Nick Nolte: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Grumbling greats and snarling suck fests...

Back in the late sixties Nicholas King Nolte was a Nebraska boy done good. Booted out of numerous high schools and colleges due to poor grades and the odd shenanigan - he was expelled from his native Benson High for fighting and stashing beer - Nolte was able to put the Midwest behind him at an early age and embark on a burgeoning modelling career. One successful Clairol ad later and his face was one that people were starting to recognise - smooth, handsome and seemingly etched from stone. But it was his dabbling in theatre productions and stage schools that set him onto his true calling, where he first found key roles in television - his role in miniseries Rich Man, Poor Man was a Brando esque calling card - a before answering Hollywood's call for a new tough yet sincere leading man. What transpired was a career littered with good, great and, occasionally, dog awful roles. While it hasn't always been plain sailing for the star - he gained an unwanted notoriety following a DUI and drugs bust back in 2002, with his mug shot being a frazzled revelation to behold - he has held his own against some of the greatest actors to ever grace Tinseltown and is already a thesping legend in his own right. Going through something of a career resurgance, there is no greater time to cast an eye back over his career. With Nolte's co-lead performance in the movie adaptation of Bill Bryson's A Walk In The Woods released in UK cinemas today, here's the very best and worst performances of his career...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Lt. Col. Gordon Tall - The Thin Red Line

If ever there was a role Nolte was born to play, it was that of an army leader and, as Lt. Col. Gordon Tall, he turned in one of his briefest yet most significant roles. In what is a star-packed and lengthy movie from director Terrence Malick, Nolte spews out a mortar blast performance, where his dogged determination to have the Japanese running scared sees him spitting orders at his troops - "this is not a court of law, this is a war - it's a god damn battle" - and showing off a dark side when he foregoes water for the troops in favour of pushing forward and sealing his legacy. A complex and shouty turn.

4. Tom Wingo - The Prince Of Tides

Far better than the mother's weepie its poster might suggest it is, The Prince Of Tides is a languid study of cultures colliding, pasts being unearthed and blocked love - it's also the complete showcase of Nolte's acting talents. As Tom Wingo, a southerner with secrets, Nolte digs deep to deliver a performance brimming with reluctance, regret and longing. Under the generous direction of helmer and co star Barbara Streisand, he carries this role with old-fashioned charm and very little grizzle, showing some serious thesping chops in the film's surprising finale. Nolte's skills didn't go unnoticed with him being nominated for an Oscar, only to watch Anthony Hopkins steal the prize at the 64th Academy Awards for his iconic turn as Hannibal Lecter.

3. Jack Cates - 48 Hrs.

Rightly cited as being the first - and let's face it, best - buddy cop movie to grace our screens, 48 Hrs. is that rare thing: a film that excites and spawns laughter in equal measure. Breakout star Eddie Murphy may have got all the best lines, but it's Nolte that has the toughest job, making a character like slightly bigoted cop Jack Cates both likeable and also funny. Nolte is clearly having a good time in this movie and special mention should also go to director Walter Hill, who by his own admission was rewriting the character of Cate's on a daily basis during filming in order to ensure the character aligned with Nolte's own personality.

2. Paddy Conlon - Warrior

Forget about Tom Hardy and Joel Edgerton's beefy sibling rivalry, the real star of this UFC-inspired Rocky throwback is, of course, Nick Nolte. As Paddy Conlon Nolte turns in his most shockingly honest performance; playing the hollowed out and drying out father of two sons heading for one heck of a public dust up. Dragged around by the most affected of his spawn (a raging Hardy), Conlon is an emotional and physical punching bag for his damaged son. Desperate for redemption via his faith, yet constantly reminded of the sins of the past, Nolte plays the role quietly as he absorbs the unfolding drama around him. Yet another sign that Nolte's career is on an upwards climb, Warrior is also the film that gifted the actor with his best chance of snagging an Oscar, where he was sadly pipped to a supporting nod by veteran actor Christopher Plummer at the 84th Academy Awards.

1. Wade Whitehouse - Affliction

As an absolute pro at being able to portray true git in any surroundings, be it the mean streets of New York (Taxi Driver), neon-drenched Tokyo (Yakuza) or the greasy floors of a Detroit auto plant (Blue Collar), writer/ director Paul Schrader surprised everyone with this nineties drama. Set in picturesque New Hampshire, Affliction centres on beleaguered cop, Wade Whitehouse, as he puts family squabbles on the back burner in order to look into a seemingly innocent hunting accident. As Wade, Nolte is on blistering - and Oscar-nominated - form, a bundle of rage intent on getting to the bottom of a small town mystery, while at the same time having to spar with his father (a career-topping James Coburn) and the ex wife. If you ever need to bear witness to a true testament of Nolte's skills as an actor, sit back and watch the film's devastating final third, where Nolte somehow manages to create a legend around his own character. A stone cold performance.

€ And 5 That Sucked

5. Butch - Cats & Dogs: The Revenge Of Kitty Galore

Following on from its largely forgettable predecessor, this sequel does a pretty bad job of rehashing the original, complete with its plot of feline world domination. Thrown into the litter is a gaggle of new furry faces, an overload of James Bond references and one Nick Nolte to liven things up a little. Voice acting roles aren't something you'd expect Nolte to attempt and while his role as Butch, the grumpy shepherd dog, is half credible, it is simply too much of an odd contrast to watch hear Nolte's gruff tones coming out of such a sweet - albeit CGI - pooch. Not the mutts nuts by any stretch of the imagination.

4. Lucas - Three Fugitives

Nolte ended the eighties with a near career-defining dud in this noisy buddy caper. In a slight role reversal, Nolte plays a recently released criminal intent on going straight, who by a twist of fate is taken hostage by a bumbling yet well-meaning crook - Martin Short, in overdrive - and finds himself having to fight to prove his innocence. Showcasing none of the straight man skills we all loved from 48 Hrs., Nolte spends the majority of this movie looking bemused and unable to get a word in edgeways around a rampant Short. One for the diehard fans only.

3. Jack Cates - Another 48 Hrs.

Oh what a difference a star-making turn can make, as the winning buddy formula of Walter Hill's seminal eighties buddy picture gets kicked to the curb in favour of this full on Eddie Murphy vehicle. Arriving eight years after its predecessor, and encumbered by an early nineties, high concept story treatment from Murphy himself, Another 48 Hrs. sees Nolte's Jack Cate's under the cosh and in need of some assistance from his old buddy Reggie (Murphy). What transpires is a feature-length platform for Murphy to run riot and show off his already getting tired motormouth shtick. While this isn't exactly bad enough to sully the original, this will perhaps always remain Nolte's most pedestrian roles.

2. Dr David Banner - Hulk

Frazzled, mumbling and prone to bouts of rage himself, Nolte's take on papa Hulk is a role that is perhaps best forgotten. As David Banner, Nolte tramples through scenes of angst, anger and shouty monologues as his character struggles to come to terms with his past and the changes happening to his son. At the time this film was released, critics were kind to all of the performances that helmer Ang Lee coaxed out of his cast, but on repeated viewings it's Nolte's crumpled performance that comes off the worst, where for the most part he seems uncomfortable and unable to find some semblance to his character. In a round about way you can't help but blame him for the killer poodles, too.

1. Peter Brackett - I Love Trouble

Ever wondered why Nolte hasn't starred in many - or any, for that matter - rom coms of late? You'll find the answer in I Love Trouble, a clunky genre yarn deserved of the top spot. Paired up with Julia Roberts, Nolte generates zero chemistry with his co star, where they play bickering journos on the hunt for a milk conspiracy scoop. The two leads famously didn't get on during the filming of this surprisingly hollow Nancy Myers picture, with Nolte for the most part acting through gritted teeth and no doubt wondering how he let himself be so woefully miscast. While in the past casting Nolte against type has kind of worked - Cape Fear, Lorenzo's Oil - the gamble didn't pay off in this one, a movie that Nolte himself cites has being the worst film he's ever starred in. Got any more Nolte nuggets of thesping gold to share with us? Or are there some stinkers not included on this list? You know the drill: hope to the comments thread below and wax lyrical.

Contributor
Contributor

Shaun is a former contributor for a number of Future Publishing titles and more recently worked as a staffer at Imagine Publishing. He can now be found banking in the daytime and writing a variety of articles for What Culture, namely around his favourite topics of film, retro gaming, music, TV and, when he's feeling clever, literature.