The Muppets: Ranking Every Movie From Worst To Best

In light of Muppets Most Wanted's release, we look back on the film careers of those lovable bundles of felt.

It's no secret that Kermit the Frog has worked with more stars than Tom Jones. From Sir Michael Caine to Bob Hope, the Muppets have stood toe-to-toe with the very best the entertainment industry has to offer - simply because they are the best the industry has to offer. They've been a constant in the pop culture spectrum, imbuing everything they grace with a certain lovability and a touch of light-hearted class unparalleled in any other cultural institution. Whether it's Miss Piggy's turbulent love affair with Kermit, or the comedic thrashing and chaos that accompanies fan favourite Animal, the Muppets have all the ingredients that allow such a collection of characters to stand the test of time and remain as beloved now as they were when they started out. Their comedy is one laced with innocence, underlined with a heart as big as any. Characters like Fozzie Bear anchor the group with as much poignancy and class as they do humour, while Kermit continues to teach us lessons of compassion and selflessness, making it all the more odd that one of the true gentlemen of popular culture is a talking frog puppet? The answer lies with the late Jim Henson, the voice of our green hero (as well as a host of others),who injected all his heart and dignity into his Muppet creations, just as he did with his creative input on works such as Fraggle Rock and Sesame Street. Not only was he the lead puppeteer on many productions, he was also the mastermind behind the ragtag gang's rise to superstardom; guiding them from our television sets to cinema screens before duly passing the torch on to Disney. Between these two mammoths of the industry, the Muppets have appeared in seven theatrical films, as well as plenty of television movies and shows. It's fair to say their presence has been felt for over half a century; a presence that continues to educate and entertain as well as heaping doses of nostalgia onto an aged audience that has been there since the beginning. In celebration of the latest helping of Muppet mayhem, we take a look at their feature films and determine which Muppet caper should be crowned the most glorious.

8. Muppets From Space

Slapping the label 'worst Muppets movie' onto one of these films is no easy task. In fact, it would be more suitable to label this the least entertaining of the franchise rather than being necessarily bad. Anything with the Muppets involved will have some redeeming factors because the characters are just so charming and irresistibly funny, but Muppets From Space should probably go down as the least rounded or satisfying of all the films. That being said, it's hard to see what makes this one the worst movie on the list. Maybe it had something to do with the human cast - there's only so much David Arquette can do right - or that the jokes just seem to fall flat. Earlier installments had such reliable performances from guest stars and some truly memorable comedic moments that stuck with the audience for years to come, but Muppets From Space really lacks in that department. Kudos to the efforts of the production team who attempt to answer the question of what the hell Gonzo actually is, but this Muppet movie does not fully capture the magic that made the others so special. In fact, it's kind of boring.

7. Muppets Most Wanted

Following the success of the 2011 reboot, Muppets Most Wanted was always going to have to reach for an extremely high bar. Did it do that? Well, the answer is yes and no. On one hand, the sequel is pretty much a continuation of what we've come to expect, particularly in The Muppets. We still get that innocent humour we're so used to and a host of celebrity cameos. The introduction of the antagonist Constantine - in every definition the nega-Kermit - is by far and away the film's strongest point and his interaction with the others and Ricky Gervais is the funniest aspect of an otherwise bland production. It is somewhat disappointing that Muppets Most Wanted has left many reviewers scratching their heads, begging the question of when did the Muppets become so scarce in their own film. Yes, films like The Muppets Christmas Carol and Muppet Treasure Island were led by Michael Caine and Tim Curry, but the beauty of the 'human' characters in each of these is that they allow the room and the screen-time for the Muppets to take centre-stage and truly shine. This isn't a stab at Ricky Gervais or Ty Burrell or ... Hornswoggle. But for most of James Bobin's follow-up, they're all we get. Never have the Muppets been so underused, in particular Gonzo. Seriously, he and Fozzie have about two scenes in the whole film. It may be more telling to call this film a comedy about overly-colourful characters and Muppet guest appearances. Jason Segel didn't return for the sequel - as a writer or performer - and it's evident straight from the off. The musical numbers grow stale and the script feels a lot more paint-by-numbers than the first. It isn't particularly a bad film, but more Muppets and a great deal more heart wouldn't have gone amiss.

6. The Muppets Christmas Carol

A solid adaptation of Charles Dickens' classic novel about Ebenezer Scrooge and his ghostly plight on Christmas Eve, The Muppets Christmas Carol has required viewing for many families during the festive period. That isn't to say it's without flaws, but for the most part, the film is a decent and a genuinely faithful retelling of an old favourite. The story is one that has been done to death in Hollywood with Bill Murray and Jim Carrey filling the cranky miser's slippers, but the Muppets' take on the tale may be the most memorable. For instance, Gonzo takes on the role of Charles Dickens and is easily the most entertaining part of the film. His interplay with Rizzo is a welcome addition to an otherwise bleak plot, and his narration sets up scenes without becoming overbearing. Kermit is his usual gracious self as Bob Cratchit, echoing themes of togetherness and selflessness against the Victorian backdrop, while Michael Caine - in no ways at his absolute best - still gives a reliable performance as he treads the character arc from miserly banker to generous do-gooder.

5. Muppet Treasure Island

Just like The Muppets Christmas Carol, this one was also based on a celebrated literary work in Robert Louis Stevenson's Treasure Island. Directed by Jim Henson's son Brian, you can really see the gap the great man had left. Whatever he brought to The Muppets, it was intangible - something that couldn't be copied-and-pasted to the same effect. Quite simply, there was too much plot and not enough Muppets. While this isn't necessarily a bad thing, they're really the things we came to see - it's a good job the source material is so riveting and Tim Curry more so as Long John Silver. He takes every bit of charisma he has shown in works like Rocky Horror Picture Show and Stephen King's It, and hams it up in a scene-chewing performance as the infamous marauding pirate in search of treasure. This one may have been short on the Muppets in some respect, but the musical numbers, jokes and action turn what would just be a Muppet film into a truly entertaining swashbuckling adventure all round - despite losing the creative genius of Jim Henson.

4. The Great Muppet Caper

It's surprising that the only Jim Henson-directed Muppets movie was also the sappiest in terms of its overall message. Themes of compassion and togetherness were tent-poles in Henson's ideology and work with the Muppets, but given free rein they become a little irritating. Not to the detriment of the film however, at least in scope. Whereas the original boiled down to being a road trip movie (and a good one at that) The Great Muppet Caper boasted a bigger and bolder plot concerning thieves and robbery. It was a brave move on Henson's part and his vision should be commended at least, but his true genius lies in his performance - displaying an everlasting talent for puppetry and emotion. The characters are as lovable as always, but it wouldn't have been a bad thing if the whole thing had been toned down from sickly-sweet to something more palatable.

3. The Muppets Take Manhattan

If anything keeps The Muppets Take Manhattan from the top-spot on the list, it is purely nostalgia and has nothing to do with the quality of the film. What's truly remarkable is that this is the first Muppet movie to really thrust Kermit into the limelight. As was the case with The Great Muppet Caper and Muppets Most Wanted. these films are often so preoccupied with the human element, and forget the main selling points are the puppets. This time round, Frank Oz (in a directorial debut) finds the perfect blend of man and Muppet - providing the likes of Juliana Donald and Louis Zorich with just the right amount of screen-time that lets them shine without being overbearing. The character of Kermit has come such a long way since his days plucking the ukulele in a swamp, and it's a testament to his fictional and real-life fame that he finds himself mixing it up in Broadway this time round. But it isn't all lights and glamour for the Muppets when they hit New York - this may have the harshest undertones of the whole franchise, singling out the trials and tribulations that come with being a performer, yet still maintaining the same high-level of whimsy and fun we've come to expect from the group.

2. The Muppet Movie

As you may have noticed, the Muppets boast an impressive list of acting talent in their celluloid collection. Tim Curry and Michael Caine stand out as some of the best, completely owning their respective roles, but you have to look back to the very beginning of their Hollywood career to uncover the most stellar and impressive cast they've assembled. From Charles Durning to Orson Welles, The Muppet Movie was a family film that oozed class. It was the road trip movie to end all road trip movies, with Kermit and the gang embarking on a cross-country adventure to Hollywood. The escapade not only sees them work with such decorated and talented actors, but also delivers the most laughs. Needless to say, this really allows Fozzie, Statler and Waldorf the space to shine. Their transition to the silver-screen was so successful which delivered critically and financially, making the original Muppet Movie one of the very best. The premise was simple but executed to perfection by Jim Henson and Frank Oz, including welcome nods to the Hollywood classics. Not only is this one of the greatest Muppet movies, but it's also one of the greatest family movies of the last forty years.

1. The Muppets

Much like this article, James Bobin's The Muppets was a celebration of all we loved about the band of characters and, essentially, a passion project to bring such larger-than-life personalities back to the screen. In this sense, the film was very aware of itself and the objectives it was obviously striving to meet. For one, our latest puppet, Walter, is a Muppet fanatic who has grown up with the gang's television show - much like writer Jason Segel. In fact, Segel has kept it no secret that he harbours passion for everything Muppets. Take for instance his character in Forgetting Sarah Marshall, he works on a Dracula musical involving puppets, and a similar enthusiasm really shows in his script. The writing is loaded with nods to previous Muppet escapades - whether it be Gonzo reciting Hamlet while performing a dare-devil stunt or Bob Hope's special guest appearance on the Muppet Show. It is laced with the usual underlying message, cementing the wacky antics with a great deal of heart and teachings of compassion and the importance of family and friendship - something so prevalent in previous Muppet films. The Muppets was a triumphant return for Kermit and the others, hitting all the right notes with old and new generations. Jim Henson may have passed away some years prior to filming but the love he stitched into his characters remains as strong as ever, dutifully replicated by true fans of his beloved source material.

Contributor
Contributor

I love all things imaginative, from the page to the screen, and nurture a soft spot for Donald Sutherland and Daniel Bryan.