Once Upon A Time In Hollywood: Ranking Every Major Performance
Who dominates Tarantino's latest?
With Tarantino's latest film, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood finally being unleashed upon the world at large, it is bound to be a great many things to a great many people. Set in Hollywood circa 1969, the film sees Tarantino assembling a truly all-star cast to bring his nostalgic, glimmering ode to innocence lost to life in thrilling fashion.
From long-time Tarantino regulars such as Kurt Russell or Brad Pitt to newcomers such as Margaret Qualley or Austin Butler, this film is practically bursting at the seams with award-worthy star-power. Even discounting characters and actors who make only minor appearances such as Damon Herriman as Charles Manson, Bruce Dern as George Spahn, or even Emile Hirsch as Jay Sebring, there's still an unbelievable amount of huge stars playing major roles in this thing.
But which one of them steals the whole show?
Let's recount all of the all-around stellar performances given in Tarantino's latest film and see exactly how they all stack up.
*SPOILERS AHEAD*
Special Aside: The late, great Luke Perry is not featured on this list but his brief yet powerful performance as Wayne Maunder is utterly wonderful.
11. Timothy Olyphant As James Stacy
Tarantino has always had a gift for utilizing an actor's real-life history or career and using it in his casting choices to add a meta-weight to the role. And Once Upon a Time in Hollywood is certainly full of examples of this, one of the easiest and most blatant ones being that of Olyphant as James Stacy.
Olyphant famously served as the star of the critcally-acclaimed television show Justified for years, in which he played a modern-day cowboy of sorts. So when he shows up in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood playing a real-life actor (James Stacy) playing the protagonist of a real-life cowboy television show (Johnny Madrid Lancer on Lancer), it isn't exactly a stretch to see why he's such a swell fit for the part.
And while Olyphant does an excellent job in the role, sophisticatedly straddling the line between impression and original interpretation, he doesn't get all that much to do. He's essentially there as a piece of scenery for Leo to play off of in a couple of scenes and that's about it, which lands him (fairly or not) at the bottom of this ranking.
Having said all of that, we would still watch a few hours-worth of a Tarantino-helmed, Olyphant-starring version of Lancer in a heartbeat.
10. Kurt Russell As Randy
In the later phase of Tarantino's career, Kurt Russell has become something of one of his regular players. After first appearing in Death Proof, Russell has gone on to have a starring role in The Hateful Eight and play a crucial role here in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.
As the on-screen Randy, it's a ton of fun to see Russell get to chew some scenery alongside actors like Pitt and DiCaprio. His confrontation with Rick Dalton about how he's uncomfortable with using Cliff because of his checkered past is one of the film's subtlest moments and it is so affecting because of Russell's nuanced heel-turning performance.
Sadly, the film doesn't have a ton of time to allot to Randy (or his cameoing scene-stealing wife, played by ludicrously talented and endearing real-life stunt legend Zoƫ Bell). Tarantino goes the extra mile to make up for this by having Russell as the on-again/off-again narrator of the fairy tale narrative, which Russell is clearly having a lot of fun delivering.
Overall, Russell's just so godd*mn good in it that he leaves you wanting more from him, which is never a bad thing.
9. Al Pacino As Marvin Schwarzs
It's been a few years since Al Pacino was really *Al Pacino*.
The revered and absolute legend of an actor has spent the past decade-or-so alternating between distinctly generic fare (see: Hangman or Misconduct) and films so downright awful it's kind of embarrassing (see: Jack and Jill). But in typical Tarantino fashion, Pacino is back to true form here in a small but critical role that gives the actor easily his biggest win of the last decade.
As Marvin Schwarzs, a Hollywood producer newly representing Rick Dalton, Pacino essentially gets one big scene right at the start of the film and then a few cutaways peppered throughout. But what puts him a cut above the previous entries on this list is the way in which Pacino *really* makes his one big scene count.
The scene in which he meets Dalton for the first time and tells him what a huge fan he is only to then slowly reveal to Dalton that he feels his career is being mismanaged and that the actor is on the verge of irrelevancy if he continues down this path is downright haunting. It's the inciting incident of the entire film and Pacino delivers a tour de force performance in the span of minutes that anchors Rick Dalton's entire subsequent arc in genuine believability and pathos.
It's so great that it feels like Pacino swiftly and nonchalantly kicking the audience in the teeth, reminding them precisely how he got to be legend in the first place.
8. Dakota Fanning As Squeaky
Tarantino has always had something of a gift for crafting suspenseful sequences. While people rarely think of him as a horror director, some of his greatest films (see: Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction, Death Proof, The Hateful Eight) have been thoroughly rooted in Hitchcockian suspense-and-tension-building filmmaking.
Seeing as Once Upon a Time in Hollywood frequently feels like a Great Movie Ride of sorts through Tarantino's catalog and various influences (this is very much a compliment, it fits the film's glitteringly nostalgic tone perfectly), it's only fitting that it features a standout suspense sequence that may very well do down as one of his very best, in the form of the Spahn Ranch setpiece.
It is here that Dakota Fanning shows up in a reserved performance that kind of steals the entire sequence. As Cliff Booth investigates the ranch and it's Manson Family inhabitants, growing increasingly suspicious, Fanning's Squeaky is the titular bomb under the table. Even before we see her face, she is the dominating force of the scene (introduced via feet because of course, she is). By the time Cliff makes his way to her and Squeaky is officially introduced on-screen, Fanning has already built up an immense amount of tension and anticipation through her vocal performance alone.
Her scene with Pitt features a chilling and calculated performance from her which sees her raising the hairs on the back of your neck without ever having to move a muscle. It is extremely impressive.
7. Austin Butler As Tex
1401911One of the smartest choices the film makes in its depiction of the Manson 'Family' is in how it completely and totally thumbs its nose at them in the final act. Similarly to how Tarantino very much attempted to deflate the legacy of Adolf Hitler in Inglorious Basterds, he shows the Manson 'Family' as unwitting and utterly incapable idiots and it is simultaneously hilarious and incredibly satisfying to watch.
But seeing as Charles Manson himself is all but absent from the film proper, the bulk of this parodying doesn't fall on him but rather on his 'children' who attempt to carry out the murders. Chief among them is Tex, as played by Austin Butler.
Tex is first introduced as a member of the 'family' during the Spahn Ranch sequence but he doesn't really get to shine until the final act, where he acts as the misbegotten leader of the group of would-be murderers. This sees him having to subsequently deliver all-timer lines such as "I'm as real as a doughnut, motherf*cker" with outraged conviction, and Butler plays this to *perfection*.
From his physicality to his comedic timing, Butler very nearly steals this climactic scene from a room quite literally packed-to-the-brim with scene-stealers.
6. Margaret Qualley As Pussycat
After serving as something of a scene-stealer a few years back in Shane Black's The Nice Guys, Qualley is back in full force here with yet another scene-stealing role that sees her going toe-to-toe with some of biggest names in Hollywood.
While she gets smaller scenes peppered throughout the film, her big moment comes in the form of the lead-up to the Spahn's Ranch setpiece, in which she convinces Cliff Booth to give her a ride up to said ranch.
The resulting car ride and conversation see her and Pitt engaging in a fair bit of verbal sparring and to her immense credit, Qualley essentially steals the scene out from under Cliff (and subsequently Pitt's) nose. As Pussycat, she deceptively uses her physicality to take control of both Cliff and the scene itself.
As if this wasn't impressive enough, Pussycat's dawning realization that Cliff isn't the perfect match for the 'family' that she thought he was, is played with startling grace and power. Qualley imbues Pussycat with a presence and personality entirely her own and even manages to foreground her character's very own arc in the brief screentime she has, leaving a huge impression on the film.
5. Margot Robbie As Sharon Tate
The movie's handling of Sharon Tate has already been dominating a great deal of the conversation surrounding the film and with good reason; it is her film. And while each viewer's mileage seems to be varying on just how effective they find the approach that Tarantino and Robbie took to bringing the real-life actress to life once more on the big screen, this writer found it boldly elegant and ultimately touching.
Sharon Tate doesn't get the screentime or development that her fellow co-stars Rick Dalton or Cliff Booth get. Instead, both in the narrative of the film and in the form of the film, she is deified. In-narrative, characters like Rick and Cliff watch her from the house next door and view her as something of an icon, someone too famous for even them to interact with.
In the form of the film, Tarantino and cinematographer Robert Richardson treat us to extended sequences such as her trip to go see The Wrecking Crew at the Bruin Theatre, in which they allow us to simply sit with Robbie as Tate. To her immense credit, Robbie delivers an astounding performance that embraces this unique take on the character, working in synchrony with Tarantino and Richardson's form to create a truly special ode to innocence lost in the form of a love letter to Sharon Tate.
4. Leonardo DiCaprio As Rick Dalton
Fresh off of his Academy Award-winning performance in The Revenant, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood sees DiCaprio returning to the big screen for the first time since and delivering an all-around astounding performance that is destined to go down as one of his all-time bests.
As Dalton, DiCaprio crafts an intricate portrait of a performer coming face-to-face with his own mortality and it's kind of enthralling to witness. He's anxiety-ridden, full of guilt, and ultimately just kind of a mess. In the same way that Tarantino allows us to simply sit with and marinate in Robbie's performance as Tate, we're allowed to simply witness Dalton doing daily routines such as rehearsing his lines for the next day's filming and DiCaprio turns these intimate moments into some of the film's best.
His best sequence in the entire film though is the quietly revolutionary setpiece centering around the filming of his Lancer episode. The episode is shown to the audience as an edited, finished product, except for when Dalton makes a mistake. Then, the form itself will rewind or reset without ever removing us from the episode itself. It's a brilliant stylistic choice, one that allows Tarantino and DiCaprio to essentially break down the bounds of the form by acknowledging it.
It sees them turning the artform into visual jazz and allowing DiCaprio to give a mesmerizingly affecting performance that is simultaneously funny, compelling, and emotionally poignant.
3. Julia Butters As Trudi Fraser
1401912If there is one new name audiences remember from Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, it should undoubtedly be Julia Butters.
Much like the majority of the actors on this list, Butters essentially gets one key scene in which she gets to perform, with a few other little moments here and there, thanks to the film's sprawling narrative. Yet, among all of the various pint-sized performances from A-list, award-winning actors, it is this four-minutes of screentime from a relatively unknown young girl that beats them all out.
Butters plays Trudi Fraser, a young actress on the set of Lancer who plays an integral role in convincing Rick Dalton to take his career and his craft seriously and she is absolutely incredible. Their conversation sees her running the gamut of various emotional responses to Dalton's insecurities and subsequent emotional breakdown, all while maintaining a powerfully reserved performance.
She steals the scene from Academy Award-winner Leonardo DiCaprio and it makes it look like a walk in the park. Dear casting directors, please cast Julia Butters in everything until given further notice. Thank you.
2. Sayuri As Brandy
This award-winning dog is the real hero of the film and pretty much immediately ascends into the upper echelon of truly great dogs of cinema history.
In a film full of really satisfying setups and payoffs, written and directed by a filmmaker known for providing really satisfying setups and payoffs, Brandy becomes the most satisfying payoff in all of Tarantino's history. After being introduced early on as Cliff's sweet, loving, and loyally protective companion, Brandy gets to really sinker her teeth into juicy action beats when the third act comes around.
She gets to rip members of the Manson 'Family' limb-from-limb, all in the name of protecting those she loves. The sheer amount of extensive choreography and action that Sayuri, the real-life dog playing Brandy, as to do is beyond impressive and she does it all with utter conviction.
Brandy may eat dog food branded for 'mean dogs' but she is, in fact, the best dog. Ever.
1. Brad Pitt As Cliff Booth
While Margot Robbie achieves a greater thematic weight and cinematic synchrony through her performance, Leonardo DiCaprio gets more capital-A acting moments in his, and Butters and Sayuri are the film's most effectively brilliant scene-stealers, it is in fact Pitt's understated performance as Cliff Booth that ultimately takes the cake.
It's been a decade since Pitt last appeared in a Tarantino film (see: 2009's Inglourious Basterds) and even longer than that since he and long-time collaborator David Fincher worked together (see: 2008's The Curious Case of Benjamin Button). In that intervening time, Pitt has given some interesting performances (see: Tree of Life, Killing Them Softly) but they've rarely reached the euphoric heights he had previously.
In this way, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood is a genuine return to form for Pitt. Looking even more like a reincarnated Robert Redford than ever before, Tarantino practically weaponizes Pitt's persona, legacy, and physicality for the role of Cliff. The result is a performance that is endlessly compelling to watch.
Whether he's speeding along the highway, eating Kraft's mac and cheese at home with Brandy, engaging in backstage fist-fights with Bruce Lee, or beating members of the Manson 'Family' to a pulp, Pitt imbues each aspect of his performance with such understated power and weight.