more important, but it's still disappointing that Mother! is at its core an incredibly predictable romp.

Certain images and ideas that are raised early on hint very explicitly at how the scenario is going to conclude, and if you're paying a decent amount of attention, you'll be able to see the ending coming a mile off.

Again, the audacity of Aronofsky's style does somewhat soften this blow, but it's still a shame that certain visuals unnecessarily shown off in the first few minutes are needlessly spoilerific.

It would've been more compelling and surprising had Aronofsky withheld these glimpses, which he certainly could've done without appearing to excessively manipulate viewers.


1. The Excessive Length

Mother Jennifer Lawrence
Paramount

This isn't a hugely long film, but at 121 minutes, it is certainly longer than it needs to be, in large part because of a somewhat shaky opening 20-or-so minutes, which don't get the film off on the strongest foot, and could certainly have been trimmed down for a leaner overall experience.

Aronofsky's better films tend to clock in at around the 100-110 minute mark, and it's probably not a terrible coincidence that with 15-ish minutes chopped away, this would feel much tighter.

Instead, Aronofsky doubles down on a slow-burn approach that only works intermittently, with some scenes dragging sluggishly and repeatedly raking over ideas to the point that they feel like glorified cutting room floor material.

These complaints accepted, though, Mother! is certainly more good than bad, and here's everything that works...


Ups...

5. Jennifer Lawrence's Mesmerising Performance

Mother Jennifer Lawrence
Paramount

Jennifer Lawrence gives easily one of her best performances to date as a character credited simply as "Mother", a young woman married to a successful poet (Javier Bardem) riddled with writer's block.

Though there seems to be a back-and-forth love-hate relationship between audiences and Lawrence, she again proves why she's one of the best actresses of her generation with a thoroughly tortured turn that's incredibly hard to shake.

The film largely hinges on her work because Aronofsky shoots so much of it in close-up, her reactions selling the abject horror of the increasingly twisted scenario.

She won't be getting any Oscar nominations for it as many initially expected, in part because the film is built to be so polarising, but it's incredibly strong work all the same.


4. The Intense, Unsettling Atmosphere

Mother Jennifer Lawrence
Paramount

Even Aronofsky's lesser films are absolutely masterworks of mood and atmosphere, and Mother! is no exception.

From the bizarre opening sequence to the slow-build of unease, the director revels in making the audience confused and intrigued all at once, before unleashing a full maelstrom of bats*** insanity as he's done in so many of his previous movies.

The third act in particular sees Aronofsky fully giving himself and the audience over to his more demented instincts, and while they will inevitably be too much for some viewers, it's hard not to at least respect his sheer, full-tilt commitment to such zany images and ideas.

Whether you love or hate the movie, you'll almost certainly come out of it repulsed, which is presumably exactly what the director intended.


3. The Terrific Ensemble Cast

Mother Michelle Pfeiffer
Paramount

Say what you will about the film as a whole, but Aronofsky's barmy vision has attracted quite the ensemble cast, most prominently Javier Bardem as Lawrence's husband "Him", and Ed Harris and Michelle Pfeiffer as an older couple who end up staying at their home.

There are two other prominent actors who also show up later on, though considering how little they've appeared in the movie's advertising, it's more fun for you to experience them for yourself.

Still, this collection of terrific actors ensures the movie mostly remains intriguing even though its more trying parts, with Michelle Pfeiffer's scary-sexy wife proving particularly entertaining.

Harris and Bardem, meanwhile, are as reliably terrific as ever, while the two other unnamed actors slot in well in their smaller roles.


2. There's One Scene You Will Never Forget

Mother Jennifer Lawrence
Paramount

No spoilers here, but a lot of reviews have been going nuts over "that scene", an incredibly shocking moment that's prompted walk-outs and is sure to be the most-discussed and controversial moment of the movie.

Whether you deem it an act of shock value or something intended to strike a more meaningly visceral note, it is very much in step with the horrific images Aronofsky has shown us in his previous films (especially Requiem for a Dream), and certainly the most upsetting thing he's ever put on screen.

In terms of execution, it's a great scene, even if it's naturally going to push the film over the edge for many. Decades from now, you'll probably still remember how revolted you were at this particular sequence, even if you never watch it again.


1. It's Like Nothing Else Out Right Now

Mother Jennifer Lawrence Javier Bardem
Paramount

Though some of the film's themes aren't exactly subtle or fresh, the movie as a whole is truly unlike anything else in cinemas right now.

It is an utterly unrestrained slice of inventive madness for better and for worse, and if you're fed up of mainstream studio fare that caters to the lowest-common denominator, then Mother! just might be the violent, cinematic slap in the face you're craving.

Again, it's not for everyone and you might end up only begrudgingly respecting it, but Aronofsky should be lauded more than not for his fearless attempt to bring a vision to the screen that's like nothing else starring an A-list cast.

What did you think of Mother? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.